Stuggles Of Women From Two Different Points Of View

2198 words - 9 pages

“Hills like White Elephants” was written by Ernest Hemingway was first published in August of 1927. The other work that I have chosen to compare with the short story is “Black Woman” written by Georgia Douglas Johnson which was first published in 1922 during the Harlem Renaissance. The short story “Hills like Whit Elephants” is about a woman who is pregnant out of wedlock. The man in the story is trying to make her have surgery to remove the child, like an abortion. But the woman is debating about keeping the baby and making their relationship work with the child in their lives. She thinks that maybe having the child will make their relationship stronger.
The poem “Black Woman” is depicting a colored woman who is talking to her unborn child that is inside her and begging the child to not be born into this world yet. She is that the world is a terrible place for her to raise the child. The mother’s fears are that the child will be treated very horrible and having to live the life of a colored. She even goes into the poem stating that is going to take the life of her baby and herself, so that she doesn’t have to raise the child in the conditions. Both of these works are similar and yet so different in terms of literature. They are both dealing with the struggles of the woman when they are expecting a child when there is an unstable future. However, I believe that Johnson’s work accurately portrays the struggles of the woman over Hemingway.
The first topic that can be brought up is the point of view in Johnson’s poem shows the struggle, pain, and fear more than the woman depicted in the short story by Hemingway. This is also a valid point because the woman in the poem is colored; only adding to the pain that she is feeling towards bringing a baby into the world. She is trying to convey that the world is a horrible place and it not the place to raise a baby. As stated, “Don’t knock at my door, little child, I cannot let you in, you know not what a world this is” (Johnson). She is begging and begging the baby not to come, that they do not know what the world is like and all the evil that is in it. Another example is “Don’t knock at my heart, little one, I cannot bear the pain. Of turning dear-ear to your call” (Johnson). The woman is stating that she cannot bear the pain not being able to answer the child’s call that it wants to come into the world, she is also very saddened that she has to turn a deaf ear to the child’s calls.
The impact of the poem on the reader is very sad and depressing. This shows to them that the pain the woman is experiencing is very real and in a way can connect with the woman. It shows that world can be a dark and evil place for those that are easily taken into the horrible life that it can offer. The poem shows that the times being reflected in the poem are very negative and unforgiving to colored people and women, it is saddening to think that a mother would want to harm themselves and their children all so that they...

Find Another Essay On Stuggles of Women from Two Different Points of View

Stuggles Of Neil Young Essay

1915 words - 8 pages in Young's life that had problems with a heroin addiction, Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young's long time roadie Bruce Berry had also overdosed on heroin as well (193). The death of Berry inclined Young and the remaining members of Crazy Horse to record Tonight's the Night an album, which many fans view as an anti-drug album, at Bruce Berry's brother studio (McDonough 431). The death of two people heavily involved in Young's life caused him to then

Compare and contrast two of the set texts from two different periods "Everyman" and "Doctor Faustus"

1081 words - 4 pages individual and thenatural world in second place. The emergence of the Renaissance is evident in DoctorFaustus by the clash between the church and the introduction of knowledge throughscience. The Reformation caused a dramatic change at that particular time, England hadconverted from predominantly catholic to a protestant country. This shift becomesapparent in Doctor Faustus in the scenes with the Pope. The Renaissance was also a timewhen the bubonic

Freud and C.S Lewis: Opposite Points of View on Religion

1252 words - 5 pages Two great men, two exact opposite points of view, when it comes to the question of a master creator. These two men would have a profound effect on the life that we live today. Freud who was born to an orthodox Jewish family in the mid 1800’s was born into a lower class family his father was in the wool trade. The collapse of the family business moved him and his family to a Vienna, Ghetto. Freud would later become the voice of science in a

Two Different kinds of Marriage

1459 words - 6 pages . The parents still control both of them. Even for some cases, they will talk together about their marriage with the parents also. They will not be allowed to do more intimate activities before marriage, for example, dating. Moreover, from Islamic culture point of view, arranged marriages in Islam is the best way in choosing one’s partner because it is not allowed when a woman and man loves each other before marriage. It is because Islam does not

The Elizabethan View Of Women

1657 words - 7 pages The Elizabethan View of Women Women in Elizabethan times had few rights or luxuries. Their entire lifestyles depended upon that of their husbands, picked out for them by their fathers. They had almost no say in their lives, and they were expected to be thankful for having someone to rule over them. This is made abundantly clear by Katherina's famous speech in 5.2.137-180 of The Taming of the Shrew. She compares a woman's proper devotion to her

Two different countries in two different continents. One of them

1340 words - 5 pages . Although they are located in different region and different continent in the world these two countries both have the same problems. These two countries are members of International Money Fund. However there are lots of similarities between Turkey and Congo, these countries are not exactly the same countries. Both of them are taking financial aid from this international institution to develop and overcome some economic problems in their countries such

The View of Different Defendants by Police

1467 words - 6 pages The View of Different Defendants by Police This extract from Pat Carlen's Magistrates Justice describes how the police view different types of defendants. The findings have been compiled in the 1970s, practices and perceptions have dramatically improved since then. Magistrates justice involves many people including policemen, magistrates, clerks, and other supporting roles involved in the courts. Police

Warfare: The Different Viewpoints of Men and Women from World War I

1681 words - 7 pages World War I. People no longer lived according to the norms they had known before. Both men and women had to adjust in order to fit the societal experience brought about by the war. Though suffering was experienced by both men and women despite where they were during the war, their experiences were completely different thus making it important to look at these experiences from a deeper perspective. The Experiences and thoughts of men during World

The Two Faces of Women

2248 words - 9 pages ” (Gardener 10). Welthow is the complete embodiment of grace and hospitality as she walks around Hereot Hall and pours mead for Beowulf and all of his men. Welthow is everything that a queen and woman of time should aspire to be, unlike Grendel’s Mother who is dominant and unpleasant, while Welthow is calm, peaceful and graceful. Like Beowulf, Christina Rossetti’s poem “Goblin Market” also captures the role of two very different women

Iron Absorption from the Whole Diet, Comparison of the Effect of Two Different Distributions of Daily Calcium Intake

1441 words - 6 pages % = reference dose absorption % X 0.322 +15.71.Results - The nonheme iron absorption of high calcium intake was 12.1 +- 2.20% (range, 1.8%-32.3%) and low calcium intake was 15.9 +- 2.50% (range, 1.6% - 40.6%). When log serum ferritin concentration was used as a measure of iron status, the r-squared values were 0.68 and 0.51, respectively.The mean difference of the individual total iron-absorption figures from the two 10-d periods was 0.52 mg. In 16 of

GCSE media studies coursework: A comparison of two local newspaper articles. This essay compares two newspaper articles taken from two different local newspapers in England

1264 words - 5 pages In this essay I will be comparing two articles taken from local newspapers in different areas. I will be looking at the techniques used in each article and their effectiveness. I will use this comparison to eventually decide which article is the more effective of the two.The two headlines from the articles are quite different. 'Inches from tragedy' is a large, bold headline written in a way that makes you want to see what the headline is talking

Similar Essays

"Testimony Before The U.S. Senate, 1883" And "The Political Economy Of Seventy Three Million Dollars, 1882," To Compare And Contrast The Two Different View Points.

1759 words - 7 pages Gould v. LloydAre government regulations really needed in the late 1800's to stabilize industrialization or is "control by the government...contrary to our institution..?" To better describe the long time feud between ideas, we will be using two documents titled "Testimony before the U.S. Senate, 1883" and "The Political Economy of Seventy-three Million Dollars, 1882," to compare and contrast the two different view points of industrialization

A Text Can Be Considered From Many Points Of View And In Many Different Ways. Appropriation Is One Of The Ways Of Doing This.

2507 words - 10 pages in Holden and Igby's attitudes and actions and lastly, as a text that fits into the rites of passage genre being measured by the conventions of idealism vs. realism and conformity vs. realism. Appropriation is the most influential method as it creates cultural differences in values, impacting the methods of portraying the rites of passage conventions and the psychoanalysis. The three different methods of viewing the two studied texts illustrate that the statement a text can be considered from many points of view and in many different ways is correct.

'abortion Is Never Justified'. Do You Agree? Give Reasons To Support Your Answer And Show That You Have Thought About Different Points Of View. You Must Refer To Christianity In Your Answer.

1568 words - 6 pages wanting abortions. It is good from the point of view that women are no longer dying trying to rid themselves of something they cannot look after, or do not want. It is often the best solution for many young girls, and mothers from a financially unstable background, but that also does not necessarily mean it is a justified action. Some people say that if a foetus was brought into the world unwanted, unloved and entering into a life of merciless teasing

Points Of View Essay

1222 words - 5 pages Points of View Aeschylus faces off with Euripides in a dramatic contest and is declared the victor. The decision is one of cosmetics more than substance. Aeschylus wrote plays that appealed to the people of Athens. The Oresteia is a story with strong characters faced with difficult decisions in which justice prevails. On the other hand, Euripides wrote plays that were more realistic, such as The Electra, which reveals the weakness of men and