Subjective Bravery Essay

967 words - 4 pages

There was a story in the news a few years ago about Rachel Cory, an American student in Israel, who put herself in a precarious situation. She had decided to stand against the destruction of Palestinian homes by an Israeli defense force. The 23 year old was crushed to death by an Israeli bulldozer. Is it brave or stupid to put yourself between a large piece of war machinery and its intended target? What actually happened to her depends on who you listen to. Some say she was callously run over and then dumped on by the bulldozer's driver. Others say she slipped, fell and was crushed because the driver couldn't see or hear her. Still others have suggested she actually meant to get herself killed. However, unless they can come up with some proof to that end, I think we can safely disregard that theory. Of course, these perceptions have all been filtered by the viewpoints of those involved. The people she was protesting with think the Israelis meant to kill her, and she's a hero. Meanwhile, the Israelis she was protesting against say it was an accident, and that she was being irresponsible. Everyone's got a story to sell here, and they have all been tweaked to taste. But what makes no sense at all is how she came to be there, in front of that bulldozer, in the first place. That has to either be extreme bravery or extreme stupidity. There is a fine line between bravery and stupidity and it all depends on various factors such as the final outcome of the action at hand, and the point of view from which it is seen, and possibly even the naivety and ignorance of the individual. These factors have nothing to do with the subjects' righteousness. Where does bravery end and stupidity begin?A cynical few may say the only difference between bravery and stupidity is that the brave ones come out of the situation alive, while the stupid ones don't. But that is a gross oversimplification: there are a lot of dead men who were very brave, and a lot of stupid ones who are still alive. Simply watching the television show "Jackass" is an easy way to verify this fact. We've all seen those pictures of the Chinese man standing before a line of tanks, during the unrest surrounding the Tiananmen Square massacre. He was able to stop them from going any further, but if he had been run over. Would we still view this man as being brave? Or would we see it as being just another stupid miscalculation by a crazy man?Some may think the way we look at it revolves around our own viewpoints on what was going on at the time. What was the underlying situation the action took place within, and what was their relation to it? What...

Find Another Essay On Subjective Bravery

Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle Essay

1510 words - 6 pages Many believe the two are interchangeable when speaking about morals and ethics, when the two in no way mean the same thing. Morals are subjective beliefs that belong to an individual, they are one’s own beliefs as to what is right and what is wrong. Ethics on the other hand are the rules that society creates and teaches regarding proper and improper, right and wrong, social behavior. Morals are internal, ethics are external, and they have been

Free Will Determinism Essay

1448 words - 6 pages . Without free will, morality and ethics are meaningless. We would also have to throw away the “best” things about people, such as generosity or bravery, just two among countless traits. If we had no free will, one would not be considered generous for giving their kidney away. One would not be considered brave for taking a bullet for someone. They were “destined” to lose their kidney and their life, respectively. If everything was determined, then

Journalism Errors: Double Check The Spelling of Names and Other Facts

1221 words - 5 pages business where one must present his work to people who will examine it, and after one mistake deem it “crap,” Davis said, “it takes bravery to do that every day.” This harsh reality of the news writing industry provoked the thought process behind the Newhouse School’s spelling/grammatical/factual error grading policy in news writing and editing classes. In the first half of the introductory news writing course, NEW 205, students

The Façade of Heroism -- Discusses the Presidency of John F. Kennedy; his successes and failures, and that his success resulted more from inspirational demeanor than true talent.

1204 words - 5 pages subtle subversion.Although short fallings of leadership are concrete and objective, the analysis of character represents a much more subjective viewpoint. Thus, the question of John F. Kennedy's character is a perennially thorny debate, further catalyzed by the contradictory extremes of his actions. Not surprisingly, however, it is the extreme that represents the argument that Kennedy was overwhelmingly of good character that receives the most weight

Atticus Finch

1102 words - 4 pages admired for their outstanding bravery. Spider-man voluntarily put himself in harm's way to help the community. Odysseus had several outstanding achievements including the idea of the Trojan horse and enduring ten years of hardships. The only thing that Atticus did was defend Tom Robinson. In today's world, a hero is someone who puts himself in danger for the good of society. Atticus did put himself in danger by sitting outside of the jail, but it

The Countdown Of Mortality In Shakespearean Sonnet #12

1061 words - 4 pages waiting. Watching a clock slows the passage of time, giving time a predatory attribute, as if it is slowly creeping up on us for the strike. It is important to note that the speaker repeatedly uses "I". Thus, the poem is subjective and the speaker is projecting upon his own death. Then in lines 2-8, the speaker's provides his observations over the course of time. He describes the "violet past prime" (3), the death of a kind of flower, and

Description, Function, Attribution, and Analysis of a Red-figure Type B Kylix

2414 words - 10 pages unanimously viewed as an act of sheer bravery, but the playwright questions this view. Euripides suggests that the concept of bravery is much more complex, and he asserts that a single heroic act does not entirely define its hero. Therefore, the analysis of the text and characters contrast with the simpler, more idealized scene on the Nikosthenes Painter’s red-figure kylix. This critique enables scholars to better understand the goals of artist

Comparing The Media Techniques Used to Present the D-Day Landings in the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan

2062 words - 8 pages Comparing The Media Techniques Used to Present the D-Day Landings in the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan The heroism and bravery of those who took part in the D-Day has been brought to the big screen from several perspectives. 1939-1945 were some of the most horrific times in the broad spectrum of human conflict ever seen by mankind with unmatched weapons of devastation and the senseless slaughter of millions of lives

Lord of the Flies: Character analysis

1789 words - 7 pages . His victory over Piggy represents the triumph of violence over intellect, as he smashes one of the lenses of the fat boy's glasses. The knife that he carries is a symbol of the death and destruction that accompany his every act. He does have some attractive qualities-bravery and resourcefulness. But these are easily obscured by his wrath, envy, pride, hatred, and lust for blood. He is constantly attempting to weaken Ralph's hold on the boys. He

Positve Psychology and Aristotle's Virtue Ethics Converge

1627 words - 7 pages efforts to flourish, and are fundamental to human well-being. Positive psychology describes the “good life” as being pleasant, engaging, meaningful, and full of achievements and connections. Seligman proposes positive subjective experiences illicit and promote positive emotions. Positive psychology distinguishes two types of happiness that can be derived from experiences and events: Hedonic and eudemonic happiness. Hedonism describes immediate sensory

Comparison of Franco Zefferelli’s Romeo and Juliet to The Adaptation by Baz Luhrmann

2339 words - 9 pages her slumber Romeo raises the bottle and empties the contents into his mouth. Juliet wakes to she the last breath of her one true love. Life without love is nothing to Juliet, she grasps Romeo’s dagger and ends her own life in an act of bravery and devotion. In respect to the untimely deaths of their children the Montagues and the Capulets agree to end the feud. At the begging of Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo and Juliet there

Similar Essays

Heroism And Duty Essay

1048 words - 4 pages In the ancient world, the definition of a hero was subjective among the Egyptian and Israeli cultures. The Egyptians believed heroes were those of higher status, whether they were gods or had a personal relationship with the gods, and their duty was to be a representative of the people. The Israelites’ heroes were those that selflessly worshipped God and for that, God chose them to lead others by example as part of their duty. Ancient Egypt and

The Role Of History And Memory In The Fiftieth Gate, Schindler's List, And The Send Off

1114 words - 4 pages emphasised due to the context of the film. Lastly, the poem ‘The Send-Off’ by Wilfred Owen expresses Owen’s personal feelings towards war which is enunciated through his strong emotive language. Mark Baker’s ‘The Fiftieth Gate’ creates a struggle between memory and history as each represents the Holocaust but through different means of representation. The language of memory is partial, subjective, and emotional and experiences confusion and doubts

'elements Of The Anzac Tradition And Spirit That Have Remained Constant In The Australian Society'

1065 words - 4 pages people enthusiastically accepted his subjective view. Charles Bean's historical writings represent Australia's commitment to serve and protect their 'motherland' England.Australia and New Zealand commemorate the ANZAC Day public holiday on the 25th of April every year to honour the bravery and sacrifice of the members of the Australian and New Zealand Army Corps (ANZAC), and of all whom served their country in time of war. The Anzac tradition began

Deadly, Unna? Book Analysis

947 words - 4 pages ; Blacky symbolizes what it means to have true courage, as he stands up for what he believes in and refuses to succumb to the pressures of his small-minded community. The author, Phillip Gwynne, wrote this book portraying Blackys true courage through learning to stand up for himself, being subjective to the lack of support towards the Indigenous people and by learning the importance of following his heart by making respectable --> [Author:jrp