Success In Gangster Movies Now And Then Through Robert Warshow's "The Gangster As Tragic Hero"

1572 words - 6 pages

"In the deeper layers of the modern consciousness, all means are unlawful, every attempt to succeed is an act of aggression, leaving one alone and guilty and defenseless among enemies: one is punished for success."Robert WarshowThis is a quote from the famous essay "The Gangster as Tragic Hero", a "classic example of film criticism and cultural analysis". The essay was published for the first time in 1962 in Robert Warshow's book "The Immediate Experience". In it the author examines some of the generally accepted conventions that most gangster movies follow and draws conclusions from them about the reasons and the way this genre appeals to the audience.The quote represents one of the main ideas of Warshow's argument - it shows the attitude of the mass public towards success. According to Warshow, we need to be able to "acquiesce in our failure". He says that we have one intolerable dilemma: "failure is kind of death and success is evil and dangerous, is - ultimately - impossible", and the resolution of this dilemma by the gangster's death makes us feel safe. He also argues that the gangster is doomed "because he is under the obligation to succeed" and claims that "he is what we want to be and what we are afraid we may become". The author gives us the reasons for the inevitable failure of the gangster. These are "the very conditions of success". He states that success is established by imposing the individual on the others, by drawing himself out of the crowd. And what dies is not some anonymous man but "the individual with a name, the gangster, the success". The gangster is doomed for his attempt to be something more, to be above the others, above the crowd. But the general public is "the crowd". Most of us are ordinary people with everyday lives. We all dream of being successful but in most cases we are not. And that's why we need the gangster. To help us cope with our failure. He exemplifies the impossibility of success. Now "we can choose to fail".One of the best illustrations of this view about the gangster movies is Brian DePalma's 1983 remake of "Scarface". In it Tony Montana, portrayed by Al Pacino, who starts from being kept in a camp for Cuban immigrants, gradually becomes one of the biggest mafia bosses with enormous million-dollar profit. But then follows the inevitable failure. He has a break up with one of his partners who send people to kill him. He kills his best friend and his sister for having an affair. Even his wife leaves him. At the end we see him alone against the whole world. At the end he fights alone and dies alone - a typical Warshow type of gangster.There is one particular scene that exemplifies the beginning of the end. After this scene we all know that Tony Montana is doomed. It takes place in a fancy restaurant. He is shown drunk and on drugs. First he has a fight with his wife and she leaves. Then he overturns the table and addresses the people in the restaurant, who watch him astounded and appalled:"You're all a...

Find Another Essay On Success in gangster movies now and then through Robert Warshow's "The Gangster as Tragic Hero"

The Big Lebowski and American Gangster

1381 words - 6 pages I have decided to analyze the film Underworld: Awakening in terms of the three act structure and then compare it to two other films that we watched in class, namely: The Big Lebowski and American Gangster. This movie was the fourth in the Underworld sequel and was released on January 20th, 2012. It was among the first films to garner more $ 100 million in revenues during that year. It was also the most watched of the four films in the

The Change of the Gangster Genre

1267 words - 5 pages visual splendor for the emotional story. Al Pacino also narrates his own film which makes the viewer be on his side a lot of the time as we only se his views and life through Carlito's eyes. Carlito is dressed quiet smartly in black suits and ties whereas his other gangster mates sometimes dressed in colourful clothes, totally keeping them and Carlito apart. The start of the film starts with weird and unusual camera

Frank Lucas: The Nefarious American Gangster

1074 words - 5 pages behavior into the executive leadership position of an infamous and democratic gangster. Through the character of Frank Lucas, the movie referred to the leadership concepts of power motive, business knowledge, and the dark sides of charismatic leadership. Soon after Bumpy dies, Frank becomes captivated by power such that it consumes him and forces him to commit his wicked acts. He is a stern character who believes that “you are who you are in this

Romeo's role in "Romeo and Juliet" as the tragic hero.

569 words - 2 pages by the chorus tells the stories conclusion, six distinctive characteristics of a tragic hero is exemplified through the novel that a reader should look for while attempting to identify the tragic hero - noble stature, tragic flaw, free choice, the punishment exceeds the crime, increased awareness, and produces catharsis. Although Romeo, the tragic hero of the novel, displays examples of all six elements, in the following analysis, three elements

The Declaration Then And Now

1333 words - 5 pages The Declaration Then and Now      The year was sixteen hundred and eighty-nine and a man by the name of John Locke wrote Second Treatise on Government (Zinn 73). In it, Locke wrote that in a natural state everyone, all people, are born free and equal, and possess certain rights. He said that these “natural rights” were life, liberty, and property. He also said that the evildoers who conspired to deprive others of their

The Transformation: Then and Now

2197 words - 9 pages world mercy would mean absolutely nothing because it would become an everyday occurrence. Another correlation in the poems lies between jealousy and pity. Both are portrayed as having a human face, which puts forth the idea that both of these feelings require some form of “seeing” what another person has or what they are going through. Jealousy is also a quality that opposes pity because jealousy is resentment of another’s success and pleasure

Oedipus as a Tragic Hero in Sophocles’ Oedipus the King

1473 words - 6 pages The tragic hero has served as the foundation of Greek tragedy since its inception in ancient times. He or she serves as a rallying point for the audience to cheer for and mourn with throughout the story, and ultimately teaches the audience a lesson about human vulnerability and strength through defeat. A tragic hero is “a privileged, exalted character of high repute, who, by virtue of a tragic flaw and fate, suffers a fall from glory into

Antigone or Creon as the Tragic Hero in Antigone

754 words - 3 pages A tragic hero is a character in a play that is known for being dignified but has a flaw that assists in his or her downfall. Antigone is a Greek tragic piece written by Sophocles. In the theatrical production the use of power and morality versus law is evident. The promotion to the conflict was that Creon created a law in which enabled Polynieces, Antigone’s brother, to be buried in the proper way. As it is the way of the gods Antigone found it

Marcus Brutus as the Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

1280 words - 5 pages Brutus as the Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar Because of Shakespeare's popularity among scholars and literary critics, his plays have been studied time after time. In the four hundred or so years since they were written, Shakespeare's plays and other literary masterpieces have been categorized. Many of them, including Shakespeare's portrayal of Julius Caesar's murder and the resulting events for Rome and for Caesar's

The Knights of Now and Then

1013 words - 4 pages of people not knowing if you are going to be a success or failure.Truth is defined as being true. In my life view this means being true and honest to yourself, your team, your school. Honor is defined as high regard or respect, good reputation, integrity, and adherence to principles considered right. Truth and honor go hand in hand because on the football field you wouldn’t intentionally hurt someone or take cheap shots. You tackle the

Microwaves: Then, Now, and the Future

586 words - 2 pages Microwave ovens were once though of as evil and cancer causing. That view has changed dramatically as the microwave went from an experiment, to what we know today, and will continue to advance years into the future. The purpose of this paper is to give some insight into the past, present, and future of the little box that cooks our food oh-so-quickly - the microwave oven.The technology used in making the first microwave was accidentally

Similar Essays

Robert Ross Tragic Hero ("The Wars").

835 words - 3 pages is flawed, as we all are, and whose flaws widen as war goes on. By traditional definition, hero is someone who is larger than life, someone who possesses great strength and courage. Was Robert Ross, the protagonist of "The Wars", a hero? First answer that comes to mind is "no", but the more one thinks about it, the more he starts to believe that Robert indeed was a hero, though not a traditional one. Although Robert Ross does not blindly follow

Antigone Vs Creon As Tragic Hero In Sophocles's "Antigone". Quotes Taken From Harcourt/ Dudley Fitts And Robert Fitzgerald Translation.

748 words - 3 pages result of the tragic flaw of the real tragic hero, Creon. By focusing the play on the tragic heroism of Creon but having the foil of his character as the protagonist, Antigone, Sophocles creates a vision of tragedy which is as complex as the human condition it explores. Sophocles raises the question of man's ultimate place in the universe with two characters, each representing different strata of the human spirit, torn between mortal and immortal law, free will and fate. He answers with the tragedy of Creon, who in the end finds wisdom and learns through his own suffering.

Evolution Of The Gangster And America

1520 words - 7 pages Public Enemy with Tom Powers life story. Powers wants more for himself, and is raised to think that only way to do so is through crime. As said by Edward Mitchell, “his chief weapons in his struggle are the manly fortitude, traditional virtues… and the continuous stream of fortuitous circumstances” (Barry 220). This ideal cemented by Horatio Alger myth, the American Dream, is apparent in both Tom Powers and Frank Lucas. In American Gangster, Lucas

Money, Power And Respect: The Gangster Life

2418 words - 10 pages author Shadoian indicates that "The gangster/crime genre documents America as a failure. The experience of failure…its myths are used up. The frontier is closed; there is no place left. America is prematurely middle-aged and must face its middle- aged problems.( Shadoian 238)" This brings the conflict and chaos in the life of dreamers, and not all the people who come with the dream want to go through the trouble of hard working, and all they