Suffering In Photographs Essay

1512 words - 6 pages

Suffering in Photographs

Photographs are used to document history, however selected images are chosen to do so. Often times these images graphically show the cruelty of mankind. In her book, Regarding the Pain of Others, Susan Sontag asks, "What does it mean to protest suffering, as distinct from acknowledging it?" To acknowledge suffering is just to capture it, to point it out and show somebody else that it exists. In order to protest suffering, there has to be some sort of moral decision that what is shown in the photograph is wrong, and a want from the viewer to change that.

Sontag says that throughout history, things focused on in art and history tend to be the "product of wrath, divine or human." There is much art showing the suffering of Christ and the executions of Christian martyrs. These pictures are supposed to bring up emotion strong enough to make people have faith. "The viewer may commiserate with the sufferer's pain . . . feel admonished or inspired to model faith and fortitude." This is an example of protesting suffering. There are also many violent and disturbing things shown in the pagan myths. These are different because "no moral charge attaches to the

representation of these cruelties." So in that case, suffering is being acknowledged, but only to see if you can bare to look at it.

Sontag points out that it is much different to have a piece of art which shows a made up cruelty as apposed to a photograph which shows the close up of an actual person in the middle of a painful event. She says, "perhaps the only people with the right to look at images of suffering of this extreme order are those who could do something to alleviate it." She is saying that unless we have a way to stop the suffering, our looking at it has no purpose except to satisfy some part of human nature, which makes us interested and unable to look away from horror. This strange need is not a new thing, since this focus on violence went all the way back to Christian and pagan art.

In war, photography and art again serve the purpose of acknowledging and sometimes protesting suffering. In the First World War cameras were used for military intelligence, to capture an event. "The caption of a photograph is traditionally neutral informative: a date, a place, names." A photograph is supposed to just record what happened and not takes sides. However, "it is always the image that someone chose; to photograph is to frame, and to frame is to exclude." So the photograph is supposed to be neutral, but the photographer is still deciding what details to focus on. The caption has just facts on it, because supposedly that is what the photograph is recording. While it is true that photographs cannot explain everything themselves, they do serve as visual aids to, what otherwise be, a pallid world.

Goya was an artist who made etchings called The Disasters Of War. These etchings showed the horrible things that were done by Napoleon's soldiers. They...

Find Another Essay On Suffering in Photographs

Value in Creative Practice Essay

2270 words - 10 pages dying of aids. The photographs that Jennie Gunhammar produced for this series was showing the day to day life and struggle of; her twin sister Jessie and her partner Stan, who are both suffering from different diseases. Jennie Gunhammar along with her twin sister Jessie was born in Sweden in 1975. They then later on in 1992 moved to London to educate themselves. Jennie and Jessie then at the age of 20 in 1995 started to do some modelling to support

A Risen Hell: Capturing memorable moments

969 words - 4 pages photographs in general, or photographs of civilians caught in the middle of conflicts. For many people, the photographs of the concentration camps, which came out only after World War II, were too much. The suffering and death at these and other concentration camps were greater than any before endured. These photographs may be the most shocking ever published. After them there could be equally graphic horrors (such as the Columbine tragedy for

The Works Progress Administration

1063 words - 5 pages captured the lives of those who suffered greatly with the Great Depression hovering over them, but also the emotions that these people felt. Russell Lee, like Dorothea Lange and Walker Evans found his opportunity to prosper during the Great Depression with his photographs that would document the average American life suffering the wrath of the Depression from either unemployment or lack of home or even both. Lee’s photography ranges from themes of

Dorothea Lange: A Photographer

1584 words - 6 pages respected by many. "She found dignity, strength of character, and fortitude in the midst of suffering, and her remarkable ability to capture the human spirit so ennobled her photographs that many of them, though noted in time and place, are timeless" (Newall 7). She left a great impression on the people of the 1930s; Her photographs will continue to capture the hearts of the people in the present and the future, for her photographs will remain a

War Photographer

740 words - 3 pages taking pictures of the war, while seeing everyone, he can now sit in his darkroom (a room where photographs are processed) almost isolated from the outside world, and ready to look at the developing cold, gruesome photographs that he has taken. In the second line of the first stanza , the writer is said to quote: "with spools of suffering set out in ordered rows". The words "spools of suffering" suggest to me that the photographs are

Dorothea Lange. Biography and analysis of Dorothea Lange and her work

1425 words - 6 pages , and is still respected by many. She found dignity, strength of character, and fortitude in the midst of suffering, and her remarkable ability to capture the human spirit so ennobled her photographs that many of them, though noted in times and place, are timeless .BibliographyAbbey, Susannah. "Artist Hero: Dorothea Lange." My Hero. 12 Feb. 2007. ."Eight Women Who Came to the Front." Women Come to the Front. 7 July 2005. Library of Congress. Oct

Richard Avedon

1286 words - 6 pages , the expressions were real. Avedon captured them exactly as he wanted, the loss of mankind seen across their faces. In 1974 his intense portraits of his terminally ill father were exhibited at the Museum of Modern Art. The bitterness he had towards his father for the neglect he showed him as a child came through the photos. But there is more than just that in the photographs, there is tenderness because they reflect man’s suffering. Many

Frozen Memories

1094 words - 5 pages Photos speak when there are no words and gives insight to the past. The Great Depression and dustbowl caused unimaginable suffering which gave photojournalism the perfect platform to become popular. Dorothea Lange and Walker Evans’ works influenced photography as a whole. Photojournalism has enhanced the newspapers through images. Photography in the 20s and 30s revolutionized photography today through the dustbowl, and efforts of Dorothea Lange

Fsa Photography During the Great Depression

1230 words - 5 pages shot, believed he could find beauty in any situation including a poverty stricken farm house. Many critics feared the photographers went too far in their attempts. One such critic stated, "What you've got are not photographers. They're a bunch of sociologists with cameras." These critics used these photographs as evidence against the New Deal saying that it was simply an attempt to overstate the tragedies caused by the Great Depression. "By

Nan Goldin

1900 words - 8 pages visual diary of the surrogate family that I found in New York. After viewing Goldin's work I felt increasingly confident in my ability to produce personal and intimate photographs about my life. Goldin has documented her life through the joy, laughter, and lovemaking, to the pain, vulnerability, and the loss of loved ones. Her images capture mundane everyday life moments as well as personal life changing dramas. I felt a personal connection to many


2180 words - 9 pages 1 DO WE NEED WAR PHOTOGRAPHY If we need to understand the concept of war you must realize that death and destruction falls within that notion, but why do we need to produce images of people dying and suffering, do we have the right to photograph this? I believe that we the inhabitants of this world have the right to see images in direct response to the decisions government’s policies, whether or not we can make a difference. We of our

Similar Essays

How Photography Helped Change People's Opinions Of The Civil War

1131 words - 5 pages through some author’s point of view which usually contained useless bias, people were able to look at photographs and criticize the written propaganda about the good outcomes of comes, since most of the photographs depicted death and destruction. Furthermore, Matthew Brady’s opening of the civil war photo gallery in New York City in 1862 gave more and more people the access to experience war through realistic photographs which changed many

How Is Suffering Presented In The Poem ‘War Photographer’?

954 words - 4 pages word choice of mass is significant using it in the context of those less fortunate suffering. There is also a mention of ‘ordered rows’ which could represent graves. This presents the aftermath of suffering. But the word is used when talking about ‘spools of suffering’ suggesting the photographs present suffering and how suffering can never be ordered. Suffering is also presented when talking about the ‘editor’ back in ‘Rural England’ and how he

Why Is Retouching Photographs Necessary? Essay

1316 words - 6 pages Manipulating photographs have been around for years, but it has been increasingly more controversial in recent times. Celebrities and models are retouched in various forms—photographs, online advertisements, magazines, and more. There are more forms of advertisements today than ever before. Technology is becoming more and more advanced. With more advanced technology come more consumers, ranging in all ages. Younger generations are becoming more

The Relationship Of Photographs, History, And Memory

5350 words - 21 pages the photograph is also a process of destabilizing memory resulting--perhaps more importantly--in superimposing a new text, that is, the memory of the act of violence itself. Consequently, photographs and the incision merge irrevocably to reproduce a different memory as history and biography are reconfigured permanently by the thrust of the bayonet. While injuries to the human body heal--with scars to remember pain and suffering--the strike to