Suffrage For The People: A Report On The Electoral College And Possible Alternatives

1795 words - 7 pages

Suffrage For the People?When our nation was in it's infancy nearly 300 years ago, our founding fathers had a dream of a government that served the people. While they wanted to have this government's positions filled by popularly elected officials, our founders felt the American public did not know enough of politics to rest the decision solely on their shoulders. Recently The Electoral College has come under fire about whether the feudal system is still effective or if it should be changed for a direct popular vote. Many officials have taken sides on the issue and both sides have well-established reasons to both get rid of the College and keep it. There have been several key issues which politicians have taken sides over; some are recent issues while others are dated and classic flaws. There are three arguments that seem to raise the most controversy; they are public interaction with the current system, the balance of voting power granted to the smaller states, and several minor flaws that add up to a generally big problem. The Electoral College is considered by many to be an archaic and non-Democratic system while others hail it as a fair and just system for choosing the next American president.When looking at the effectiveness of the Electoral College, some people question the interaction with the public that the debate would produce. Under the current system of voting, "candidates only have to travel to 14 or 18 states, as in recent elections, which still produce a majority of the votes" (Phillips 67). This current system requires far less money from supporters and is better at decreasing the fear that those with money really have control over who will be next in the White House. If a wealthy person really wanted a candidate to win, they would simply give large amounts of money to that person's campaign - increasing voter awareness. Likewise, "within those 14 to 18 states," candidates really "campaign hard," and this "creates a closer person-to-candidate ratio, which allows that section of the public to get fairly acquainted with their future president" ("Analysis"). If candidates had to campaign nation-wide it would require much more money and there would be a raised voter-to-candidate ratio, roughly 273,000,000:1. But, as with all issues, there are always two sides and each is entitled to their forum.Those who wish to change the current Electoral College system to a direct popular vote hold the other side of this issue. "If the electoral vote were eliminated, there would no longer be any pressure upon the candidates to impress those states, which hold the most electoral votes leaving a much broader area to attract voters" (Hansen 1). Of course, this would simply leave the most populated states in a more likely chance to be campaigned in but a candidate could also go around the smaller states gaining individual support that way. Through this direct popular vote, a candidate would be more encouraged to make this voter-to-president ratio much...

Find Another Essay On Suffrage for the People: A Report on the Electoral College and possible alternatives

The Electoral College Essay

2395 words - 10 pages States are indirect popular elections. Even though voters cast their ballots for the presidential candidate, they are really voting for a group of electors who pledge to vote for a particular candidate. (Project Vote Smart) This group known as the Electoral College is made up of 538 citizens who are responsible for voting on behalf of their states and it is this group that actually chooses the president. The number of electoral votes is based on

The Electoral College Essay

1191 words - 5 pages Mackenzie Marquess Professor Beange Govt 2305 23 October 2013 Electoral College Outline The Electoral College is a system that elects the president, it is possible for a presidential candidate to win the popular votes of the citizens and still lose the election because of the electoral college, a prime example of this rare happening is the election of 2000 where George Bush lost the popular vote to Al Gore but still won the votes of the

The Electoral College

946 words - 4 pages vice president are elected have been made.One set of proposals looks towards keeping the Electoral College but eliminating its winner-take-all features. This shift could bebrought about by choosing most electors on a congressional district basis, with only two electors per state chosen state wide. A1969 Maine Law provides for this method, and similar legislation has been considered in several other states. Alternatively, theoffice of elector could

Abolishing the Electoral College

748 words - 3 pages votes should be synchronized due to the fact that Electoral College is a body of people who represent each state. Also, the election does not have to be between only two parties for competition wise. The lack of equality from popular vote to electoral votes and the lack of power the 3rd party can have is why the Electoral College should be eliminated. The electoral vote favors large states like Texas and California. The sway they can produce is

The Electoral College - 1192 words

1192 words - 5 pages electoral votes to cause an inability of any candidate to gain an absolute majority. Winston Churchill once said, "the electoral college system is probably the worst possible method of choosing a president except for all the others" (Wikman 2). The system as it stands has only failed our nation a handful of times and never caused the United States a catastrophe. The nation has always gone on. Until someone can come up with a system that does not

The Electoral College - 1010 words

1010 words - 4 pages select the president (Wikipedia The Free Encyclopedia n.d.). The compromise was to set up an Electoral College system that allowed voters to vote for electors, who would then cast their votes for candidates, a system destined to change our beloved America forever.The Electoral College came to be at the Constitutional Convention in 1787. Our founding fathers wanted to create a system that consisted of checks and balances for two main reasons. Firstly

Elimintating the Electoral College

1661 words - 7 pages for most politically motivated Representatives and Senators to even give the issue much thought. No mainstream politician would support an initiative that would drastically reduce, if not entirely shatter, their permanent grasp on political power. Such an amendment would have to originate and be ratified by the states. A reasonable and solvent amendment would abolish the electoral college by repealing Article II, section I of the Constitution

The Electoral College - 733 words

733 words - 3 pages of representatives that state has in Congress. Arizona, for example, has eight electors because it has six representatives in the House of Representatives and two in the Senate. This guarantees that every state has at least three electors. A popular election in each state determines which party the electors will be chosen from, and all electoral votes from the state will go to that party. The electoral college is the best way to elect the

The Electoral College System

1413 words - 6 pages based on percentage and multi-member district. Electoral College consists of 538 electors. To become a president 270 or more votes are required. However, if none of the candidate gets 270 votes, then the House of Representatives would select the president. I argue against Electoral College system. First of all, people are not voting directly for the President or the Vice President. A pure form of democracy is in which people exercise direct power

Pros and Cons of the Electoral College

970 words - 4 pages . Overall, Professor Best implies that the Electoral College is important because it creates a balance in popular sovereignty here in the United States. The source that state the governmental power rests within the people and that the government exists for the benefit of its citizens creates the Electoral College to be viewed as a system that guide citizens choose the right President to govern through an election system that serves to balance local

The Electoral College - 834 words

834 words - 3 pages conclusion, one can see the various flaws of the Electoral College and realize that the winner take all policy is unfair to our democracy. Popular vote will ensure that whom the public desires as president will be carried out. Proportional representation will lead to more ideas being dealt with and will involve many more people in politics. Hopefully the public can fight for a change in our flawed system and improve democracy in our country

Similar Essays

The Electoral College: A Blemish On Democracy

1159 words - 5 pages college is a system of electing the president where the people choose electors to vote for them. Each state has a certain number of electoral votes. This number is based upon population. The higher the population, the more electoral votes. The people vote and the electors can choose whether or not to base their vote on the peoples' choice. The electors vote, and all the electoral votes are given to the candidate who earned the majority of those

Electoral College. A Persuasive Essay On Reasons Why The Electoral College Should Be Changed

1025 words - 4 pages become purely advertisementcampaigns. (third party times)But there are a few serious flaws in the electoral college that need to be dealtwith. For example, the well known Democratic motto "one man, one vote," (whichmeans every vote counts) doesn't apply to presidential elections because of the EC.The electoral college makes it possible for a candidate who wins the popular vote ofthe people to lose the presidency. (electoral college)This has

The Need For Electoral College Reform

1170 words - 5 pages constituents reflect the diversity of the states themselves and elucidate the complications of change on a national level to this system. Direct election would be one option but it’s major disadvantage is that candidates may ignore smaller states because their campaign stops’ value is proportional to the concentration of people there. The electoral college, then, can be seen as a compromise between large and small states very much like the “Great

A Speech Disputing The Electoral College

1112 words - 4 pages .          Transition: Now lets move on to how the Electoral College imposes unfairness today. Get ready because I am going to be throwing out a lot of figures. 1. The first major problem with the Electoral College is the winner take all system. According to Dahl, a professor at Yale, in his recent book, it reduces the incentives of candidates to compete for votes in "safe" states, reduces the incentives of potential third party candidates and