This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Summary Of For Gay Marriage Essay

1106 words - 4 pages

Summary of "For Gay Marriage"In his essay "For Gay Marriage," Andrew Sullivan argues that marriage isn't and has never been, in his view just a "private contract" between two people, and that now marriage is seen as a social and public recognition of such a commitment (404). Sullivan argues that to refuse homosexuals the right to marry is a public offense to their rights and equality as citizens. Sullivan makes the case in his essay that homosexual couples deserve the same rights, the right to marry, because they are just as capable of fulfilling the requirements of marriage as heterosexuals.Throughout his essay Sullivan argues that marriage should be allowed between any two people. He explains that marriage can no longer just be defined in the narrow sense as between a man and a woman, rather it has to be viewed in a broader perspective as it is an "emotional, financial, and psychological bond between two people", who are consenting adults who are not closely related to one another (404). Sullivan makes the argument that marriage should not be denied to same sex couples because marriage is no longer viewed in our society as being for the sole function of procreation. It no longer matters if a couple has children or not, so why should whether or not a couple can have children be a stipulation that keeps the right to marry from homosexual couples. Sullivan finally asserts that marriage is an emotional commitment by two people for life, and that it requires sacrifice, commitment, and responsibility. He argues that by that definition one cannot believe in equality for all and still believe that homosexuals should not be allowed to marry.In his essay Sullivan also introduces and argues the point, one that comes from the conservative side, that domestic partnerships undermine the idea of marriage. Many cities across the United States recognize relationships that do not fit into the mold of a heterosexual marriage and give them benefits that previously had been set aside for heterosexual couples. Some of these benefits include health insurance, adoption, pension and inheritance rights. Sullivan states that conservatives worry about the ease of such a relationship. All domestic partners have to do is be able to prove is that they share living spaces, a financial connection , and that they are both committed to caring for one another. A domestic partnership doesn't have to include a sexual relationship or even resemble and "old-style" marriage (405) either; this means that anyone, homosexual or heterosexual, could qualify for a domestic partnership. Even an "elderly woman and her live-in nurse" or even "two frat buddies" (405) could qualify. While still only heterosexual couples in many states can be married. You're either married or you're not, it's a simple question, Sullivan states. However, domestic partnerships lay in a grey area and are hard to define. This Sullivan believes makes homosexual couples feel lesser and unequal in that regard. Domestic...

Find Another Essay On Summary of for gay marriage

Legalization of Gay Marriage Essay

1072 words - 4 pages cannot produce a biological child.Lastly, and very important to note, is that gay marriage is not equivalent to a civil union. According to Equality Maryland, "A civil union is a separate and unequal legal institution for same-sex …to avoid allowing same-sex couples to legally marry" ("Equality Maryland"). A civil union does not even come with a status that can be kept outside of specific states, whereas in a marriage a husband and wife are

Issues of Gay Marriage Essay

1192 words - 5 pages equality, liberty and justice for all. A government should not be able to prohibit any one person from declaring his or her love for someone else. Allowing the government to intervene in gay marriage represents class discrimination, denies marriage benefits, and rejects civil rights. One of the most widely known acts of discrimination would be the Loving vs. Virginia case. This case involves an interracial marriage, which was against the law in

Support of Gay Marriage

1785 words - 7 pages book reviewing civil rights movements. If we get down to numbers, it is shown that same-sex marriage would actually bring in money to state and local government. The profits or revenue from gay marriage comes from the marriage licenses, higher income taxes and decreases in costs for state benefit programs. The cost for a marriage licenses range anywhere from a low of ten dollars to as much as one-hundred and fifteen dollars. As for income taxes

Solution of gay marriage

819 words - 3 pages (2011), "a staggering 90 percent of transgender workers report some form of harassment or mistreatment on the job." Many also have lost their jobs or have been paid unfairly due to their sexuality. Reported by the Huffington Post, "Discrimination, Gay Voices News, A teacher at a private Catholic high school in Pennsylvania says he was fired for getting his gay marriage license on Friday, reports local ABC affiliate WPVI-TV." Many homosexuals are

Legalization of Gay Marriage

972 words - 4 pages conclusion, gay marriage should be legalized in all 50 states. The fact that the Supreme Court has struck down DOMA claiming it unconstitutional shows that many American’s views on this matter is changing for the better. Many heterosexual couples are recognized as married whereas same-sex couples are not leaving them more vulnerable because of the lack of marital benefits provided by the government. To help the transition for same-sex couples

A Critique of "For Gay Marriage," by Andrew Sullivan

523 words - 2 pages , the fact is that he could overcome much of the ambiguity of his presentation by citing more concrete studies, including long-term studies, which support his key points. For example, when he makes the assertion that "in some ways the marriage issue is exactly parallel to the military" (283), it is unclear exactly what he means. Is he referring to prejudice against gay soldiers? On the other hand, is he referring to a common requirement of self

The Legalization of Gay Marriage

918 words - 4 pages . LaFleur that the, "Freedom of personal choice in the matters of marriage and family life is one of the liberties protected by the Due process Clause." [2] Beyond just constitutional reasons for legalizing gay marriage, there are also economic benefits to it. Revenue is generated by gay marriages from marriage licenses and higher income taxes. It will also decrease the costs for state benefit programs. [3] Furthermore, the Comptroller for NYC

Critque of "Against Gay Marriage"

1597 words - 6 pages Andrew CarrollProf. WesleyEnglish 18510/2/14Critique of "Against Gay Marriage"In his essay "Against Gay Marriage," William Bennett, a great spokesman for conservatives and former Secretary of education under President Reagan, maintains his conservative stance that allowing same-sex couples to marry would have a harmful and lasting effect on our society's intrinsic values and, in his view, would stretch the "fragile" institution of marriage

The Tragedy of Gay Marriage

2073 words - 8 pages general point that gay marriage does not and can’t have “the authority and majesty of the kinship system”(383). Since he sees gay marriage as entirely rooted in the relationship between two people, and he dismisses that as a minor part of the institution of marriage, he predicts this kind of marriage will disappear and will only be remembered with a laugh. This paper does not consider for a second that any marriage apart from one that fulfills

The Importance of Gay Marriage

945 words - 4 pages should see this as a great boon that gay marriage could bring to kids who need nothing more than two loving parents“ (Klein). I completely agree with Klein’s statement, and believe that adoption is one of the biggest pro’s for same-sex marriage. A family doesn’t need to have a male and female parent. All children really need is parents who will nurture, care and love them, and same-sex couples are certainly capable of being exceptional parents

The Legalizaiton of Gay Marriage

1195 words - 5 pages prohibiting same-sex marriage are involving both church and state together and creating politicians out of those who had never before been interested. One avid churchgoer stated of gay marriage, “It’s not a civil right, it’s a moral wrong.” One Pastor spoke out and said “I think this is the ultimate avalanche if we let go of this foundational concept of a marriage between a man and woman as the foundation for family life.” (Wehmeyer, par

Similar Essays

Gay Marriage Summary Essay

944 words - 4 pages to urge the court to uphold Proposition 8. These religious organizations believe that recognizing gay marriage would interfere with the religious freedom of those who oppose it. There were some religious groups, however, who opposed the accusations saying same-sex marriage interfered with religious freedom. Gay rights groups in the United States are focusing on getting approval from state governments to pass gay rights bills and allow for gay

For Gay Marriage Essay

759 words - 4 pages In Andrew Sullivan’s article, "For Gay Marriage,” he appears to be so fully committed to democratic values that he seeks to extend equal rights in marriage to homosexuals. And he makes an admirable case for equality and dignity for all people, including homosexuals. Instead of begging the question or avoiding the issue, which is seen in many politic debates, Sullivan tries to persuade conservatives about the emotional, financial, and

Legalization Of Gay Marriage Essay

1585 words - 7 pages Legalization of gay marriage has been a major controversial topic for a long time. Although, many people do not know what it means to be homosexual, most people do not know the actual definition of homosexuality and they do not know how difficult it is to be gay in this society. There are many reasons why people are against gay marriage and homosexuals all together. Most of the reasons are based on religious bias another big reason is being

Legalization Of Gay Marriage Essay 1072 Words

1072 words - 4 pages cannot produce a biological child.Lastly, and very important to note, is that gay marriage is not equivalent to a civil union. According to Equality Maryland, "A civil union is a separate and unequal legal institution for same-sex …to avoid allowing same-sex couples to legally marry" ("Equality Maryland"). A civil union does not even come with a status that can be kept outside of specific states, whereas in a marriage a husband and wife are