Sympathy In Beowulf Essay

1379 words - 6 pages

While the classic battle between good and evil forces is a major theme of the medieval epic Beowulf, one may question whether these good and evil forces are as black and white as they appear. Scholars such as Herbert G. Wright claim that “the dragon, like the giant Grendel, is an enemy of mankind, and the audience of Beowulf can have entertained no sympathy for either the one or the other” (Wright, 4). However, other scholars such as Andy Orchard disagree with this claim, and believe that there is “something deeply human about the ‘monsters’” (Orchard, 29). While Grendel, Grendel’s mother, and the dragon are indeed portrayed as evil and violent foes, there are parts within Beowulf that can also lead a reader to believe that the “monsters” may not be so monstrous after all. In fact, the author of Beowulf represents the “monsters” within the poem with a degree of moral ambivalence. This ambivalence ultimately evokes traces of sympathy in the reader for the plight of these “monster” figures, and blurs the fine line between good and evil within the poem.
The first opponent Beowulf must face in the land of the Danes is Grendel, textually described as “a fiend out of hell … [a] grim demon / haunting the marches, / marauding round the heath / and the desolate fens” (Beowulf, line 100 – 104). The author also provides us with a moral description, explaining how Grendel is “merciless … malignant by nature, he never showed remorse” (line 135-137). As we can see here, the author’s physical and moral portrayal of Grendel is rather unforgiving. We also resent Grendel further once we learn that he has wreaked havoc upon the Heorot hall for twelve years, “inflicting constant cruelties on the people / atrocious hurt” (line 165).
One may wonder what caused Grendel to commit such atrocities. The author claims “it harrowed [Grendel] / to hear the din of the loud banquet / every day in the hall, the harp being struck / and the clear song of a skilled poet / telling with mastery of man’s beginnings, / how the Almighty had made the earth” (line 87 – 93). The raucous feasts and joyous celebrations within Heorot make the reader believe that Grendel is attacking the hall out of envy, an emotion generally associated with wickedness. However, ambivalent lines such as: “Grendel waged his lonely war” offer the possibility of dual meanings (line 164). Grendel is waging his war alone, but also waging his war due to his loneliness. If Grendel is indeed attacking Heorot due to his loneliness and misery, which are probably caused by his exile, then one may begin to question whether Grendel is as evil and malignant as the author claims. Grendel may not have been acting out of pure evil, but out of grief. Signe M. Carlson elaborates on the portrayal of Grendel’s moral ambivalence in the fight with Beowulf, explaining how Grendel’s “enormous strength, wrestling ability, and blood-thirsty cannibalism are contrasted with his very real pain and anguish on having his arm wrenched off...

Find Another Essay On Sympathy in Beowulf

Christianity and Paganism in the Epic of Beowulf

1844 words - 7 pages Christian virtues being instilled upon the listeners. The good qualities of loyalty, humility, sacrifice for the good of others, and sympathy for those less fortunate are seen woven into the text as well as the negative consequences from greed and pride. The characters of Grendel, his mother, and the dragon are tools used by the author to teach values, but also to rejoice in the legendary success of Beowulf. The menacing character of Grendel

Loyalty and Treasure-Seeking in Beowulf Essay

2182 words - 9 pages of Beowulf’s woes and dark thoughts, operates as an interesting mirror to Beowulf. Despite the hellish connotations associated with dragons, the poet shows an unusual ambivalence in tone when describing the dragon, a tone that can be best described as a volatile mixture of awe, fear and sympathy: When the dragon awoke, trouble flared again. He rippled down the rock, writhing with anger When he saw the footprints of the prowler who had stolen

Christianity and Fatalism in Beowulf

2573 words - 10 pages Christian audience, a sympathy that might be lost if the heathen character of the heroes was emphasized. (Cavill 28).There are specific allusions in Beowulf not just to Christianity in general, but specifically to Old Testament as well, which suggest that the intended audience was already quite familiar with the Bible. The most important mention of the Old Testament that is prominent in the storyline is the fact that Grendel is said to be the offspring

Grendel Vs. Beowulf

921 words - 4 pages Grendel      One of the most compelling and highly developed characters in the novel Grendel, written by John Gardner, and the poem Beowulf, written by an anonymous poet, is the monster, Grendel. Even though these pieces show two different sides to Grendel they are similar in many ways. Grendel evokes sympathy toward the hideous monster by making him seem like the victim, while Beowulf portrays him as being the most

Grendel's Mother's Attack

744 words - 3 pages at Heorot, now that the she-monster has sought "payment" for the death of her son. Yet since she and her son are monsters, the thanes feel little sympathy. In this scene we also see the pointlessness of the blood feuds, especially in the line, "This was not a good bargain, that on both sides they had to pay with the lives of friends." (Norton, page 44.) For twelve long years Hrothgar's men were murdered. Beowulf put a stop to the madness when

A broadening perspective of the hero's journey

807 words - 4 pages The hero's journey is the typical path the hero in a mythological adventure follows and is typically characterized by certain key stages. In the Anglo-Saxon poem, Beowulf, the hero's journey can be characterized through a valiant warrior as he quells evil and protects his people but the hero's journey does not necessarily require itself to be seen through the eyes of a inherently righteous man. A few hundred years later writers still made great


1257 words - 5 pages in both these extracts, I would say, that in "Grendel" the author seems to feel a kind of sympathy towards the monster. The author associates him with personality, he describes him as he could think, feel, fear as a human being. In this extract we can see the conflicts and characteristics that are characteristic for humans. In "Beowulf" Grendel is associated with monster. He comes, kills and eats people.There is a suspense in John Gardner's

The Finn Episode in Beowulf

1571 words - 6 pages draw sympathy from certain characters in Beowulf. The emotions that Hildeburh experiences are extreme. At no other point in Beowulf are women described as having feelings. Wealhtheow is only mention to give a description of how women were viewed at the time. The presence of women were used to bring peace between tribes through marriage. But nobody knows how Wealhtheow feels about that because it is not brought up. The other woman in the

Point Of View In Grendel And Beowulf

1145 words - 5 pages Contrasting points of view in Grendel and Beowulf significantly alter the reader’s perception of religion, good and evil, and the character Grendel. John Gardner’s book, Grendel, is written in first person. The book translated by Burton Raffel, Beowulf, is written in third person. Good and evil is one of the main conflicts in the poem Beowulf. How is Grendel affected by the concepts of good and evil? Grendel is an alienated individual who just

My notes from class over Beowulf.

798 words - 3 pages hates happiness *Scop is the author of Beowulf. Scop means storyteller *Beowulf is not a Christian poem *Evil dweller wants to be isolated and away from others *Uncontrollable rage that gets out *Has no dignity and is a coward and hurts people when not looking *It opposes the actions of the community whatever he does *Grendel is a betrayer and betrayal is the worst crime you can commit in this time period *Line 168 *2. epic hero-physically more

Beowulf and Grendel

2326 words - 9 pages Beowulf and Grendel Beowulf and Grendel are actually the same stories in the fact that they are based on the same epic "Beowulf." "Beowulf", that is told of here is translated by Kevin Crossley-Holland, and there are many different translations which makes Beowulf the epic so interchangeable. Although "Beowulf" and "Grendel" seem very similar they do have many differences as well. Reading the two stories back to back gives you the

Similar Essays

Do The Evil Deserve Sympathy In Grendel Or Beowulf?

1143 words - 5 pages According to Sympathy can be defined as “the fact or power of sharing the feelings of another, esp. in sorrow or trouble; fellow feeling, compassion, or commiseration.” ( Pertinently this definition, as well as the information provided after reading both, The Poem Beowulf translated by Burton Raffel. and the novel Grendel by John Gardner, it appears evident that the character Grendel

Curiosity In Grendel By John Gardner And Beowulf And Grendel, By Sturla Gunnarsson

1185 words - 5 pages Grendel and his personality in the book allows one to show sympathy for Grendel. Conflicting views of the book are shown in the movie where Beowulf is seen as personable because of his search for the truth about Grendel’s past instead of simply killing him. Grendel in the book and Beowulf in the movie both show their intelligence and curiosity which helps the reader or viewer to relate to and respect these characters. The conflicting views of

The Characters' Personalities In "Grendel" And "Beowulf"

1057 words - 4 pages the simplest of fights. When first introduced in the poem Beowulf, it’s hard to feel sympathy for Unferth because he is in verbal conflict with Beowulf, insulting Beowulf. When switching to the outside view in the book Grendel, it becomes apparent that Unferth isn’t just doing this to pick a fight. Grendel has been his arch enemy ever since the twelve year war started. Unferth was embarrassed and infuriated in his first meeting with Grendel when

Two Grendels Essay

587 words - 2 pages monster and not much more. He appears more evil and you don’t give him much sympathy as you do for the Grendel in Gardner’s novel. The poet describes Grendel as, “The shepherd of evil, guardian of crime” (Beowulf 750) showing what he is suppose to be seen as and who he is. Also, in Beowulf Grendel didn’t slip on any blood like in the novel, he was wrestled down by Beowulf, which the poet said, “Grendel saw that his strength was deserting him…his