Synoptic Problem Essay

2256 words - 10 pages

To understand the synoptic gospels of the New Testament, one must have a clear understanding of what synoptic means. Synoptic is defined as viewing or defining something in a similar manner using various vantage points or sources. The synoptic gospels are the first three gospels within the New Testament: Mark, Matthew, and Luke. These gospels are considered to be synoptic for the vast amount of material that is shared between the three books that is very similar and in some instances almost identical. If one were to place verses from each book side by side regarding certain events they would notice that much of the phrasing and explanation in one book mirrors the phrasing and explanation in ...view middle of the document...

(Harris 156). This method of criticism also provided a possible theory which explained the differing amounts of material between the three gospels. The theory is primarily based on the concept that an additional collection of works named the Q document was the source for the additional materials found in the gospels of Matthew and Luke, which were not included in the gospel of Mark. “Most scholars now agree that Matthew and Luke employed two principal sources in composing their Gospels, Mark and Q” (Harris 156). Although this theory would rationally explain why there are differences between the three gospels, it fails in the fact that there is not a separate Q document that can be produced or that can be seen as its own book within the Bible. This means it is a hypothetical work that’s possible existence can only be validated by reconstructing parts of Matthew and Luke that are absent from the gospel of Mark (Harris 156).
A theory that also contributes to source criticism but is in direct conflict with the Q source document theory is the Griesbach Theory. The main difference between these two theories is their evaluation and interpretation of the importance of the Gospel of Mark as a foundational basis for the synoptic gospels. As indicated above the Q source document theory relies heavily on the idea that both the gospels of Matthew and Luke are
Wisniewski 4

composed using Mark and the Q document as their source. In the Griesbach Theory the Gospel of Mark is considered to be a product of the blending together of the other two synoptic gospels, rather than a foundational source of inspiration. Although most scholars agree with the Q Source Document Theory, each possibility holds its own merit and indicates the importance of source criticism in understanding and providing a possible solution to the synoptic problem.
FORM CRITICISM AND THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM
Form criticism provides a different way of viewing and providing explanation for the synoptic problem. This method of evaluation is based on the premise that each of the gospels was made up of “many individual units – brief narrative episodes, discrete conflict stories, pronouncements, parables, and sayings – that presumably circulated orally and independently of one another before the Gospel authors gathered them together and placed these units in a narrative context” (Harris 118). Form criticism also seeks to clarify the setting and circumstances through which the stories of Jesus originated and the audience that these stories were initially intended for.
In viewing the setting and the circumstances as well as the intended audience for the individual gospels we can understand why there may be some differing material presented in each of the synoptic gospels. By allowing for these differences in small details it made the story of Jesus relatable to a wider range of people. The similarities between the gospels allow for the preservation of the bigger concepts the story of Jesus...

Find Another Essay On Synoptic Problem

The Synoptic Problem in the New Testament Gospels

1545 words - 6 pages The synoptic problem is the basis of historical critical scholarship of the gospels. As a result, the solution to the synoptic problem will influence "one's redaction criticism, and form criticism of the gospels as well as affect the quest for the historical Jesus, early church history, and even the text of the gospels"(Carlson). And the synoptic problem is an examination into the existence and nature of the literary interrelationship among the

The Synoptic Gospels Essay

1035 words - 4 pages The Synoptic Gospels There is no real solution to the synoptic problem. What is the synoptic problem? "The synoptic problem is the existence of which was practically unknown to the ancient ecclesiastical writers as defined in the Catholic encyclopedia" (Synoptics). "These gospels recall the same events of Jesus' life in the same order of succession and in phrases that range from the similar to the identical" (Synoptics)."To grasp the complexity

Program Planning Definitions - St Petersburg College - Homework

732 words - 3 pages ("Program planning", n.d.). Five approaches for the planning process have been identified. These approaches are Synoptic, Incremental, Advocacy, Transactive, or Radical planning. Synoptic Planning Synoptic planning, also called the rational comprehensive approach is the leading practice in planning. Synoptic planning is a step-by-step guide to making decisions and activities. This method is based on a problem-oriented style of planning

Police Administration: Planning, Decision Making, Organizational Communication, and Leadership

1270 words - 6 pages characteristics of its victims and perpetrators (FBI, 2013). As more police and sheriff departments submit their crime data through NIBRS, the departments, along with legislators, municipal planners and administrators, academicians, researchers, and the general public, will be better able to assess the scope of the nation’s crime problem. International Association of Chiefs of Police website, 2013. www.theiacp.org Roberts, N. (2000). The Synoptic Model of Strategic Planning and the GPRA: Lacking a Good Fit with the Political Context. Public Productivity & Management Review. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3380721

The Depiction of the Transfiguration

1219 words - 5 pages The Depiction of the Transfiguration The Transfiguration, depicted with minor variations in Matthew, Mark, and Luke, is an event in which Jesus’ true glory is revealed to the privileged disciples (Peter, James, and John) who were there to witness the event. Our author, Jerome Murphy-O’Connor, O.P., gives us a literary critical perspective on what he believes really happened atop Mt. Tabor in Lower Galilee. As the story in The Synoptic

TLBO ALgorithms and Optimization

977 words - 4 pages Optimization, in simple terms, means minimize the cost incurred and maximize the profit such as resource utilization. EAs are population based metaheuristic (means optimize problem by iteratively trying to improve the solution with regards to given measure of quality) optimization algorithms that often perform well on approximating solution to all types of problem because they do not make any assumptions about the underlying evaluation of

Who Guards the Guardians? Judicial Control of Administration

2827 words - 11 pages political theory: different interest groups that share a particular set of preferences are struggling for power - summating of group preferences in the way elections summated individual preferences. The critical response to pluralism is that inequality occurs, because of some groups are politically more influential or have more material support. Administrative response to this problem was increasing access to information, but still pluralism

Description of meteorology and different fields meterologists can work in

1726 words - 7 pages Meteorological Society and has a B.S. or M.S. in meteorology. Another sought after quality of people in this field is the ability to work with many computer programs in order to produce graphics that will be appealing to the viewing audience.The second, and largest, group of meteorologists to be discussed is operational, or synoptic, meteorologists. Operational is the technical name for weather forecasters, who interpret given weather

Biblical Autobiography, Part 3

1040 words - 5 pages . Since God allowed me to born into an ideal Christian family, I’ve always known about the Bible and what it teaches. Growing up, I went to church on Sunday mornings and followed along during the sermon. I made it my personal goal to be the best little girl sitting in the pews, and more importantly, to be the best example of a Christian out there. I thought this was made possible by adamantly reading the Bible. I was wrong and this was a problem

Inadequcies of Language in the Gospels

1541 words - 7 pages different cultures. Therefore, each language should be used as a cultural tool to communicate with its speakers. Every language conveys the shared experiences of its people. Since language is a worldview, and different people have different worldviews, people have the  problem of understanding the same reality through different worldviews when using different languages. When using different languages, people are often misunderstood and criticized

Critique of the Government Shutdown

2342 words - 9 pages to function. If the shutdown had lasted longer there would have been an even bigger issue. Something this big isn’t a joke this could have turned out significantly worse and people need to understand this. This debt problem that had a large impact on this shutdown didn’t just pop out of nowhere. This thing’s been piling up since Bush was in the Oval office, and since then the issue has been avoided and unnecessary spending has never been higher

Similar Essays

The Synoptic Problem Essay

1351 words - 5 pages The Synoptic Problem The synoptic problem is that of considering which of the 3 synoptic gospels. Matthew, Mark and Luke was written first and perhaps which gospel was written aided via the other and/or which writer used the questionable Q source. It is believed that there is a literary connection between the gospels as there is an obvious verbal agreement that suggests some kind of interdependence between them

The Explanation Of Synoptic Problem Essay

780 words - 4 pages As we have already noted in the gospel introduction that each writer was having its unique perspective to present Christ as the Messiah to their audience. This three-gospel writer’s argument was rightly attesting that Jesus is the messiah and the son of God. Even though, the gospel has the distinctive element, but most of the scholars still apportioned to the gospel similarities and term as "synoptic problem." Synoptic problem had explained

The Synoptic Problem: The New Testament

1101 words - 5 pages come. The study of these similarities and differences within these gospels is an attempt to find a solution to what is termed as the synoptic problem. SOURCE CRITICISM AND THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM In evaluating the gospels of Mark, Matthew and Luke many scholars employ a number of methods of analysis and criticism to help explain the synoptic problem. Among these methods one of the most helpful is source criticism. Source criticism is the “analysis of a

The Synoptic Problem: Analysis Of The Two Gospel Hypothesis

2089 words - 8 pages historical similarities with the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke through a balanced approach utilizing both internal and external resources to address the long standing debate regarding the synoptic problem. The Synoptic Problem The synoptic problem is a debate in regards to the literary relationship among the first three synoptic gospels, Matthew, Mark, and Luke, found in the New Testament and their account of the life, death, resurrection, and