This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Taking Sides Essay

1101 words - 5 pages

Ian Kershaw is correct when he argues that while Hitler was responsible for the execution of the German foreign policy that inevitably led to World War II, Hitler was not free from the influence of outside forces. Kershaw, a professor of history at the University of Sheffield, is a structuralist. Structuralists generally believe Hitler cannot be held solely responsible for World War II and that he was “was a product of the environment he helped to create”. When it comes down to specifics, the structuralists tend to emphasize different aspects; for example, one may focus on the effects of socioeconomic pressure while another may focus on the lack of a coherent plan (343). Kershaw’s article draws from many aspects of structuralism and delivers a sufficient comprehensive argument in his excerpt.
German foreign policy during the Third Reich is a great source of great debate. Many historians agree that Hitler did make the big decisions of foreign policy after 1933. However, the disagreement occurs when discussing the extent which the foreign policy was derived from Hitler’s own “ideological pre-possessions and programme” (356). According to the structuralists, the foreign policy emphasized expansion and contained unclear and unspecific aims. This was due to the “uncontrollable dynamism and radicalizing momentum of the Nazi movement and governmental system” (353). Hitler’s foreign policy stressed his image and ideological fixations, not his direct intervention and initiative. Hitler is seen as an opportunist who makes spur-of-the-moment decisions, rather than a man with a concrete plan (354).
Kershaw provides support for his argument by including the views of other structuralists, such as Hans Mommsen, Martin Broszat, and Tim Mason. Mommsen’s approach displays an emphasis on “Hitler’s improvised, spontaneous responses to developments he did little directly to shape”, and views Hitler “as little more than a gifted opportunist”. The execution of Germany’s foreign policy was inconsistent and illogical, and only appears to be consistent in retrospect (354). Broszat also saw “little evidence of a design or plan behind Hitler’s foreign policy”. One particularly strong piece of evidence Broszat provides is the lack of any plan about Poland before 1939, despite the fact that Poland was in a prime geographical location for an attack on the Soviet Union. Broszat says Hitler should not have been viewed as a self-directed person who worked “independently of social motivation and political pressures of his mass following”. Mason states that an inability to come to terms with foreign affairs caused Hitler to turn to foreign policy. The 1930’s caused more confusion than development in Hitler’s foreign policy (355). Nazi foreign policy can be viewed as a “barbarous variant of social imperialism” (356).
Looking at the role Hitler played in dealing with other countries is helpful in showing just how Hitler was responsible for the execution of...

Find Another Essay On Taking Sides

Taking sides essay

1820 words - 8 pages Lincoln is nervous about the Franklin verses Columbus game because he doesn’t know which team to have pride in. Instead he decided to play for himself than school pride. Lincoln was still nervous even though he thought he wasn’t going to play. Since Lincoln can’t choose between the two teams, he didn’t care who won because he is playing for himself. He also sees his fellow team members nervous and unsure. Lincoln liked both teams, he can’t pick

Was Colonial Culture Uniquely American? Refers to a section in the book "Taking sides" by Gary B. Nash

857 words - 3 pages After reading the section entitled 'Was Colonial Culture Uniquely American' in the book Taking Sides, I came to the conclusion that colonial culture was uniquely American. Professor Gary B. Nash states time and time again that the combination of the Europeans, Native Americans, and Africans created a unique triracial society. Although other reasons do comply with my choice, they all basically come back to this statement.First, Mr. Nash describes

Analysis of the arguments for and against Affirmative Action (Issue #10, Stanley Feingold, George McKenna, "Taking Sides" 13th ed.)

1878 words - 8 pages problems due to this discrimination and it's effects on the black community. One solution to the problem of past discrimination and racial inequality has been to take "Affirmative Action" with regard to minority races in America, enforcing certain levels of opportunity mandated for minority groups, most notably black African Americans. McKenna and Feingold's "Taking Sides" dedicates a section to this debate of whether or not affirmative action

Taking Sides: An Analysis of A Doll’s House

2573 words - 11 pages ends up leaving him and their children for “duties to herself”. While Langas would have seen that as a step of independence, Tufts sees it in the light of being self-conceited. Nora is not seeing the impact that her actions will be making on her three children or husband. Thus, both articles fulfill the view that most people have of Nora. The play itself can back up both sides of my argument by what the characters say or do in the play. There are

Socil Parts

612 words - 3 pages . Overall, students participating in social parts of college supplies confidence, happiness and less stress. Moreover, taking up new activities, having new friends and fun are social profits of the college’s social sides. Initially, taking part in various activities is an indisputable consequence of sociality. Thus, because of the joy and priceless experiences, social activities leads to positive personal development. In addition, people gain and

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Walker Morris

936 words - 4 pages In the novel, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the author, Robert Louis Stevenson, uses the characters in the book to talk about the two sides of the human nature. He says that everyone has two different sides; a good side and an evil side. Some people may accept the fact that they have both, but others try to convince themselves that they do not. In this novel, the most obvious characters used to explain the two sides of human nature are Dr. Jekyll and

Negotiation style

629 words - 3 pages negotiations for new factories in a foreign country, there can be issues with understanding local customs and legal issues. The collaboration method puts all the information into the negotiation and allow for creative solutions that meet the needs of community and the company. Language is less of a problem because the two sides are taking time to create solutions and making sure, they understand what the other side wants and needs. Customs that

Summarizing the Information         I think it was rather easy to

666 words - 3 pages articles with a yes opinion and some articles with a no opinion. I think the "no" article from Taking Sides was my best article. It had so many facts about the topic and it also has very good opinions that are backed by evidence. It kept the reader reading because it was so interested. You never really thought of some of the stuff he was stating. It was a very creative article that is definitely the best article I have. The least

The Two Sides of Abortion

706 words - 3 pages a pro-choicer is an issue of women, so it should be the woman's right to choose. (Taking Sides-Volume 3)Abortion is one of the most controversial issues in the world today. Everyone has his or her own opinion. Some feel abortion is wrong. Others feel that the woman should only be the one to make the choice. It is her body. There are even people who do not really hold either viewpoint specifically, and believe it all depends on the circumstances

"The Tiger" by William Blake.Poem analysis

587 words - 2 pages Are things always what they seem? Is our first impression always right? In "The Tiger" William Blake uses tone, theme, and rhyme to make the point that there are two sides to everything.If you came face-to-face with a tiger you would probably be afraid. But if you put your fear aside and took a closer look you would probably notice how beautiful the tiger is. Blake uses particular words to make the tone of fear and awe in this poem. Almost like

Critical overview of Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States

745 words - 3 pages adrenaline, fear and resentment surging them, is really any more reliable than the person who brings the ax down.Zinn refers to "the taking of sides which comes from selection and emphasis in history" as being "inevitable." (Page 10) Why he believes this to be the case remains unclear; he simply states it as fact. In this way, Zinn makes the same mistake as the historians whom he condemns- he acknowledges that traditional historians are correct

Similar Essays

Taking Sides: Inclusion Essay

824 words - 4 pages Taking Sides: Inclusion According to Stout (2001) the concept of inclusion can be differentiated into mainstreaming, inclusion and full inclusion each describing the amount of time special education students become part of a normal education classes. “Inclusion is a term which expresses the commitment to educate each child, to the maximum extent possible, in the school and classroom he or she would otherwise attend” (definitions section, para. 2

Citi Group: Taking Sides Essay

1077 words - 4 pages Taking SidesDebates are healthy ways to express opposing sides of an issue. In every debate there are issues over which there is no debate. There is no debate that Citigroup is an excellent example of an organization that has displayed environmental adaptability. However, when the discussion turns to Citibank's expansion efforts with respect to China, other considerations exist.The purpose of this paper is to discuss whether or not Citigroup has

Taking Sides: Global Warming Essay

3056 words - 12 pages The following research paper was written for a literature class but the topic is global warming. It explains what causes it, what it affects, and what we need to do to fix the problem before it grows out of hand.Taking Sides: Global WarmingFor decades global warming has been a hot topic of debate in society. For many people there is the concern that too much global warming will have an impact on climate, economy, and health. Some people choose

Taking Sides: Issue 21: Kaplan And Kagan

826 words - 3 pages Taking Sides argument: Issue 21Democracy is Government by the people. There are many different views on whether democracy is good or bad and if it works. Robert Kagan and Robert Kaplan have opposed thoughts on democracy.First off, Robert Kagan supports the concepts of democracy. He states that it has taken part in many countries like it never has before. The conditions that are necessary for democracy are economics. Another is literacy, which is