This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tax Evasion Or Tax Avoidance: Is Starbucks` Tax Planning And Practice Setting A Bad Precedent?

1949 words - 8 pages

Is Starbucks` tax planning and practice setting a bad precedent? The following is a review on the Reuters’s report on ‘How Starbucks avoids UK taxes’: Reuters (2013). It looks at what tax avoidance and tax evasion are, and the issues affecting the ethics on Starbucks` tax planning and practice. Finally, to comment on whether Starbucks` tax planning is recommended for any other multinational company.
2. Tax Evasion or Tax Avoidance

2.1. A review about the tax planning
Tax avoidance, subject to what is said below, may be broadly described as the legitimate ordering of one’s affairs in such a way as to minimise the tax which is chargeable. The distinction between this and evasion must at the ...view middle of the document...

An example to show intention is, for a transfer price of $1 a trademark could be sold overseas. So instead royalties being paid to the home country, royalties are paid to offshore companies located in a lower taxing country.

2.4. International Profit Shifting Schemes

Here are some of the tax planning techniques used by large and complex enterprises
• Allocation of profits or income offshore; (e.g. profits shifted to lower tax rate countries)
• Expenses allocated onshore; (this increases deductions in the home country and lowers profits and lowers the tax payable)
• Countries offering Tax Holidays, incentives or low tax rates
• Re-invoicing arrangements (through tax havens and parking some of the profit offshore)
• Loans and funding arrangements; (Thin capitalisation i.e., high debt to equity issues) and funding issues and guarantee fees.
• Business restructures; (Chapter 9 OECD 2010)
• Intangibles (marketing or trade) such as royalties and patents.
• Foreign entities direct involvement and control over subsidiary. These are common where the company operates in a country but without any staff or were the company is charged higher prices for products, services and assets from other related parties overseas.
• Profit shifting through, undercharging for products, services and assets sold to other related parties overseas. Normally, selling at a lower price lowers the profit in the home country.
• Treaty shopping using Double Tax Agreements. An example is of shifting the payments of dividends to a country where taxes are lower instead of sending them back to the parent company.
• Currency Exchange, for example, timing issues on terms of payment.
• Non- compliance to contracts - contracts are ignored.

2.4. Tax Planning; is it legal and ethical?

One of the main issues has been as to what is legal or ethical. Need to consider the facts and circumstances. The following can involve tax planning as its aim.
 Transfer Pricing - Usually there is not a lot that can be done with tax issues within the framework of the law. There may be a question of ethics but a legal approach to arrange international associated dealings to take advantage of the various countries tax laws and double tax agreements would normally pass the test. However the arm's length nature needs to be addressed to determine whether there is a transfer pricing issue, and if so, is an adjustment a possibility?
 Tax Avoidance – This is a case of ethics and would be a borderline with the legal approach. It may be questionable if the law was intended otherwise. This can be done by arranging international dealings to acquire unintended advantages of the various countries tax laws and double tax agreements.
 Tax Evasion – Usually an illegal and unethically approach by various means of concealment or misrepresentation.
In my opinion, it is unethical and immoral to evade the payment of tax, however planning to reduce or minimise tax is entirely something different. The tax authorities...

Find Another Essay On Tax Evasion or Tax Avoidance: Is Starbucks` Tax planning and Practice Setting a Bad Precedent?

Soda Tax or Behavior Tax? Essay

1481 words - 6 pages feel when seeing a billboard or television commercial advertising foods specifically created to appeal to their tastes. Consumers crave these products, anticipate the pleasure of consuming them and consequently feel driven to purchase them. The appeal of these junk foods is clearly by design, and some legislators may think that the simplest fix is to increase taxes on these products, making them less attractive to consumers. A similar tax strategy

International Tax Planning Essay

1334 words - 5 pages . Tax evasion is a violation of the law or even a criminal offense. And yet, I find that the legislation boundary between planning and avoidance is sometimes blurred. The most important task in international tax planning is to comply with this boundary, remaining within the law. Thus, international companies should be engaged in the development of qualified professionals in order to make tax schemes both effective and legitimate Works Cited

A Flattened Income Tax

2874 words - 11 pages falls (Merino 40). In general, when one brings in an income of $16,000 or less, he no longer has to pay taxes (Duby 1). The progressive tax is just one of many ways the government can collect income taxes. Another way of collecting income taxes is by using a flat rate. Americans should implement a flat tax on incomes because the tax system would be simpler, fairer, and promote work and education. A flat tax is a tax in which the rate of taxation

IRS and Tax Regulations

2115 words - 8 pages regulations of the IRS, follow a modified cash basis to determine revenue. Therefore, it can be seen that these amounts differ because of the differences between tax regulations and GAAP. The majorities of financial advisers do not have a formal accounting or tax background and thus have some challenges to overcome when reading tax returns of their clients. However they are still asked to help their clients in future planning. Since most accounting is

Thailands Tax

1383 words - 6 pages for them within the topic of tax structures and avoiding/minimising tax.[7: Phillip Lynch, 'Human Rights and Corporate Social Responsibility' (2006) 10(3) Corporations and Markets Advisory Committee <$file/Human_Rights_CSR.pdf>]There is a fine line between tax avoidance and tax planning. Tax planning can be descried as the arrangement of financial affairs to take full

Tax Shelters

1358 words - 5 pages The Internal Revenue Code Section 6662 defines "a tax shelter as any partnership, entity, plan or arrangement if a significant purpose of such partnership, entity, plan or arrangement is the avoidance or evasion of federal income tax" ("What is a tax shelter"). The Internal Revenue code was purposefully created in order to avail corporations to benefit from legitimate tax shelters in order to ensure applicable social and economic benefit

Tax Incentives

947 words - 4 pages development and growth. While most of the city’s revenues come from business establishments, economic enterprises and real property according to the city Treasurer, it is intriguing how the city manages to reach their target tax collection and continue to increase their registered business permits. Incentives can be in the form of individual or corporate tax incentives, which can include deductions, benefits, etc., which will likely influence the trend

Flat Tax

2979 words - 12 pages for the first two years). For businesses, taxes are paid on income from the sale of goods or services. The business first adds up all of its income and then subtracts all of their expenses. The income that is left after these subtractions is taxed at 17 percent. What a Flat Tax Means for America “After seven decades of amendments, revisions, exceptions, loopholes, extenders, and the occasional overhaul, the current U.S. tax code is a

Tax Reform

1274 words - 5 pages has been widespread anger on the current structure of taxation. Consequently, the wealthy have managed to become even richer despite the economic crisis. Furthermore, many taxpayers in the upper class have found loopholes to avoid substantial taxation or otherwise known as tax evasion. (Stewart 2013) Tax evasion has only grown over the years and with the national debt has become a major issue. What is more, is the intense complexity of the entire

Fair Tax

2316 words - 10 pages expanded sales tax bad for consumers and interest groups who rely on state resources, but it would have a significant impact on those owning or conducting business in Missouri as well. According to then state representative Jason Holsman, a Democrat, “70 percent of Missouri residents live next to border states,” and “those states, if the fair tax passed [in Missouri], would have lower sales taxes,” (Miles, 2010). Holsman and others believe that when the

Tax Strategy

2814 words - 11 pages and major provisions for considering how to use them for planning the next year's tax strategy.An Overview of the new Tax Laws Rule of the Game--- Tax Laws Congress writes the tax laws, which become part of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) or tax code for short. The tax code is amended every year. Congress has given the IRS the power to interpret the tax code through a series of IRS Regulations. These regulations are expanded versions of some, but

Similar Essays

Tax Planning And Tax Avoidance Analysis

2668 words - 11 pages ). Consequently, advantage on a full year’s cash gains is achieved through tax avoidance. Tax planning facilitates anticipation on taxes that a business is to remit. This is through applying of suitable accounting methods whether accrual basis or cash basis to minimize tax liability that best suits type of business and will result in maximum reduction on tax liability. Negative implications of tax planning and tax avoidance Inaccurate interpretation of

Tax Evasion Essay

852 words - 4 pages incidence of tax and therefore determining the taxpayers’ predisposition to comply with the tax (Allingham and Sandmo, 2007). Turnover Tax (TOT) was introduced in Kenya through an amendment to the Income Tax Act vide the Finance Bill of 2007 as one of the TMP to address the low compliance level among the small businesses in Kenya.TOT is a final tax levied at 3% of turnover and is payable quarterly on or before the 20th of the month immediately

Tax Planning Essay

817 words - 4 pages TAX AND TAX PLANNING FINA 6005 RESEARCH AS A CHARITABLE ACTIVITY The registration of the charitable institution is done by the Canada Revenue Agency in accordance with the income Tax Act and they ensures that once they got themselves registered through them, they should meet the requirements of the charitable institution as defined by the Act. The documents issued by the CRA outlines the legal and administrative requirements that a registered

Corporate Tax Avoidance And Benford's Law

3255 words - 14 pages avoidance and this is the reason why I use the CASH ETR instead of the GAAP effective tax rate in this study. One limitation of the annual CASH ETR is that the numerator and denominator could be misaligned. This is the case when the numerator, thus cash taxes paid contains taxes paid on earnings in a different period, for example, earnings from an IRS audit which was completed in the current year, while the denominator “pre-tax income” contains