Tax Exemtion Case Analysis

954 words - 4 pages

Article Analysis:
Hospitals use tax exemption as a way for facing financial burdens. This allows hospitals to continue their operations by providing high quality care and providing free or discounted care to poor individuals. The implications for denying tax exemption can be financially detrimental to many non-for-profit hospitals and subsequently for many uninsured individuals who need access to care. Although I truly believe that there should be very strict regulations to rule tax exemptions for hospitals and healthcare organizations and I totally agree with the Supreme Court ruling in this case, I feel that this case is very controversial and leads to many fundamental arguments in regards to this subject.
The court analyzed each of the factors outlined in Korzen’s case and concluded that Provena only satisfied two of the necessary factors and therefore did not qualify for the tax exemption. According to the court, Provena’s funds were mainly generated from providing medical services for a fee rather than from charities organizations. Patients were billed regularly and they were automatically referred to collections agencies when they could not pay. Hospital charges were waived only after it was determined that patients did not have or were not eligible for insurance coverage, lacked the resources to pay directly, and were eligible for the charitable care program. On the other hand, Provena alleges several important arguments in response to the courts analysis. They alleged that the hospital provided care to everyone who requested it regardless of their financial circumstances and that they provided discounted care for poor individuals. Nevertheless, the court stated that the discounted care was illusory because the charges were more than double the actual costs of care and therefore the hospital was still able to generate a profit when it gets paid. Furthermore, Provena urged the court to consider its treatment of Medicare and Medicaid patients as charitable care because the payments it receives for treating such patients do not cover the full costs of care. The court rejected this argument stating that accepting Medicare and Medicaid patients is optional and even with the lower reimbursement rates the hospital will still receive a reliable stream of revenue and generate income from hospital resources that might otherwise be underutilized. For all the above reasons, I agree with the court’s decision that the hospital did not provide enough evidence to prove its role in supporting the “charitable purposes”, lessening the burdens of the Government, and promoting social welfare.
Although I believe that the court delivered a clear statement that tax exemption rules are very strict, one of the main criticisms is that the court relied on old precedent to determine whether hospitals should be granted tax exemption without taking into account current market and social conditions. Since the Korzen case in 1968, the hospital industry has...

Find Another Essay On Tax Exemtion Case Analysis

Taxation influences multinational companies structure and investment Decisions

992 words - 4 pages they might manage the affairs of the entity they manage. In that case, this claim of a ‘duty’ is actually used as an excuse to justify chosen corporate behaviour. [1] 3.) There may be a valid reason for a company locating a subsidiary in a tax haven if real trade is occurring and no suggestion of tax avoidance would result. However, it is largely due to when careful planning of group company structure decides that it not only wishes to take

Corporation Tax and the Harberger General Equilibrium Model

937 words - 4 pages larger proportion of the corporate tax. Another variable is the elasticity of substitution between labour and capital in the taxed industry. If it is hard to substitute labour for capital as it may be in the short run, then it will be the case where labour will bear a larger proportion of the tax incidence. This is because the tax would cause a reduction in the use of both labour and capital; however, if it is not easy to substitute labour for

Buoyancy and Elasticity: Determinants of Local Tax System's Performance

2083 words - 8 pages adjustment then it is a breeze to translate the analysis in terms of any other years as reference year.       Inherent in the proportional adjustment method is the assumption that "the revenue effect of any discretionary measure grows in proportion to total revenue, i.e. that discretionary measures alter the level of yield but do not change the elasticity of the system" (Osoro, 1994). This implies that the tax

Dividend Tax

1576 words - 6 pages ). While in a recovering economy, it would be difficult to make an argument to cut taxes from those who are not necessarily in a credit bind and do not necessarily need the money. A corporation’s after-tax profits can be distributed either as dividends or as capital gains. In either case, these after-tax dollars are taxed again at the personal level. In contrast, when corporations take on debt, they receive a tax deduction for their interest

Case Study on Umicore N.V., CEO Marc Grynberg

1920 words - 8 pages : This report deals with the case study on Umicore N.V which is a material technology multinational. The case study talks about the impact of Income Taxes in managerial decision making and financial statement presentation. The case study starts with the company’s profile and tells about what the company is and how it is performing currently. While reading deeper you will learn about the tax depreciation method used by the company, capital gain

Corporate Compliance with IAS Regarding Income Tax: IAS 12, Income Taxes: Disclosure Issues

4696 words - 19 pages 3 iii.Table of Contents 4 iv.Abstract 5 1. Introduction 6 2. Related Definitions and Concepts 9 3. Literature Review 11 4. Data Analysis & Findings 14 5. Recommendations 22 6. Conclusion 23 Reference 24 Appendix 1 25 Appendix 2 27 Appendix 3 32 ABSTRACTTax is the levy or charge imposed upon a taxpayer by the Govt. or state when income tax is the tax charged on the person or

PRESSCO CASE ANALYSIS

961 words - 4 pages positive it should be accepted. We calculate the NPV by:Determining the cash out flow or cost of the equipment or project.Any installations or set up costs should also show as cash out flows.There may be tax credits that need to be taken into consideration because, in essence, that would be a cash inflow.Another important factor in calculating the NPV is that tax rate used by the company. The tax rate can cause a "tax shelter", which in the case of

cri etos crietos

1850 words - 7 pages wealth. In this view, economic realities are building a compelling case for a more progressive tax system. But judging from the experience of other wealthy countries, the opposite may be true. As inequality has risen in the developed world, many governments have been dismantling - not increasing - estate taxes. Countries from Austria to Canada to Sweden have abolished estate taxes outright. There is nothing inevitable about high estate taxation

Corporate Finance

2753 words - 11 pages this basis, we are trying to make some suggestions on the standpoint of Pressco and its counterparts with the help of sensitivity analysis method, and finally our takeaways.Keywords: Cash Flow, Net Present Value, Investment Tax Credit(ITC)Content41.1 Parties related 41.2 Investment tax credit (ITC) 51.3 Rumored tax legislation 52. Financial analysis 62.1 NPV for equipment replacement without tax change 72.2 NPV for equipment replacement under new

Whether a Cut in Corp Tax Rate be Beneficial

4338 words - 17 pages the corporate tax rate positively influence market volume and different firms’ financial activities (i.e. investing, repurchasing, options)? A question of this nature can be answered through analysis of the benefits or detriments obtained by two companies due to the reduction. There is a basic relationship between the market volume and corporate tax rates. A decrease in the corporate rates would allow companies to pay less on their earnings

An Economic Analysis of Oregon’s 2007 Road User Fee Pilot Program

3503 words - 14 pages , David, David Porter, Jim Whitty, Jack Svadlenak, Norman Larsen, Darel Capps, Betsy Imholt, Jill Pearson, and Douglas Hall. "Technology Evaluation of Oregon's Vehicle-Miles-Traveled Revenue Collection System." Transportation Research Board 2079: 37-44. Print. McMullen, Starr, Lei Zhang, and Kyle Nakahara. "Distributional impacts of changing from a gasoline tax to a vehicle-mile tax for light vehicles: A case study of Oregon." Transport Policy

Similar Essays

Michigan Sales Tax: Sales Of Cars, Who Should Pay?

1304 words - 6 pages collecting the purchase price and sales tax from the consumer. If the finance company was unable to collect, they looked to the State of Michigan Sales Tax department for a refund for the sales tax paid to the dealers. Under the Michigan General Sales Tax Law, does the State of Michigan owe the finance company a refund? Legal Issues The case of Andrie Inc. v. State of Michigan involves the State of Michigan’s assessment of use tax for years in issue

Taxation Influences Multinational Companies Structure And Investment Decisions

913 words - 4 pages . Companies undertake this activity to maximise their financial return from the activities in which they invest by creating what can, quite often, be arbitrary financial structures motivated not by the needs of group financing but by a desire to abuse tax rules for the sake of increasing the after tax profit. [1] This practice is normally well regulated in developed countries, but this is not generally the case in developing countries. ***go over and

Tax Structure: Habitat For Humanity Essay

1693 words - 7 pages , and case resolution. Quantification "In 2004, property tax collections in the U.S. exceeded $300 billion. Property taxes are responsible for approximately 72% of all local tax revenues, representing the most important tax revenue source for local governments" (as cited in Shan, 2010, p.195). National statics does not separate Habitat for Humanity homeowners from other property owners. Consequently, this is also true for Wake County

Tax As A Means Of Control And Stimulator Of The Economy In The Uk. Is It A Good Idea To Fluctuate The Tax Rates For Stabilizing The Economy? Is Tax Necessary For A Country’s Growth? Is Green Tax ...

9199 words - 37 pages PAGE 36 TAX AS A MEANS OF CONTROL AND STIMULATOR OF THE ECONOMYCONTENTSPageAbstract 2Chapter1: Introduction 3Chapter 2: Literature review 52.1: Equity of tax on society 52.2: Fluctuating tax rates to control and stabilize the economy 62.3: Tax rates adjusted and used to promote growth 82.4: Effects of green tax policy 9Chapter 3: Research Methodology: 11Chapter 4: Analysis of findings 14Chapter 5: Conclusion and recommendations 18References