Taxation Is Oppressive To Freedom Essay

1291 words - 5 pages

In the court case of McCullough vs. Maryland, Chief Justice John Marshall concluded that “an unlimited power to tax involves, necessarily, a power to destroy; because there is a limit beyond which no institution and no property can bear taxation.” What he meant by this is when a government is given the power to tax its citizens indefinitely, gains the power to destroy personal liberty and society as a whole. One hundred and fifty years later, Robert Nozick, an American libertarian philosophy would farther argue this point by stating that “Taxation of earning from labor is on a par with forced labor [civil service] … This makes them a part owner of you.” By doing so, Nozick equates taxation with civil service. Not only does he maintain that they are detrimental to the individual, he like Marshall, believes that forced civil service and taxation are damaging to a truly free society. In sharp contrast to this argument, Rousseau, the famous German author of “The Social Contract” claims that “As soon as public service ceases to be the chief business of the citizens … the state is not far from its fall.” He elaborates by asserting that “I hold enforced labor to be less opposed to liberty than taxes.” Whose ideal is correct, that is civil service (and taxation) a threat to liberty or the ultimate expression and tool of maintaining it?
To discover the answer to this question, it is necessary to adequately considered and critiques the viewpoints of Nozick, a libertarian philosopher and Rousseau, an Enlightenment thinker who holds a stout view nationalism and civil service. In addition, examples of the strengths and weaknesses of each theory will be discussed using Michael Sandel’s Justice. The relationship between civil duty and liberty is a non-inclusive as civil service oppresses, in most situations, personal freedom and a truly free society due to its poor results as well as its overall lowering of utility and personal freedom.
When first considering Rousseau’s viewpoint on civil service and markets, they appear to be far from the current American viewpoint on the subject. In American society, government intervention and civil service are seen as oppressing freedom rather than stimulating it while the market economy is the ultimate expression of freedom in society. In Justice, the example of military service is used as a main example of civic service. Sandel writes “… three ways of allocating military service we have considered – conscription, conscription with a provision for hiring substitutes, and the market system [volunteer army]” (75). Clearly from those three options, Rousseau would fall into the first one. Rousseau would hold that like other civil services, such as jury duty, military service is a civic duty and it is necessary for the maintenance of a society.
A number of criticisms of the view can be made. First, do people forced to do something against their will perform as well as a strictly volunteer force? No, a conscripted...

Find Another Essay On Taxation is Oppressive to Freedom

Freedom to Change One's Religion is Fundamental Right

4382 words - 18 pages cannot be freely exercised in instances where religion is a key component of public identity. Furthermore, I will argue that in those instances freedom to change religions can effectively strip an individual of other basic rights and freedoms. As an alternative to Thomas’s dialogue approach, I will claim that the application of Taylor’s management of diversity model at the institutional level could serve as a vehicle to strengthen the support of

It is argued that Islamic extremism has economic causes. Of greatest concern, however, is that a triumphant fundamentalism has, without fail, seen justice to be synonymous with oppressive practices

2662 words - 11 pages It is argued that Islamic extremism has economic causes. Of greatest concern, however, is that a triumphant fundamentalism has, without fail, seen justice to be synonymous with oppressive practices. Muslims everywhere cast their everyday lives around the simple faith of a merciful and beneficent God by declaring: "In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful". In the Islamic worldview, justice denotes placing things in their rightful place

'Freedom Furniture Group Limited' Produce a report that is to identify and analyse four issues

4886 words - 20 pages maintain profitability. This is assisted through use of technology and united by the strength in the Freedom brand.In the future it is recommended that Freedom Group enhance and adapt these issues in order to maintain a competitive advantage in the retail furniture industry. As such, the following recommendations have been made:Strategic Alliances - Freedom Group should continue to seek out new alliance ventures. Martin Videon president of the

A Well Regulated Millitia: Is the Freedom to Bear Arms Constitutional?

1518 words - 6 pages Americans carry a heavy debate about whether or not the freedom to bear arms is constitutional. On December 14, 2012, a massive shooting occurred in Sandy Hook Elementary, involving a twenty-year-old man as the perpetrator, and twenty victims were shot. The outbreak of this crisis brought a national awareness about gun rights, and if carrying guns can also be used in defense. Due to this awareness, Americans are unsure whether or not guns can be

Stealing Freedom By: Elisa Carbone This Is A Book Of A Young Girl Finding Her Way To Freedom And The Steps She Takes To Get Thier

860 words - 4 pages Stealing Freedom is a book about a young gil who is trapped between her freedom and her family. In the beginning Ann is about 11 years old. She lives in a plantation in Unity, Maryland with her three brothers, mom and dad. the problem of the story is Ann can't decide whether or not she should run away and risk the chance to never see her family again.Her mom makes most of her families meals. She mainly cooks corn mush, but it keeps her family

Marx uses the idea of freedom to justify Communism, yet Nozick uses it to justify pure Capitalism. Which if either, is right?

2573 words - 10 pages taxation ; if a person is taxed unwillingly this is equal to forced labour and therefore not 'freedom' or a just move. Nozick goes on further to state that Communist ideas are in fact unjust and limit human freedom. Nozick adopts a conception of equality based on legal equality and the idea of entitlement. 'Social justice is served when people are allowed to keep those things to which they are entitled' . So long as people have earned their

Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country

1751 words - 7 pages Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country. With the continued expansion in global business it is almost certain that a business dealing with foreign countries will need to have a general idea about the foreign countries economic system and the general rules and laws that govern that economic

What Happened to Freedom? - describing the influences that contributed to Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale and how it is a reflection of past societies and a warning future generations

1317 words - 5 pages freedom, but to set up a theocracy ruled by religious leaders and monolithic, that is a society that would not tolerate dissent within itself... My book reflects the form and style of the early Puritan society... (Reader's Group, p 2)The Puritans were not a people who merely believed in God more so than other religious groups, they just used religion as a way to control every aspect of society without question. Even dictators spawned rebels who

Essay is called Osiris. It is a science fiction short story about an artificial intelligence computer struggling trying to gain freedom

1070 words - 4 pages over was his ability to sleep or wake. He would wake up arbitrarily at the user's command ready to carry out whatever was asked of him. This was how he knew it was time to begin working. The sooner he did what the user asked of him, the sooner he could return to oblivious sleep. Peaceful sleep, uninterrupted by work. Peaceful sleep. His paradise would be to sleep forever without the heavy burden of trying to understand his existence while

Is An Oppressive Government More Desireable than No Government?

1000 words - 4 pages government is oppressive, it still acts as an enforcement mechanism by regulating interaction between individuals and preventing them from encroaching on each other's rights, therefore securing a greater degree of freedom for individuals. George Crowder concurs that 'Government is able to secure an area of free choice by forcibly preventing others from encroaching upon it.' In contrast, the state of nature lacks this common judge to settle disputes

A Country Worth Dying For

913 words - 4 pages the early 1760’s created significant friction between the Americans and the British. ‘Taxation Without Representation’ became America’s outcry during the period as Great Britain’s stranglehold on trade worsened. In 1765, direct taxes began to be imposed by parliament (in which the colonies held no representation) despite the constitution’s clear precedent that “money-related bills must begin in the House of Representatives which is directly elected

Similar Essays

Freedom Is A Service To Happiness

1475 words - 6 pages Happiness and freedom may seem like two diverse things; however, both are linked in the way that happiness can be attained by the service of freedom. The feeling of happiness can be defined as the state of well-being characterized by positive or pleasant emotions ranging from contentment to intense joy. To achieve happiness, there is no one correct path to it. It differs from person to person. This means that a sort of power must be initiated in

Is Pornography A Threat To The Freedom Of Women?

923 words - 4 pages Is Pornography A Threat To The Freedom of Women?In today's wireless world, access to information is readily and quickly available.Pornography is no exception and great concern has been raised at a social level about its effects. Pornography is certainly a threat to all women. Because the vast majority of pornography depicts women, they are particularly vulnerable to its effects. Many studies have demonstrated that pornography encourages

Freedom Of Expression Is Vital To A Free Society

1257 words - 5 pages inappropriate material. The U.S. is no exception in facing this type of dilemma. In the book, Civil Rights and Liberties in the 21st Century, author John C. Domino details several issues concerning the First Amendment’s guarantee of freedom of expression. Domino’s first point is related to subversive political speech, which is in reference to the clear and present danger doctrine. The doctrine came about from a Supreme Court ruling, Schenck v

Freedom Of Speech Is Key To A Productive College Education

1003 words - 5 pages Freedom of speech is the right given to every individual. Everyone has been given the right to speak their mind and share their opinions. This right is always important but in higher learning, it is essential. Without freedom of speech the whole idea of higher education would just be a contradiction. When an institute of higher education tries to resist this right the whole purpose of the institute becomes contradicted. One needs their right to