Teaching The Philosophy Of Science With Non Scientific Examples

3662 words - 15 pages

Teaching the Philosophy of Science with Non-Scientific Examples

ABSTRACT: This essay explores the benefits of utilizing non-scientific examples and analogies in teaching philosophy of science courses, or general introductory courses. These examples can help resolve two basic difficulties faced by most instructors, especially when teaching lower-level courses: first, they can prompt students to take an active interest in the class material, since the examples will involve aspects of the culture well-known to the students; second, these familiar, less-threatening examples will lessen the students' collective anxieties and open them up to learning the material more easily. To demonstrate this strategy of constructing and employing non-scientific examples, a lengthy analogy between musical styles and Kuhn's theory of scientific revolutions is developed.

Without a doubt, one of the most difficult tasks in teaching undergraduate philosophy courses is motivating the students to take an active interest in the abstract and complex issues normally presented. One obvious method of overcoming this dilemma is to provide numerous historical examples and analogies of the relevant philosophical problem, since concrete instances are frequently less complicated than general descriptions, articulate the main points more clearly, and have the added bonus of being more "personal" and relatable. Thus, if one were presenting, say, Imre Lakatos theory of scientific research programs, describing the conflict between the Ptolemaic and Copernican views would serve as an excellent backdrop for the introduction of Lakatos' ideas. Nevertheless, if the students are unfamiliar and/or bored by the kinds of examples employed, the strategy will, of course, spark little enthusiasm from the class. This is a problem particularly acute in teaching the philosophy of science, moreover, since the average college student's generally low levels of instruction in science, let alone the history of science, will render the majority of real-life scientific examples as opaque as the philosophical issues they were supposed to make clear!

In this essay, one possible strategy for overcoming this obstacle, which has been culled from personal experience, will be recommended by way of demonstration. In short, the suggestion is to devise examples and analogies from outside the realm of science and its history, but which can serve to both highlight and augment the actual scientific cases typically offered, as well as provide an interesting test-bed for the exploration of philosophical concepts. If these examples are tailored to reflect the interests of the students, most notably by drawing upon the humanities and popular culture, then a marked increase in class enthusiasm and participation will be the likely result. In short, these non-scientific analogies can help explain the nature and purpose of a philosophical/scientific concept. In what follows, consequently, we will develop a lengthy...

Find Another Essay On Teaching the Philosophy of Science with Non-Scientific Examples

My Philosophy of Teaching Essay

1214 words - 5 pages believe in the back-to-basics approach of teaching. Essentials in the academic process along with the development of the students’ character is extremely important for these students when faced with the real world. It is extremely important that students learn the primary subjects. I do feel certain subjects need to be addressed each and every day to help the students achieve the necessary skills they will rely on later in life. Math, science, and

My Philosophy of Teaching Essay

697 words - 3 pages My Philosophy of Teaching I didn’t grow up wanting to be a teacher. I went to college after high school and studied Journalism, International Studies, and Psychology. Teaching was not a career I ever thought about pursuing. Then, I had the opportunity to spend time in the classroom and the teacher pointed out to me that I was a natural. I have had extensive experience volunteering with young people through school and church

Philosophy of Teaching

838 words - 3 pages Philosophy of Teaching My goals as a teacher are to help students communicate effectively and foster a desire to learn. I believe these two characteristics are important for students to have because despite what problems they encounter or what situation they are in, the ability to communicate effectively will help them in working with others and the desire to learn will motivate them to make positive changes in their life. As a teacher, I

My Philosophy of Teaching

1237 words - 5 pages Philosophy of Education As Malcom Forbes once said, “Education’s purpose is to replace an empty mind with an open one.” As a future teacher and educator, I heartily agree with the quote from Mr. Forbes, a successful businessman. Because I have been a student in school since I was five years old, I have had many opportunities to look at my education and assess what I have truly learned. Honestly, I can say that the most important part of

My Philosophy of Teaching - 762 words

762 words - 3 pages My Philosophy of Teaching Education is an important aspect in the lives of all individuals. From the day we are born until the day we die, we are constantly learning. At a very young age, children begin attending school. Throughout their educational career, children have many different teachers who hold many different views, beliefs, and values. Methods of instruction, personalities, and classroom interaction are all unique

My Philosophy of Teaching

1208 words - 5 pages Philosophy of Teaching I started my college career heading towards a degree in child psychology, law, or orthodontics. In all of these professions children are heavily involved and I knew I wanted to be around children. Then I decided to change my major to teaching, which combines aspects of many professions, and is completely child oriented. The main reasons that I want to become a teacher are not for the money or the power of the

My Philosophy of Teaching - 1466 words

1466 words - 6 pages . Scaffolding will be a part of my classroom teaching giving the children a chance to pursue their own learning with me being a figure for them to model after. The next philosophy that will be a segment in my teaching is existentialism. Existentialism deals with more freedom then does progressivism to facilitate students in taking responsibility for their own lives. Jean-Paul Sartre coined the thought behind this philosophy. I agree that each

My Philosophy of Teaching - 1228 words

1228 words - 5 pages My Philosophy of Teaching Teaching is a daunting task that I do not intend to take lightly. Becoming a teacher has been a dream of mine for several years. I always knew that teaching would be the career for me, especially when I began working in the school system as a substitute secretary. I loved working in the school environment; coming in contact with children everyday made me realize how much I would enjoy teaching a classroom full

My Philosophy of Teaching - 1396 words

1396 words - 6 pages Philosophy of Education Teachers, unlike any other professionals have the chance to shape and change young lives. For this reason, I believe that teaching is one of the noblest professions that one could choose. From the time I was a young boy and watching my father in his classroom I knew always wanted to be a teacher. It always seemed like the perfect career. A career in which I felt was best suited for me. One in which I

Philosophy of Teaching

571 words - 2 pages . This is merely a first draft of my philosophy of teaching. As for now, I will continue to learn more about myself and what I hope to see for my students in the classroom. Hopefully with experience it will become more focused, better summarizing my beliefs concerning both the teaching and learning of English.

Philosophy of Teaching

1197 words - 5 pages Philosophy of Teaching As I think back to teachers in my past, many images come to mind. I remember teachers that were kind, patient and understanding. I also have memories of teachers that were short tempered, angry or just plain lazy. Some were eccentric, while others taught with a relaxed teaching style. So I ask myself, what separates the good from the bad? Why are some teachers so effective while others fall short

Similar Essays

The Philosophy Of Science Essay

2532 words - 10 pages The study of the philosophy of science explores whether scientific results are actually the study of truth. Scientific realism is an area of study in the philosophy of science and has a contrasting view called anti realism. The debate between the two revolves around their disagreement between the existence of an external world. A scientific realist believes that an external world exists independent of our minds whereas the anti realist, or the

Children’s Conceptions Of The Earth: Scientific Or Inconsistent/Non Scientific

1326 words - 5 pages . It was predicted that different age group and types of questions would elicit different responses in terms of scientific or inconsistent/ non-scientific concepts of the earth. The finding were significant with the children responses from different age group, that children in the younger group made more inconsistent/non-scientific and fewer scientific responses, whereas children in the older group made more scientific responses and fewer

The Gandhian Philosophy Of Non Violence Essay

1834 words - 7 pages to a stalwart rebellion leader shows and symbolizes how devoted and steadfast he was to God and his country. The aspect that I desire to learn is the good and bad of his non-violence philosophy and how it influenced and changed the future through analyzing the change he went through, as well as the change India went through. Based on a plethora of prior knowledge, I would predict that it was his words that had gotten through, as well as India’s

The Problem With Teaching Creationism In The Science Classroom

1363 words - 5 pages group of people who want creationism taught in schools, especially public schools, alongside evolution. This fight goes all the way back to the 1920s, during which time the ACLU instigated a trial in the hopes of overturning a law that banned teaching evolution in the classroom (Larson, 1998). In 1925, a teacher, John Scopes, agreed to teach evolution with the knowledge that he would be breaking the law and would, therefore, go to trial. After