Television And Media Is Iraq The Next Big Hit For Reality Tv?

1390 words - 6 pages

Iraq – The Next Big Hit for Reality TV

We went into Iraq with a heroic action movie playing in our heads, but the photographs from Abu Ghraib showed us another movie. Not Independence Day but Kill Bill—and, in the deluge of new photos and videotapes, Kill Bill 2.

Yet for all that the photographs from the Iraqi prison invite comparison to big-budget depravity, this is to give the perpetrators too much creative credit. Ultimately, the better comparison is not to the imaginative chaos of a Quentin Tarentino movie but to the mundane chaos of reality TV.

To compare the kind of humiliation suffered by the prisoners in Abu Ghraid to reality TV may seem in bad taste. The shows deal with middle-class men and women who have willingly chosen, based on some twisted idea of celebrity, to subject themselves to public humiliation. The photos deal with citizens of a conquered nation whose humiliation is coerced. The prisoners are literally and figuratively a world away from the caterwauling TV contestants. What is similar about the two situations, however, is the underlying dynamic and the role the camera plays in both.

Reality TV is the enactment, for entertainment purposes, of primal drives. These are the drives that Freud identified as libido (the drive for sex) and aggression (the drive to destroy). The two archetypal shows in the reality line-up are Survivor and The Bachelor. The former favors aggression; the latter, libido. Other reality shows can be viewed as spin-offs of one or the other of these two: The Apprentice, for example, is Survivor set in the corporate board room; Extreme Make-over is The Bachelor set in a plastic surgeon’s office.

Although in most of these shows, one drive predominates, it is impossible, as Freud explained, to activate one without bringing into play the other. In The Bachelor, the harem of women who want the bachelor for his looks, money, or celebrity, engage in duplicitous wiles and backbiting in order to win him. Likewise, in Survivor, coalitions of friendship and romance allow the participants to continue in the game until it becomes practical to jettison these alliances.

At the center of these shows is the idea of humiliation. Those who do not win must suffer losing on a grand public stage. Since only one person can win, while many must lose (and do so week after week), the spectacle necessarily centers more on the losers than on the winner. This is true in a more abstract way on the makeover shows, which display the ugly duckling for the entire length of the show and the ravishing beauty only briefly at the end. The structure of the spectacle entails that we are more often placed in the position of gaping at the humiliation of losing (or being ugly) than applauding the triumph of winning (or becoming pretty). As viewers, we vicariously connect with both, but to different degrees: sharing in the glory of the winners, but enjoying, in a more sustained way, a sense of superiority over the losers. We...

Find Another Essay On Television and Media - Is Iraq the Next Big Hit for Reality TV?

Television and Media Violence - Is Aggressive Behavior Linked to TV Violence?

3458 words - 14 pages Canada were blessed with television, so the homicide statistics from 1945 were the last statistics that did not have the influence of television. South Africa, in contrast, did not receive television until 1975. Before 1975, South Africa had introduced other media  radio and cinema for example  so these statistics isolate the effect of television as a cause of increased homicide rates. Centerwall included statistics from

Television and Media - TV Violence and Murdering Children

2720 words - 11 pages shows and presented that: 1. The context in which most violence is presented on television poses risks for viewers. 2. Perpetrators go unpunished in 73% of all violent scenes; 3. The negative consequences of violence are often not portrayed in violent programming; 4. 25% of violent interactions on TV involve the use of a handgun; 5. Only 4% of violent programs emphasize an anti-violence theme (Int6, 1); Kids grow up

Television and Media - Categorization of TV Sitcom Fathers

1414 words - 6 pages Simulacrum Father does not merely represent ideals but America’s adoption of simulations. Jean Baudrillard concisely describes his complex idea of simulacra as “the generation by models of a real without origin or reality” in “The Precession of Simulacra.” Mid-Twentieth-century television fathers such as those on Leave it to Beaver, The Brady Bunch, and Ozzie and Harriet serve as the origin for this type: these patriarchs appear caring, benevolent

We Are Big Brother's Reality Television Star

1473 words - 6 pages Today, the American people are obsessed with reality television. Television shows such as, So You Think You Can Dance and The Bachelorette are just two examples of the fifteen reality or unscripted shows that placed on the Top 20 Highest Rated Television Programs in 2010 (Carter). What Americans fail to realize is they too are the stars of their own reality television show. Although their actions are not being broadcasted to the rest of the

Media Perception and The Hunger Games How Reality Television Skews our Perception

1598 words - 7 pages Reality Star and in the case of Kim Kardashian, with her vast social and mainstream media popularity, also created a perfume, cosmetic and clothing empire. (Shrhak) Today, there are numerous reality stars that come from the sports, entertainment and political world and the format is a staple of television programing. Though reality TV seems like a fairly new concept, reality shows were first introduced in 1948 when Allen Funt then debuted “Candid

Television and Media - TV Advertising - Selling Magic Potions and Happy Pills

983 words - 4 pages Advertising - Selling Magic Potions and Happy Pills   The marketing world is a sea of fishermen waiting for some starving little fish to snatch up the bait.  The bait is the commercial.  Although the advertising industry provides the consumer with the opportunity to explore what is available, this industry can also lead people into believing that there are magical cures that can eliminate the unwanted and create the

Television and Media - Social Messages in a Coca-Cola TV Commercial

1634 words - 7 pages . This act is not entirely negative, though, as the commercial presents the women’s success at having her cake (by maintaining appearances) and eating it, too (literally). More importantly, Hayeck’s asking for cilantro in a kitchen comprised mostly of men represents female assertiveness in a male-dominated environment. Also, her speaking Spanish in the kitchen shows her being herself, which is certainly a positive message in the ad

With particular reference to television news, assess the role that the mass media have in shaping "reality".

1759 words - 7 pages television is the most common home based leisure activity for men and women in the UK [and other western countries as well]" (Macionis and Plummer, 2002: 712). This indicates that television is likely to have an impact on the way people shape their ideas and how they view reality. The mass media has been around since the printing press and since newspapers started becoming commonplace. Since the beginnings of mainstream media those at the top have

The Emergence and Popularity of Reality TV

2280 words - 9 pages findings in the articles may be inapplicable to all the used languages include in the program, considering the limited sample size (less than 2 minutes Transcript), argument purpose selected clips (most presented scenes are arguments related) and the fact that reality TV program process a high tolerance for changes in the used languages — to be “real”. 2. Findings 2.1 Power realization findings in tenor aspect Since tenor is associated with people

The Benefits of Television and Entertainment Media for Children

1601 words - 7 pages public’s rapid grasp of entertainment media and its assimilation into American culture logically indicate that there must be positive benefits to using the new technologies. However, nothing is free from criticism. Parents and psychologists have recently come to question the effects of television and entertainment media on infants and young children. Some believe that the unnatural nature of television makes it fundamentally bad and unsuited for the

Television and Censorship - Violence Rating System Needed for TV

1149 words - 5 pages Violence Rating System Needed for TV Programs While society recognizes the detrimental effects of general television on children, parents and other child advocacy groups don't feel as though there is an adequate rating system. Consequences of ineffective rating systems are that children's personalities are being negatively affected. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has made legislation to address this issue, but the children's

Similar Essays

Television And Media Tv Violence Is Ruining Children

855 words - 3 pages TV Violence is Ruining Children   A young child sits in front of a television watching cartoons while his mother runs around the house doing various chores.  The mother passes the room the child is in and glances at the television each time she passes.  The child is watching "Sesame Street."  Then, a half an hour later, "Mr. Rogers" is on. The mother walks into the room a half an hour later and stops in horror at what is on the television

Television And Media Essay Four Arguments For The Elimination Of Tv

2890 words - 12 pages introduction of television enabled advertisers to combine the effectiveness of both print and radio advertisements. Mander suggests that television is the optimum medium for the deliverance of advertisements for this reason and the following nine reasons.   Television is itself a commodity, and an expensive one too. Therefore, it is physically consistent with the prevalent reality. Its purchase gives the commodity system a boost

Television And Media Essay Daytime Talk Tv

1723 words - 7 pages out to be wild and crazy and make money, with no regard for those who help them achieve this. The other talk shows that appear on television, however, tend to be very positive and are working to some goal. These shows deal with people's feelings, conflicts and experiences and present them to the audience to help council them or guide them through common struggles that other people are dealing with . Oprah is renowned for her ability to deal

How Real Is Reality Tv Based On The Example Of Big Brother

774 words - 4 pages How real is reality TV Reality TV is a great way to enjoy a night and have a good laugh. Big Brother is an example of a reality TV show that is not completely real because of the fact they have selective casting, editing and character representation. Big Brother is set in Dream World, Gold Coast and it was created first in 2001 and aired on channel 10 for 7 years before being bought by channel nine and has been airing there since 2012. It is