Tempnature Art Vs. Nature In Shakespeare's The Tempest

1295 words - 5 pages

Art vs. Nature in The Tempest


   The debate between Art and Nature in The Tempest is very much based on the Renaissance debate, on whether “civilized man” or the "natural man" was superior. The advocates of  “civilized man” presenting the "natural man" as being savage, intemperate and brutal in contrast to the nobility, self-control and high-mindedness of the  “civilized man”. The advocates of "natural man" presenting him as what Rousseau was later to term the "noble savage" and the civilized man as being corrupt, affected, merely more adept at cloaking his vices, which were at best more refined, but nevertheless hardly a reason for pretensions to moral high ground. Montaigne, in his famous apologia for the "natural man", observes that it may be arguably more barbaric to "mangle by tortures and torments a body full of lively sense [...] under pretence of pietie and religion" than "to roast and eat him after he is dead".

            Shakespeare does not go to either extreme in The Tempest. The "natural man" (i.e. Caliban) is savage, intemperate and brutal, incapable of higher reasoning and lacking the innate intelligence for nurture to "stick" (as Prospero says in frustration) responding only to something that in effect could be considered, not inaccurately, as what would in modern terms be called a form of Pavlovian conditioning. While his portrayal is not totally unsympathetic (cf. the touching passage in Act III Scene II where he speaks of his "cr [ying] to dream again", it can also be argued that Prospero's alighting on the island, installing himself as ruler, and consequently -- albeit not unjustifiably -- depriving Caliban of his rights and liberty is per se somewhat questionable, depending on how one views colonization) he is nevertheless far from being admirable, far from being a "noble" savage in any way. Admittedly, he does serve to show the implications of Antonio's conscious choice of evil despite being born of a "good womb" and having every advantage of mind and upbringing.  However, he does not only "indicate corruption and degeneracy in the civilized world"; that would suggest a certain one-sidedness to the argument. On the contrary, he also serves as a contrast with the radiant virtue (Miranda and Ferdinand) and enlightened benevolence (Prospero, albeit more towards the end) of untainted nobility.

            It is in this context that the debate between Art and Nature takes place. Art, using the stricter definition, refers specifically to Prospero's magic, which he uses to control Nature; this Art, though not without some questionable aspects, (cf. "graves at my command / Have wak'd their sleepers", and his excessive threats to punish Ariel in Act I for nothing more than a polite request that he remember to release him), is chiefly used for benevolent purposes (i.e. for the restoration and perpetuation of the appropriate social order, for the edification of the others e.g. Alonso). Even the tempest at the...

Find Another Essay On tempnature Art vs. Nature in Shakespeare's The Tempest

European Colonization in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1306 words - 5 pages No Critique of European Colonization in The Tempest    Since the 1960s, several critics have found a critique of colonialism in their respective readings of Shakespeare's The Tempest. The most radical of these analyses takes Prospero to be a European invader of the magical but primitive land that he comes to rule, using his superior knowledge to enslave its original inhabitants, most notably Caliban, and forcing them to do his bidding

Prospero’s Loss in Shakespeare's The Tempest

2061 words - 8 pages Prospero’s Loss in The Tempest     Shakespeare’s The Tempest is a play about loss - more specifically, Prospero’s loss. Prospero is a tragic hero, in a sense, because he makes the transition from having everything to having nothing. He loses his daughter. He brings his enemies under his power only to eventually lose control and release them. In the end, he gives up his influence on the world – including his incredible power over nature

Importance of Environment in Shakespeare's The Tempest

2000 words - 8 pages begins with a tempest which invokes explicitly all four elements in their uproars, G. Wilson Knight has shown how constant the "tempest" idea and symbolism is in Shakespeare's thought: the movements of the cruel, ruthless, raging sea are frequently a symbol of the passions and emotions of men. It is Prospero's responsibility then as creator of the tempest to initiate change amongst the men under his rule; he has to bring disorder to order, storm to

Defending Prospero in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1796 words - 7 pages Defending Prospero in The Tempest      In William Shakespeare's The Tempest, the character of Prospero brings about a great deal of debate. Modern literary critics are quick to use him as a poster child for English colonial practice in the sixteenth and seventeenth century. Many see him as person who desires complete control of everything around him from the fish-like monster Caliban to his spirit servant Ariel, even his own daughter

The Theme of Colonialism in Shakespeare's Tempest

2640 words - 11 pages . Similarly, the colonists would do the same when they colonize a new land. They would take over whatever land they see and use nature as they see fit, such as exploiting resources and cutting forests to make way for farmland. In A Tempest by Aime Cesaire, the author takes a more literal approach in reflecting the colonial aspects of the play by depicting the characters Gonzalo and Sebastian as true colonists, who reflect on the financial gains they can

Mothers in William Shakespeare's The Tempest

2268 words - 9 pages Mothers in William Shakespeare's The Tempest Although Miranda’s mother and Sycorax never actually appear in The Tempest, their memories occupy a precarious position in Prospero’s will to power. Prospero invokes the memory of Miranda’s mother to legitimize his lineage, yet feels threatened by the control she exerts over it. His narration deftly erases his wife’s presence from Miranda’s memory, rendering him the sole purveyor of his

William Shakespeare's The Tempest

2257 words - 9 pages William Shakespeare's The Tempest Love, as defined by Merriam-Webster, is a “strong affection”, a “warm attraction”, an “unselfish loyal and benevolent concern” for another. It is “to feel a passion, devotion, or tenderness” for another. Love is simple and yet so utterly complex. Love is that which has the power to build you up and when taken away has the potential to knock you down. The Tempest by William Shakespeare is a political

William Shakespeare's The Tempest

3428 words - 14 pages before the opening performance of 'The Tempest' (1611), the first English settlement was established in Virginia, America and named after the reigning monarch, James I. This process, later termed as colonisation, clearly provoked much thought and consideration on behalf of Shakespeare. His play's remote island setting, previously inhabited by a single native and now amok with men of supposedly more civilised nature

William Shakespeare's The Tempest

1888 words - 8 pages William Shakespeare's The Tempest ‘The Tempest’ was Shakespeare’s last major play and is partly based on a true story about a ship called ‘The Seaventure’ which set sail for America in 1609. However, the ship was blown off course by a storm and ended up in Bermuda. This was the time when people were just beginning to explore the world and Bermuda was thought to be inhabited by spirits, demons and monsters. Shakespeare

Women in Elizabethan England and Shakespeare's Miranda in The Tempest

3502 words - 14 pages Women in Elizabethan England and Shakespeare's Miranda in The Tempest Treatment of women has evolved much since Elizabethan England. As a preface to the dissection of The Tempest – in particular, the character of Miranda, Shakespeare’s role for women as a whole must be addressed. According to Carolyn Ruth Swift Lenz’s introduction of Woman’s Part, “patriarchal order takes different forms and is portrayed with varying degrees of emphasis

Essay on the Setting in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1078 words - 4 pages Importance of Setting in The Tempest      Shakespeare’s enchanted island in The Tempest is a restorative pastoral setting, a place where ‘no man was his own’ and a place that offers endless possibilities to the people that arrive on it’s shores. Although the actual location of the island is not known, the worlds of Seneca aptly describe it’s significance to the play – it represents the ‘bounds of things, the remotest shores of the world

Similar Essays

Art And Nature In Shakespeare's The Tempest

1151 words - 5 pages Shakespeare bid farewell to his.  Prospero's island of paradise is no longer a place for enchantment, but instead a bare island, lacking "Spirits to enforce, art to enchant" (Tempest, 121).  The lonely state of nature without art to enhance it is one of Shakespeare's final points.  Prospero realizes then he must move back from whence his came, to his dukedom in Italy.  The island is now regarded as a place of transition where reality is reaffirmed

Opposition Between Art And Reality In Shakespeare's The Tempest

1181 words - 5 pages Opposition between Art and Reality in The Tempest       The Tempest is a self-reflexive play that explores the boundaries of art and reality. Shakespeare's island is a realm controlled by the artist figure; where the fabulous, the ideal and the imaginative are presented as both illusory and palpable, and where the audience is held in an indeterminate state, a "strange repose". The juxtaposition of the world of art with political and

Caliban In Shakespeare's The Tempest Essay

1868 words - 7 pages Shakespeare had read, and indeed quoted from Michel de Montaigne’s ‘Of Cannibals’ where it is argued that the customs of natives were not barbarous or uncivilised, merely different. Post – colonial interpretations of The Tempest appear to view Caliban in a similar light. Caliban’s wonderful grasp and description of his surroundings does not suggest evil, rather his words imply a true innocence. Caliban is not a monster and so should not be presented as such, he is simply bare, unimproved nature, an example of humanity at its rawest form.

Importance Of Language In Shakespeare's The Tempest

1866 words - 7 pages authors evaluate Shakespeare's play The Tempest to be a romance with a "comic subplot", and thereby show how important the interpretation of the language and interaction is in finding meaning in the play. Literary critic Richard Hillman says that, in general, romantic dramas are characterized by their fantasy-like atmosphere with love as the main focus or concern of the play, and they usually exhibit a complete disregard for normal or