"Ten Politically Incorrect Truths About Human Nature," In The July Issue Of Psychology Today Alan S. Miller

961 words - 4 pages

In his article, "Ten Politically Incorrect Truths About Human Nature," in the July issue of Psychology Today Alan S. Miller lacks evidence for the claims he makes. This article is an interesting read but hardly sound, if we pay attention to the facts. He is missing the key points when he claims that life is all about the interaction of experience, behavior, and environment. Miller forgets to include one's spirit, intuition, and love. Miller omits the role of culture to sustain a feedback for only what is attractive. This is an article summarizing conclusions which are presumably drawn from statistics like a horoscope. With all the statistics and collection methods removed, all these observations are only sometimes true and for some particular groups of people, but the devil is in the details which are not given. Even a philosophy teacher can tell us that good philosophy is backed up with sound reasons. Speculation may be interesting over a beer, but it does not make for good philosophy.Miller uses the idea of polygamy to explain the motives of suicide bombers in the Middle East when it is not even common in Muslim cultures. Postulating that this explains suicide bombers from those cultures is a stretch at best. The amount of polygamy practiced in such cultures is not nearly enough to have a significant impact on the population as a whole. "Polygamy increases competitive pressure on men, especially young men of low status. It therefore increases the likelihood that young men resort to violent means to gain access to mates." Miller appears certain that Darwinian incentives are the only motivators for human behavior; hence the astoundingly sweeping generalizations. "The surprising answer is that Muslim suicide bombing has nothing to do with Islam or the Quran." Having found a Darwinian reason why young Muslim men might be inclined to suicide bombing (assuming, of course, that there actually is a vast shortage of females for Middle Eastern Muslim men), they jump to the absurd conclusion that the phenomenon "has nothing to do with" the barbarous teachings of Islam. This is nonsense. Beliefs absolutely have behavioral consequences and suicide bombing is one consequence of Islam's conquering mentality and cult of martyrdom.Most of the reasons given why men like the sort of women that appear on modern magazine covers are not backed up by any evolutionary psychology. Miller alleged that "A recent study shows that in Iran, where exposure to Western media and culture is limited, women are actually more concerned with their body image, and want to lose more weight, than their American counterparts." This a perfect example of sexism. Just because the women in a country, such as Iran, would try to look more beautiful for men's attention long ago, does not justify an evolutionary reason for men to look at women as targets to conquer and abandon....

Find Another Essay On "Ten Politically Incorrect Truths About Human Nature," in the July issue of Psychology Today Alan S. Miller

Thoreau´s View on Nature and Human Necessities

1495 words - 6 pages describes the hooting owls as “idiotic and maniacal”, meaning they voice “unsatisfied thoughts which all have”. He takes note how Nature creeps up to his windowsill. Thoreau says, “Nature and human life are as various as our several constitutions. The draught of the morning air was the only medicine he needed in life. He was in awe of the morning air, he felt that every man should have a dose, and it should be sold in the shops. Why did he choose to

"Forever Linked to the Ancients" -describes how Homer's "The Odyssey" is still very much relevant today. -explains how human nature links us to the ancient greeks of Homer's time

1101 words - 4 pages characteristics that transcend time and place. Human nature has yet to change and it is more than likely that it never will. By observing the heroic epic The Odyssey, one could find that the ancient Greeks possessed many of the same traits as modern people do today such as love, greed, and deceit.One of the major elements of human nature that dominates The Odyssey is love. Love is what drives Odysseus to endure ten years of grueling hardship during

The issue of occupational stress in 1990's-2000's.

1336 words - 5 pages Occupational stress in the 1990s-2000's is an important issue. In our society, work underlies self-esteem and identity. In the past, workplace health concerns focused mainly on safety and physical working conditions. However, over this period complaints of occupational stress have skyrocketed. Today, it is recognized that occupational stress can affect people in all areas and at all levels of work. Occupational stress impacts people's health and

The Nature of Psychology

1477 words - 6 pages behavior because it is an assumed quality and not a concrete fact or set of rule. Overconfidence is a human behavior that lends us to be self-predicting on what will be done. In actuality this overconfidence is only correct about 30% of the time when used for a specific behavior, which makes it a poor judge or aid in behavior study. Believing one would have seen an outcome after it has already happened is hindsight bias. Hindsight bias would

Miller: Finding Religious Truths in Science

1236 words - 5 pages [sending] ourselves to Hell.” (Miller 591) The metaphor manifests itself frequently to strengthen the author’s emotional appeal of stirring scientists who equate The Bible with God by using similar appeals as the beloved biblical text to support free agency. Furthermore, Miller deliberately states his credentials as a scientist and a Christian to give the reader ethical evidence that he is qualified to write about spiritual topics in relevance

Human Race - Race of Human? Essay about the various aspects of "Cry, The Beloved Country" by Alan Paton

1397 words - 6 pages Human Race - Race of Human?Whose fault is it when people are murderers when they have no other option? Is it the nature of the murderer or is the person shaped to be a murderer by society? Either of these two circumstances, it is the society that creates these unfortunate murderers. The native people of South Africa are the victims of this kind of biased society. Alan Paton's 1948 novel, Cry, the Beloved Country addresses these problems of South

Human Nature in Lord of the Flies

659 words - 3 pages appreciate the island's beauty as opposed to being their graveyard. These are examples of how Golding counters his own belief in the book Lord of the Flies.Lastly, there is the rational belief in human nature. In real life, what is evil? Why kill? What is the difference between Hitler and Gandhi? The fact is, the nature of people is not evil, but that of an animal. The clownfish and sea anemone do not fight, but coexist for mutual beneficence. But

Human Nature in Lord of the Flies

598 words - 2 pages Human Nature in Lord of the Flies Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, is a captivating narrative in which the reader lives through the trials and tribulations of a society set up and run by a group of marooned British teens. Golding believes that the basic nature of the individual is evil. The group ultimately proves this thesis by their actions. The evils of the individual are shown through the actions of the group’s hunter Jack

Failure of the July Plot in 1944

4593 words - 18 pages information on Hitler's movements. Thankfully Stauffenberg was appointed as Chief of Staff to General Fromm, head of the Home Army. From there he would have ample information on Hitler's whereabouts. In the summer of 1944 Rommel was approached about joining the July Plot. He refused, criticising their tactics and claiming that assassination would turn Hitler into a martyr. Instead he suggested that Hitler should be

The Issue of Human Trafficking

1436 words - 6 pages When we think about slavery, we think those days are long behind us. We think about the 19th century when people used others to do their labor in exchange for shelter and food. What we don’t realize, however, is that the act of slavery is still a very prevalent issue today, under the name of human trafficking. Human traffickers are those who victimize others in their desire to profit from the existing demand. People of all ages, even

The Meaning of Nature and Nurture in Psychology

1863 words - 7 pages The Meaning of Nature and Nurture in Psychology The nature nurture dichotomy is a theme always present in many areas of psychology. But is it right to talk about it as a dichotomy? , Certainly not. To say so would be like stating that they never act

Similar Essays

Human Nature According To Psychoanalysis And The Humanistic Psychology

1649 words - 7 pages Human Nature According to Psychoanalysis and the Humanistic Psychology As Carl Jung stated “ As far as we can discern, the sole purpose of human existence is to kindle a light of

Analyzing Shakespeare´S Account Of Human Nature In King Lear In Comparison With Other Authors

1697 words - 7 pages Human nature is a concept that has interested scholars throughout history. Many have debated over what human nature is – that is, the distinguishing characteristics that are unique to humans by nature – while others have mulled over the fact that the answer to the question “what is human nature?” may be unattainable or simply not worth pursuing. Shakespeare explores the issue of human nature in his tragedy King Lear. In his play, he attempts to

A Treatise Of Human Nature: David Hume´S Philosophy

932 words - 4 pages believe that knowledge is sensory, or experience, based; in essence, that human beings are tabula rasa. It is upon the latter end of this dichotomic spectrum that we find Hume’s epistemology; that of empiricism. Hume divides experiences, or perceptions, into two categories. The first is impressions, and the second is ideas. These are distinguished between one another, he says, by their respective degrees of force and vivacity; that is, how strongly

Relationship Magnitude Paper: Write On The Balance Of Human, Animal And Nature From A Case Study In "Watersheds 4: Ten Cases In Environmental Ethics". Case Study Skunked Was Picked.

850 words - 3 pages In the case study Skunked the balance of human, animals and the nature itself are in constant struggle for balance. Over fishing the waters has become a major concern with the decreasing amount of fish caught annually which in turn decreases the money coming into the fisherman’s family. An ecological balance may never be met due to the current demand worldwide and it will only get worse if regulation is not implemented and agreed upon.Over