This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tension Between The Legislative And Judicial Arms Of Government

1991 words - 8 pages

Tension between the legislative and judicial arms of government would appear to be an inevitable consequence of the doctrine of separation of powers. This has evolved as a key tenet of most modern democracies and is designed to safeguard the population against autocratic or dictatorial rule. The separation of powers is a functional dimension of the Australian Constitution designed to divide power between the legislative, executive and judicial arms of government, and to assign areas of responsibility. These responsibilities, to put it simply, are:1.Legislative-The power to make laws;2.Executive-The power to carry the laws into effect; and3.Judicial-The power to interpret or discover the law .In theory, the doctrine provides a system in which power cannot be concentrated in to any one governmental or political arm. It presents a system of checks and balances and provides a method of accountability given the interdependence of roles. But the fundamental element of the doctrine that gives rise to considerable tension between the arms of government is the ability for one arm of government to restrain the actions of another. For example, the legislative arm can restrain the executive by refusing to pass proposed legislation or initiating investigations against the executive. The executive can restrain the legislature by calling for elections to replace the parliament or by refusing to enforce certain laws. The courts can restrain both the legislature and executive by nullifying laws and preventing them from acting unless they are in accordance with fundamental laws. The Executive and Legislative arms can restrain the Courts by overturning judge-made law and, in extreme cases, by removing particular judges from the bench .It is due to both the threat to use these checks and balances and the system of accountability, and occasional confronting actions, that tension is generated between the arms of government.In practice, the doctrine of separation of powers is difficult to execute precisely as it was intended. Due to the necessity for a practical, effective and efficient system of governance, the executive and legislative arms of government are required to somewhat blur the lines of separation and work together with some degree of compliance. This prevents situations of deadlock in implementing effective governance, where one or both contending arms may take into account political or social imperatives rather than insisting on absolute actions or compliance. It could be said that they are then semi-autonomous. The judiciary, however, must always remain strictly autonomous in order to be seen as independent.Another of the duties granted to the High Court of Australia, in relation to the legislature, is to determine whether federal legislation falls within the powers granted to the legislature by the constitution. This responsibility in respect to the consideration of the constitutional validity of Commonwealth laws and executive actions granted to the...

Find Another Essay On Tension Between the Legislative and Judicial Arms of Government

The Causes of tension Between Hinduism and Islam

1226 words - 5 pages While analyzing past interactions between Hinduism and Islam, we can see some outstanding tensions that arise from territorial conflict between India, a predominantly Hindu country, and Pakistan, a predominantly Muslim country. The primary focus of this tension arises from a common area – Kashmir/Jammu. The conflict in this region can be accredited to the differences in religion. The conflict in Kashmir stems from 1947. This was the year the

The gradual transfer of legislative power from the imperial government to the colonies, States and the Commonwealth

2510 words - 10 pages important bill in Australia's history. It made a long list of changes and had significant symbolic impact on Australia and its legislative independence.It established the new federal government and regulated the relationship between federal and state governments (as the colonial governments were redesignated). The six states continue to have an important role in government of the nation. Section 106 of the Constitution provides that, subject to that

Legislative Success: The Legislative Point of View

791 words - 4 pages In general for any level of government, a private agency or even within one group, gaining support starts with interest, need, demand, and potential success. Legislative changes will go nowhere without one or more of these concepts. Nor should it- whats the point? Legislative success among the president deals greatly with legislative advocacy. Legislation is generally successful when a large majority of those to be affected will benefit from

Causes of Tension Between Cuba and the United States, and The Bay of Pigs Invasion

1282 words - 5 pages Causes of Tension Between Cuba and the United States, and The Bay of Pigs InvasionOn January 9, 1959, following their successful overthrow of the oppressive Batista regime, a band of freedom fighters, anchored by Fidel Castro, marched through the Cuban capital city of Havana. Upon his arrival, Castro immediately seized control of the Cuban government and declared himself the highest executive of the island nation, Premier of Cuba. In April of

Coexistence of capitalism and democracy, tension between capitalism and democracy

1761 words - 7 pages We live in a globalize society, where economy and politic are intertwined, creating tensions in our society. Question is, what caused these two spheres to combine together, how they are combined together to create tensions and when did the combination happen? According to Eric Hobsbawm, in "The Age of Empire", he argues that fusion between economies and politic appeared in modern empire or he refers as the "New Imperialism" during 1875 to 1914

Conflict and Tension Between The Proctors in The Crucible

1461 words - 6 pages How Does Millar Create a Sense of Tension and Conflict Between John and Elizabeth Proctor at the Beginning of Act 2? Arthur Miller was borne on the 17th of October 1915 in New York City. Miller believed that tragedy was not confined to the rich and important but that the ordinary man’s failure was just as moving and terrible. The play ‘The Crucible’ was first produced in 1953 in the middle of the McCarthy political witch hunt in America

The Tension between Beauty and Virtue in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95

1229 words - 5 pages The Tension between Beauty and Virtue in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95      "Sonnet 95" of Shakespeare's "blond young man" sonnets depicts a tension-filled variation on the classic blazon. The poet seems torn between the "shame" (1) that taints his subject and the "sweets" (4) of the subject 's beauty. The initial imagery of a "canker" (2) within a "rose" (2) serves to set up the sexual overtones that dominate the poem, as well as to

How does the tension between traditional and modern views of the world play itself out in Achebe's and Desai's novels?

899 words - 4 pages In both Achebe's and Desai's novels, tension and conflict between the new and the old, traditional and modern are the strong undercurrents that move the story and the reader into an unconscious emotional uneasiness. In both novels, the backdrop and the story are engrossed in a struggle between two worlds, the new and the old fighting out its battles in the characters portrayed within. Achebe makes his stand in eastern Nigeria while Desai

How does Galileo view the issue of religion and science? How does he resolve the tension between religion and science?

1127 words - 5 pages Christina was Galileo's attempt to resolve the tension between religion and science; his letter tried to open the minds of people to new findings. It also examined the true meaning of the scripture and then correctly interprets it.Church officials were unwilling to except new findings because of their own self-pride and fear. Galileo accused them of, "showing a greater fondness for their own opinions than for the truth, they sought to deny and disprove

The Legislative Process and the Congressional Committees

1571 words - 6 pages The United States Congress was created by the framers of the Constitution as the most important part of the legislative branch of the national government. The Congress was set up with a bicameral structure composed by the House of Representatives or Lower Chamber and the Senate or Upper Chamber. According to “Origins and Development” and “History of the House”, two descriptions of the history of the Congress, both chambers assembled for the very

The Relationship Between Business and Government

1534 words - 6 pages Stone, 1096, 30-45, 62. http://search.proquest. Machan,T. (1988). Government regulation of business: The moral arguments. The Freeman,38 (7). Retrieved from -business-the-moral-arguments/ Milkin Institute Global Conference (2009). The new relationship between government and business. Retrieved from detail&EvID=1957&eventid=gc09 National Center for Smart Growth Research and Education. (2008). Retrieved from http://www.

Similar Essays

Who Really Has All The Power: The Executive, Legislative, Or Judicial Branch Of Government?

986 words - 4 pages . Executive Branch, which pertains to executing the laws. The legislative, which creates the laws and the judicial which interprets the laws. The constitution states their powers and their checks on one another, and its obvious that the legislative has the most power over all the other branches. “Congress, as one of the three coequal branches of government, is ascribed significant powers by the Constitution.” ("white house") Article I of the

Comparison Of The Government Of Japan And Australia Legislative System

856 words - 3 pages Constitutional amendments, independently investigating the Government and impeaching Judges of the judicial branch convicted of unethical conduct. The Legislature also plays the pivotal role in formally selecting the Prime Minister of Japan. The lower house of the Diet of Japan has 480 members, elected for an unrenewable four-year term. In Australia the lower house consists of 150 members who are elected for a 3 year term which is renewable once. The Upper

The Difference Between Judicial Activism And Judicial Restraint

846 words - 3 pages The Difference between Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint Our American judiciary branch of the federal government has contributed and molded our American beliefs in this great nation. This branch of government is respected because of the code of conduct that the judges, no matter how conservative or liberal. The language of the court as well as the uniform of the cloaks that judges wear has most probably contributed towards this

Ways The Executive Branch Of The U.S. Goverment, Through Various Laws And Acts, Gained Power Over The Legislative And Judicial Brances

1735 words - 7 pages "Using specific examples discuss how Madison's observations in Federalist Paper 51 apply to the relationship between the legislative branch and the modern president."In order to keep the government from becoming too powerful and endangering the liberty of its people, the framers of the United States' Constitution endorsed the implementation of separation of powers so that the different branches of the government would keep one another in check