Tenure And Termination Essay

1761 words - 7 pages

Tenure and Termination
Tenure is a position aspired to by all beginning teachers. Tenure is a form of job security that teachers can earn after they reach a certain level of professionalism (Scott, 1986). Once a teacher has earned tenure they are able to maintain an ongoing employment contract within an educational system, as long as they abide by the rules and regulations outlined in their contract.
Many states have created tenure policies to protect competent teachers from malicious accusations, and these policies can vary state to state. In this report there will be an exploration on the tenure and termination policy as it applies to the state of New York, an examination on an allegation against a school teacher based on facts and details provided, a review of the investigative process as it pertains to state law, and an outline on the various steps taken by an administrator in addressing this situation.
Overview of Statutes and Case Law in New York
Tenure is a policy that has been designed to protect teachers from false accusations and various injustices that may take place throughout ones career. For example, one of the rights afforded a tenured teacher is they cannot be discriminated against based on their personal views or belief systems outside of the educational arena. Also, they cannot be terminated without full due process. Tenure will not, however, protect educators who are incapable, ineffective, or are in violation of school board rules (Essex, 2012).
Based on the tenure in New York, Code-Section 3012, it stipulates that teachers will have a probationary period of three years, with the exception of a teacher who has demonstrated satisfactory service as a regular substitute for a period of two years (FindLaw, 2014). Tenured teachers are viewed as having a greater right to due process than non-tenured teachers. The purpose of “tenure” is to keep teachers from being discharged for “arbitrary and capricious reasons” (Essex, 2012). Teachers of tenure should not be removed from teaching except for (1) “insubordination or immoral character,” 2) “inefficiency, incompetency, physical or mental disability or neglect of duty,” and (3) “failure to maintain certification” (FindLaw, 2014).
According to the court case Stoddard v. School District, a teacher was denied renewal of her teaching contract because of teaching deficiencies (Leagle, 1974). The teacher contested that the board failed to show how she violated the first or fourteenth amendment, which was her freedom of speech and the right to have equal protection under the law. The teacher won the case as the board did not have a constitutional reason to have a non-renewal of her contract (Leagle, 1974). In another case, Toney v. Fairbanks North Star Borough School District (1994), the Alaska Supreme Court upheld a teacher’s termination because she failed to disclose a sexual relationship with a former student (Find Law for Legal Professionals, 2014). The school felt they were...

Find Another Essay On Tenure and Termination

Decentralizing the Railroads after the Great War

1685 words - 7 pages the industry, including the addition of provisions for railroad workers, unions, and customers. Upon examination of the Transportation Act of 1920 itself, one can clearly see the great lengths Congress went so workers' and customers' rights were protected from the railroad companies. The act is broken into several sections, namely: • "Termination of federal control," • "Disputes between carriers and their employees and subordinate officials

Constitutional Rights in the Workplace- Patton-Fuller Community Hospital

1608 words - 6 pages drug testing is up 277 percent from 1987 - despite the fact that random drug testing is unfair, often inaccurate and unproven as a means of stopping drug use." (American Civil Liberties Union, 1997)Even though drug testing in the workplace has been become common place in most work environments when applying for a new job, what about random drug testing during the tenure of employment? Random drug testing is not regulated in the private sector

People’s Democratic Party

1211 words - 5 pages Goodluck Ebele Jonathan-- a southerner to the seat of power before the formal termination of Yar’dua’s first-four-year tenure in 2011, the political equation has been significantly altered. This incident had caused tension in the political arena, with the conservatives mostly from the northern part of the country insisting that the current president should not contest, per the gentleman agreement reached in 2002. But, both the PDP’s and the

Technology and The Workplace

1776 words - 7 pages tenure, learned status, ethical practices, and a variety of other matters. Ethics in business is primarily an applied ethics. Ethics influences the value system of every organization and employee by serving as a moral guide or base. Furthermore, business ethics is a potential vehicle for employee pride and motivation as well as a focus for customer satisfaction. Ethics is a part of the manager’s

Workplace Case Study

1739 words - 7 pages and Evaluate AlternativesReviewing the Case Study we can clearly say that Mr. Dunlap's philosophy was effective to a certain extent. His approach was able to get the company turned around and out of the red. That doesn't necessarily make it the best option. The Scott company executives could have instituted initiatives that would have had the same effect. The Scott executives could have recommended the termination of all non-essential personnel

Case Study Analysis: Faith Community Hospital

2248 words - 9 pages organization, employees, and patients. Of the problems identified, the most prevalent on its own and in the other issues recognized is the deficiencies in communication.BackgroundIn approximately two-weeks, Pat, the CEO of Faith Community Hospital is conducting an all-member staff meeting with media in attendance. This will be the first all-member staff member conducted during Pat's 10-year tenure as CEO. Pat wants to use that opportunity to

Andragogy: The Art and Science of Helping Adults Learn

2385 words - 10 pages certain paths within various times. Although some have taken issue with Knowles assumptions, Knowles assumptions do give a general context for andragogy that will always have a degree of validity, no matter the critics. Although, my previous experience did not help my tenure within higher education, I am of the opinion, after subsequent learning experiences, I could go back and appreciate the information that one should acquire from such an

The Labor Movement

2247 words - 9 pages Blacks seeking a better life. (Lane, 1987) The bargaining position of such laborers was weak, since no legislation existed at the time to protect their rights, and any protests made about working conditions or other issues were met with termination and replacement, owing to the large pool of unskilled labor. (Lane, 1987) The time period also met with the rise of the "captains of industry", many of whom were instrumental in the success of the North

Senior managers can be rewarded as much for their contribution to organisational failure as for their contribution to organisational success. Discuss.

3276 words - 13 pages ;26,302 a month for the next nine months, bringing his pay-off to £379,293, Mellor will also enjoy private health insurance and the use of a company car.This nearly provoked investor rebellion as Mellor was not exactly seen as being the most competent of directors. During a 5 year term at the helm of AWG his tenure had been chequered to say the least. He was criticised for his restructuring of the company, which involved refinancing the

Importace of Corporate Governance

3419 words - 14 pages water privatisation plans. As well as a one-off cash payment of �142,575 and �26,302 a month for the next nine months, bringing his pay-off to �379,293, Mellor will also enjoy private health insurance and the use of a company car. This nearly provoked investor rebellion as Mellor was not exactly seen as being the most competent of directors. During a 5 year term at the helm of AWG his tenure had been chequered to say the least. He was criticised

Age Discrimination in the Public Sector

3396 words - 14 pages filed a wrongful termination action against the hospital claiming, among other cause of action, “wrongful discharge in violation of a public policy against age discrimination.” The hospital argued that the policy against age discrimination in employment was not a fundamental public policy and that the claim was barred because Stevenson had not exhausted her statutory remedies under FEHA. The court held that “the policy prohibiting employment

Similar Essays

We Must Reform Teacher Tenure Essay

1532 words - 6 pages . . Tenure began in the early 20th century. It was meant to protect teachers from wrongful termination. In that time race, personal bias, and politics could get even very effective teachers fired. Women were often targeted when they got married or became pregnant. With tenure, even if a school district tries to fire an incompetent teacher or one who is guilty of misconduct it can become very difficult and expensive It also protected teachers whose

Tenure Proposal Essay

2023 words - 8 pages of ability” (p. 3). But is tenure necessary for these things to occur? Shouldn’t any professional have the right to do their jobs to the best of their abilities, without fear of wrongful termination, and be able to have economic security while doing those jobs? While most people, including me, would answer “yes” to wanting all professionals to do their jobs well, be paid appropriately, and have some semblance of job security, this is not

Law Case Study On Property

2981 words - 12 pages dangerous drug). Mary immediately gives John notice to vacate the studio saying "I won't allow you making trouble on my property". Advise John.The essence of this case is whether John's occupation is under a lease or just under a licence. The distinction between a lease and a licence is important because John will enjoy the security of tenure legislation found in the Land and Tenant (Consolidation) Ordinance (LTCO), while he does not if he occupies

Higher Education Essay

913 words - 4 pages shared skills, it is imperative that higher education challenges established traditions and values which are no longer in alignment with the new academic perspectives. The national debate on education raised similar concerns about the educator tenure process, teaching strategies, and resources. These three areas are not the only ones higher education may try to improve. However, they represent a starting point to positively transform the teaching and