This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tenure Proposal Essay

2023 words - 8 pages

Tenure, according to the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), “is an arrangement whereby faculty members, after successful completion of a period of probationary service, can be dismissed only for adequate cause or other possible circumstances and only after a hearing before a faculty committee” (“Tenure,” n.d.). While this may sound quite simple and straightforward, tenure is a concept that has been met with much debate, especially over the past several years. “Some institutions and administrators contend that tenure is an antiquated system that imposed inflexible burdens on the academy, and may foster – or even encourage mediocrity” (Hill, 2010, p. 112). Schools have spent a great deal of effort looking for ways to institute, improve, or even eliminate tenure policies at their institutions.
“The goal of tenure is to create a contractual relationship between a professor and the college or university that is enforceable in a court of law” (Cameron, 2010, p. 1). It is also a “means to a certain ends,” according to the 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure (the “1940 Statement”), published by the AAUP (p. 3). Namely, these ends are: “…freedom of teaching and research and of extramural activities, and (2) a sufficient degree of economic security to make the profession to men and women of ability” (p. 3). But is tenure necessary for these things to occur? Shouldn’t any professional have the right to do their jobs to the best of their abilities, without fear of wrongful termination, and be able to have economic security while doing those jobs?
While most people, including me, would answer “yes” to wanting all professionals to do their jobs well, be paid appropriately, and have some semblance of job security, this is not always the case. Many professionals, especially those outside of teaching, have lost their jobs as management changed or when arbitrary staffing decisions were made. Professionals are not always paid enough for what they do (consider fire fighters, public school teachers, and other civil servants), and not every professional performs at their job at the highest level of which they

are capable. Should college or university professors be any different? Should professors be guaranteed lifetime employment, just because they earned tenure?
Before these questions can be answered, the tenure policies that have already been established in various colleges and universities need to be explored. In order for tenure to be implemented at a college, it must be promised via faculty handbook, contract, or any other written policy (Kaplin & Lee, 2007). Administrators cannot verbally make promises to faculty or job candidates that either “contradict the written policies” or make it seem as though there is more job security than there really is (2007, p.187). When this does happen, it generally does not win in court. A notable example of this was the case of The Johns Hopkins University...

Find Another Essay On Tenure Proposal

Higher Education Case Study: Weston University

1705 words - 7 pages Weston University Case Summary The new president of Weston University, Dr. Diana Ball, took over in late 1995, succeeding Dr. Harold Powers. Dr. Powers led the prestigious private university for fifteen years from a human resource frame to tailor the organization to individuals (Bolman & Deal, 2013, p. 16). Moreover, during Dr. Power's tenure, the reputation of once-leading private university in the Midwest diminished. Dr. Power's reputation

Fixed-Term Contract Essay

2460 words - 10 pages STATEMENT Fixed-term contract of employment has been characterised by the detrimental effect of this type of employment to the worker. For the purpose of this research, three legal issues are highlighted. They are the lack of specific legislation, security of tenure, unequal treatment and elimination of direct employment relationship. 1.2.1 LACK OF SPECIFIC LEGISLATION The first legal issue in regards to the fixed-term contract of employment in

Presidency of James Carter

1161 words - 5 pages . There were various events that occurred during his presidency and affected his tenure. His political resume started when he took the seat on his local board of education. He then proceeded to run for Georgia State Senate. In 1962, he won the election and became the Georgia State Senate as a Democrat. Two years later, in 1964, he was then reelected. President Carter’s next step was an attempt to run for governor’s position in office. Unfortunately

Gun Control Proposal

1194 words - 5 pages A Proposal Based on President Obama's 2013 State of the Union Address2013 has been embossed by recent incidents such as a Vegas shooting that ended the lives of three people, four gruesome murders in Orange County in California, and many more tragedies. It is estimated that there are 300 million guns in personal hands in the US today, many legally owned and others not (Neyfakh). Every year, close to four million guns find their way into the

The Unique History of Alabama State University

1518 words - 6 pages 1873. George N. Card is mostly noted for serving as president when the Lincoln Normal School became the nation's first state supported Liberal Arts College for African American. Card also established Alabama State College Laboratory High School, in Marion, Alabama in 1874. During Card's tenure as president, the Klu Klux Klan in Marion, Alabama endangered the lives of the African Americans attending the institution. In 1878, to the delight of

Protection, Reintegration, And Resettlement Of IDPs

2576 words - 10 pages of IDPs and immigrants to resettle and start a better life. Besides this the project contributed in upgrading human knowledge in terms of educational training for IDPs, municipal workers and authorities. It also structured legal matters like security of tenure that later became a reference for the rest of municipalities in Somalia. Its success has been replicated to other IDPs in Bosasso and other cities of the country. Site Bosaso is a city

Outdoor Education Program and Research Proposal Part 2

2222 words - 9 pages students will have the necessary skills to progress to the next levels of the curriculum. Budget The College of Education has an annual operating budget of $10 million. 90 percent ($9 million) of this goes to payroll and benefits. $200,000 of this $9 million is spent on part-time employees. For the purposes of this proposal, budget considerations will focus primarily on the delivery of the major courses only, and will exclude items such as

Combining the Techniques of Journalism and Radio

1644 words - 7 pages country’s most historic football clubs and as such this story attracts a large amount of public interest. The politico-economic context of the story means it touches on a wide range of issues affecting football not just that of one club. Proposal 1: Print Journalism Theoretical Background Journalism is the factual reporting of an event both contemporary and contextual. A central concept to the production of journalism is the idea of what is

The New Change

1116 words - 5 pages years now, the U.S has been fighting the issues within the problem of healthcare insurance. Therefore the two main causes for preventing every citizen in the U.S from getting healthcare insurance is unemployment and high cost. Throughout the years in the U.S, there have been proposals to solve providing healthcare to citizens. One recent proposal that has occurred in present day is the Obamacare plan. The Obamacare plan is called the “Affordable

Interclean Compensation Plan

1217 words - 5 pages InterClean Compensation ProposalJulie DeanUniversity of PhoenixHRM 531December 21, 2009MEMORANDUMTO: HR Department Manager FROM: Julie Dean SUBJECT: Proposal for the New Compensation PlanDATE: December 21, 2009Over the past few weeks we have made a lot of progress in the merger of InterClean and Enviro Tech. We have completed the job analysis and selection requirements, the training and mentoring plan and the performance and career management

Frederick Douglass

677 words - 3 pages . Douglass’ achieving literacy was his first step towards achieving his freedom.   Douglass also demonstrated great courage during his tenure as a slave. When his master sent him to live with Mr. Covey for a year, a man who had a reputation for breaking slaves, Douglass tells us that “scarce a week passed without his whipping me.” After six months of regular beatings he had had enough; he “resolved to fight. ” When Covey began to beat him, Douglass

Similar Essays

Education Policy In Michigan Essay

2340 words - 9 pages the House and Senate, created Proposal A. This policy increased funding to all levels of education, reduced the large funding gap between poorer and richer school districts, and opened schools of choice. Proposal A was largely effective in its’ objectives, but was unable to maintain the projected budget needed to maintain efficiency due to the recession, and Michigan laws requiring education cuts when school revenues fall below projections

Pleasant Ridge Collective Bargaining Case – Analytical Paper

1701 words - 7 pages 30 to 25 students in each class, but 27 students in the class is the median elementary (K-6) class size. The school budget cannot handle more teachers’ employment for the time being. The granted tenure change from the sixth grade to the second year of teaching will cause harm to 50 teachers who are not members of PRCTA and not covered. It is difficult for the school to handle any staff reduction, because the school still have to pay for the

Changing The Image Of The Youth Minister

2631 words - 11 pages Changing the Image of the Youth Minister For the past twenty years, the average tenure of youth ministers has been disgustingly short. “Fifteen hundred Youth Pastors leave the ministry each month due to moral failure, getting a better paid position, spiritual burnout, or contention in their churches” (Krejcir 1). What factors are causing this? Do they have commitment issues? Do the senior pastors not trust them? Do they see the job as a

Institutionalized Sexism In Academia: Real Or Perceived

1969 words - 8 pages Introduction: For this research proposal I will study what effects perceived and actual sexism on the upward mobility of women in academia. It is clear that sexism effects women’s progress in many facets of society. The gender gap is especially prominent in time consuming and intensive professions such as academia. This research seeks to explore the causal factors for the gender disparities in order to help develop effective solutions. My