Test Creators Should Not Edit Quotes

879 words - 4 pages

Whether you know it or not, the plethora of literary excerpts that you have been exposed to throughout your education may have been edited and sanitized. That’s right, those so-called “quotes” extracted from literary professionals may very well have been mangled and rearranged so as not to risk “offending” any test takers or to avoid “controversial issues.” This may not sound like a major concern to many, however, how can we know the extent to which the creators of standardized tests warp these works? When they do this, are we as the readers truly receiving the pure message of the author? If you were to ask any author about this issue, they would most likely tell you something along the lines of the ideas of author Anna Quindlen, that editing pieces of writing for tests is not only “betrayal of the writers by bureaucrats, but the betrayal of children by educators.” In all sense, writing is meant to provoke thought, to cause a commotion, so what good is it if we take out every word, idea, even theme that one person could view as inappropriate? On one hand, editing excerpts and essays may serve a noble purpose, so as to not offend a group or individual, but overall, sanitizing a work of literature can often lead to a misconstrued understanding of the piece that only results in educational deprivation for students.
Consider this situation. You are a high school student taking the state standardized English test. You sit down and begin to read the first passage, one from The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, a novel you had read earlier in the year. However, this time something does not seem right and upon rereading you notice that where the original novel had once used the “N-word”, this excerpt constantly replaces it with “slave”. Now back to reality. This exact situation in occurring across our nation as not only this novel, but many other books, essays, and poems are being changed for scholarly purposes. Although the manner in which these pieces are written may be offensive to some, there is a reason that the authors write what they do. Whether it is in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, where the author is illustrating the time period and sentiments through language, or if it is a novel recounting the brutal events of the holocaust, standardized test agencies and creators take it upon themselves to excise these “unacceptable” aspects in order to avoid any discomfort, distraction, or offense that could possibly be provided for the students. This seems...

Find Another Essay On Test Creators Should NOT Edit Quotes

Animals for biomedical research Essay

793 words - 3 pages (3a).___ Quotes, paraphrases, and summaries should be used to support your assertions (51BH). Introduce and cite quoted material (52): One critic states that "Hamlet's major flaw is indecision" (Smith 21).Don't use quotes or questions as topic sentences to begin your paragraphs or as a thesis statement. Quotes should not make up more than ¼ of your paper.___ Works Cited page formatting pp. 571-2 and p. 588 BH___ Put the word count on bottom

How To Make a Website Essay

594 words - 2 pages necessary changes should be made, edit your document. The third step in making your own site is to find a web host. A website host let’s you upload pages and files. In order to do this, you’ll need an FTP client. A web host may have an FTP feature or you can download your won FTP program in filezilla-project.org or in smartftp.com. After uploading them, your site is finished! Before anything else, test drive it first. Ask friends to visit your new site

How To Do A Essay

541 words - 2 pages questions can be an effective way of getting yourself to think about specific topics.      Secondly, the next step is supporting the thesis. Usually, you need three supporting paragraphs and those can be the body parts of the essay. You should organize adequate and specific details. Supporting paragraphs consist of concrete evidence such as giving examples, getting direct quotes, and personal experiences. Each one has the

testx

10872 words - 43 pages change sets can be configured to not just contain committable files, but files with other file states as well, e.g. unchanged files. You also can configure, whether the change set should be kept or deleted automatically once it becomes empty. These options allow, for example, to put files into change sets and hence remove them visually from the project structure, which will be changed temporarily but should not be committed. Change Sets are

Mexican Constitution

4428 words - 18 pages Amendment[edit]On November 8, 2005, The Senate of Mexico adopted a final decree amending the Constitution as approved by the majority of the Federated States, modifying articles 14 and 22[28] banning the use of capital punishment in its entirety.Current articles of the constitution[edit]The main ideas or an abstract of the current contents of the articles of the Political Constitution of the United Mexican States is as follows. Not all articles are

Great Gatsby

8525 words - 34 pages Sunday? (Pause.) Or Monday? (Pause.) Or Friday? VLADIMIR(looking wildly about him, as though the date was inscribed in the landscape) It's not possible! ESTRAGON Or Thursday? (1.132-40) Add this to the list of uncertainties surrounding the act of waiting for Godot. Not only are the men unsure of what day they are supposed to meet him, but even if they were, they couldn't know what day it is anyway. Part of the problem here is that what should be

Testing

950 words - 4 pages Fortunately, Montana homeschool parents are not required to test their students each year. Montana homeschool families have fought hard over the years and have been diligent to protect this freedom of choice. While it is true that standardized achievement tests have their flaws, achievement tests can be a useful tool for homeschool parents, helping them evaluate their student’s course of study or the parent’s teaching materials or methods

Programming experience

1027 words - 5 pages test-cases with set of parameters through hierarchical structured xml files test suite. Primary xml file consists of test-scenarios and maps to secondary xml files for each test-scenario. The secondary xml file consists of set of test-cases which completes a test-scenario. For example, a simple record and publish test scenario should comprise of record test-case and publish test-case. Test-cases present in secondary xml file is mapped to ClassA test

Eight Grade Mathematics Lesson Plan

1996 words - 8 pages * Student email accounts: o Students will use the email account to register and log onto the website o Students will obtain important information such as passwords from the website using their email account * Microsoft Word: o Students will write their word problems or solutions in a word document so that they can edit their work + Students must be able to use the functions and

Design innovators

3655 words - 15 pages attention. At least Japanese intellectual property right system, design rights are registered for the protection of not only the ornamental design but also the functional shape (Japan Patent Office, 2010). Therefore, creators of design rights are sometimes engineers. Since they are not majority among creators, we can distinguish the total number of design registrations of each creator; large number creators may be designers and medium/low are

Bauhaus and Its Influence on Graphic Design

1206 words - 5 pages Bauhaus: People, Places, Product, Philosophy, http://academic.chrissnider.com/bauhaus/pages/philosophy.html "Walter Gropius Quotes", The Brainy Quote, http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/authors/w/walter_gropius.html “László Moholy-Nagy”, Iconofgraphics, http://www.iconofgraphics.com/Laszlo-Moholy-Nagy/ “Original Creators: The New Vision of László Moholy-Nagy”, The Creators Project, http://thecreatorsproject.vice.com/blog/original-creators-the-new-vision-of-l%C3%A1szl%C3%B3-moholy-nagy Extract from “Malerei, Photographie, Film”, László Moholy-Nagy “The New Typography”, Scribd, http://www.scribd.com/doc/75320137/Laszlo-Moholy-Nagy-The-New-Typography

Similar Essays

We Should Not Judge Students By Test Results

776 words - 3 pages We Should NOT Judge Students by Test Results Are people who get good grades and/or who get high scores on tests more intelligent than those who do not? Can we just distinguish people who get good grades and/or high scores on tests are more intelligent than those who do not get good grades? I firmly believe that it is not fair to judge people who get good grades are more intelligent than those who do not. Test scores are not a fair

The Hacker Subculture Essay

2020 words - 8 pages specific group with which they do not agree. In a computer security context, it is often synonymous with a computer intruder. Paul A. Taylor quotes Steven Levy when describing the hacker ethic as:[6] 1. All information should be free; 2. Mistrust authority--promote decentralization; 3. Hackers should be judged by their hacking, not bogus criteria such as degrees, age, race, or position; 4. You can create art and beauty on a

The Maze Runner And The Scorch Trials

2501 words - 10 pages throughout the journey they should remember that there might be an antidote. Otherwise, they have to make the people responsible for their fates suffer. Unfortunately, some of the characters are not on the same boat as Thomas. They do not mind what The Creators did to them and they do not want revenge on them, instead they want the antidotes all for themselves. This just shows that just like in everyday life, people can be either generous or backstabbing

Animals For Biomedical Research Essay

793 words - 3 pages (3a).___ Quotes, paraphrases, and summaries should be used to support your assertions (51BH). Introduce and cite quoted material (52): One critic states that "Hamlet's major flaw is indecision" (Smith 21).Don't use quotes or questions as topic sentences to begin your paragraphs or as a thesis statement. Quotes should not make up more than ¼ of your paper.___ Works Cited page formatting pp. 571-2 and p. 588 BH___ Put the word count on bottom