Test Critique Essay

1154 words - 5 pages

The Name of the Test
The Children’s Apperception Test (CAT), according to Albert I. Rabin (1995) “was first published in 1949, and the manual reviewed was the eighth revised edition.” The test was revised in 1991. The Children’s Apperception Test is an extension from the TAT, which is for adults, using pictures of humans rather than animals. There is a CAT-H that uses human pictures, which was created after a controversy about whether animal or human pictures were best. There is also a CAT-S supplement.
Purpose of the Test
The Children’s Apperception Test (CAT) is a projective personality test used on children ages 3-10 years old. Children will decipher a series of 10 pictures consisting of animals, each in different situations. The purpose of this test is to reveal the child’s thoughts and feelings towards conflicts and relationships at conscious and unconscious levels based on the story they made up with each picture (Hatt, 1980). This test was originally designed to understand psychosexual conflicts at different stages of child development. Today, the CAT is used mainly in clinical evaluation. Knoff (1992), states the following:
The 10 cards presumably address the following issues: feeding problems, oral problems, sibling rivalry, attitudes toward parents, relationships to parents as (sexual) couples, jealousy toward same-gender parent figures, fantasies about aggression, acceptance by the adult world, fear or loneliness at night, and toileting behavior and parents' response to it. (p. 1)
The Manual
The manual for CAT was revised in 1980. According to Shaffer, the manual “contains a brief history of the test; an account of its 'nature and purpose'; directions for administration; description and interpretation of anticipated responses; a few samples of stories; and a copy of the recommended recording and analysis blank.” However, the manual does not state what the developmental norms are. There is no set standard for how a typical child of each stage of development should respond. Information is not available about consistency, test retest reliability, or validity. The manual does not meet the standards that are recommended in the American Psychological Association Standards (Reinehr, 1992).
The Development of the Test

Test Administration
The manual for the CAT indicates that knowledge of theories of personality, ego psychology, and cognitive development must be understood to interpret the made up stories of children (Shaffer, 1980). However, there is no set restriction of who can purchase the test, administer the test, or interpret the test responses. According to Shaffer (1980), “The CAT manual avers that it 'may be profitable in the hands of the psychoanalyst, the psychiatrist, the psychologist, the social worker, and the teacher, as well as the psychologically trained pediatrician.'” The test is given in the form of a game. Each of the ten cards are presented one at a time and the child’s story is to include the past, present, and...

Find Another Essay On Test Critique

The effect of the use of video texts on ESL listening test-taker performance

1546 words - 6 pages addressing by posing three research questions, one of which is already addressed in this critique. Summed up the other two research questions Wagner posed were, how much higher do the test-takers score on the dialogue and lecturette tasks in comparison to the audio-only test-takers? And how are the non-verbal cues effecting test-taker performance? While the experiment conducted within this article appears to be time consuming, due to all the testing

The Professional Assessments for Beginning Teachers

1703 words - 7 pages Critique of Praxis General Test Information The Professional Assessments for Beginning Teachers or Praxis is administered through Educational Testing Services and is currently the most popular norm-referenced test being used (Brown, 2008). The Praxis Series tests measures the knowledge of important content and skills required to teach (Educational Testing Service, 2010). Each of the tests reflects what is believed to be important for new

Research critique 1

784 words - 4 pages direct correction with metalinguistic explanation) and one control group. The language analytic ability test was a 14 items of multiple choices test, asking students to pick the best translation of short English phrases in an imaginary language. The pretest, posttest, and immediate post comprised of three similar tests: (1) speed dictation test, containing 14 items that should be completed in 8 minutes, (2) writing test, asking students to

Review of the SAT Test

2918 words - 12 pages In researching the types of tests that are administered to determine intelligence, it became very clear that there were many differing opinions surrounding the efficacy of intelligence testing. There exists compelling information that suggest there is a lack of ability for any test to clearly identify and measure intelligence. It is very clearly noted that there is a question of the ability for academics based testing to measure a persons

Critical essay on the personality test theory and how different issues helped us to understand the human mind.

586 words - 2 pages personality test we rated the best colors that suit us and used some mathematical skills by adding up scores to determine our primary, secondary, third and last color. This test helped us to realize the color that best described certain characteristics like our abilities, thereby increasing our personal wellness.The second is the Validation essay. This essay required us to validate whether our true color best described our behavior. The essay also

Adaptive Management

865 words - 3 pages assumptions, necessary in order to adapt and learn, involves a six-step iterative process: 1) problem assessment or outline purpose; 2) model design of the system in question, and a management plan; 3) implementation of the plan; 4) monitoring of activities that test assumptions; 5) evaluation of activities and analysis of collected data; and 6) using results to adjust or adapt the project and to learn from the experience, then repeating the

Predictive Validity of College Admissions Test

1238 words - 5 pages Predictive Validity of College Admissions TestsOne would think the future of America's youth is ensured by objective measures and time-tested procedures, but according to some, the decisions made by college admissions boards are anything but. Over a decade ago, fiery debates ignited over the validity of college admissions tests, such as the SAT and ACT, as a result of a disturbing trend of inequality in the test scores between students of

Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction by Ralph Tyler

2119 words - 8 pages . As I was reading, though, I found it amazing that much of what Tyler said nearly sixty years ago is relevant today. However, as I attempted to examine Tyler’s rationale from a neutral perspective, meaning not through the eyes of an educator today, but simply through the eyes of an educator, it was the section on which he devoted the majority of the book, the objectives, that I was able to critique several aspects. Two areas of criticism emerged

Comparison of the Three Major Sociological Theories

1817 words - 7 pages the data. The positivist is an objectivist.3. Methodology.The methodology of positivism is experimental and manipulative. The approach isthe same as propounded in most junior high science classes: begin with a hypothesis onhow 'reality' works, then gather data and test the data against the hypothesis. Thequestion propounded initially is tested against empirical data gathered in the experimentunder carefully controlled conditions.B. INTERPRETIVE1

iconic memory test adhd

1385 words - 6 pages child symptom inventory -4 that reference symptoms question related to ADHD according to the DSM-5. Then Iconic memory test adapted from a test initially introduced by Sperling and Averbach in 1961 for testing iconic memory in healthy individuals. In this test children were present with images of an object which are easily identifiable for 6-9 years old children. There were 12 images shown to 20 6-year old children, and 4 images were most

Blushing and Physiological Arousability in Social Phobia

2239 words - 9 pages Blushing and Physiological Arousability in Social Phobia Introduction This paper will provide a critique of the article titled “Blushing and Physiological Arousability in Social Phobia,” (Gerlach et al., 2001) located in the Journal of Abnormal Psychology (Vol. 110, No. 2). Blushing is defined as: “to become red in the face especially from shame or embarrassment. ” It is believed that blushing involves physiological, behavioral, and

Similar Essays

Bench Mark Assessment Test Critique Essay

1516 words - 6 pages For the Test Critique Assignment I choose the Bench Mark Assessment Test for fourth grade. I think it is a great asset to know how my bilingual students are performing against other fourth graders or even to compare them with the national and state scores. The Bench Mark Assessment test is not an option, all students in grades third through eight who take the Illinois Standards Achievement Test (ISAT) must take the Bench Mark assessments test

Test Critique: The Alcohol Dependent Scale (Ads)

1197 words - 5 pages The Symptom Inventory that I reviewed was the Alcohol Dependent Scale (ADS). The ADS was developed by Harvey Skinner and John Horn in 1984. The ADS consists of a 25-item alcohol use questionnaire. The items are multiple choice, easy to read, have from two to four alternatives, and come in a booklet with clear instructions. Test administration is approximately 10 minutes and the ADS can be given to both groups and individuals either as a

The Mini Ipip Personality Scale : A Test Critique

2179 words - 9 pages . Test Description The Mini-IPIP (Donnellan et al., 2006) is a 20-item assessment used to measure levels of the Big Five Personality Factors. In the longer IPIP-FFM, there are ten items for each factor. The Mini-IPIP gleaned four items to represent each factor. It tests Extroversion (i.e. Am the life of the party), Agreeableness (i.e. Sympathize with others’ feelings), Conscientiousness (i.e. Get chores done right away), Neuroticism (i.e. Have

Morality Via Kant And Hegel Essay

1505 words - 6 pages Discourse Ethics will not be spelled out with reference to modern alternatives, it does not follow that they are uncontroversial. Indeed, Discourse Ethics’ insusceptibility to Hegel’s critique is not the litmus test of Discourse Ethics; rather, it is one amongst many.