Testimony: Crises Of Witnessing In Literature, Psychoanalysis, And History By Dori Laub

2715 words - 11 pages

Testimony: Crises of Witnessing in Literature, Psychoanalysis, and History by Dori Laub

Dori Laub, author of, "Testimony: Crises of Witnessing in Literature, Psychoanalysis, and History", discusses a concept of missed experiences referred to as the 'collapse of witnessing'. The 'collapse of witnessing' is the idea that a person can witness an event and yet at the same time not really witness it at all. Through the analysis of Laub's 'collapse of witnessing', a connection can be seen between St. Teresa and Mary Rowlandson. St. Teresa is a nun that devotes her life to God, while Mary Rowlandson is the wife of a minister that is taken captive by Indians. They both have missed experiences and/or situations of the 'collapse of witnessing'. A traumatic event that can not be understood, can not be mastered, and can not be incorporated in the social, often times also, can not be witnessed. This 'collapse of witness' can be seen in both The Life of Saint Teresa of Avila by Herself and The True History of the Captivity of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson; and the 'collapse of witness' can be used as a tool to connect these two trauma texts.
According to Dori Laub there are, "three separate, distinct levels of witnessing" (Laub 75). These three levels are, "the level of being a witness to oneself within the experience; the level of being a witness to the testimonies of others; and the level of being a witness to the process of witnessing itself" (Laub 75). The 'collapse of witnessing' is how in relation to trauma, many times a person can not witness the event because the event is beyond the realm of the social. "The events [that] are remembered and seem to have been experienced in a way that [is] far beyond the normal capacity for recall" are the events, according to Laub, that often succumb to the 'collapse of the witness' (Laub 76).
A person that experiences a traumatic event has trouble, in many ways, witnessing the event even though they were physically there. This relates to the concept that trauma and traumatic events can not be incorporated into the mainstream of the social. People can not master the concept and therefore can not incorporate the event into their everyday life and everyday understanding. Laub says, "the loss of the capacity to be a witness to oneself and thus to witness from the inside is perhaps the true meaning of annihilation, for when one's history is abolished one's identity ceases to exist as well" (Laub 82). In other words, people have difficulty being a witness, but by not acknowledging the traumatic event, by the 'collapse of the witness', it is actually the collapse of that person's identity. Therefore there is a constant struggle to not have a 'collapse of witness' in order to not lose one's identity, but also to not be a witness in order not to have to face the trauma.
The 'collapse of witness' of a person that has physically experienced a traumatic event can be connected to the latency period discussed by Caruth....

Find Another Essay On Testimony: Crises of Witnessing in Literature, Psychoanalysis, and History by Dori Laub

King Arthur in Literature and History

1396 words - 6 pages King Arthur in Literature and History King Arthur is the greatest of British literary heroes, although little is known about the real person. Little real historical information is left, only texts, chronicles, verses, myths, fragments of epic poems, inscriptions, symbols, graven images and graffiti. Although these writings can be interesting literature, they lack factual evidence and are obscure in details. It is not even possible to

The Unreliability of Eyewitness Testimony in Children

2963 words - 12 pages accurate eyewitness testimony has been the subject of increasing attention by social scientists and members of the legal profession (Davies, 1996). Cases relying on evidence provided by child witnesses, such as physical or sexual abuse cases have helped bring to the fore issues pertaining to the accuracy and reliability of such eyewitness reports (Ceci & Bruck, 1993). As a result there has been a related increase of scientific studies of children’s

The Tell-Tale Heart, by Edgar Allan Poe: 3 of the Modern Age literary elements used: Detailed exposition, Interest in the inner-mind(psychoanalysis), and Suspense

570 words - 2 pages The Tell-Tale Heart was written by Edgar Allan Poe in 1843 and is considered one of the finest stories of psychological horror. A man becomes obsessed with a vulture-like eye and tells very descriptively of his methods in how he got rid of the man. In the end, his madness drives him into confession. The plot has three main literary elements that contribute to the atmosphere of the story. These characteristics are detailed exposition, interest in

IMF and its role in economic crises

1270 words - 5 pages IMF and its role in economic crisesIntroduction:The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is an international organization that provides financial assistance and advice to member countries. It has become an institution integral to the creation of financial markets worldwide and to the growth of developing countries.The IMF is responsible for the creation and maintenance of the international monetary system, the system by which international payments

Personal Statement of Testimony and Faith

804 words - 4 pages surrendered my life to Him. As time went by, I felt I didn’t have a great testimony, that my story was not important. I found myself listening to countless inspirational speakers and pastors who had miraculously turned to Jesus, and wondered why that could not be me. But then I realized that, just like Elijah, my story was no less significant than that of these great speakers. In fact, instead of being jealous, I should instead be grateful that

The Process of Jungian Psychoanalysis in Siddhartha

868 words - 4 pages drastically as his family began to fall apart. His wife showed symptoms of mental illness, while his third son became very ill. Hesse… experienced, albeit second-hand, the horrors of war. He publicly denounced the war, and in retaliation, the German press labeled him a traitor. As a result, Hesse left Germany and traveled to Lucern, Switzerland to receive Jungian psychoanalysis. He was naturalized in 1922." (World History: The Modern Era). Hesse

Psychoanalysis in Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment

2761 words - 11 pages vivid description of Raskolnikov, Dostoevsky shows his readers first hand what a sociopath is like. First one must understand that there is no such affliction as sociopath. The technical name is antisocial personality disorder and there are certain criteria a person must meet in order to receive this diagnosis. It is reserved for the most violent criminal minds and therefore is taken very seriously by the psychiatric community. In order to be

Freudian Psychoanalysis of Victor's Dream in "Frankenstein"

1136 words - 5 pages . These deep-rooted sexual feelings and desires not only affected Victor's actions, but also his character. Although Victor proclaims much love and desire for Elizabeth throughout the novel, he also harbors feelings of hate. We see Victor's reverence towards his mother in his description of her almost to the point of deification. By seeing his mother in Elizabeth, Victor is constantly reminded of Elizabeth's responsibility for Caroline's

Psychoanalysis and Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness

1134 words - 5 pages Psychoanalysis and The Heart of Darkness         In Lacanian psychoanalysis, telling stories is essential to the analysand's (re)cognition of trauma. Julia Kristeva refers to the analysand's narrative as an instance of "'borderline' [neurotic] discourse" which "gives the analyst the impression of something alogical, unstitched, and chaotic" (42). She then explores the pleasure (jouissance) that the analysand experiences in the course of

Witnessing Death Causes Desire for Life in "Catch-22" by Joseph Heller

778 words - 3 pages doing poorly on the missions because he didn’t want to take any risks of being attacked by the enemy. “Catch-22 says that they have a right to do anything we can’t stop them from doing.” The overall way that I can say that Yossarian supports this theme is based on how many people had died around him, or that he knew, and how they increased his desire to live. In the story, many of the soldiers that Yossarian knew either died, or disappeared

The Main Goal of Psychoanalysis by Sigmound Freud

666 words - 3 pages First developed by Austrian physician Sigmund Freud, psychoanalysis has been expanded and revised by many. The main goal of psychoanalysis is to reduce internal conflicts like rigid ego-defenses or compulsive behavior that lead to emotional suffering. To do this, four techniques are used to uncover the unconscious roots of the brain: dream analysis, free association, analysis of resistance, and transference analysis In dream analysis

Similar Essays

Laub And Sampson’s Age Graded Theory Of Informal Social Control

813 words - 4 pages Laub and Sampson are interested in the agencies and social experiences through age-graded social and how they play a role in whether an individual decides to persist or desist from offending (Laub and Sampson 2003). Laub and Sampson (2003:38) want to answer the question, “What are the mechanisms underlying the processes of persistent offending and desistance from crime?” To answer this question, Laub and Sampson look at informal social

Piecing Together The ‘Here’ And ‘There’: Identity Crises In Diasporic Literature

2059 words - 9 pages makes him hopeful that he will one day be able to return to Barbados and build a beautiful home. Selina’s mother, Silla, wants Deighton to sell the plot so that they can buy their house in Brooklyn (to achieve the American Dream), but Deighton refuses to give up the land. They continue to argue about the situation for months. This plot of land, and by extension Deighton, clearly symbolizes a return to the homeland, and the culture and traditions

Psychoanalysis Of Caesar And Cassius

551 words - 2 pages have a tendency to modify or change their previous beliefs. It is said by Vivian Thomas in Twayne's New Critical Introduction to Shakespeare, "Rather than fate governing events, what we see is that human tendency, in any crisis, to feel that there is some intangible force at work" (23). Caesar's and Cassius's conversion of beliefs is justified because of a human's proclivity towards solutions which help satisfaction of the ego and mind. Thomas also

Cold War Politics: Shaped By The Global Economic Crises Of The Usa And Ussr

1540 words - 6 pages the global economic crises of the late 1970s and 1980s in the United States of America and the Union of the Soviet Socialist Republics shaped the cold war politics. To begin with, it is necessary to mention that by the early 1970s, the USA had just abandoned the Vietnam War without relevant results either in the military aspect, or in the social international environment of the public opinion of its citizens. According to LaFeber (1997, p.252