Testing Evolutionary Brain Size Change In Bats

2593 words - 10 pages

Testing Evolutionary Brain Size Change in Bats

In his classic text on the evolution of the brain in vertebrates, Jerison (1973) demonstrated with numerous examples that brains have increased in size over time in most mammal lineages. He thus confirmed a general trend that had been progressively recognized since the time of Marsh (1874). More recent studies have confirmed Jerison’s findings for primates (Martin, 1990), cetaceans (Marino et al., 2004) and carnivores (Finarelli & Flynn, 2007). It was originally thought that the development in brain size was related to body surface area (Jerison, 1973), but then it was shown that brain size may be correlated to maternal metabolic turnover instead (Martin, 1981). This alternative interpretation was proposed because of the high energetic cost of brain tissue. However, brain size may vary by a factor of five relative to body weight. This wide range of variation cannot be explained by variation in adult basal metabolic rate alone, so the brain size of mammals must be affected by other things such as the early developmental period. Recognition of this led to formulation of the Maternal Energy Hypothesis (Martin, 1996). Larger brains may therefore be due to increase in the resources the mother provides to the developing offspring, according to the mode of reproduction. However, on an evolutionary scale, brain size usually increases due to new adaptations and generally beneficial characteristics.
This interpretation was challenged by Safi et al. (2005) with respect to bats. These authors proposed that evolution of the brain in different bat lineages had involved reduction as well as enlargement in brain size. The suggestion that bat brains may become smaller in evolution was specifically linked to the energetic cost of maintaining a large brain. However, that conclusion was based on a theoretical analysis of brain size in living bats and made no mention of the need to test it with reference to the fossil record. In fact, the major problem in this paper is that brain size in fossil bats is a totally neglected area. How could it be possible to test for an evolutionary trend without looking at the ancestors?
The paper by Safi et al. goes on to claim that, among bats, fast flyers have undergone a decrease in brain size relative to their ancestors because they needed reduced weight to forage in open spaces. They needed flight efficiency, and the energetic cost of a large brain would be a disadvantage, so sensory needs were relaxed. By contrast, in bats that have large wings for maneuvering in highly structured habitats, brain size would increase over time. These bats would need better spatial memory and hearing in order to fly in dense habitats.
When phylogeny and body mass were corrected for in a phylogenetic least squares approach (PGLS), wing size had a positive correlation with brain size, showing that wing size can predict encephalization after phylogeny has been corrected for....

Find Another Essay On Testing Evolutionary Brain Size Change in Bats

The California Bat Essay

1348 words - 5 pages one or more sensory systems to have their brain remain sensitive at low temperatures and quickly start heat production for activity, which is mainly used for getting their prey. They mainly tend to stay in areas within their body temperature which is usually at 98.6F and will never exceed that temperature because if these bats were to come in contact with temperatures between 104-106F, they will not survive (Web 3, 5, 6). The organ that the

Morphometric Essay

1304 words - 5 pages prey to enable the bats to get more of these preys (Fenton et al., 1998; Zhao et al., 2003). In order to change the calling frequency to fit the range that cannot be detected by the prey, modification in ear length or size is required. A study conducted by Zhao et al., (2003) discovered that the call frequency shows significant impacts on ear size in hipposiderids. Echolocation call is also important to enable bats to distinguish between echoes

BBCOR vs. WOOD

1142 words - 5 pages major sports leagues, according to yahoo.com. In order for all these players to make money and play the way they do, they need good equipment. Most of the players have sponsors or people who represent them like many well-known brands. Many of these sponsors will give them like bats, balls, or gloves to try out to see what they like the best and to represent the company. If they do not like the object they got from them they can send it back and

wood bats vs. metal bats

705 words - 3 pages introduction in the early 1970's aluminum bats have dominated the youth and amateur adult baseball and softball markets. Ever year new designs and models are introduced, each one claiming to be better than previous models. Each new bat is made to have a wider sweet spot, more power, better feel, and higher performance. Almost everyone who has ever used an aluminum bat knows that they perform better than wood bats. It is pretty much an accepted fact

A Report on Bats.

1534 words - 6 pages closely related to primatesbecause of their similar brain tissue. Bats are highlyevolved animals that have amazing characteristics (Gibbons1992 and Bailey et al. 1992).LITERATURE CITEDAnonymous. 1988. Bats. Pamphlet distributed by Missouri Departmentof Health. pp 1-2.Anonymous. 1990. Bats In Connecticut. Pamphlet from ConnecticutDepartment of Environmental Protection. pp 1-8.Anonymous. 1991. Warning From Bat Conservation International.Pamphlet from

White Nose Syndrome in Bats

1050 words - 4 pages diversity. Also, bats are long living animals that have an extremely low reproductive rate. They tend to only mate once a year and have a single pup whose survival rate is only fifty percent. It would take many decades to produce enough offspring in order to come close to the original population size. Going forward, biologists across the nation, including Dr. Reeder, are working vigorously to find a solution to this problem. Many treatment methods

Altruism and the Fluctuation of Intelect

1012 words - 4 pages evolutionary period? It is interesting to entertain the possibility that we have in fact become too smart for our own good, and that our intellect is now producing some emotions which will in turn counteract the drive towards more intellect. All the advances that humankind has made since the age of the Neanderthals 150,000 years ago have been a product of our creation of cultural knowledge rather than a result of any increase in our brain size. It

Evolutionary Development Biology

2165 words - 9 pages connect biology of developmental to standard perspectives from theory of evolutionary (Laubichler, 2010). Large number of theoretical and experiential efforts are being devoted to novelties that have exercised biologists for more than one hundred years, for instance the fins basis in fish, the fin-to limb change and the feathers evolution. Biology of developmental promises to formulate a main contribution to these explanations, in division as

Brain Conquered Brawn in Early Humans

915 words - 4 pages grind the toughest foods."We're not suggesting this mutation alone defines us as Homo sapiens," said Hansell Stedman of the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. "But evolutionary events are extraordinarily rare. Over 2 million years since the mutation, the brain has nearly tripled in size. It's a very intriguing possibility." University of Michigan biological anthropologist Milford Wolpoff called the research "just super." "The other

Evidence of the theory of evolution

809 words - 3 pages , molecular biology, and comparative anatomy and embryology, propose mechanisms responsible for the evolutionary patterns observed in nature.Population genetics, which emphasizes the extensive genetic variation within populations and recognizes the importance of quantitative characters, was a significant turning point for the theory of evolution. In small populations, there is greater chance for evolution. In all populations, more organisms are born than

Brain Tumor

1359 words - 5 pages well as its size and location.SymptomsThe signs and symptoms of a brain tumor vary greatly and depend on the brain tumor's size, location and rate of growth.General signs and symptoms caused by brain tumors may include:New onset or change in pattern of headachesHeadaches that gradually become more frequent and more severeUnexplained nausea or vomitingVision problems, such as blurred vision, double vision or loss of peripheral visionGradual loss

Similar Essays

Circadiam Rhythms In Humans And Animals

1682 words - 7 pages Just as humans have a circadian rhythm that can be changed when entering a new time zone or season, other animals also exhibit time behavior - especially for food collection. As an animal’s environment changes over time, the they have to evolve to constantly change their time intervals for when they collect their food. This is very common in nectarivorous animals such as honeybees or bats. For example, honeybees know when to go out of their hive

From Persistence To Cross Species Emergence Of A Viral Zoonosis

922 words - 4 pages viruses, including severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), Nipah, Hendra, and Ebola viruses, which often emerge in the context of anthropogenic change with devastating outcomes for humans and animals. From an ecological and evolutionary perspective, the high species diversity of bats also presents a unique and fascinating system to test hypotheses on cross-species emergence in complex host communities.Despite recurrent cross-species transmission

Comparison Of Adaptations For Nectar Feeding In Hummingbirds And American Leaf Nosed Bats

1850 words - 7 pages in the evolutionary line, the leaf-nosed bats have the most research on nectar feeding. Hummingbirds are within the order Apodiformes which also include swifts, their family is Trochilidae, which includes all hummingbirds. Leaf-nosed bats are within the order Chiroptera, which include all bats, their family is Phyllostomidae(leaf-nosed bats), which includes the new world nectar and fruit feeding bats. These traits can be seen as functionally

Metal Bats In Major League Baseball

2852 words - 12 pages 2013, the rate has lowered to an average of 0.46 bats broken per game (White). The skill level needed to successfully hit off the different materials remains another argument between metal versus wood bats. Metal bats have been proven to require less skill to hit with because of their weight difference and the size of their "sweet spots" compared to wooden bats. With most metal bats being made of aluminum, they weigh in much lighter than bats