Texts Across Time Have Portrayed Women In Terms Of A Dichotomy Between "Good" And "Bad", But To What Extent Are The Composers Of The Texts You Have Studied Ambivalent Towards Their Female Characters?

2007 words - 8 pages

Composers throughout the ages have often used dichotomy as a tool to depict the rift between "good" and "bad" women, but their exact intentions are often unclear. Examples of this ambiguity may be found in "Vanity Fair", a BBC television mini-series set in nineteenth century England, Fay Weldon's eighties novel, The Life and Loves of a She-Devil, and Chocolat, a single mother's integration into a rural French community, by Joanne Harris. No true saints or villains exist in the three texts; their female characters are neither wholly good nor evil, but an ambiguous mixture of both, which is open to interpretation. This is done through the partial shift of the blame for wickedness, or a cause of righteousness, to the social surroundings and the past of an individual. The reasoning behind women's deeds, which they commit in the name of "goodness", or indeed, "badness" exposed by the composer, also blur the composer's stance on the dichotomy. The power of institutions to affect and sometimes distort perception are also used by composers to reflect the many different and conflicting ways in which people may be perceived.Frequently other people surrounding a person, and the individual's history, have an influence on their development, and in some cases are given responsibility for aspects of their character. For example, while Becky Sharp in "Vanity Fair" behaves in a seemingly inappropriate way for a "good" woman by attempting to seduce Jos Sedley, her best friend Amelia's brother, causing friction with the potential parents-in-law, Amelia immediately supports Becky, saying "Miss Sharp has no kind parents to arrange these delicate matters for her", offering as an excuse for her behaviour the fact that she has no people around her for support, and must take on a multitude of roles, including the matchmaking role of her mother and father. Interestingly, the opening scene of the film is of a young Becky serving drinks to a group of drunken men, lying in squalor, which invokes pity in us, as it is immediately apparent to us that no child could escape such a past psychologically unscathed. Another "bad" woman is Ruth, Fay Weldon's she-devil. While Ruth is, as her name suggests, ruthless in her approach, and her ready embrace of the role of a she-devil - "This is wonderful! This is exhilarating! If you are a she-devil...the spirits rise...I can take what I want...", as she recites the "Litany of the Good Wife", the use of repetition, "I must..." at the beginning of each phrase, and "for everyone's sake" at the end, bring about a sense of blind following, a set of unjust demands placed upon women such as Ruth as they take their place as "less than" men, and slave away unrecognised. Ruth's history as the "ugly duckling" of her family, who gave her no support and caused her to grow "lumpish and brutish" over the years to protect herself from mental attacks. Similarly, in Chocolat, Vianne Rocher, with her illegitimate daughter Anouk, is shunned by the virtuous...

Find Another Essay On Texts across time have portrayed women in terms of a dichotomy between "good" and "bad", but to what extent are the composers of the texts you have studied ambivalent towards their female characters?

How are the texts you have studied (Frankenstein and The Vampire of Kaldenstein) typical of the Gothic genre?

2308 words - 9 pages gothic genre in different ways. The story is not set in a medieval town, like "The Vampire of Kaldenstein" but still manages to get the desired effect of isolation, as well venturing into the unknown. The story is set mainly in the Swiss Mountains and in the Artic. These places are obviously very remote and this gives a sense of isolation while set in very real places that the reader can picture and relate to. Although you could argue that the room

"Change isn't always easy." Discuss the impact of Change in the texts you have studied

1777 words - 7 pages period of change. Francesca’s mother being supportive seems to be the normal, so does the boy in “Out, out” working with a saw, the normal lets them down and both incur a period of change. Both Billy and Francesca have friends for support and their friends have their peculiarities. Siobhan being unpopular and Justine being a loner for Francesca while Billy’s friend having homosexual tendencies. In these ways, the texts are

How have the following Speculative Fiction texts you studied gone beyond the expectations of the genre?

2819 words - 11 pages For a text to be classified as Speculative Fiction it must be a combination of both Fantasy and Science Fiction and include the conventions which are traditionally associated with the genre. The elements commonly found in Speculative Fiction include the examination of humanity's misuse of technology, abuse of power, politics, religion, perceptions of freedom and above all presenting a question as to what may be in the future?The three texts

“People experience a sense of belonging in varied and complex ways.” How is this explored in the texts you have studied?

1251 words - 6 pages like home and how places can positively affect our sense of belonging, even if it takes a long time to realise it. Pip born in what he describes as ‘a most beastly place: mudbank, mist, swamp, and work’, feeling that he is too good for the ‘marsh country’ Pip decides to move to the elusive London, after meeting the ‘more bright and beautiful’ rich Estella. London filled with ‘gloomy streets’ which are ‘all asmear with filth and fat and blood’. Pip

PHYSICAL JOURNEYS How have the texts you have studied this year effectively shaped your understanding of the impact of journeys?

1334 words - 5 pages journeys as a physical journey is not just traveling from place to place but so much more, as seen in The Road Not Taken as the choices that are made 'often make all the difference.'In the film The Grapes of Wrath there is a similar migratory journey just like the Skrzynecki family the Joads are forced to move away from their home in Oklahoma across America by poverty and their home being flooded, while searching for work and a home along the way.The

How have the texts you have studied this year effectively shaped your understanding of the meaning of ?change??

1784 words - 7 pages positive and accept what they have, working towards positive outcomes in life.In displaying this concept of ?change?, Marchetta uses a first person retrospective narrative that immediately captures reader?s attention. The story is told through Josephine's eyes who is the protagonist of the novel. This allows responder's to see how the process of ?change? is working on her. Events are related as if they are happening at present, and Josephine

How do the composers convey their attitudes towards cultural values associated with the ways of thinking evident in the texts?

1366 words - 6 pages support of the idea. He incorporates the process of objectification through “presenting” Amelia in addition to the use of unusual syntax when Ms Pinkerton says “not unworthy” to again show the gap between good and great, hence, how Amelia was not truly worthy, but not unworthy either. Thackeray additionally alludes to the occupation of women when he says “occupy a fitting position in their polished and refined circle”, furthering the concept that

How have the texts you have studied this year effectively shaped your understanding of the meaning of ?change?? Includes "The Door" by Miroslav Holub and others

1803 words - 7 pages and working for a positive outcome towards those who are affected by their decisions to avoid fruitless consequence for those experiencing the ?change?.The texts discussed make evident that ?change? is a process that can have valuable or futile outcomes. The type of outcome resulting from ?change? is closely associated with the dynamism of an individual or group in their ability to open their rationale to changes in perspective. ?Change? allows us to move forward, and brings with it a host of benefits.

"Outsiders are victims of themselves and society" What is your view? use the texts you have studied ("The Floating World" by John Romeril and "Death Be Not Proud" by John Donne)and one other text

1365 words - 5 pages structure of the play symbolises that his insanity stems from his guilt about visitingJapan. His psychological and physical journey propels the play towards a climax. Thelength of each scene is different, and scenes are fragmented to heighten the effects ofLes' fragmented mind. John Donne uses a similar technique in "Death Be Not Proud";the length of each line varies greatly, this goes against the conventional sonnet form, which would normally have

How have the texts you have studied this year, "Empire of the Sun", "Journey to the Interior", and "Willow", effectively shaped your understanding of the concept of "The Journey"?

3338 words - 13 pages throughout this adventure, human beings will experience many smaller journeys, which will differ greatly in nature and significance. The most noteworthy of these are processes of self-actualisation and emotional development. A quiet, introspective consideration of the human psyche is fundamental to a mature understanding of the journeys of, and in, life. As a result of such introspection many composers choose to focus their texts on the concept of

Discuss the way one or more groups of Australians are represented in film and to what extent this representation reflects wider social attitudes. Refer to at least one feature film you have studied

1319 words - 5 pages representations of women in Sunday Too Far Away (hereby known as STFA) do to some extent reflect the social attitudes of that time period. The two main female characters, Ivy and the cocky's daughter are greatly marginalised in STFA. Even though both characters are marginalised, they do show signs of wanting to be seen as not accepting the social attitudes. This is evidently presented in the cocky's daughter. The cocky's daughter is a young and

Similar Essays

What Aspects Of Change Are Discussed In The Texts You Have Studied This Year?

2023 words - 8 pages saying that the essence of change is found with in the individual and only through one's actions can change be triggered.The Song "The Times They Are A-Changin" by Bob Dylan demonstrates that change is inevitable, indiscriminative and that we need to accept change, regardless of our status in life. Dylan start off by summonsing all people to acknowledge that their lives have changed and will continue to do so: "Come gather round people wherever

What Do The Texts You Have Studied Have To Say About The Positive And/Or Negative Effects Of Institutions?

1131 words - 5 pages individual. It shows us how the fight for power within this institution can prove to be fatal, but the positive is that Brett achieved what he was aiming for.After analysis of the above, it can be concluded that the institution has many influences on an individual, both positive and negative in nature. It's the lessons that are taken out of these experiences that determine the true effect that it can have. Institutions such as the farm consist of a

Write An Essay Of 950 To 1200 Words On How Historical Facts Are Represented In The Texts You Have Studied. You Must Make Detailed Reference To Your Focus Texts And Related Texts

1625 words - 7 pages language and techniques used to get their point across. All of the studied texts were examples of reportage, but Hiroshima is the most purest form of a report because it is a first hand eye witness account, factual and does not contain bias, it contains 'unvarnished facts,' while the supplementary texts were examples of reports they contained some form of bias. The crucible and All quiet on the Western Front were changed for entertainment purposes and

In The Texts You Have Studied This Year Have You Found That Criminals Have Received A Fair Punishment? Refer To At Least Two Texts In Your Answer

3115 words - 12 pages the shock, despair and maybe even guilt of what has happened to him.I don’t believe a just or fair punishment for a crime exists. I think that most of the characters in “The Scarlet Letter” by Nathaniel Hawthorne were punished much too severely. However, I have less pity for Rodger Chillingworth. Although, I believe that the main character, George, in “The Habit of Loving” learnt his lesson, I think he should have punished