This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Abortion Arguments Of Cider House Rules

1105 words - 4 pages

The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules

I am writing this essay on a Saturday evening, not with any real contemplation, or even planning. I am writing this because I was just minutes ago watching the movie Cider House Rules. I won't go into the plot of the movie, but, to explain my motivation for writing this, I will simply describe one portion of the movie.

The scene at issue in my mind right now is one where a fourteen-year-old girl comes to the orphanage which is the setting for part of the movie. This girl came to the orphanage because it was known in the region as a place that performed abortions. She had had a crude abortion performed in such a way that she had been severely injured (her uterus was punctured by a crochet hook, and, not being a sterile instrument, this caused an infection of the uterine lining, eventually killing her). The resident doctor is disgusted by this, and uses the girl's injury as an example explaining why he performs abortions. The doctor's argument is fairly simple. If the girl had come to him, rather than the ignorant abortionist she chose, she would likely have survived. In addition, he claims that potential parents have a right to choose to be parents or to not be parents. The doctor, a seeming proponent of utilitarianism, says that this demonstrates a duty to perform abortions.

The young man to which the doctor is speaking, Homer, has been in essence an apprentice under the doctor, but has refused to perform abortions. His reasoning is this: those individuals seeking an abortion should have been responsible enough to have not conceived an unwanted child. Their lack of sexual responsibility should not be an excuse to take human life.

Homer, while not legally a doctor (having had no formal training) believes the doctor's reasoning to be faulty. He refuses to dehumanize the fetus, and insists that the "potential parents" be responsible for their actions. In the movie, Homer is an orphan, and this may provide an interesting perspective in regards to the status of the fetus. As an unwanted child himself, he empathizes with the unborn children that he refuses to destroy.

So far, all we have talked about really is the emotion of the question of abortion. The purpose of this essay (which will not be very long), is to examine these lines of reasoning, and to come to some conclusion about the differing philosophies of these two characters.

The doctor's argument is, as I mentioned, very much a utilitarian one, and as you know, this sort of argument doesn't sit well with me (see my "Truth" essays). Regardless of my perspective, though, the doctor's first argument is one which many people (including some that I greatly respect) accept as a good reason for legalized abortion. The doctor is making the very simple assessment that one death is preferable to two. If the mother dies along with the baby, this is a waste and a shame, therefore he feels as though he is obligated to perform an abortion...

Find Another Essay On The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules

The Struggle for Acceptance in The Cider House Rules

1887 words - 8 pages its views on abortion.         After writing his first few books, Irving was left disappointed that although the literary critics embraced them, for the general masses his books fell on deaf ears.  (Hill 250) Unfortunately it is the general case that the masses and the elite are not in agreement on what is worth reading.  With this in mind, Irving set out writing The Cider House Rules with the intent of reaching not only the critics

The Right to Choose in Cider House Rules

1057 words - 5 pages morally right and justly right. The major theme of The Cider House Rules is the right to choose. More importantly the right of a woman to choose whether she wants to have a child. The point of the movie is not to prove whether abortion is right or wrong but to make a statement saying that woman deserve the right to choose for themselves. The other main characters in the film besides Dr. Larch and Homer Wells are Rose Rose, Mr. Rose, Candy

Outline the arguments in favour of abortion

545 words - 2 pages Religious Studies - website)They also believe that if the pregnancy is a result of a rape, then abortion is the lesser of two evils, also if the mother's life is at risk, then abortion should be permitted."It is argued that in these tragic cases the great value of the mental health of a woman who becomes pregnant as a result of rape or incest can best be safe-guarded by abortion." (Christian answers.net)These are only a few of the arguments for abortion, there are many more.

The question of abortion: the issue, arguments for and against

2360 words - 9 pages 1. IntroductionAbortion is one of the most controversial moral issues that has become the center of discussion in our contemporary society. This issue has raised strong arguments, and for some people simply to mention 'abortion' is to stir up emotions. In this essay, I will present both sides of the argument: in favor and against. To take a closer look at this issue, I will discuss the arguments of Judith Jarvis Thomson, Michael Tooley, Don

THE HEALTH BENEFIT OF APPLE CIDER VINEGAR

713 words - 3 pages Apple cider vinegar has been seen as a cure for everything. For this reason the health enthusiast have gone ahead to use it for everything that is from acne and allergies to so throats and warts. With the many forms of vinegar it has been used for many centuries for every sort of folk remedies. People have become more skeptical about something as apple cider vinegar becoming such an effective for such many ailments. It has been used as a natural

Consider the arguments for prefabrication in relation to house building and discuss some of the problems that house builders face when developing and implementing house building systems

1775 words - 7 pages IntroductionThis essay aims to look at how prefabrication has affected house building. In order to do this, the essay shall cover the arguments for and against prefabrication. To achieve this, various aspects shall be covered in finding out how prefabrication has affected the housing industry and how its perceived by the public, and industry alike.This essay aims to discuss the arguments for and against the use of prefabrication as a house

The Rules of Baseball

953 words - 4 pages Baseball. To some people, that means the game starts at 5. For others, it means the American pastime. And for people like me, it means a game with a bat and ball. But baseball isn’t only about hitting the ball with a bat, like every game, there are rules. Before rules can be discussed, we must first know how to play the game of baseball. The game can be divided into 4 simple sections: The Game Two teams of nine players that alternate offense and

The Rules of Procrastination

600 words - 2 pages how to fill their time, for these things distract you, become addicting, and suck you away from anything that you're doing. The creators of such devices should be looked upon as deities of procrastination.There you have it. The three most important rules of procrastination. If you follow these requirements, you too will be blessed with the relaxing skill of procrastination. Please pass this information on so the poor over-achievers will experience the sacred skill of delaying until the last minute--a skill that should be passed down from class to class.

The rules of leadership

688 words - 3 pages A manager should have a set of guidelines or rules to keep in the back of his or her mind to keep everything running smoothly. According to there are fifty rules to be successful leader, but I will focus on what I feel are the top ten. I have seen them in action at and they have influenced how I would lead when I lead. The number one rule would be Leadership is confusing as hell. I feel this is important to remember because one must remember

Partial-Birth Abortion: The Logical and Illogical Arguments

1961 words - 8 pages abortion is not used very often and only when the mother’s life is in danger or the fetus is badly deformed. There were a few problems with their arguments. One problem being that every report that came out had a different number when it came to the frequency of this procedure. The National Abortion Federation claimed that “this procedure is used only in about 500 cases per year” (Scully). Then a reporter named Ruth Padawer conducted her own

The Rules of Avoiding Procrastination

755 words - 4 pages vacuumed into social media and the internet. An environment with a comfy working station and a large space will help a student work at the most comfortable level, thus leading to more work being completed earlier than in an environment with many distractions. Overall, the most comfortable environment is the one that students must find early in their lives, so they can start finishing work sooner than last minute. The rules of early planning are

Similar Essays

The Theme Of The Cider House Rules

1056 words - 4 pages mind with the idea that being a football captain in senior year was supposed to be filled with keg parties, and orgies with cheerleaders. Schoolwork and housework weren't a a part of my 12th grade master plan. My thinking continued in this manner until I happened across a movie named "The Cider House Rules." It made me sit back and look at how ungrateful I was. I have both of my parents still alive and still together in the same house. I

Cider House Rules Essay

736 words - 3 pages The Cider House Rules" is a movie based on John Irving's best selling book. It is a very wonderful, touching, and real 1943¡¦s life story. The story centered on an orphanage child named Homer and a sick doctor, Dr Larch who will have an emotional bond with Homer. I watched the movie before, and my first impression on this movie, I think it is a very good, and relax movie, where you can watch it with your family, although some of the scene

Cider House Rules Essay

1027 words - 4 pages The movie Cider House Rules involves many different characters that one can focus on, but the main character I want to focus on is Homer Wells, who is also the main character of the film. Now every character goes through many different situations and are faced with different obstacles that they must over come. Dr. Larch has to over come the ability to realize he is human, and how the board wants to replace him. Mr. Rose has to over come non

John Irving’s The Cider House Rules

1386 words - 6 pages John Irving’s The Cider House Rules Contemporary society advocates that without love, happiness is impossible. Webester’s Dictionary defines happiness as, “ a state of well being or contentment.” Three types of love which are necessary for contentment are; familial love, romantic love and friendship. In John Irving’s, The Cider House Rules, Melony’s bitterness prevents her from developing these forms of love vital for true happiness