The Accused Essay

1383 words - 6 pages

The AccusedThe accused is a movie about Sarah Tobias, a woman of questionable character, who is gang raped in a bar by three men, while others looked on and cheered. Outraged by the plea bargain made by the prosecuting attorney, Sarah is appalled. In an effort to right this wrong her attorney, Kathryn Murphy, brings the onlookers to court for soliciting the crime, thus restoring Sarah as the victim, and putting the rape on record. In the end the onlookers were found guilty and Sarah is vindicated.From the beginning you could see the prosecuting attorney tearing holes in the allegations being made. Sarah was drunk, she smoked some grass, she had a prior record, she went to the bar alone dressed in a sexy manner, and her license plate read "Sexy Sadie". Kathryn had no doubt a rape occurred at least technically, but saw her client as a, "sitting duck", and a horrible witness. In her eyes there was huge doubt that a jury would convict. Based on this, she was told to cut a deal; she plea-bargained the case down to reckless endangerment, which carried two to five years.This scenario was described perfectly in the article, "Discrediting Victims' Allegations of Sexual Assault: Prosecutorial accounts of case rejection." Only cases characterized as "solid" or "convictable" are filed. As we saw in the movie, prosecutors are actively looking for holes or problems that will make the victim's version unbelievable, hence unconvictable (212). The motto when in doubt reject, or as the movie showed, make a deal, but don't take it to court.Sarah's behavior at the bar was considered by many to have contributed to the crime. In essence she was also to blame. In a study by Kalven and Ziesel, it was shown that jurors would go to great lengths to be lenient with defendants if there is any suggestion of contributing factors. This is just another reason a case may be rejected or plead down. To explain this reasoning the article, "Is it Rape", sets up the scenario of a bar room fight. Police in order to find fault would ask, who started it? If a woman comes onto a man, didn't her own actions precipitate the offense? Such behavior might include: agreed to drinks, rides, dates, or if the victim failed to react strongly enough to sexual suggestions and overtures such as kissing or dancing with the accused.In the movie the men that watched, not only did they clap and cheer, but they ensured the rape continued. If one hesitated, they were called "fagot", the peer pressure and the need to protect their manliness fostered the rape scenario. When gang rape was looked into on campuses, researchers found that there was almost always a leader, who pushed others into the crime. This is made easier by men who believe they are expected to live up to socialized norms of manliness. Such socialization norms for men include sexual entitlement and superiority over women. Society sees empathy as girliness, and a sign of weakness. If a woman is too friendly, men perceive her behavior as...

Find Another Essay On The Accused

Salem Witch Hunts: Who Were The Accused

993 words - 4 pages contagion would engulf at least twenty-two Massachusetts villages, culminating in the arrest of over one hundred and fifty people. Fifty-nine were tried, thirty–one convicted, and nineteen hanged (Foulds vi-vii).” Women were the majority of the accused, because in that time witchcraft was mostly a female perversity. The over one-hundred and fifty accused in 1692 were from all backgrounds, ages and genders. “Persons who scoffed at accusations of

The Accused Essay

1897 words - 8 pages Textiles have had a huge impact on the development of the contemporary world. Ever since humans discovered rubbing multiple strands of natural fibres together made them stronger, humans have experienced rapid and unprecedented growth in all areas. The patterns of global exchange have been created, shaped and transformed in a number of ways because of textiles and textile production. Approximately 40,000 years ago humans survived by hunting

Wrongfully Accused and Convicted: “The West Memphis Three”

1096 words - 4 pages the “West Memphis Three”. The case involves three teenage boys from West Memphis accused of killing three 8 year old boys. After being reported missing a day later, the victims were discovered in a drainage ditch. During that time, there was no supporting evidence collected at the crime scene to prove who committed the murders. A lieutenant who contacted a juvenile officer in Memphis both agreed someone in a cult executed the gruesome murders. The

The Davis Trial-Accused of Murder by Abortion

1195 words - 5 pages bearing a child. Prior to the 19th century, the abortionist was blamed for the crime. However, in the 1860s, that perspective changed and women were also charged of the crime. Single women had few resources as there were no support systems available. Laing and Gilmour were alone and resorted to Davis as they did not want the pregnancy to cause them shame. In the criminal justice system during the 19th century, the accused were usually

Falsely Accused: A Defense of the Death Penalty

3056 words - 12 pages accused of inaccuracy, ineffectiveness, and racism. And as the only course of action capable of adequately displaying our outrage and disgust at the savage destruction of innocent life, the death penalty deserves a defense. "Since the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1976 that capital punishment is not `cruel and unusual,' 618 prisoners have been executed across the nation and about 80 have been exonerated. Those disturbing odds beg the

The Davis Trial-Accused of Murder by Abortion

2206 words - 9 pages of 1892 states “with intent to procure the miscarriage of any woman, whether she is or not with child, unlawfully administers to her or causes to be taken by drug or noxious thing or unlawfully uses any instrument or other means whatsoever with the like intent.” In the matter of Gilmour and Laing, the victims were both four to five months pregnant and had no other option but to rely on privately seeking an abortionist. The accused Dr. Davis and

BOOK REVIEW: "THE ORDERING OF JUSTICE: A STUDY ACCUSED PERSONS AS DEPENDANTS IN THE CRIMINAL PROCESS"

3320 words - 13 pages are funded by the government represent the people, and defence lawyers who are privately paid or paid by the government represent the accused. In his book, Ericson argues that through time in Canada the accused has played very little to no role in his own defence and depends entirely on his lawyer who makes his living in the criminal justice system. Because of this, he argues that the accused is more of a dependant than a defendant. For Ericson

Sinful or Feared?: An Exploration of the Reasons Women Were Accused of Witchcraft

776 words - 4 pages Did people really believe women were more sinful and evil than men, or were they afraid of women taking over? In the 1600’s, Witch Trials took place in Salem, Massachusetts. Many of the accused witches were in fact female. Witch accusations were mainly aimed at women due to the Puritan ideas that women were more vulnerable and evil than men, their sexuality was more obvious and sinful, and the fear of women gaining power and authority

The life of Richard the III of England, and a defense of his so-called "crimes" as accused by Shakespeare and the Tudor/Lancasters. With footnotes and bibliography

1749 words - 7 pages marry her without a dowry."... Clarence is come -- false, fleeting, perjured Clarence..."##George was greedy to begin with. He had participated in a coup against his own brother, Edward IV, and was an inconstant supporter during the War of the Roses. When his wife Isabella died, leaving him none of the Earl of Warwick's land, George accused her serving maid of poisoning her. Despite Edward's insistence that the trial not go forth without some

An essay on the International Criminal Court, with a mark of 18.75/20. Including- Overview, History, Jurisdiction, Structure, Rights of the accused and Current Cases

1026 words - 4 pages can only exercise its jurisdiction under the following circumstances•Where the person accused of committing a crime is a national of a state party or where the state has accepted the jurisdiction of the court.•Where the alleged crime was committed on the territory of a state party.•Where a situation is referred to the Court by the UN Security Council.>The structure of the court is made up of the presidency, the judicial

The summary of the story "To Kill A Mockingbird". A white lawyer defends a black man in court who has been accused of raping a white woman. He is innocent

750 words - 3 pages , who has been accused of raping a white woman. Because of Atticus's decision, Jem and Scout are subjected to abuse from other children, even when they celebrate Christmas at the family compound on Finch's Landing. Calpurnia, the Finches' black cook, takes them to the local black church, where the warm and close-knit community largely embraces the children.Atticus's sister, Alexandra, comes to live with the Finches the next summer. Dill, who is

Similar Essays

The Falsely Accused Essay

927 words - 4 pages falsely accused and some died because they were accused of being a witch even though, witches don’t exist. In Salem Massachusetts there was mass hysteria caused by a few girls. It all started in the house of Reverend Parris, 1692. During a long and cold winter, one day Reverend Parris’ daughter Elizabeth, age 9, and his niece Abigail, age 11, started to shake and have fits. They would scream and contort their bodies into unearthly shapes. Ann

The Rights Of The Accused Essay

3624 words - 15 pages law stands void as per Article 13 of the Constitution. If an individual does a certain crime then he will be dealt with as per the law, for example if A murders B then A will be charged for murder under section 300 of the Indian Penal Code and punished under section 302 of the same. For every crime there is a specific punishment or sanctions. The person who has done a crime is called a criminal or an accused however that person is innocent until

Rights Of The Criminally Accused Essay

885 words - 4 pages Everyone in the United States have specific rights when they are criminally accused. “I consider trial by jury as the only anchor ever yet imagined by man, by which a government can be held to the principles of its constitution.” This quote was from Thomas Jefferson. Trial by jury goes along with everyone having rights when they are accused, it is one of the basic things in the bill of rights, that when you are accused, you have the right to

Were The Accused Witches Really Witches?

958 words - 4 pages The Salem Witch Trials of 1692 were one of the worst events in pre-US history. Hundreds of people were imprisoned, and 20-40 people died. The girls who accused the people were ruthless and lied in court. The accused witches had no way to be declared innocent. I believe the accused witches were innocent. When Tituba told Betty Parris and Abigail Williams stories and showed them voodoo tricks, things started to go haywire. As Betty and