This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Affect Of Prototyping Practices On Design Results

1383 words - 6 pages

Article Critiqued: Dow, S., 2011, ‘How prototyping practices affect design results’, interactions, 18(3), pp. 54-9.

Summary

The article explains about the affect of prototyping practices on design results. Using Iterative practices in making designs can lead to better results. Instead of working on making a perfect design, Iterative practices helps designers to learn from their previous mistakes and give a better output. For example (cited in Bayles and Orland 2001), two groups were asked to make ceramics by a teacher. He accessed one group on quantity and the other group on quality. Surprisingly, the first group made many ceramics while learning from their mistakes while the quality ...view middle of the document...

For making convincing designs designers have to broaden up their ideas rather than focusing on a particular design idea. Parallel approach also boosts up the thinking of an individual in exploring new ideas and gives confidence to present their ideas. While creating prototypes individuals should have a broad way of thinking in making design solutions.

Significance

The intention through this article is to show the affect that prototyping practices impose on the design results of a product. Two approaches have been discussed for effective designs:-
 Iterative approach - In this approach Designers work on making the prototype and then evaluating it to make refinements in the next iterative design. It is based on learning from the mistakes of previous design. Iterative practicing will ensure the best design solutions.

 Parallel approach - Multiple designs are made by different individuals at the same time. The goal is to make diverse design solutions. Individuals share their designs with each other to make an impressive design. Parallel practicing opens gateway for exploring new ideas in design contexts.

The problem is clearly stated as Iterative practices helps designers in getting feedback about their designs so that they can make refinements in it but on the other hand it also limits the product design to just one type of idea. The existence of an explicit prototype bound the discourse on just improving the prototype. All other possibilities are neglected. Making a prototype confines the exploration of new ideas in making designs.
It is important for designers to delve into notion by considering all possibilities in making designs. If the individual stick to just one idea and worked on improving that idea only, he will not be able to make creative designs and will limit his thinking to that design only. Every product in the world is trying to get attention but a good design does not need to vociferate. It is the design that makes the product unique. So designers should always look for new opportunities for making creative designs.

Argument and use of evidence

The author has claimed that the practice of iterating solutions to a problem may give you a better result but it also limits the scope of finding other alternatives to solve that problem. Instead of iteration, if people use parallel prototyping that is to create multiple designs at the same time and then sharing their designs for a better outcome. The author has used various evidences to support their claims.
To prove effective results of iterative practices he used an example of classic middle class activity. In the activity people were instructed to construct vessels from raw materials to protect a raw egg’s plummet. Half of the participants were told to iterate rapidly and the other half to focus on one perfect design. To measure the efficiency, vessels were dropped from height. Results show that people doing rapid iteration...

Find Another Essay On the affect of prototyping practices on design results

The Affect of War on One's Innocence

1412 words - 6 pages first hand. The other is from the perspective of a soldier, reflecting on the death of one of his fellow soldiers and realizing that there is nothing he can do to save him. While “Song of Becoming” and “Dulce et Decorum Est” both focus on the theme of the loss of innocence, “Song of Becoming” illustrates how war affects the lives of young boys, whereas “Dulce et Decorum Est” depicts the affect on an experienced soldier. In “Song of Becoming,” Fadwa

The Affect Of Television On American Filmmaking

771 words - 4 pages ) states that "in a move towards creating a higher form of motion pictures, Hollywood began utilizing new technologies in order to differentiate its product from those films shown on television."While these techniques helped regenerate sales and encourage attendance, the positive results were short-lived. By 1956, most of the major Hollywood studios had sold films to television. That same year, at least one television set could be found in nearly

THE AFFECT OF BEAUTY PAGEANTS ON WOMEN

961 words - 4 pages Beauty pageants have negative impacts on both those who compete in them and women in general. Some may argue that the women in the beauty pageants can feel good about themselves. However, the overwhelming evidence against this claim proves that beauty pageants also lower self-esteem of those in the beauty pageants and those watching. This can have major consequences in society concerning the status of women. Some positive aspects of beauty

The Impact of HR Practices on the Retention of Employees

4218 words - 17 pages developing the connection between human resource practices and organizational performance anticipated that career development programs exhibit a true interest of the organization for the expansion of its personnel, which in turn stimulates commitment and devotion which lifts up personnel productivity. It can be anticipated that firm investments in both technical and non-technical training will have a positive affect on the extent to which the

The Impact of HR Practices on the Retention of Employees

1039 words - 4 pages ). So we need to understand that basically itself employee turnover is not a disease but it is a symptom of the disease i.e. Failure to retain employees. The main problem under study in this research is “The impact of human resource practices on the retention of employees”. Employee retention as effective employee retention is the result of systematic attempt by employers. It needs to develop and establish an environment that attracts employees

The Impact of Technology on Assessment Practices in Mathematics

4057 words - 16 pages assessment practices for medium to high-stakes assessment. The Centre for Interactive Assessment Development (CIAD) at the University of Derby offers and provides support for staff in all aspects of test production, including question design, quality assurance, monitoring of delivery and reporting results (JISC, 2007). Despite the sophistication offered by TRIADS, 70% of use occurs in the first year of courses at Derby, tailing off to 20% in the

Edict of Milan: a Source Analysis on the Results of the Document

894 words - 4 pages become more public and had different branches all with separate views on how the religion should be practiced. The Edict of Milan gave rise to the freedom of Christianity, however what was not intended by the edict was that as the popularity and diversity of Christianity rose this gave birth to the beginning of Christian wars; the first war was that of Christians versus the Pagans and the second, more violent was that of the Christians versus

Investigating the affect of concentration on the rate of reaction

1168 words - 5 pages remove all traces of sulphur that could affect the light getting through to the sensor on the next experiment, but it did not seem to affect our results. On the whole I do not think that our experiment was inaccurate and the computer method proved to be fairly easy when carrying out the experiment, and very easy when plotting the graph and making the results table.

Historic and Social Aspects Report on Australia's farming practices Compare and contrast the impact on the Australian environment of European farming practices and Aboriginal land management...

1639 words - 7 pages Historic & social aspects reportCompare and contrast the impact on the Australian environment of European farming practices and Aboriginal land management practices.For over 200 years, Australia has been adopting European farming practices. Although these practices have generated a lot of money for the farmers, the impact on the Australian environment is starting to take its toll.But how come these practices are still being used in Europe

The Affect of Slavery on Whites in the South

1010 words - 4 pages break out that it was referred to as "King Cotton." Slavery drove this plantation economy, but also made it increasingly unstable and monopolistic. With slave prices of around $1,200 for prime field hands, many small farmers were forced to sell their farms to more prosperous farmers, making the plantation economy extremely monopolistic, and with the one crop economy, the well being of the south was dependent on price fluctuation. Slavery made the

The Effects of Internet Use on Academic Results at Nigerian University

1185 words - 5 pages Botswana, Gaborone. The research is based on expost-facto research design in which Tella is interested with the relationship between the variables and what has happened to the sample subjects without any attempt of manipulation and control. Besides, the employment of experimental research design is to form the cause and the impact of the Internet use on perceived academic achievement. The targeted population is 4000 senior undergraduate students who

Similar Essays

The Design And Implementation Of Strategic Human Resource Practices

1043 words - 4 pages firm which is based on competencies, so a concrete theory has not been built in this area of knowledge. In this regard, culture has a very important role to play. Culture guides the employees of an organization about the desirable practices, it vision and a sense of direction. Some of the cultural values that are also the HR policy objectives include commitment, flexibility and competence. The HR should play a proactive role in maintaining a

Picking A Prototyping Design Tool For The Car Checker Android Application

1415 words - 6 pages on greater importance than ever.”(Page 399) This is an important idea to be taken into account when the car checker application is in development, even in its prototyping stages. Wasserman also discusses the importance of user interface design in the mobile application and compares it to a web application as, “Mobile users are often seeking to quickly complete a simple task, and can’t take advantage of the full range of functionality provided by

The Results Of Aging Essay

1643 words - 7 pages ....................10LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONSTables1. The results of aging.....................................................................................................................4INTRODUCTIONThe purpose of this report is to discuss several aspects of aging.Several theories of why we age, based on genetic research, cellular research, andphysiological research will be examined, along with physical and mental changes that are the resultof

Affect Of The Internet On World Culture

2760 words - 11 pages Abstract As the collective world turns on their computers, it is becoming increasingly important to know why they have decided to turn them on and what drives them while they are on. There have been several theories governing modern social society that can be translated rather precisely into the world of the Internet. The personality theories developed by John Atkinson, Abraham Maslow, Joseph Veroff, and Dan McAdams helps define the different