This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Afl Canadian: Labor, National Identity, And Transnational Discourse 1936 1955

1868 words - 7 pages

The AFL Canadian: Labor, National Identity, and Transnational Discourse 1936-1955

“The American Federation of Labor is an American organization,” declared William Green, president of the AFL, in his 1947 keynote speech, “It believe[d] in American, the fundamental law of the United States, the Constitution, freedom, liberty and democracy. We will have nothing to do with Communism in any shape, or form ... This sixty-sixth convention will redeclare its opposition to Communism and to Communist philosophy, and ... to [those who would] attempt to establish it among the organized labor of our country.” Though Green declared “Communism abhorrent to American labor” not all the members of the AFL were American. Indeed, Canadians and their unions had been part of the AFL since its inception in 1881.

Craft unions in Canada were primarily organized under the Trades and Labor Congress of Canada (TLC), which had been a subdivision of the AFL since 1910. However the power relation between these two groups had been hotly contested over that time. Should the Trades and Labor Congress be able to act independently of the AFL leadership? After all, as Green said in his 1947 speech, “The American Federation of Labor is an American organization.” Canada was a sovereign state, yet its labor organizations were dominated by a foreign power.

At the 1939 American Federation of Labor convention in Atlantic City, NJ, this issue of Canadian labor sovereignty in regards to the AFL came to the fore. The executive council of the AFL recommended giving the Trades and Labor Congress sole authority to grant central labor body charters. Although primarily an economically unimportant act, as central labor bodies did not arbitrate wages or work conditions, it was culturally significant as it symbolized Canadian autonomy. This would have constituted a modification of the 1910 agreement governing the relationship of the TLC and the Executive Council of the AFL, and there was a strong reaction from the floor delegates against such a proposal. The resulting Resolution 15 demanded “that every Central Labor Union in Canada MUST hold a charter from the A. F. of L. in addition to any charter they may hold from the Canadian Trades and Labor Congress [and the TLC additionally] CANNOT issue charters of any kind without such application for charter first having received the approval of the Executive Council.” There was a perception that TLC-chartered unions were coming under the control of Communists and the CIO, both direly opposed by the AFL. Thus the reaction of the delegates was both economic and political; they opposed the dual-unionism, that is, two unions representing the same industry, of the CIO, and the expansion of the Communist influence in North America. Yet from the perspective of many Canadian unionists, the greater threat was not Communism or the CIO, but that a foreign labor organization, primarily constituted of, and entirely led by Americans, could dictate the...

Find Another Essay On The AFL Canadian: Labor, National Identity, and Transnational Discourse 1936-1955

Communication Technology and Canadian Identity Essay

1374 words - 5 pages in Canada such as the limitation of high speed Internet in rural remote communities so students taking long distance education will have delayed information and cannot access all services such as interactive video services. Television Television is one of many powerful tools that help influence and shape the Canadian identity. Each region has a number of television stations but each is a participant in a national network. This allows shows

Canadian Identity. A personal comparison of Canada and the U.S

564 words - 2 pages 1: The Canadian Identity is the stuff that all Canadian's have incommon, it's like we invented hockey so that is considered part of ouridentity. We also invented Basketball but the U.s. took that away from usby exploting it and saying that because the man was in the U.s. it was notCanadian, but for the people that know they realize that our identity is fallingapart because the U.s. is a much bigger country so they have more power.2: The thing

A look on the Canadian Identity as a Canadian citizen and what it means to me

1345 words - 5 pages or be labeled as the Canadian identity. Ask any Canadian or foreigner for that matter, and you will see that this is so. A hockey fan will say that we are famous for being excellent hockey players, and that is our identity. A landscape artist will claim that it's our rolling wheat fields, Rocky Mountains and beautiful bodies of water. A railroad conductor will say it's our vast land and immense size that give us our identity. A monarchist will

The Environment as Master Narrative: Discourse and Identity in Environmental Problems

1609 words - 6 pages environmentalism's potential to bring grassroots actors into a globalized civil society, forming transnational networks for public participation (Lipshutz 1996; Peet and Watts 1996). Other scholars warn us to pay close attention to novel forms of global governance fostered by international environmentalism that may occlude local public participation (Jamison 1996).Anthropologists are now beginning to study the formation of local, regional, and

Sporting Heritage and National Identity

4192 words - 17 pages This paper will discuss how Sporting Heritage engenders national and group identities. The topics related too in this paper, are the types of identity represented by sporting Heritage, as sporting heritage has the ability to represent groups and entire nations across the world. Sport is a fundamental part of British and world culture and is an important aspect of modern life. This topic is relevant to recent trends within modern interest as it

Man’yoshu and Kokinshu: National Identity

1320 words - 5 pages In Japan, two poetic anthologies, the Man’yōshū and the Kokinshū, are highly revered as literary embodiments of the Japanese spirit. Though both are similar in their purposes as literature, the intent behind compiling each anthology as well as the legacy each has left behind differ greatly. With its inclusion of poets from all classes and embodiment of makoto or sincerity, the Man’yōshū helped the Japanese form a national identity through its

Australia's reputation and national identity

1756 words - 7 pages itself because of its eager troops and excellent mounted riflemen. The young nation suddenly had a national identity. Nationalism of Australia was at its peak as it was a new nation as well as its involvement in the Boer War.The First World War (1914-1919) for Australia, as for many nations, remains the most costly conflict ever in terms of deaths and casualties. From a population of fewer than 5 million, 3000,000 men enlisted, of which over

The Relationship Between National Identity and State-building

1750 words - 7 pages contemporary. Culture has a prominent role in germinating national identity among the people, as Fanon (1963) in his book Wretched of the Earth describes that the colonizers have a tendency to impose their culture on the people whom they have colonized and this aggravates the people (ibid), the British in India enforced the Indian soldiers to use the cartridges greased with fat of cow and pig. As the cow is considered to be sacred among Hindus, an

The Global Feminist and the Transnational Feminist

1217 words - 5 pages Rights': Feminist Practices, Global Feminism, and Human Rights Regimes in Transnationality”. This paper shall analyze and discuss how Grewal applies previous theoretical concepts related to feminist discourse in order to offer a Transnationalist Feminist critique to the Global Feminist notion of Women's Rights as Human Rights. First and foremost, what are the concepts of Global feminism and Transnational feminism? Charlotte Bunch explains

The Topic of Power and Transnational Corporations

2578 words - 10 pages The topic under discussion will be that of power in regards to the large transnational corporations (TNC): who has this power, towards whom this power is exerted and how this power is maintained are the central themes. Profoundly related is the concept of globalisation, a process which has become ever so evident and shapes the nature of modern economics. While some consider the power in the hands of the TNC to be "natural" and overall socially

Golf and the Sencondary Discourse

2733 words - 11 pages language. Over several years, I have been able to learn the secondary Discourse of golf by learning about the golf swing, learning terminology, principles of the sport, and through my experiences. When I started playing golf around age twelve, I was uncertain about the technicalities of the game or any of the rules that are involved. It took a long time for me to understand the nuances of golf because of the challenges it presents. It started with

Similar Essays

National Identity And The Consumer Essay

1039 words - 4 pages National identity is a group or an individual's collective characteristics by which they are known and recognise themselves with respect to the country they live in or have other ties with. More specifically, literature often refers to patriotism and nationalism attitudes. Patriotism can be defined as one's love of his country (Berns, 1997). Nationalism, on the other hand, is the exalting of one's country and its culture above all others. The

The Canadian National Flag Essay

558 words - 2 pages The Canadian National FlagThe Canadian Flag, sometimes referred to as the "Maple Leaf", is a true symbol of Canada and shows how we love our land by having a maple leaf on the flag. The colours of the flag are the official national colours of Canada, red and white. King George V appointed them in 1921.The Maple Leaf wasn't the only flag Canada had. Prior to the Maple Leaf there was the St. George's cross. The St. Georges Cross was an English

What Is The Difference Between Ethnic Identity And National Identity?

1556 words - 7 pages part of Lee of granting ethnic Malays in Singapore the same privileges they enjoyed in Malaysia, brought to its separation in 1965. (Liu et al, 2002) Upon independence, Singapore had to find a reason to exist as a nation: largely of immigrant stock, it was difficult even to create a discourse on a “Singaporean identity”, for lack of common descent and kinship myths. There was no tradition or governmental structure which could be resurrected, and

National And European Identity Essay

1717 words - 7 pages Scholars of the European Union (EU) have a strong interest in the concept of European Union identity (Cram, 2009). The ‘European union’ identity can be identified nowadays, although there are still conflicts between national identities and a shared European identity which can be illustrated by the data from Eurobarameter and other sources. Most people perceive themselves as Europeans, as Anderson (1991) state, there is no contradictory between