The Age Of White Guilt By Shelby Steel

1051 words - 4 pages

    “Since the social victim has been oppressed by society, he comes to feel that his individual life will be improved more by changes in society than by his own initiative.” These words belong to conversative author and social critic Shelby Steele. Steele is often criticized by the Black community for his right-wing views on ideas such affirmative action and multiculturalism. In Steele’s short essay, The Age Of White Guilt, Steele discusses how the black community has been and still is losing their sense of individuality to the “mob mentality,” and how the modern-day black community is a victim of no-racism. Although Shelby Steele is a wonderful writer with senseful rhetoric, his stance doesn't cover the whole, true scope of Black America. Steele’s view on the African-American community is a broad, straightforward take and Steele’s take on a less-racist community is incorrect, for racism has only become more subtle.
  While Steele’s main argument is faulty, the techniques that Steele uses to convey his ideas form a coherent and senseful essay. Steele opens his piece with an anecdote about him growing up as a black child in segregated Chicago. In the dying days of rhetoric, Steele not only uses this story to keep up with the times, but to also establish ethos with Black readers and others who would criticize Steele as an “Uncle Tom” who can’t relate with other Blacks. His black experiences depict him as a black man instead of someone who kisses up to white people. Steele’s second anecdote is about his experience and
inspiration after watching Paris Blues, a movie starring African-American actor Sidney Poitier in which a young black man seeks to find his identity in Paris. Steele uses this story to illustrate Steele’s idea about black individuality and to introduce the topic of African-American individuality in America. Another truly important rhetorical technique used in Steele’s writing is proper diction. Steele proves that he has a high vocabulary and uses it with words such as: avarice, anathema, contrite, and enmeshment. Steele’s diction also establishes ethos with the reader because a high vocabulary shows Steele’s intelligence. The final rhetorical technique that Steele rides on for support is allusion. Steele alludes to multiple events such as James Baldwin’s move back to America from Europe to support the Civili Rights Movement and Lawrence Summers’ decision to not hire Cornel West as a Professor at Harvard .Steele uses allusions as examples to support his argument of the loss of black individuality and the submission to the ideas of the black community and the age of white guilt.
  Despite Steele’s effective use of rhetorical techniques, his argument is flawed because the African-American community promotes individuality and overlooks the present racism in America. Although it is believed that African-Americans have pledged allegiance to the group rather than themselves, the community originated from a need of individuality....

Find Another Essay On The Age Of White Guilt by Shelby Steel

Eliezer Internal Conflicts caused by the Guilt of Surviving

1446 words - 6 pages Eliezer and cause him to feel that life is not worth living. He mentions continually throughout the novel that he wishes he were dead. These feelings are caused by the guilt that he carries for surviving when compared to the fate of others. Throughout his time in the hospital, Eliezer struggles with an internal conflict between surviving and dying, which suppresses his personal growth; he simply cannot erase his past memories, which cause him to

Macbeth: The Effects of Guilt Essay

1218 words - 5 pages do what she thinks is best. Though Lady Macbeth may have initially seemed unaffected by the murders she had been involved in, her desires eventually faded and were replaced with an invincible feeling of guilt which eventually took her life. An overpowering emotion, guilt once lay dormant in Lady Macbeth, but this dormancy foreshadows the effects it would have on her later in the play. At one point, Macbeth states, “…We but teach

The Age of Innocence, by Edith Wharton

2466 words - 10 pages born on January 24, 1862 into a wealthy family that was high ranked in society, and after World War 1 she used her book to replicate a similar time in her childhood. “In a sense she tried to escape the vexations of the post-war years by commemorating a culture that she had known as a child” (McDowell 59.) Edith herself reported, “I found a momentary escape in going back to my childish memories of a long vanished America and wrote The Age of

The Importance of the Cell Phone Age: From Stone Age to Phone Age by Barbara Ehrenreich

865 words - 3 pages In “From Stone Age to Phone Age”, Barbara Ehrenreich describes that cell phones are not well suited to her even though they are fashionable. In her article, she points out cell phones are not used to connect people to each other but to isolate them from a big group of people. I think cell phones are very important to our daily life because they are convenient to manage our lives. Moreover, from the earlier cell phone age to nowadays, cell phones

The Age of Innocence, by Edith Wharton

908 words - 4 pages end he has to choose one of the two, Newland sacrifices his happiness to maintain everyone's reputation. Just because of the way that he was raised, “with proper family values” Newland ends up marrying a woman his family accepts, May. As well one of the themes that Wharton presents in “The Age of Innocence” is hypocrisy within the society. The author presents the New York society during the 1870s that ignores reality and pretends to act

The Politics of Trade in Steel

652 words - 3 pages 1. Do you believe the Bush administration was correct in imposing tariffs in March 2002 on a wide range of steel imports?I believe that President Bush needed to do something to protect the US steel market. At the time that President Bush decided to impose temporary tariffs on steel imports, 16 steel manufactures were already operating under bankruptcy protection (Hill, 2005). The whole idea of the tariffs as explained by Leo Gerard, the

A Brief Analysis of The Steel Industry

1511 words - 6 pages raw material sources or suppliers, which enable them to control their market. Chandler understood that company’s needed to have a minimum efficient scale. By keeping track of costs he could lower prices and gain a competitive advantage over his rivals. (p. 96-97) However it was Andrew Carnegie who realized that the development of steel needed to be improved. He would later adopt England’s method of iron production through subjecting it

Critical Essay of The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne ( Do you dread guilt?)

700 words - 3 pages What is guilt? We all have guilt about something. Maybe forgetting something,lied about something, or even did something that shouldn't of been done. In The ScarletLetter by Nathaniel Hawthorne we saw guilt fester in the minds and outward appearanceof the main characters, Hester Prynne, Arthur Dimmesdale and Roger Chillingworth.When you hear the word guilt what do you think it means? Guilt meansremorseful awareness of having done something wrong

Film Analysis: Man of Steel Directed by Zack Snyder

1173 words - 5 pages Man of Steel Review Man of Steel is a sci-fi drama movie based on a combination of Superman movies created in the late 70s to late 80s. The movie is directed by Zack Snyder who had a heavy hand in the action packed digital innovations movie 300 as well as the movie Watchmen, who is known for doing movies on major DC Comic heroes, with his latest being the most recent of the Batman trilogy, The Dark Knight. Man of Steel starts off

An Examination of Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond

1137 words - 5 pages An Examination of Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond Yali posed an interesting question. Why did Europe come to dominate the rest of the world after 1500? Jared Diamond, in his book Guns, Germs, and Steel, concludes that geography is the defining factor in all of human history. While some people may disagree with his conclusion, that is only because it might not seem to take individual choice into consideration

The Psychological and Physiciological Effects of Guilt

543 words - 2 pages sense of inadequacy. There are negative physiological effects caused by guilt. Guilt can make someone over responsible. They will think that life has to be perfect, and will do everything to try to please everyone. It may make someone over conscientious so that they may neglect their needs to avoid affecting others with the negative consequences of an action. Oversensitivity becomes a problem, as one becomes obsessed with every aspect of right and

Similar Essays

The Age Of White Guilt By Shelby Steele

1936 words - 8 pages , “because all they can do is accuse Republicans of racism.” We’ve gotten to a point where everything is deemed racist, he and Coulter agreed. At that point, he aired a montage of “Democrats playing the issue hard.” These “tactics,” Hannity said — citing “class warfare,” “scaring granny” and the “race card” — are proving effective to a certain extent” (Vamburker). In Age of White Guilt, Shelby Steele writes to both whites and blacks to express

Is Racism In The Heart? By Tommie Shelby

1547 words - 6 pages evaluated. Shelby gives the hypothetical case of Stephen (white) disliking Andre (black) because Andre was having an affair with Stephen’s wife. In this example, Shelby illustrates that Stephen’s derives his dislike of Andre from Andre’s behavior not his race (480). Thus, Shelby raises the question of what racism actually signifies. Rather than disliking someone simply on the basis of skin color, Shelby suggests that is has a “deeper meaning” (480

Analysis Of The Poem "Prayer Of Steel" By Carl Sanburg

1323 words - 5 pages Prayer of SteelCarl Sandburg(1878-1967)Lay me on an anvil, O GodBeat me and hammer me into a crowbar.Let me pry loose old walls.Let me lift and loosen old foundationsLay me on an anvil, Oh God.Beat me and hammer me into a steel spike.Drive me into the girders that hold a skyscraper together.Take red-hot rivets and fasten me into the central girders.Let me be the great nail holding a skyscraper together through blue nights into white stars.A

The Guilt Of Uncertainty Essay

1267 words - 5 pages heretofore been sleeping with. At this point, it seems as if Josef is finally ready to face the reality of his trial and get it over with. He soon lapses into a depressive obsession, however, after determining to draw up a petition of everything he's ever done to prove that he must be innocent. In this part of the story, Josef begins on the right path by trying to face his guilt himself, and he even sets about starting to interrogate himself