This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Ambiguous Line Between Right And Wrong In My Sister's Keeperby Jodi Picoult

1034 words - 5 pages

There is an ambiguous line between right and wrong that can cause difficulty when making decisions. Jodi Picoult's My Sister's Keeper demonstrates the grey area between right and wrong through a family's struggle with ethics. First, Anna's character struggles to do what is right while keeping the consequences of her actions in mind. Second, Sara's conflict with society shows how problematic it can be to do what seems right for one's family. Finally, the symbolism of stars and dark matter depicts how natural it can be to overlook what is unjust and only see what is right. Through Anna's character, Sara's conflict with society, and the symbolism of stars and dark matter, Picoult's My Sister's Keeper suggests that in order to do what is right, one may have to do what is perceived as wrong.
First, Anna faces many challenges when making decisions that could have both positive and negative results surrounding her sister's acute promyelocytic leukemia. To begin with, Anna is a mature and independent teenager who is capable of making her own decisions. Anna does not want to involuntarily donate a kidney to her sister, Kate, so she sues her parents for medical emancipation. By wanting full rights to her own body, which she is entitled to, Anna's actions are perceived as selfish and morally wrong because she is risking Kate's life. Eventually, at the climax of the novel, Anna demonstrates that she is compassionate by disclosing her hidden motive. Anna admits that Kate “asked me to kill her” (Picoult 388), revealing her real reason for filing a lawsuit. Because Anna is doing this as the result of her sister's wish to die, she is doing the right thing for Kate, demonstrating that her “wrong” is really a “right”. Ironically by the end of the novel, Anna becomes the sacrifice that is needed in order to save Kate's life. Initially, Anna was born to save her sister's life and she ends up doing just this when she dies in the car accident, providing a kidney transplant for Kate. It is tragic for Anna to die, but it results in good as Kate lives on, cancer free. The reader is forced to accept their feelings of both sadness and relief, to understand that right and wrong sometimes overlap. The seemingly selfish things that Anna does, and is subject to, are revealed to be selfless, which emphasizes how unclear the difference can be between right and wrong.
Anna's mother, Sara, also faces many difficulties in trying to do what is right for her family, through her conflict with society. First, Sara conceives Anna as a “designer baby”. Sara “received hate mail” (Picoult 102) as a result of conceiving Anna as a bone marrow match for Kate. Making a “designer baby” is very controversial and is deemed unethical by society. At the same time, Sara is right to be doing everything she can to save her daughter. Later, when Anna is thirteen, Sara tries to force her into donating a kidney for...

Find Another Essay On The Ambiguous Line Between Right and Wrong in My Sister's Keeperby Jodi Picoult

The Novels by Jodi Picoult Essay

1166 words - 5 pages Once I picked up Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult, reading was forever changed for me. At the time, I was confident that I would write my own novel some day and longed to possess the magic that Picoult’s work had. Her style for writing narratives is unique from almost anything else I’ve found to read with a mixed genre of contemporary, mystery, and crime. Elements in her writing that inspire me include topics that are realistic, relatable, and

Analysis of My Sister´s Keeper by Jodi Picoult

690 words - 3 pages always be with her, because of that kidney. Through her death she learned how strong she really was and how some people need to leave so some can stay. This Novel shows Kate growth in many more ways than just what was mentioned but the fact is Kate went from that strong, brave, caring , but very ill teenager to an even stronger, even braver, even more caring and so thankful to be a health young adult. Anyone can learn from her growth and be inspired to donate their organs. Works Cited Picoult, Jodi. My Sister's Keeper: A Novel. New York: Atria, 2004. Print.

themes in My Sister's Keeper and Tfios - Comparative - Essay

1686 words - 7 pages Connecting Text Study Essay My Sisters Keeper and The Fault In Our Stars Compare and contrast the themes of love and sacrifice in the two texts My Sisters Keeper and The Fault In Our Stars. My Sisters Keeper and The Fault In Our Stars written by Jodie Picoult and John Green respectively, are both stories of teenage girls suffering with cancer, based around the themes of love and sacrifice. These themes are explored throughout the texts with

Right and Wrong in the Stranger by Albert Camus

1167 words - 5 pages eyebrows dripped down over my eyelids and covered them with a warm, thick film” blinds Meursault and all he could feel were the “cymbals of sunlight crashing on my forehead” (59). The normally miniscule aspects of the weather overcome Meursault, causing him to commit murder. He describes his surroundings as if the “sky split open from one end to the other to rain down fire” (59). When Meursault murders the Arab he is in such state of mind as

Feeling Right in the Wrong Way

1136 words - 5 pages disagreement of my answer, Mr. Lucas.” She cocked her head to one side, feeling slightly uncomfortable and warm in her spot. “Tell me, Miss Reese, have you ever experience Love before?” He drooped his neck, dragging his face closer to her, nearly touching the tip of her nose. “What do you mean by Love? You do know that there are different kinds of them.” She tried to remain her sophisticated and professional self. “Hm… Let’s say, friendship first of all.” Painfully, her heart was stabbed like a dagger through her chest.

My Sister's Keeper: Analysis and Comparing the Book to the Movie

931 words - 4 pages Cassavetes took some liberties with the plot of the story. He essentially changes the ending and removes most of the interactions between Anna and her lawyer, one of the most dynamic relationships in the novel. I for one did not like this decision but overall the movie did live up to the expectations set by the novel. I give this movie 3.5 out 4 stars and recommend it to all my readers. Works Cited IMDb, . N.p.. Web. 12 Nov 2013. .

right and wrong

857 words - 3 pages In the passage, Ethical Relativism: Who's to Judge What's Right and Wrong? had a absolutist point of view. As an absolutist, I agree and think it is not what culture defines as moral to actually be moral at all. For example, If I start believing in a pebble and tell everyone that the pebble is a god; They believe in it yet it doesn't make it wholly universally moral.Ethical relativism refers to the values of cultures, not being questioned or

Right And Wrong

2383 words - 10 pages father and a man as they are seen in society, Holden’s would-be mentors fail him because he is given bad advice such as when Mr. Spencer fails to give him advice for the future and Mr. Antolini’s misunderstood intimacy and is left with the entertainment industry for mentorship . Contrasting the roles that mentor characters play in the two novels highlights a fundamental difference between them: unlike The Odyssey, The Catcher in the Rye implies

The Blurred Line Between Truth and Lie

1316 words - 6 pages minorities and mainland. Although a young adult book, Delirium deals with savager government systems reflected through the real world, Xizhou. While young adults in both worlds generates rebellious feelings of love and freedom, they are limited by both virtual and physical borders influenced by assumptions and lies. Life is a blurred line between truth and lie, it is a blurred line between living in an imperfect truth or in a perfect lie.

The Blurred Line Between Truth and Lie

1496 words - 6 pages The Blurred Line Between Truth and Lie Delirium by Lauren Oliver is a dark and alluring novel that wanders back and forth between the blurred lines of truth and lie. The main character--Lena, falls in love in a dystopian society where love is seen as a disease, amor deliria nervosa. “On your eighteenth birthday...you will get cured and will be happy forever...” “it is the deadliest of all deadly things: It kills you both when you have it

The Fine Line between Fantasy and Reality

1211 words - 5 pages Metafiction is a term given to fictional writing which self-consciously and systematically draws attention to its status as an artifact in order to pose questions about the relationship between fiction and reality (Waugh 2). Metafiction is a term used loosely across many genres of fictions. Using metafiction, to describe a works allows usage along a full spectrum of ideas. From this concept, many short stories, and other works of fiction

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Jodi Picoult´S My Sister's Keeper

1072 words - 5 pages My Sister's Keeper, written by Jodi Picoult, is about a family struggling to save their daughter from leukemia. By the age of thirteen, Anna, “the savior sister”, has gone through countless surgeries, transfusions and other procedures to try to save her sister from the cancer she has fought since young childhood. Anna is now at an age where she is trying to find who she truly is. She no longer wants to be defined by her older sister, she

Assisted Suicide: Blurring The Moral Lines Between Right And Wrong

922 words - 4 pages surrounded by their loved ones. Assisted suicide offers the individual that option. In the end, morals are the only argument surrounding the subject of assisted suicide. There is no real way of determining what is right and what is wrong. It all comes down to your own morals and beliefs regarding human life. Each of us is given our own life and throughout it, we all make our own decisions regarding our wellbeing. We can choose to smoke cigarettes, consume alcohol, speed in cars, and put our lives in danger every day. This is our right as human beings. We chose to live our lives the way we want to live them, why should we not be able to choose how we die?

A Battle Between Minds: Right And Wrong

2274 words - 10 pages “Right” and “wrong” are such ambiguous terms and can only be personally defined by an individual’s beliefs and values. It is said that our values are defined predominately by our upbringing, but what if it is more neurologically ingrained than we had perceived? Doctor Roger Wolcott Sperry, neurophysiologist, won The Nobel Prize in 1981 for his discoveries concerning the functional specialization of the cerebral hemispheres, in which he studied

Abortion The Ongoing Ethical Battle Between Right And Wrong. A Rebuttal To A One Sided Arguement Against Abortion

1059 words - 4 pages Abortion, a battle that'll rage through this century, right or wrong, good or bad, religion or science? Well I'm here to capture the essence of the other side of the battlefield where I'm debating for abortion.THIS IS A REBUTTAL: The text I'm referring to is given on this link, it might be helpful to go there and read that article first.http://www.cheathouse.com/essay/essay_view.php/p_essay_id/34335This is an article called abortion by Droberts