"The Amish Farmer" By Bourjaly. Essay

913 words - 4 pages

"The Amish Farmer" is a powerful tale that expresses the importance of point of view. Just as the plaintiff and defendant's testimonies create new perspectives to a court case, the narrator brings new meaning to his story with his point of view. The narrator of "The Amish Farmer", Vance, is a conflicted narrator. Although his point of view seems emotionally unattached and he refers to himself merely as the "raconteur" of the story, the narrator is torn between his true nature, similar to Noel's, and his desire to be like Daniel.There are many instances in "The Amish Farmer" that suggest Vance is depicting Noel in the story as he would if he were the main character. This is evident at the beginning of Vance's tale. The narrator has the power to choose when and how to begin his story. This choice is very important, as it determines the point of view of the story and how the characters are to be viewed by the readers.By starting the tale when Noel states that Daniel had tried to kill him, Vance seems to seek the readers' pity for Noel and presents contempt towards Daniel. These initial characterizations can be seen as Vance attempting to defend Noel, much as he might defend himself.Vance further justifies Noel's character when he states, "He probably looked archaic to some of his peers, but he looked just right to me" (p.480). It seems evident that by creating a sense of purity, naivety, and integrity in Noel's character, Vance is attempting to make up for any feelings of vulnerability that came from telling the story again.Vance is even more vulnerable in that he does not understand women and falls victim to surprise and devastation from them. This misunderstanding is seen throughout the story and is most evident at the end, when Katie Jay says to Vance, "Oh, I need that Amish farmer. Don't you see?" (p.493). It is clear that the last line can be interpreted as being said by Dawn to Noel, and just as Noel does not understand Dawn's affair with Daniel and her need for the Amish farmer, Vance does not understand Katie Jay's response and the appeal of the Amish farmer.When Vance is speaking with his students on the importance of point of view in the story, he asks the students to drop his (the "raconteur's") point of view and tell it from Noel's (p.491). Vance's declaration of being just a "raconteur" could be considered as an attempt to ease the vulnerability caused by telling the story, opening himself up to judgment and ridicule by his students. In choosing Noel's point of view as the ideal perspective for the narrator, the idea is further...

Find Another Essay On "The Amish Farmer" by Bourjaly.

The Amish Essay

2591 words - 10 pages injunctions to respect and pray for rulers ordained by God” (14). On the other hand, their beliefs hold nothing like toward neighbors residing in that state. In fact, they raise their children to be Amish not to be part of the American society. But can you blame them, when all they have been given from outsiders is ridicule and all the state has shown them is persecution for their love of Christ. “The cardinal value of Amish society is separation

Amish Final Paper

1569 words - 7 pages The term “Amish” was first used when a man by the name Jakob Ammann led a group of people who conformed to his beliefs and objected those of the Swiss brotherhood. This started the sect of Mennonite Christianity known as the Amish. From this point, Mennonite and Amish people began migrating to America. The initial cause for Jakob’s decision to sever ties with the Anabaptist was a lack of discipline within the church. During the eighteenth

Old Order Amish in the Modern World

907 words - 4 pages , black pants, and a full beard must be from back in time. It all of a sudden arises to you from reading your favorite Amish books by Beverly Lewis that you must be in Old Order Amish country where the society lives in the modern world but not up to modern standards. What has always interested me on the Amish, is the youth’s Rumspringa, the different Amish sects there are, and how there every day life is. The Amish are Anabaptist which means

Amish in Illinois

1947 words - 8 pages Who are the Amish? Some may respond by simply saying people who ride in buggies and men who have beards. However, according to Clyde Browning, the author of Amish in Illinois they are “… a humble people living close to the teachings of the Bible and close to the soil, a people intent on clinging to the ways brought by their ancestors from Europe.” (pg xv, 5). There is a large population of Amish in Illinois who have had a great influence on the

The Amish

727 words - 3 pages their adult baptism. Even though parents know their children are dating, it is rarely talked or encouraged at home. Amish communities allow adolescents to experience the world of non Amish. As a result there have been several court cases over the last few years where Amish youth have been convicted of drug distribution among Amish communities. Amish society is based on co-operation among people. By accepting the orodung, the Amish establish

Maintaining the Amish Cultural Identity

1334 words - 5 pages over three hundred years. Their belief in the bible is the bases for their structured lives, specifically Romans 12 of the Old Testament, “Do not be conformed to this world”.*** Trying to maintain their cultural identity will prove to be a challenging task. For the last two hundred years the American culture and the Amish culture have ran side by side in their ablility to survive and succeed as a society. It has only been in the last


1245 words - 5 pages culture like the Amish, one that seems so anachronistic, has not only survived but has grown and flourished while surrounded by a culture that would seem to be so detrimental to its basic ideals.Why study the Amish? One answer would be, of course, to learn about their seemingly pure cooperative society and value system, called Ordung. The Amish do not adopt the values, norms, customs, and lifestyles of the broader society today. The Amish live much

An Inside Look at the Amish Culture

1775 words - 8 pages . Everyone is expected to obey the will of God as taught by the community. Despite the strong emphasis on humility and obedience, the Amish express great respect for the dignity of each person. Community and tradition also play important roles in Amish life. The welfare of the community ranks above individual rights and choices. Communal wisdom, accumulated over the decades, is valued more than the opinion of one person. Traditional beliefs and

Rumspringa: A tradition within the Amish community

1588 words - 6 pages they can be "care-free" teenagers.According to the author Tom Shachtman, "The Amish count on the rumspringa process to inoculate youth against the strong pull of the forbidden by dosing them with the vaccine of a little worldly experience" (14). The Amish believe that by sending their teenagers out into the outside world, they will be more willing to come back and join the church, on their own terms. By allowing them to go and venture out, it

The Amish Culture

2444 words - 10 pages Anabaptists were seen as a threat to religious and social institutions throughout Europe and were persecuted. "Some four thousand Anabaptists were killed in the decades after 1512." (Nolt, 13). In the Netherlands, Menno Simons became a leader and advocate for Anabaptism. Many Anabaptists came to be known as Mennonites. The Amish division came about as a result of particular reforms by Jacob Amman and branches out from the Mennonites to form the

Social Norms

1066 words - 5 pages Pennsylvania and the modern American world of crime and violence. The main character, Philadelphia police detective John Book, is forced into hiding by a group of corrupt fellow officers looking for a little Amish boy, Samuel. The boy witnesses a merciless killing and identifies that one of the murders is Book’s boss. John Book and his witness hide in the house of the boy's mother Rachel on a farm in the Amish country. Even though Book tries to adopt

Similar Essays

The Amish Religion Essay

1004 words - 5 pages much, they use their horses to get anywhere they want to go and also to plow the fields if they happen to be a farmer, which most are.  The Amish are separated into districts; these districts are made up of about 30 families. Each district is located in a settlement. Settlements can have many districts or just a few. The districts are run by the bishop. He makes the rules, the Ordnung; he also is the head of the church there. The minister, who

The Amish Essay

2053 words - 8 pages - hundred years ago. The most significant aspects of the Amish philosophy in their simple culture lies in the pursuit of education, hard work, allegiance to their church, and of the utmost importance is their reverence for the sanctuary of their home.The overall view of the Amish people and their culture leads us down a dirt road where we see horses and buggies plodding along among their simple, plain houses. We might see a farmer toiling the soil

Cultural Change And Survival In Amish Society

5570 words - 22 pages other means, continually interacting with the enormously tempting culture of America. So, one might be led to wonder how a culture like the Amish, one that seems so anachronistic, has not only survived but has grown and flourished while surrounded by a culture that would seem to be so detrimental to its basic ideals. The Amish, through biological reproduction, resistance to outside culture, compromise, and a strong ethnic symbolism have managed to

Amish Outline

955 words - 4 pages . Amish rarely accept government handouts 3. Amish do not go to war a. Amish believe that by resisting violence and avoiding service in war, they are following Christ’s example. i. They believe that Jesus accepted the beating on the cross at Calvary without resisting and emulate this same attitude toward worldwide conflicts. ii. They live by the rule of “turning the other cheek” rather than killing in war. c. By law, Amish must register at age 18 i