This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Antagonism Of Tybalt: Zifferelli's Versus Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet

2384 words - 10 pages

“Fiery” and “saucy” are both endearments that our Prince of Cats garners throughout William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet (I.i.107, I.v.82). From these descriptors, it is no surprise that Tybalt is often credited as the primary antagonist in the play. After all, Tybalt, who is prideful and quick to anger, kills Mercutio and through his own death sends the two lovers down the inescapable path of tragedy and mutual destruction. However, it is clear that the character is capable of being treated with more nuance and dimension than such a straightforward interpretation would allow. Through a comparison of Tybalt’s portrayals in Franco Zeffirelli’s 1968 film adaptation to Baz Luhrmann’s take from 1996, the extent of Tybalt’s antagonism proves itself to be remarkably variable.
Zeffirelli’s Tybalt played by Michael York opts for an arguably more sympathetic depiction of Juliet’s cousin. While certainly not without fault, he lacks the more violent and villainous nature of Luhrmann’s portrayed by John Leguizamo. Both are ultimately brought down by pride, but York’s Tybalt acts on an overdeveloped sense of familial honor. Leguizamo’s uses this as an outlet for a more deep-seated loathing. These conclusions will be constructed, principally, via the analysis of three key scenes present in both films. These include Tybalt’s first appearance during the opening brawl, the masquerade, and the duels with Mercutio and Romeo. Outlines of each film’s version of the scene will be accompanied by discussion of the salient differences and similarities with reference to the text where relevant. The argument will culminate with a re-examination of Tybalt’s character and role as antagonist. To alleviate ambiguity, Luhrmann’s will be referred to as Tybalt L, Zeffirelli’s as Tybalt Z, and more general statements not specific to either interpretation as Tybalt.
Zeffirelli’s opening scene is one that closely mirrors the text. As Benvolio attempts to part the fighting servants, Tybalt Z appears. He speaks with a mocking tone when questioning Benvolio’s drawn sword as an instrument of peace but quickly adopts a more serious look as he expresses his hate for “hell, all Montagues, and thee” (I.i.68). The additional line “Now hie thee home, fragment!” is given to Tybalt Z as he wounds Benvolio in the face. A nameless Montague calling Tybalt Z a villain is the last we see of him as the brawl escalates.
While both have appropriately dramatic entrances, Tybalt L exceeds his counterpart in being both more ostentatious and prone to more extreme violence. Tybalt L is prefaced with a shot of a sign saying “Phoenix: Add more fuel to your fire” and then a sudden appearance as the camera pans right from Benvolio. His lighting of a cigar, styled sideburns, and red clothing all contribute to this association with fire despite Benvolio’s line characterizing him as “fiery” being absent (I.i.107). In addition, while Tybalt L does not spill the gasoline himself, he is the...

Find Another Essay On The Antagonism of Tybalt: Zifferelli's versus Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet

Romeo and juliet: Analyse and evaluate the opening of Baz Luhrmann's 'Romeo and Juliet'

2849 words - 11 pages analyse the opening sequence of Romeo and Juliet up until when the two families leave the gas station as it explodes into a sea of flames.The first shot in the film is one of a newsreader telling the story or Romeo and Juliet; 'two star crossed lovers'. The newsreader is speaking the original prologue from Shakespeare's play and reads it in an informative and neutral tone. The newsreader's screen is positioned in the centre of our own television and

A Comparison of Mercutio and Tybalt in Romeo and Juliet

1992 words - 8 pages A Comparison of Mercutio and Tybalt in Romeo and Juliet For this assignment I intend to write and discuss the differences and similarities of two characters portrayed in the play Romeo and Juliet. As well as describing and analysing them I will also show how these characters are presented in two adaptations of films by two different directors Zeffirelli and Lurhmann. These two characters are Mercutio and Tybalt; both

Tybalt in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

2457 words - 10 pages Tybalt in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet In the play "Romeo and Juliet" by William Shakespeare, Tybalt, the nephew of Capulet's wife (hence Juliet's cousin) is very close to the Capulet family and will therefore do anything to protect the family pride. Tybalt thinks that the Montagues are the canker of Verona ; he deems their mere presence in Capulet

To what extent can Tybalt truely be blamed for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet

763 words - 3 pages Tybalt is shown as a villain in Romeo and Juliet but how much can he really be blamed?Tybalt is a proud and patriotic Capulet cousin, his name reflects his personality (tybalt means the prince of cats) he is a rare swordsman and fights with honor, although he does take personal insults very far he can be viewed in two ways, first as a racist, prejudiced against the Montagues or second as an honorable man who fights for family and what he

Comparing Zeffirelli and Luhrmann's Versions of Romeo and Juliet

887 words - 4 pages pace; Luhrman never kept his film at a solid pace. “By modernizing these aspects of the play, and reconstructing the prologue, Luhrmann creates a movie that is more interesting to the modern viewers.” ("Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet." As Zeffirelli may have believed famous actors would steal his show he instead hired fresh new faces to give the movie a more fresh, innocence value, But Luhrman used well known

Baz Luhrmann's 1996 adaptation of William Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet"

641 words - 3 pages Baz Luhrmann's 1996 adaptation of William Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" contains many different camera techniques like camera angles/movements, costumes, props and soundtracks to clearly identify the different aspects and attitudes of every character.Camera and angle movements play a great role in describing the different characteristics of each character. This can refer to Tybalt. Although the editing makes the fight scene overall fast paced

Luhrmann's Movie Version of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

1089 words - 4 pages Luhrmann's Movie Version of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet All hopeless romantics get dreamy-eyed and sigh whenever the balcony scene from Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet comes up in conversation. Juliet stands on her balcony, innocently murmuring about her meeting with Romeo while the very subject of her musings eagerly climbs the garden wall and trellis leading up to the object of his love, Juliet. Anyone viewing Luhrmann's Romeo

Baz Luhrmann's Film Adaptation of Romeo and Juliet

1621 words - 6 pages Baz Luhrmann's Film Adaptation of Romeo and Juliet Shakespeare's use of language reflects the theatre of his day. There were no elaborate set designs, costumes, lighting or sound effects and there were also only a small number of actors playing many different parts. This could get confusing and therefore the language and imagery had to do all the work for the audience, as the words were the only tools available to help

Baz Luhrmann's Modern Version Of Romeo and Juliet

1356 words - 5 pages Baz Lurhmann’s creation of the film Romeo and Juliet has shown that today’s audience can still understand and appreciate William Shakespeare. Typically, when a modern audience think of Shakespeare, they immediately think it will be boring, yet Lurhmann successfully rejuvenates Romeo and Juliet. In his film production he uses a number of different cinematic techniques, costumes and a formidably enjoyable soundtrack; yet changes not one word from

Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" and Baz Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet"

1167 words - 5 pages . Mercutio overlooks these two foes fighting it out, and decides to step in. Mercutio steps in to protect his friend, Romeo, from the dangers of the villainous Tybalt Capulet. Unfortunately, Mercutio dies in both versions of Shakespeare's "The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet," never making it to the end of the story lines. However, Mercutio dies portrayed as a hero in Luhrmann's portrayal of "Romeo and Juliet," by attempting to save Romeo from Tybalt

Romeo & Juliet Benvolio vs Tybalt

884 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare's Romeo & Juliet, Benvolio and Tybalt are portrayed as characters with distinctly opposing personalities that is apparent in many different instances throughout the play. Romeo's best friend, Benvolio is depicted as the classic nice guy, incorporating all the personalities necessary to be one. He is calm, patient, an advocate of peace between the two rival families, and always viewing the cup as half full instead of half

Similar Essays

The Effectiveness Of Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet

1168 words - 5 pages The Effectiveness of Baz Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet Baz Lurhmann's modern version of Romeo and Juliet is very effective because it relates to a younger audience which makes it more appealing to watch. The audience can tell it is more modern e.g. there are cars, skyscrapers, guns, televisions and music. The characters clothes tell the audience that this film is modern. At the start of the film it shows a television

The Opening Of Baz Luhrmann's William Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

1086 words - 4 pages The Opening of Baz Luhrmann's William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet The opening of a film can make or break it - it is a vital factor determining whether or not the audience will want to watch the rest of the film. It must capture the audience's attention and imagination, be striking and introduce main characters and plotlines in an interesting way. The opening of Baz Luhrmann's 'William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet

Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet Essay

857 words - 3 pages Baz Luhrmann's ROMEO AND JULIET William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, a classic tale of rebellious youth and a pair of star-crossed, doomed lovers from feuding families, is giving a new dimension under film director Baz Luhrmann. Luhrmann inventively updated it to the blighted wasteland of Verona Beach, where Shakespeare's tragedy is set against a background of contemporary teenage street gangs and violence. The link between the society then

Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet Essay

909 words - 4 pages effectively captured and enhanced in this modern-day appropriation by the use of settings, props, editing, characterisation and filmic techniques.Baz Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet opens and concludes with the camera slowly zooming in and out on a television featuring a female newsreader reading the prologue and epilogue as an introduction and conclusion to the film. This emphasises the modern context and currency of the setting. A sudden explosion of