This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Anti Federalists’ Representation Of People Essay

1680 words - 7 pages

The Anti-Federalists had many views that were different than those of the Federalists. One the differences that seems to be important, is who they view as “The people”. The Anti-Federalists believed that common people should be able to be active participants of their government; this involvement includes having a say in the laws that are made and the protection of everyday working class people. This common man involvement is reinforced by the fact that the Anti-Federalists wanted to keep government more local, by having strong state governments. Using Rogers Smith’s Civic Ideals as a foundation, this essay illustrates that the view of the Anti-Federalists is that the United States of America is combined of many different people, and that representation should be based on these differences rather than just the elite population.
In the late 1780s there where a variety of men that would need to be represented by the government. These men included everyone from aristocratic land owners, to merchants, to hard laborers. The Anti-Federalists knew that all of these men needed to be represented in the government so that there were no laws made with the intention to harm a certain group’s way of life. In Federal Farmer Letter VII it is said that “Each order must have a share in the business of legislation actually and efficiently” (Hammond 559). By each class of men having an active role in their government, a process is created to able to prevent one class from overruling others for their own benefit. This is important to the Anti-Federalists because they think that each type of man should be considered equal. This hunger for equality leads us to see that the Anti-Federalists believe that all men should be able to be part of government without having to qualify based on where they stand economically. For this system of multiple classes to work, the different groups of men would have had to learn to compromise with each other.
To make laws that are good for the American society as a whole, it is important for the people to work together between the social classes. This means that aristocrats that own large expanses of land and hard laborers who own small estates should have the same amount of power in government. The Anti-Federalists believed that the representatives should represent all men, including the men of the lesser classes. In Brutus Essay II it is apparent that the Anti-Federalists see the need for representatives to show diversity. It states “If we may collect the sentiments of the people of America… they hold this truth as self-evident, that all men are by nature free. No one man, therefore, or any class of men, have a right, by the law of nature, or of God, to assume or exercise authority over their fellows” (Hammond 539). This statement shows that the Anti-Federalists did not want one class of people, such as elite aristocrats, to run the government. If only one league of men controlled the government, it would soon become tyrannical. The...

Find Another Essay On The Anti-Federalists’ Representation of People

Federalists vs. Anti-Federalists: The differences between Federalists and Anti-Federalists after America broke away from GB

633 words - 3 pages After America finally broke away from Great Britain, a new system of government was needed to maintain order and protect the rights of the people. Naturally, not everyone agreed on how this should be done, and two groups arose with opposing points of view on how the new American government should be run. These groups were the Federalists and Anti-federalists. The Federalists were in favor of a strong central (federal) government, while the Anti

The over representation of aboriginal people within the Canadian Criminal

2313 words - 9 pages The over representation of aboriginal people within the Canadian Criminal Justice system is a clear indication of how the justice system has failed aboriginal people in Canada. The plethora of aboriginal individuals who populate the penitentiaries and jails in Canada shows that there must be changes made within the Canadian justice system. By bringing in the aboriginal peoples traditional ways of life and incorporate it within the Canadian

The Over-representation of Black People in UK Prisons

3366 words - 13 pages The over-representation of black people in the UK prison population became an issue which needs to be addressed. The prison statistics shows that black people are over-represented and by analysing their population in the UK and a prison statistics it can be noticed that their number increases massively comparing to white and Asian people. The statistics focuses on adult male population, but by considering women and young black people, the

Representation of the Indigenous

2885 words - 12 pages tribal culture. Flaherty’s film tries to uncover and provide truths about this group of people, but he brings into question problems regarding the representation of the tribe in ethnographic documentary films. Comparing Robert Flaherty’s films and his second feature length film “Moana” to Bruce Parry’s Documentary series on BBC entitled “Tribe” I will attempt to bridge the gap and discuss the evolution of documentary starting from the birth of the

The Causes of the Revolutionary War - Viewpoints of federalists, antifederalists

1819 words - 7 pages strongly the colonies opposed the Tea Act. Britain did not think likewise. They believed that the people of Boston should be punished so they passed the Coercive Acts as Britain called it, but they were so harsh, the colonists called them the Intolerable Acts. One of the acts would close to port of Boston until the colonists paid for the destroyed tea. Others banned the committees of correspondence; groups that exchanged letters throughout

Changes and Sacrifices of the Democratic-Republicans and the Federalists

2012 words - 9 pages , especially if new states are admitted westward. Those new states would have to be agrarian states, since most states with an economy based on trade were located on the coast. The Bill of Rights were originally created for the content of Anti-Federalists as well, and here the Federalist are using it to weaken the federal government; however, they wished to weaken the federal government in order to preserve their party and their trade and commerce. The

What in your view was the short term significance of the 1918 Representation of the People Act?

1851 words - 8 pages The Representation of the People Act of 1918 is often seen to be the start of female suffrage in Great Britain. This bill was passed by the House of Commons with 385 votes for the act, challenged against by a small majority of only 55. This surprised the Suffragettes as well as a number of other suffragist movements greatly as they did not expect this much support from any form of government. The 1918 Representation of the People Act finally

The Representation of The Media

1891 words - 8 pages representation of truth in a way the public sees it as being comprehensive and not ratings driven. Improves there own reputation and hence ratings since more people would watch.The episode featured on 18/06/02 can be seen doing just that, using many techniques to provide a clear representation of the truth. From the start we see a visually strong starting feature with stirring vision of world events with dramatic music accompanying. We then view a man

The Concept of Political Representation

2773 words - 12 pages representation include Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Thomas Hobbes discussed the concept of “implied agreement” in his book, Leviathan, in 1651. He argued that people agreed to give absolute power to a sovereign, who would then be responsible for making and enforcing laws in order to ensure a peaceful society (Hobbes 1996). Hanna Pitkin (1967) stated in her work that Hobbes clarified the central feature of modern

Representation of the Green Knight

813 words - 4 pages summer and winter seasons. It was said that once the seasons begin to change, the brother of the passing season is required to sacrifice themselves in order for the other brother’s season to strive. This myth connects the Green Knight with the “Holly King”. While sharing similar traits, the Green Knight and “Holly king” show possible relations, even proposing that they are the same people. The holly held in the Green Knight’s hand, shows the

The Representation of Nature and

1098 words - 5 pages of the difficult parts of Phoenix’s journey. She could have stopped right at the creek, but she did not. She was determined to conquer every obstacle along her path. Nature represents the cruelties and hardships in life that people face daily. Phoenix traveled “up through pines” and “down through oaks” (260). Going uphill through pines and then downhill through oaks foreshadows that there will be difficulties at the beginning and through the

Similar Essays

Beliefs Of The Anti Federalists Essay

753 words - 3 pages The name, Anti-Federalists is not the best-suited name for what they truly are, or what they believe in. “They are called the Anti-Federalists, but it should be made clear at once that they were not Anti-Federal at all.” (Main xi) Originally, the word federalist, meant anyone who supported the Articles of Confederation. The term “Anti-Federalist” was placed on them to portray them as people who did not agree with the Federal Government, which

The Anti Federalists Essay

985 words - 4 pages , therefore, only the States could grant powers to a federal government. The Anti-Federalists wanted a small republican government that relied upon the virtue and participation of the citizens. They argued that only a small republic could produce the voluntary obedience of the people to submit to the authority of the new government and its laws. The Federalist believed a republic, in the truest sense, could not exist in a post commercial

The Federalists Vs. The Anti Federalists Essay

802 words - 3 pages division between the American people. These two groups were the federalists, who believed that the constitution was good, and the anti-federalists who thought that the constitution would not be able to protect the rights of the people. These two groups had conflicting views but together, they both wanted the same thing. The same thing was that America should be controlled by the people by the principles of federalism. Both

The Framers: Federalists And Anti Federalists Essay

650 words - 3 pages duties should continue to be left to each state's own discretion, so that there would be no misrepresentation of the people it governed. It's left to say that neither side saw eye to eye, but would eventually reach a "compromise", the Federalists would institute their version of the Constitution which had a clear notion of Central Government and it's duties. The Anti-Federalists would receive an additional amendment to the Constitution (The Bill