The Aquatic Ape Hypothesis (Aah) Essay

2690 words - 11 pages

Evolution and natural selection, two of the most influential scientific discoveries in biology to date, capable of unlocking our past and answering questions of how we became the way we are. However, our understanding of human evolution is hindered when pseudoscientific ideas refuses to yield to legitimate theories. One such idea is the aquatic ape hypothesis (AAH) which attempts to explain a number of human adaptations with the single explanation of a semi-aquatic ancestor. Proponents use incorrect “facts” and logical fallacies such as straw men, appeals to authority, and false comparison in their arguments. The idea appears intuitive and is easily communicated, allowing it to be picked up by a general public and survive for fifty years, making noise and begging to be let into the big kids pool.
On March 5th 1960, respected marine biologist Sir Alister Hardy presented his idea that mankind may have evolved from a “more aquatic ape-like ancestor” (Hardy 1960:642) to the British Sub-Aqua Club, a non-scientific audience. His idea was picked up by the public press and generated immediate controversy in the paleoanthropology community. Hardy was surprised by the attention and sought to correct misleading reports by publishing an explanation of his speech, and thus the aquatic ape hypothesis (AAH) took its' first strokes out into the world (Ellis 2011). Elaine Morgan picked up the reigns in 1972 and championed the theory until her death in July 2013 (Williamson 2013). Morgan's publications updated Hardy's idea and brought the AAH greater recognition from the public but failed to earn the respect of academia.
The AHH suggests that food shortages and predators forced a branch of our primitive ancestors out of the trees and into the shallows. Examples of animals who have evolutionary histories of moving from land into water - whales, polar bears, penguins, turtles - provide plausibility to the idea. Advocates of the AAH argue that humans' ability to swim well compared to other terrestrial mammals, patterns in body hair, our subcutaneous fat layer, and even bipedalism are products of our past aquatic adaptations. Humans then moved to the plains once we learned to use tools that enabled us to outcompete other terrestrial animals, but retained the adaptations we had gained during our time in the water (Ellis 2011; Hardy 1960; Langdon 1997).
Proponents sometimes use the title aquatic ape theory, rather then hypothesis, suggesting greater credibility. However, the idea simply does not have the evidence to be considered a scientific theory. The AAH is still just as it was in 1960, “only a speculation - an hypothesis to be discussed and tested against further lines of evidence” (Hardy 1960:645).
The AAH is considered an umbrella hypothesis, meaning it appears to answer many questions with one simple solution. Morgan brags that it accounts “for more of the difference between man and the other primates than does any alternative theory”...

Find Another Essay On The Aquatic Ape Hypothesis (AAH)

" Sunset on the Savanna" by James Shreeve, Discover, July 1996, pp.116-125.

616 words - 2 pages Summary PaperSunset on the Savanna"Why do we walk? For decades anthropologists said that we became bipedalto survive on the African savanna. But a slew of new fossils have destroyed thatappealing notion and left researchers groping for a new paradigm."Sunset on the Savanna, James Shreeve, Discover, July 1996, pp.116-125.It has generally been thought that it was the shift from life in the forest to life in an open habitat that set the ape apart

Animal Behavior Lab Report

1194 words - 5 pages migrate to dark areas. Our hypothesis for the second task stated that the sowbugs would exhibit hydrotactic by migrating to wet areas. Our final hypothesis stated that sowbugs preferred a light/wet area to a dark/dry area. Research shows that sowbugs tend to favor wet environments over dry environments. Sowbugs are also known to be in the order Isopoda, which are the only widespread crustacean to successfully transform from an aquatic lifestyle to

Extra Credit Lecture

842 words - 4 pages is believed that a more complex toolkit is required in order to hunt moving or mobile animals. In addition, some environments, such as an aquatic environment, require more complex toolkits than terrestrial environments. The Risk hypothesis involves the risk of resource failure and the increasing complexity of task-specific tools compared to multi-task tools. The Mobility hypothesis basically states that the structure of the toolkit is limited by

Algae Research

1195 words - 5 pages Year 10 Extension Science - The Impact of Ph Levels on the Growth of AlgaeNicholas ParaskevasBackground:An alga is a simple form of plant life that thrives in a wide range of habitats due to its high adaptability. Algae are generally defined as a single celled plant that has the ability to use photosynthesis. Algae are predominantly aquatic organisms; however species do exist that reside in terrestrial habitats. These simple organisms do not

How Bipedalism Arose

1666 words - 7 pages taken those first steps, humanity might not have evolved into the modern societies that currently exist. Although there may never be absolute evidence of why Hominids took those first crucial steps, evidence does suggest that human evolution went through many changes in order to make bipedalism the efficient way to travel. Bipedalism is the defining human characteristic that separates man from his early ape ancestors. Before the first Hominid stood

rainbows

1536 words - 6 pages animal species. To judge the sustainability of the two environments, their surroundings had to be observed. We had to look for clues that identified whether or not the ecosystems had a sufficient amount of living and non-living organisms to survive. Last but not least, we observed how much human beings have affected the natural environment, what they have taken away or what damages they have left behind. Our hypothesis with respect to habitats

Articles Review: Novelty Makes the Heart Grow Fonder and The Man Who Bottled Evolution

635 words - 3 pages The research article “Novelty Makes the Heart Grow Fonder” by Jeffrey S. Mckinnon and Maria R. Servedio provides clear evidence on the male guppies effect. The study used a hypothesis that aimed to explain the maintenance of variation of mate choice in guppies. The researchers conducted the experiment on guppies, little fishes, which are some of the numerous aquatic species. The male species, popular as poecilia reticulate, have color variation

What are the Effects of Acid Rain on Germination?

1242 words - 5 pages warn people that acid rain can affect� seed germination.� Perhaps will show people that they need to reduce the amount of acid that is released into the atmosphere. � HYPOTHESIS My hypothesis is that the percentage of seeds that germinate will decrease as the amount of acid added to the water during germination time increases. I base my hypothesis on the following quote from Microsoft Encarta 98: "Forest lakes, ponds, and other

Mysteries of the World

881 words - 4 pages as for the pictures, scientists say they are not lucid enough to distinguish items clearly, and some pictures are dubbed as "fake". A large number of non-scientists believe however, that the Loch Ness is the site of a breeding colony of large unknown aquatic animals, due to the fact that Loch Ness was once an arm of the sea. Yearly summer investigations have been conducted since 1963 in attempt to unravel the mystery. Investigators have obtained

The Role of Competition and Predation in Ecology

630 words - 3 pages many aquatic species of algae and zooplankton. It has been found that predation from zooplankton can control the density of algae is lakes but it has little effect on the blue green algae blooms caused by excess nutrients (Carpenter et al, 1995). The density of predators was directly correlated to the presence of edible algae or non edible algae (Carpenter et al, 1995). Further studies need to be done to determine the sustainability of green

Guppy Mate Preference

726 words - 3 pages aquatic plant life) to a pond setting with an orange tint (same setting with an orange cellophane overlay) we wondered if we would be able to sway the females mate choice? The reasoning that took us down this path was the fact that color is a determining factor in mate selection, in many types of species' (Ligon 2001). Since color is a determining factor in mate selection we thought that if we could change the background environment to a bright

Similar Essays

Solution Paper

2411 words - 10 pages animals living in this area are covered in hair and walk on four legs. None of these adaptations are seen in humans. The Aquatic Ape Theory of evolution states that humans evolved from the sea and had an aquatic era. Basically, it is the idea that our ancestors were trapped in a semi-aquatic environment and over time, altering their bodies to be more effective in the water. Physiologically speaking, our features are rare in comparison to land

Solution Paper

2411 words - 10 pages animals living in this area are covered in hair and walk on four legs. None of these adaptations are seen in humans. The Aquatic Ape Theory of evolution states that humans evolved from the sea and had an aquatic era. Basically, it is the idea that our ancestors were trapped in a semi-aquatic environment and over time, altering their bodies to be more effective in the water. Physiologically speaking, our features are rare in comparison to land

Homo Aquaticus? Essay

1832 words - 7 pages believe that the differences between human and ape brains are shown through man's ability to use tools and language. This traditional view cannot explain why only human ancestors developed these motor skills and language abilities, that is, why nonhuman primates and other savannah mammals didn't develop these abilities. The solution may lie in the aquatic theory of human evolution, the theory that explains why humans don't have fur, and why we

The Effect Of The Presence Of Light On The Amount Of Co2 Produced By A Plant

1041 words - 4 pages beakers under sunlight imitating lamps during dark hours) there would be more consistent data. As well as a 24-hour experiment, there could be more replicates for consistency, this way a more true average can be taken. In this experiment the aquatic plant Elodea (which the experiment was designed for) was replaced by an inexpensive aquatic plant. In another experiment, testing the same hypothesis, the Elodea plant or another aquatic plant could