This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis

1591 words - 6 pages

The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis

An old adage says, “In quarreling, the truth is always lost,” (Bolander, 1987). The truth is often considered subjective; it depends on circumstances, time, and many other variables. We understand that what is truth to one may not be truth to another, and after reading Dr. Tannen’s work, I realized that she has done exactly what she said exacerbates the argumentative culture we live in today. She has looked at only two sides. Due to this, I would call into question Dr. Tannen’s truthfulness in her book The Argument Culture. Tannen has successfully shown this attitude in our culture but her arguments and writing style force one to conclude that there is a lack personal credibility.
Dr. Deborah Tannen’s thesis, “we have plunged headfirst into what I call the ‘argument culture,” (Tannen, 1998) in her book The Argument Culture, is intended to pique one’s curiosity. Upon reading Dr. Tannen’s work I soon found myself nodding my head in agreement. How can one not agree that our society is not the pillar of chivalry it once was? After fulfilling the requirements for our last session, I find myself questioning Dr. Tannen’s work a little more. I agree that our society has been inundated with a lack of courtesy from all areas. However, I doubt that this is a new condition. Ms. Tannen has brought to the forefront of our minds the condition that our society is in, and is challenging us to change.
Dr. Tannen initially appears to do an excellent job of establishing her credibility through stories. She used examples from public arenas, such as the Holocaust debaters she refers to in The Argument Culture (Tannen, 1998), as well as her interview with National Public Radio (NPR, 1998). She used an example of her father-in-law’s reaction to dinner time solicitors (Tannen, 1998). She also used an example of how this attitude is displayed in the political arena from political nominations to partisanship gridlock (NPR, 1998).
Tannen says she has researched the origin of our aggressive society and found that it lies with the seminaries of the Middle Ages. She told Daniel Zwerdling of NPR, “They were seminaries. And all the people who went to those universities who were not getting educated so that they could learn the truth. They were learning to debate. It was the public performance of debate that was the goal,” (NPR, 1998). She says, “The roots of our love for ritualized opposition lie in the educational system that we all pass through,” (Tannen, 1998). Tannen completely disregards the aggressive ancient societies and turns a blind eye to history. She never once mentions an aggressive and contentious society being problematic for England or France, which is where the seminaries would have been located in the Middle Ages. This forces one to begin to question her credibility.
In order to look at a differing opinion, Dr. Tannen acknowledges that there are appropriate times for antagonistic...

Find Another Essay On The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis

Rhetorical Analysis: “The Real Scandal”

1543 words - 6 pages ). Just from the subject matter and timing of the “The Real Scandal” alone, the article was poised for a meaningful and persuasive entrance into the debate, a testament to the authors’ skillful use of kairos. All in all, the authors of “The Real Scandal” combine multiple rhetorical devices in order to create a logical and persuasive argument against the use of performance-enhancing drugs. By first appealing to readers emotionally, paying particular

Rhetorical Analysis of The Declaration of Independence

875 words - 4 pages audience that the colonies deserved their independence.Works CitedGibaldi, Joseph. MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers. New York: The ModernLanguage Association of America, 2009. Print."Rhetorical Analysis: Declaration of Independence." Blog at Word Press.com. The Twenty TenTheme, 1 Oct. 2012. Web. 26 Oct. 2014.

Rhetorical analysis of The Killer Instinct

1061 words - 5 pages Rhetorical analysis of "The Killer Instinct" (January 2000) "The Killer Instinct" is an article published in "A Monthly Journal of Religion & Public Life by Institute on Religion & Public life" in January 2000. This journal, which started from 1998, contains various articles with opinions, arguments, debates and commentary on religious and moral questions, and social issues going in American society. Thomas Sally, a poet and a writer

State of the Union Rhetorical Analysis

745 words - 3 pages In his “State of the Union” speech, President Barack Obama effectively uses the rhetorical devices of Ethos, Pathos and Logos to convey a more convincing message to the citizens of the United States to urge them to follow the example of the many people that have made their nation greater. Perhaps one of the most notable devices used is Logos, Obama does not speak of the state of the nation without calling out numbers and statistics of the

The Audacity of Hope: A Rhetorical Analysis

2079 words - 8 pages core political and spiritual beliefs, as well as his opinions on different aspects of American culture. The Illinois senator divided the book into nine chapters, each concentrating on both his own and the United States’ successes and failures in local and state politics. While revealing great leadership attributes, life experiences, personal qualities and hard facts, largely in anecdotal method, Barack Obama offers realistic, wide and thoughtful

The Rhetorical Analysis of Writing in the Accounting Profession

1876 words - 8 pages Running head: WRITING IN ACCOUNTING 1WRITING IN ACCOUNTINGTHE RHETORICAL ANALYSIS OF WRITING IN THE ACCOUNTING PROFESSIONAbstractThe techniques and writing styles used within the accounting profession. The accounting field requires a lot of data gathering and responding to that data in the form of formal responses in APA formatting. The paper is constructed into five paragraphs: introduction, formatting in writing, logos in writing, ethos in

Analysis of the rhetorical choices in political speeches

916 words - 4 pages little to no value, and purpose within a few months. The question is who’s responsible when impulse purchases are made, the ear and eye catching advertisment claims full of verbal jargon or is the responsibility solely on open walleted consumers? This is the argument between William Lutz, an author and Rutgers University English professor, and Charles A. O’Neill a marketing and advertising consultant. Both authors construct their articles in

A Rhetorical Analysis of “The Death of Honesty”

1078 words - 4 pages apart,” and that society expects all parties to participate with honest intentions (par. 5). He continues to build on his argument by alluding to historical references including the Roman goddess, Veritas, Confucius, and the Bible’s Old Testament, as well as, Abe Lincoln, and George Washington as examples of honesty (par. 6). He notes that current political, legal, journalistic, and business leaders are routinely dishonest, and see nothing wrong

Rhetorical Analysis of the Movie Thank You for Smoking

1129 words - 5 pages flips the table around on Ron Goode, the spokesman of the senator of Vermont who was present in defense of anti-smoking .In his argument ,he states that “the Ron Goodes of this world... want the Robin Willigers to die,” only so “that their budgets will go up.” He strategically diverts the issue from teen smoking and makes it about money making the government appear as the traitor who is trafficking in human misery and profiting from citizens who die

Rhetorical Analysis of The Talking Heads’ “Once in a Lifetime”

1896 words - 8 pages Rhetorical Analysis of The Talking Heads’ “Once in a Lifetime” Kenneth Burke’s Five Master Terms exist to bring to light the motivation behind, theoretically, any bit of text to which we care to apply them. The beauty of this Pentad is its fundamentality in regards to the motivations humans have in creating words and meaning using the tools of language available. This doesn’t just apply to long-winded theses regarding the

‘We Shall Fight on the Beaches’- A Rhetorical Analysis

1913 words - 8 pages ‘We Shall Fight on the Beaches’- A Rhetorical Analysis I have, myself, full confidence that if all do their duty, if nothing is neglected, and if the best arrangements are made, as they are being made, we shall prove ourselves once again able to defend our Island home, to ride out the storm of war, and to outlive the menace of tyranny, if necessary for years, if necessary alone. –Sir Winston Churchill, ‘ We Shall Fight on the Beaches

Similar Essays

Rhetorical Analysis: The Argument Culture

1659 words - 7 pages pathos her own. So through this rhetorical analysis, I will observe and analyze her writing structure, what is the point that she wants to tell readers and what is her main skills among three Aristotle’s persuasion skills. Deborah Tannen, the author of “The Argument Culture”, is good at persuading persons. She persuades readers, pointing problems of tradition debate that most people following without thinking by properly using Aristotle’s three

Rhetorical Appeals And Ethical Argument Analysis

1668 words - 7 pages Rhetorical Appeals and Ethical Argument “The Word “Nigga” Is Only for Slaves and Sambos” was written by Rob Nelson and first published in a university newspaper in North Carolina. Later on, the article was so meaningful that it was re-published in the academic journal, the Journal of Blacks in Higher Education. In the article “The Word “Nigga” is only for Slaves and Sambos”, Rob Nelson uses ethos, logos, and especially skillful pathos appeals

Rough Draft: Argument Essay Rhetorical Analysis/Evaluation

752 words - 4 pages John Marsh, Ph.D., shares his epiphany, that his sharing the popular belief that higher education was the answer to bringing about economic equality and curing poverty, was in fact wrong; in this short selection, “Why Education Is Not an Economic Panacea”, taken from his book, “Class Dismissed: Why We Cannot Teach or Learn Our Way Out of Inequality”. Marsh had felt that gaining a higher education himself worked to bring him to a level of

The Argument Analysis

803 words - 4 pages , makes readers consider the achievements of the opposite parties, thus successfully establishing common ground. Before Scandizzo describes the contrasting narrative, he first establishes with his readers the same understanding about the “rhetorical nature” of narrative (408). This is effective because he correctly assumes that his readers have opposing views about agriculture, thus having a different understanding about the nature of narratives