The Argumentative Indian Essay

986 words - 4 pages ✓ Expert Reviewed
VIEW DOCUMENT
Preview

According to the Indian dialect ‘Hindi’, a dialogue could be of three types: a 'vaad', i.e. a discussion seeking to reach the truth between the proponent and the opponent's view; a 'vivaad' i.e. an argument seeking to push one's point of view over that held by the other; and lastly, a 'vitandavaad', which solely seeks to raze the opposing views, while offering them no other alternative system. In that sense, the book, “The Argumentative Indian” written by Dr. Amartya Sen, the Nobel laureate has been very appropriately titled and that through this he has unwittingly revealed his own views. The way the book moves ahead, are thoughts of an argumentative individual – propagating his own views but not searching for the truth.
This book discusses the journey of India from its history to the present identity in terms of the cultural traditions related to public debate that has impacted several aspects of the nation be it in terms of culture and other forms of diversity. The book consists of four sections having four essays each, "Voice and Heterodoxy", "Culture and Communication", "Politics and Protest" and “Reason and Identity" through which it tries to argue about the success of Indian democracy, secularism and politics, demographic inequalities in the community.
In the first section the author takes a trip through the general culture of pluralistic debate that existed within India, from that of Buddha to that dating back till the king Asoka. Sen describes on an affirmative note of how argumentative nature of the Indians could and in reality has led towards raising the voices of the minorities. He continues by stating that “the demands of justice in India are also demands for more use of voice in the pursuit of equity. The argumentative heritage is an important asset to the Indian people.” He describes that raising voices against injustice has always been important, adding to it that “silence is the biggest enemy of justice.” In the second section he makes an attempt to restore Rabindranath Tagore as an intellectual, through combining political and spiritual ideas, while also exploring the country’s cultural relationship with that of the West and China. The third section looks at the inequalities present in the Indian society and the conflicts arising as a result of that. Sen again precisely tries to skewer the illogicalities and inequities inherent in the discrimination against women, low castes and the poor endemic in Indian society. He shows how these factors are deeply interrelated not only with each other but also with factors such as religion and ethnicity. The same techniques go on to show how ill-served India has been at its nuclear bomb testing program and in the foolishness of allowing religious extremism.
Ultimately, the book closes down with an exploration of modern cultures of liberalism and secularism that has been in existence with regards to the Indian context. Further ahead, with incisive wit and logic, he expresses his...

Find Another Essay On The Argumentative Indian

Githa Hariharan’S The Thousand Faces Of Night

2209 words - 9 pages , Nayatara. Rich like Us. Harpercollins: New Delhi. 2010. Sahgal. Sen, Amartya. The Argumentative Indian: writings on Indian Culture, History and Identity. London: Penguin Books. 2005. 210. Sengari, Kumkum and Vaid, Sudesh (eds). Recasting Women: Essays in Indian Colonial History. Kali for women: New Delhi. 1989. 17. Shah, Shalini. Poetesses in Classical Sanskrit Literature. Indian Journal of Gender Studies. Volume: 15, Number 1.2008:04. Spivak...

The Hybridist Limit Transgression Of Anzaldua

757 words - 3 pages third paragraph, tells the reader how, when she tells stories, she "learned to give [them in] installments" (Geyh 184). It is not long after this that the story gets its first subheading (to pave the way for a new installment) "Invoking Art", and thus creates the illusion of an essay, and not a personal narrative. An essay - factual, persuasive, or argumentative - in some respect contradicts the very form of a typical narrative. The...

Characters And Themes In The Pearl

1576 words - 6 pages "¦"� (51). This shows that the characters have the same troubles as anyone else. Money is a known source of evil that Kino deals with like many people in actuality. Another example of the character's universal traits can be looked at through Juana. Juana is Kino's wife and mother to Coyotito. A typical Indian woman, Juana's main duties are to aid Kino and care for Coyotito. This can be seen after a...

Influence Of Society In Meena Kandasamy’S Social And Poetic Identity Reflected Inside Her Poetry

2646 words - 11 pages Shudra girl. And display, “the end product. It is a Brahmin” in a concluding step. Stating a pathetic condition of a dismal class, it records the gloomy predicament of the so-called lower class people of Indian society. It is a social document, a startling reality where gender identity and casteism take a shape of anger, protest and self-assertion in which she talks about the journey of becoming a Brahmin, by recording a hypocrisy of a society...

Not Mentioned

1209 words - 5 pages , lady, were no crime". Here he focuses his love for enjoying the present time.Tone-- they're the speaker's tone is logical development of argumentative tone.Conceit--The conceits of this poem are the Indian Ganges, flood, and conversion of Jews, tomb....I wouldLove you ten years before the Flood,and you should, if you please, refuseTill the ...

Love In To Their Coy Mistress, Shall I Compare Thee, Let Me Not, And Also The Flea

2905 words - 12 pages effective than just death because it is describing love until the end of the world. The “edge of doome” also defines love and pontificates it to the end of time. ‘Let Me Not’ is an imperative because it is a strong statement so just in the title it shows the poem will have argumentative qualities. The main purpose of ‘The Flea’ is for John Donne to persuade his mistress to consummate their relationship. This aim is shown in the first stanza...

civil military relations

1783 words - 7 pages India, during the Brass tacks exercises (a major military exercise of the Indian Army in Rajasthan state in India) held in July 1986, Indian Army Chief General Krishnaswamy Sundarji had planned to turn the exercise into an operation against Pakistan without the knowledge of the Prime Minister Rajiv Ghandi. However, despite these clashes, the military remains under the civilian control in high politically cultured societies due to public...

Media Change Analysis

1767 words - 7 pages manner necessary for the Internet news pages. 2) Tenor: Tenor3 is focusing on power relation (status) and alignment and affinity (contact). On other word, that is the relationship between addresser and addressee. For the power relation, rather and argumentative article, most of the media would like to express deference by favoring possibility as a modality (possibly, maybe may, might). For ordinary media, addressees’ contact normally are the...

Globalization And New World Order

1704 words - 7 pages order for mankind to reap the benefits of globalization, a stable economic, social, political and environmental policies, proper channels of communication and end of dominion of Core Countries is necessary. Globalization needs to be reformed in order to salvage it from becoming a dysfunctional ideology. Works Cited The Argumentative Indian, Amartya Sen, (Penguin, 2005) Key Ideas: Globalization, Malcolm Waters (Routledge...

Review: Asianising Singapore – The PAP's Management Of Ethnicity By Raj Vasil, Singapore: Heineman Asia, 1995

3591 words - 14 pages majority. Thus the city state derives a unique character from Chinese preponderance both of people and of enterprise and industry. The policy challenge in managing ethnicity, therefore, remains to ensure that dominant majority adheres to Singapore's founding principle of cultural democracy, thus treating its Malay and Indian compatriots as of equal worth. At independence in 1965, this had to be accomplished as part of setting up a new, sovereign ...

Gender Relations And Inequality In India

2320 words - 9 pages has witnessed gender inequality from its early history due to its socio-economic and religious practices that resulted in a wide gap between the position of men and women in the society. The origin of the Indian idea of appropriate female behavior can be traced to the rules laid down by Manu in 200 B.C.: "by a young girl, by a young woman, or even by an aged one, nothing must be done independently, even in her own house". "In childhood a female...

Other The Argumentative Indian Essays

Different Types Of Love In A Midsummer Night’S Dream

1568 words - 6 pages Love (Egeus and Hermia, Titania and Little Indian Boy), Friendly Love (Helena and Hermia, The Workmen), Unrequited Love (Helena and Demetrius), Official Love (Hermia and Demetrius), Argumentative Love (Oberon and Titania), Mad Sexual Love (Bottom and Titania),Passionate Love (Hermia and Lysander). Each type of love would be discussed to support the point that the play is full of different types of love. Parental...

The Three Phases Of The Development Of West Indies Cricket Since The Late Nineteenth Century

1594 words - 6 pages Caribbean there was always loyalty shown to the mother country. West Indian cricket adopted the same structure as the British political system by electing captains and the other members of the team also gave the captain the needed support. As Hilary Beckles mentioned "This bred honourable behaviour because team members would not let each other down on or off field...

Native American Relations Throughout The Seven Years War

1637 words - 7 pages colonies, and often times the more powerful nations were sought after by other tribes in addition to the European powers. In the southeast, “the Creeks were important not only to the white men… but also to other Indian tribes” (Indian Affairs in GA, p. 97). During the beginning of the war, the English had the upper hand with Indian Affairs in the Eastern area of North America. Many groups in the South East were able to work with the Creeks and...

Arturo Islas' Migrant Souls: The Lonely Effects Of Assimilation

1189 words - 5 pages The Lonely Effects of Assimilation The Europeans who claimed what was to become America chose to integrate the land's present inhabitants and future immigrants in order to become the dominating race and, consequently, made other cultures feel inferior to their own. The Angel family, Mexican-Indian immigrants and the subject of Arturo Islas' Migrant Souls, becomes victim to the Americans' forceful demands for conformity. While Sancho, the...