The Aria Of War: Justifications For The Pursuit Of National Security At Any Price

1715 words - 7 pages


The end of the Cold War and attacks of 9/11 dramatically altered the landscape of United States national security endeavors. Gone was the singular, nearly tactile threat as presented by a major superpower, and in its place was the “amorphous nature of a terrorist opponent,” (Snow, 2014, p. 112). This novel threat defied easy definition or identification, and attacked in ways to which the U.S. had grown unaccustomed. Phrases like “asymmetrical warfare” and “war on terror” were used liberally by an executive branch wholly unprepared for mitigating such a threat, and exploited to justify any number of means to achieve an end that as yet remains elusive. With the threat now subsiding, and certain means of statecraft and defense now thrust into the harsh light of public scrutiny, we are faced with questions of worth. Specifically, have the measures utilized in pursuit of national security been worth the human costs of moral ambiguity, privacy encroachment, and civil liberty infringement?

Moral Ambiguity and The Making of a POW

Inconsistent and convenient applications of the Geneva Conventions have been particularly highlighted in the delineation of prisoner of war (POW) status as it applies to terrorists. The Bush administration agreed that the Taliban were fighting for a state (Afghanistan), and as such would normally be accorded protections under the Geneva Conventions. However, they declared that both al Qaeda and Taliban fighters would, in fact, not be classified as POW’s. Because they deemed the war to be asymmetrical, they concluded they were not bound to the covenants regarding conventional war upon which the Conventions are drawn (Caseldine-Barcht, 2006, pp. 76,77). This accomplished a very important goal for the executive branch. By refusing to classify detainees as POW’s, the U.S. could interrogate prisoners far beyond the constraints of international laws. The Bush administration justified the overt inconsistency by again arguing that the “War on Terror is an unprecedented war,” (Caseldine-Bracht, 2006, p. 76). However this slanted definition brings up an important question. Even this is determined to be an “unprecedented war,” do the means of operating outside international law and norms justify the ends?

The advantage of selective application of the Convention lies in the ability for an administration to be able to justify certain activities that otherwise would be unlawful. Colin Powell attempted point out this inconsistency in his appeal to various executive branch leadership by stating, “The United States and international community have consistently held Afghanistan to its treaty obligations and identified it as a party to the Geneva Conventions” (Caseldine-Bracht, 2006, p. 77). Insinuations of hypocrisy aside, the use of prisons outside the United States failed to place the use of harsh interrogation techniques beyond American culpability (Lowenthal, 2012, p. 286). These extraterritorial arrests have...

Find Another Essay On The Aria of War: Justifications for the Pursuit of National Security at Any Price

The Pursuit of Knowledge at the Cost of Ethics

1175 words - 5 pages interactions; put more informally ethics are a construct of the collective conscious of any given society. As ethics are a construct of society across the globe there are different ethical codes in existence. Ethics are most often used to determine the morality of a given topic; to determine if the topic is acceptable to a specific society. For instance what is acceptable for teens to view in cinema is very different than what a toddler can view in

The Atomic Bomb: Necessary and Just. This essay delves into justifications for the use of Atomic Weaponry during the second World War

1533 words - 6 pages Japanese culture. They would have continued to fight until every last person on the island was deceased. 1 Therefore, I assert that the Atom Bomb was not only necessary to end the war in the Pacific, but also to save many innocent lives. There are justifications for both the negative side, which says the bomb was not needed to end WWII, and the affirmative side which holds with the validity of our actions at Hiroshima and Nagasaki.On April 12th, 1945

The USA PATRIOT Act of 2001: Need for National Security vs. Protection of Civil Liberties

1436 words - 6 pages In a post-September 11th America, it is not uncommon for the mentioning of the word “terrorist” to spark any number of emotions in its citizens. In response to activities such as the attacks on the World Trade Center, Pentagon, as well as the 2001 anthrax scares, Congress proposed the USA PATRIOT Act. Supporters of the Act cite the importance and immeasurable need for greater protection in terms of national security, which is the government’s

The pursuit of happiness

787 words - 4 pages Everyone’s lives are dependant upon the goals that they set for themselves. When one attains their goals it gives them pleasure and satisfaction, but so does the pursuit of one’s desires. While one is pursuing a goal, one is imagining the pleasure of attainment. Once one achieves the goal, the pleasure may not be as great as one had imagined. The pursuit of happiness is the way of life. It keeps people believing and having dreams and that

The Pursuit of Happiness

2171 words - 9 pages all citizens are aware of is the case of debt. As of 2011, Danny Dorling and Benjamin Henning quantify the United States' national debt at $14.3 trillion. As a result, the market is worrying that the shutdown is depressing economic growth. However, weak growth is good for bonds. In fact, even if the government fails to pay interest, it might not be bad for bonds. The resulting loss of liquidity and fear for the stability of the financial system

The Pursuit of Equality

1024 words - 5 pages Women have faced the subordination of their male counterparts since the beginning of time. They have endured some of the most dehumanizing violations of any persecuted group in history. Some dauntless women defied the cultural norms and stood up to these immoralities. For example, the Sitones, a society acknowledged by Cornelius Tacitus, were looked down upon in contempt as their matriarchal tendencies were viewed as “the measure of their

The Pursuit of Meaning

1573 words - 6 pages amount of money, property, or belongings will guarantee someone’s love for their own life. Overall, because of the way the modern world has evolved, the idea of happiness has been skewed with the idea that an abundance of perishable items will promote the ‘good life’. Yet, this is not the case when it comes to true joy. Unlike fake items, happiness cannot be measured in any form , nor can it be purchased at any extent. Additionally, the real emotion

The Effectiveness of the National Security Association (NSA)

2052 words - 8 pages the United States of America. The National Security Association was established on November 4, 1952 by President Harry Truman. This program helped break Japanese and German codes during World War Two (Frequently Asked Questions About NSA). The NSA stepped up their technology department and adapted to modern technology after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. This is effective because the government can intercept more information more

Descartes’ Arguments for the Existence of Body as Distinct from the Mind and His Justifications to Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia

1722 words - 7 pages , at least to Elisabeth, that the distinction Descartes draws between the mind and body is flawed, for if the soul were truly a separate and distinct substance, why should afflictions of the body, whether drunkenness, stress, or fevers, affect the ability to reason? The only way to explain the connection, for Elisabeth, is for the soul to be material as well. In her various letters she advances the solution of an extended soul, saying at first

Interpersonal Skill: The Cornerstone of Good Leadership at any Level

1071 words - 4 pages Interpersonal Skill: The Cornerstone of Good Leadership at any Level. In every organization there are managers at different levels. Front line managers interact every day with employees; leading teams at the deck plate level. Middle managers oversee the front line managers and report to the top managers who are responsible for the overall direction of a company and its future potential. According to Organizational Behavior by Griffin and

The Demands Of National Security Vs. Individual Rights

716 words - 3 pages must be done to protect them.Contention II: Government must provide for the safety of the society during war by further restricting rights. The highest obligation a government has is to provide the protection of its citizens, and certain rights that may be allowed in less vulnerable times may jeopardize national security during military conflict. Because new forces endanger the society, new measures must be taken to preserve societal order. Jean

Similar Essays

A College Education At Any Price

1160 words - 5 pages maximize the benefit of getting an education. If a student does not have an interest in seeking employment in some of those highly competitive companies, student must take a good consideration in attending community colleges and public universities. If in any case, students who do not qualify for financial aid and any form of grant, they would still be better off attending high ranking public universities such as UCLA, UC and other State

Role Of The National Cyberspace For American National Security

3032 words - 12 pages , UBS, SHS, BAT, CMD, and PIF. So, it is in a computer user's best interests to not even open any e-mail from a unknown sender or an e-mail with a file attached with more than one extension.Cyber security should be a high priority to our countries national defense, but it continues to seem like the United States government is not doing all that it can do to improve amaerica's cyber security. Scot Peterson wrote an article for eWeek titled, "Wanted

A Critical Analysis Of The Key National Security Issues Faced In The Post Vietnam War Period

630 words - 3 pages assessment of various sides of a single coin. The administrations of Nixon, Ford, and Carter inevitably faced many challenges especially since the national security policies of the US were questioned after the Vietnam War. However, it can also be said that these three presidents equally contributed for the development of approaches in dealing with national security issues.

Pursuit For The Meaning Of Life

779 words - 3 pages . In the second poem, however, images drawn from the speaker's experience with the pastoral world is everywhere. It is not easy to distinguish reality from dream. Since the speaker is for the most time in the state of unconsciousness .If we see the" apple-picking" as accomplishment and success or pursuit for the meaning of life, then obviously it is sweet at some point ,but the author also thinks it as "too much" . He recalls the details of the