The Articles Of Confederation And The Constitution Answer To A Former Dbq (Document Based Question)For An Ap Us History Class

942 words - 4 pages

Question: "From 1781 to 1789 the Articles of Confederation provided the Unites States with an effective government. Use the documents and your knowledge of the period to evaluate this statement."Although the Articles of Confederation provided a working government for the United States, it was not necessarily an effectively working government; an effective government would be one that not only establishes control and authority, but one under which the nation flourishes. Certainly the Articles set down a basic government with the idea of a democratic republic. However, the Articles of Confederation didn't impose an effective government as much as it set the basis for one. It was unable to enforce many laws and many of those set were also unequal in operation, as unfair to some states as fair to others. Thus, from 1781 to 1789, the Articles of Confederation established a working, yet ineffective government, with very little control or authority over foreign relations, the economy, and western lands.In foreign relations, the government set down by the Articles of Confederation had minimal, if any, control and authority over diplomatic efforts with Spain, France, Britain, and the foreign presences in America. One contributing factor to this was the lack of an executive branch. Congress was the chief coordinating agency of any war efforts and almost every action of meaning. During a disagreement over foreign policy, the argument could possibly have lasted for weeks with no decision or compromise set, leaving the problem standing unresolved. What authority Congress did have over commerce was shown in some unfair tariffs on foreign trade, that consequentially affected foreign relations. There was a marked decline in the estimated market of United States exports to Great Britain; in those, there was a definite per capita drop [Document B]. There was much difficulty with diplomatic efforts with other countries. For example, while negotiating a treaty with Spain that could have given America access to the Mississippi River, the Southern states refused to go along, with the result of the treaty negotiations and the Mississippi had to be given up [Document F]. In America itself, Congress was unable to enforce the Treaty of Paris. There were British troops still occupying some parts of America [Document D]. Since Congress could not directly assemble an army, there was no way to deal with the problem and the existing American troops were discontent with the government's failure to pay their wages [Document C]. Considering the state of foreign relations under the Articles of Confederation, the Louisiana Purchase wouldn't have been possible. The negotiations for the territory would have failed and Congress would have argued over the purchase of land long after the offer would have been voided. The difficulties in foreign relations were too much for the government set by the Articles of...

Find Another Essay On The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution - Answer to a former DBQ (Document Based Question)for an AP US History class

AP US History - Articles of Confederation

676 words - 3 pages *As the title indicates, this is an AP US History essay written for class. The basic gist of the topic was: To what extent were the Articles of Confederation successful.*Enlightenment idealism and political conflict served as a catalyst for war in the mid- and late-1700s. However, as vociferous as calls for freedom were, the effort for liberty was a disorganized one and stability was a problem during and after the American Revolution. The

The Constitution and The Articles of Confederation

950 words - 4 pages Bankrupt, and on her knees for solutions, America was in a state of distress. Politicians alike recognized that The Articles of Confederation, adopted in 1777, desperately needed revision as well as modification. Under the Articles, a Continental Congress had been shaped, which was allocated virtually no authority to collect revenue, handle domestic affairs, or control commercial trade. Shortly after the Revolutionary War, America

AP US History essay. Document Based Question Essay #4.

1148 words - 5 pages -Republicans received much criticism for this, and John Randolph declared that the present government was one of false Republican principles and the Democratic-Republicans were not being true to the beliefs they once held (Document F). But Jefferson, in his dialogue with Presbyterian minister Samuel Miller, demonstrated that the government would only be ruled by the Constitution, and not even God would have a say. Jefferson strongly opposed the idea of

Salutary Neglect - Detailed Outline for a Paper - Answer to a 1995 FRQ (Free Response Question) for a AP US History class.

718 words - 3 pages laws by repassing laws in a slightly altered form.« The Assemblies came to see them selves as miniature parliaments, sovereign over their colony.« American politicians question the right of Parliament to tax legislate for America in reaction to a British call for a return to salutary neglect and home rule.« The Indians/Mutiny Acts impose permanent military occupation - Americans continue to encroach on Indian land and resent

DBQ Articles of confederation

704 words - 3 pages government? No, due to the many overlooked flaws for example the unanimous votes needed to amend the articles and it's inability to regulate commerce. But the Articles were essential to the progress and creation of an effective government.. It was the first error in the trial-by-error policy. The articles helped political leaders realize the need for something better and in September the right answer came : The U.S. Constitution(draft).The Articles

DBQ: Articles of Confederation

583 words - 2 pages The Articles of Confederation provided the US with an effective government. Though, it was not a strong document, it satisfied the needs of the people. With a weak central government, the people were pleased, simply because they were used to the much more centrally based government of Great Britain. This weaker central government did not have total power in anything. The Articles did not allow the government to pass anything if the

Articles of Confederation DBQ

576 words - 2 pages In order to support and protect their newly-won freedoms, the Second Continental Congress proposed an Article of Confederation in 1777 to the thirteen colonies, and it was ratified by March 1, 1781. It has been said that these Articles provided the United States with an effective government from the time of its ratification until 1789, upon which time the current Constitution was widely accepted. It can certainly be said that it provided an

Articles of Confederation vs. the Constitution

839 words - 3 pages , Washington also states that "a liberal and energetic Constitution, well guarded and closely watched, to prevent encroachments, might restore [America] to that degree of respectability and consequence, to which [America] had a fair claim" (Document F). Rebellions were more likely to occur under the Articles of Confederation because it would be difficult for the states to raise an army in order to stop the rebellion. Additionally, it would be

Articles of Confederation v.s. The Constitution

1902 words - 8 pages While the country was just three years old, and was being governed by the weak Articles of Confederation, there were obvious disturbances calling for a new form of government. In 1786, a band of farmers rallied together under the Revolutionary War veteran Daniel Shay. The farmers believed that the Constitution of Massachusetts unfairly took away farmer's lands to settle the debts of the farmers. The rebels marched onto Springfield, Massachusetts

Articles of Confederation vs. The Constitution

1063 words - 4 pages required to win an election. If there were no majority, then the House of Representatives would cast one each for each state.In contrast to the Articles of Confederation, the Constitution would give more power to congress, set up a Supreme Court, the powers to tax, borrow and coin money, regulate commerce, and raise armed forces that the Confederation lacked. Furthermore, the Constitution and all national legislation were to be "the supreme law of

Comparing the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution

1402 words - 6 pages Amendments to the Constitution involve provisions for freedom is religion, speech,, press, assembly, and petition. Through the year 2000 the Constitution has been amended twenty seven times due to interminable needs by the people. Before the Constitution was framed, a weak central government had been established under the Articles of confederation. The Articles of Confederation were created when Richard Lee offered his resolution for independence

Similar Essays

Populism And The Jacksonian Democrats Answer To A Past Frq (Free Response Question) For An Ap Us History Class.

699 words - 3 pages should offer "equal protection and equal benefits" to all its white male citizens and favor no region of class over another. This meant an assault on what he considered the citadels of the eastern aristocracy and an effort to extend opportunities to the rising classes of the west and south. It also meant a firm commitment to the continuing subjugation of African Americans and Indians, keeping these "dangerous" elements from the politic body to keep

The Articles Of Confederation (A Document Based Question) (Documents Not Included)

1077 words - 4 pages , ending the revolt. Shay's Rebellion made people realize that a new, stronger central government was needed. (Stated by George Washington in document F)In the spring of 1787, delegates from twelve of the thirteen colonies arrived at Independence Hall, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, with intent to revise or replace the Articles of Confederation. Two plans for government surfaced during the drafting of the Constitution, the Virginia Plan and the New

The Us Constitution: A Radical Departure From Articles Of Confederation

635 words - 3 pages of powers. By dividing the government into three separate branches it would take total power away from anyone or group. Which also created a checks and balance system that would not allow any abuse of power by either of the branches. So that way it would be fair to everybody and there would be no drama!As you've read, both constitution and the articles of confederation are both very important documents in our country's history. Without it we wouldn't be where we are today. Now as you can see the constitution was more important than the articles of confederation. How do you think the constitution affected our country?

The Articles Of Confederation And The Us Constitution

1300 words - 5 pages leadership and had an inefficient legislature. The failure of the Articles of Confederation help the founders to create a more stable government system with the Constitution. The flaws in the Articles helped them make changes that made the new system very effective. Under the Constitution, Congress had a right to levy taxes (Feldmeth). This fixed the problem of the government always running short on funds because they could only request taxes