The Balance Of Power During The Great Italian Wars

1492 words - 6 pages

According to the school of realism in international politics, states operate in a type of system which has been dubbed the ‘balance of power.’ There are many definitions for it, but Morgenthau’s description of the theory as “an actual state of affairs in which power is distributed among several nations with approximate equality” sums it up well. While the term itself may be of the last few centuries, Hume writes that it “is founded so much on common sense and obvious reasoning, that it is impossible it could altogether have escaped antiquity.” That being said, the target region and period of time to be examined in this paper – the Great Italian Wars of 1494-1559 in Southern and Western Europe – is a prime example of balance of power politics because of the numerous alliance changes, as will be demonstrated below.
Before getting into the balancing policies, let us take a look at the key acting states during the warring period. Prior to the outbreak of the wars in 1494, the Italian city-states were enjoying a time of peace and prosperity thanks mostly to Lorenzo de Medici – the Magnificent – of Florence, who orchestrated peace between Florence, Naples and Milan to “curb the Venetians.” Once it had all begun, outside the Italian city-states (the Papal States, Ferrara and Genoa - amongst others – would have roles throughout), France and Spain were the main kingdoms at each other’s throats, with the Holy Roman Empire , and the Ottoman Empire all making appearances in the many separate wars.
The theory applies to this region mainly – as mentioned before – because of the many alliances formed and broken for the 63 years that “turned the Italian peninsula into the battleground of Europe.” The primary motor behind these alliances was one of the foundations of the balance of power theory in what Midlarsky dubbed as “the absence of alliance memory, making all other states potential allies or enemies, regardless of past friendships or hostility.”
Now, it is time to take a chronological look at the specific alliance changes throughout the whole time period, and to see if the balance of power hypotheses can be applied to them. The very first act of aggression that destroyed the peace Italy had enjoyed for a while was Lodovico Sforza’s (of Milan) appeal to Charles VIII of France to invade Naples in 1494, mainly because he feared that the “balance between the Italian states was shifting against him.” This was a clear demonstration of a small state trying to bandwagon with a larger one to advance its own goals (without taking any credit away from Charles VIII’s glory chase). However, once France had actually reached Naples, it provoked a reaction from the Italian city-states. Sforza – already regretting letting the French into Italy – realized the potential danger in allowing them to get too strong and decided to turn on them. The view was shared by the Borgia Pope, Alexander VI, the Venetians (oddly, since they were mostly against papal authority)...

Find Another Essay On The Balance of Power During the Great Italian Wars

The Balance Of Power Theory Essay

557 words - 2 pages The Balance of Power Theory The most critical and obvious feature of international affairs is its state of anarchy. The international stage features many indepent actors each seeking their own best interest and security . With no sovereign body to govern over these actors it would seem that the system would never be capable of attaining any control. However this is not the reality of the system, we have seen in history that it is possible to

The Balance of Power Theory Essay

607 words - 2 pages THE BALANCE OF POWER THEORY.The most critical and obvious feature of international affairs is its state of anarchy. The international stage features many indepent actors each seeking their own best interest and security . With no sovereign body to govern over these actors it would seem that the system would never be capable of attaining any control. However this is not the reality of the system, we have seen in history that it is possible to

The Balance of Power in the US

821 words - 3 pages , considered The Compromise of 1850 an end of the slavery debate. The provision admitting California as a free state shifted the balance of power in the Senate to the Free states. The balance of power in the senate, divided equally since the Missouri Compromise, now consisted of a majority of Free States. Additionally, the agreement called for popular sovereignty to decide the slave issue in future states. Texas received debt relief in exchange for land

Explain the development of surgery during the two world wars.

2074 words - 8 pages experiences laid a background for the subsequent advances in orthopaedics." (Wounded in Action). As it is clear on the veteran's quote, orthopaedic surgery developed to a great extent during the two world wars. Robert Jones is one of the surgeons who contributed to the significant development of orthopaedic surgery. During WWI, he was the director of Military Orthopaedics (Hagy). During his military service, he was able to reduce deaths caused by compound

The Balance of Power, capitalists and the proletariats.

871 words - 3 pages I cannot bring myself to believe that any of the problems we face in this day and age are the result of the world around us or any other specific factor we may tell ourselves play a role in the development of our shortcomings as far as our society is reflected as a whole. Instead of belying a scapegoat as we tend to so arrogantly do to allow us to sleep at night I say we look no further than ourselves.Yielding from the great and prosperous seeds

Why is the resistance of the South during the Italian liberation against the Germans during WWII ignored, or hardly remembered?

2017 words - 8 pages October 8th Armistice; On the 2nd of August 1943, in Mascalucia, Sicily, another small battle took place. Two Wehrmacht soldiers attempted robbery of two horses, provoking the rage of Italian soldiers. In this dispute, dozens of villagers and soldiers were lost from both sides. During the days after the armistice, there had been a record of opposition to the German forces by the people and soldiers united. These battles took place in the regions of

The Balance Of Nature

1621 words - 6 pages The Balance of Nature This paper will be about the balance of nature between plants and animals. It will also state how complex their ecosystems are. This paper will be informative in the areas of the balance of nature itself, plant and animal interactions, and changes in the ecosystem.Living things or organisms provide each other with substances necessary for life, and a proper balance between plants and animals is needed to maintain life (1, p

Explain the meaning and significance of the realist concept of the balance of power

2326 words - 9 pages an attempt by Moscow to tip the balance of power by positioning nuclear weapons closer to America. The establishment of a direct Teletype line between Moscow and Washington commonly known as the "hot line" agreement of June 20th 1963 was a sign of American and Soviet cooperation to reduce the risk of an accidental war. In 1969 the Soviets proposed Soviet- American negotiations for a reciprocal agreement to limit the reproduction of nuclear

A Shift in the Balance of Power Between the Generations and the Sexes Throughout Hobsons Choice

2047 words - 8 pages A Shift in the Balance of Power Between the Generations and the Sexes Throughout Hobsons Choice The stereotypical view of that period was that men had more power compared to women. Whether it was a father or a husband they had a more powerful status. The women were seen as the weaker sex and second class citizens this is portrayed by Jim, " a woman's foolishness begins where a mans leave's off." Women had a very

The Wars of Religion

1445 words - 6 pages century, extending into the seventeenth century, during a series of wars which would later on come to be called “the wars of religion.” But is this title completely appropriate? For wars claiming to be centered on religion, they seem to carry an awfully heavy load of political baggage. In fact, one could argue that the wars in France, the Netherlands, as well as in the Holy Roman Empire, had many more political influences than religious. Religion

The Italian

1430 words - 6 pages virtuous damsels or sexually deviant temptress. A woman is weak, naïve but good or empowered, dominant but evil. On the other hand in The Italian Ellena is projected as a resilient individual though at moments “shuddered” and “startled” but “forgetting fear for herself” overcame odds to try and escape. All the masculine characters such as Schedoni, Spalatro and her father did not make a great impact throughout the excerpt but just in states of

Similar Essays

The Balance Of Power During The Cold War

1237 words - 5 pages The concept of 'balance of power is an important consideration in the analysis of the cold war which in theory was successful in avoiding any global conflict during the years 1945-1989. It was an ideologically based concept; communism versus democracy, USSR and its allies versus USA and its allies. Balance of power speaks to a situation in which peace is ensured by maintaining equilibrium of alliances between major powers. This equilibrium

The Balance Of Power Mechanism And The System Of Alliances, Had Saved Europe From Major Wars For Forty Three Years, Failed To Preserve The Peace In 1914.

960 words - 4 pages production and territorial claiming were made.With the build up of tension, and once considered small countries attempting to expand there empire, gave great concern to the European powers which created a sense of false security about being attacked by one another.Secret alliances were made by Germany to Austria-Hungary and later with Italy because of this fear of invasion. These 3 central powers in Europe became known as " The Triple Alliance". France

The Balance Of Power Essay

3309 words - 13 pages discourse upon which its modern form operates. The establishment of the discipline’s discourse did not firmly cement its foundational concepts. As such, various forms, such as the balance between great powers and super power, appeared and further fractured its theoretical base. Jack S. Levy (2004) writes that “some say a balance of power helps maintain the peace; others say it contributes to the onset of war; still others claim that the theory

The Balance Of Power Theory Essay

2003 words - 8 pages was mainly due to the belief that the balance of power theory had to be used 'for managing and restraining both opponents and allies'[9]. In other words, no single state wished any other-even an ally-to gain an opportunity to enhance its influence in a power vacuum that the defeat of a Great Power (such as Napoleonic France) was bound to create. After the 1815 settlement the Great Powers in the so-called 'Concert of Europe' actively attempted