The Battle Between Gun Control And Gun Rights

1215 words - 5 pages

The debate over the right to bear arms according to the Second Amendment has been a hotly contested issue for many years in American history. The matter has been one of the most controversial issues in the second half of the twentieth century and into the twenty-first; disputed between politicians on the liberal and conservative side along with issues such as abortion, capital punishment, and gay marriage. The Supreme Court has officially defined the controversial Second Amendment by stating that states have the right to maintain a militia separate from a federally controlled army (Gale Encyclopedia, pg. 155-162). However, “Courts have consistently held that the state and federal governments may lawfully regulate the sale, transfer, receipt, possession, and use of certain categories of firearms, as well as mandate who may and may not own a gun (Gale Encyclopedia, pg. 155-162).” Therefore, the issue is one that is extremely hard to clarify. Which side is right?
An estimated 30,000 people are killed each year by guns in the United States alone according to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (Gun Control, Funk & Wagnall’s). Though there have been some restrictions and laws placed, both the conservative and liberal sides are not pleased with either the lack of action or the fact that there has been too much action that has taken place. “About 38% of U.S. households and 26% of individuals owned at least one gun, with about half of the individuals having 4 or more guns, according to a 2004 survey by the Harvard School of Public Health (Gun Control, Funk & Wagnall’s).” Both sides turn to the one document centered on the argument for evidence to support their side: the Second Amendment.
The Second Amendment states that: “a well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed (U.S. Const., amend. II).” There have been two main arguments that have stemmed from the different interpretations of the national document. “One argument supported that the Second Amendment supported an individual or personal right to have firearms, in particular for self-defense, separate and apart from citizen service in government militia. The second argument was that the amendment created a citizen “right of revolution” or “insurrection”, meaning that citizens had a right to engage in armed revolt against their government if they felt that the government was behaving in an unjust manner (Spitzer, The Right to Bear Arms).” Both of these views have been at the heart of the controversy of gun control.
Some could say that it really depends on whom you talk to of how the Second Amendment applies to the current battle over gun control in today’s society. For example, gun rights advocates like the NRA (National Rifle Association) interpret the Amendment to ensure the right of individuals to possess and carry firearms (A Right to Bear Arms?, UMKC School of Law). Gun control...

Find Another Essay On The Battle Between Gun Control and Gun Rights

Gun Control Rights Essay

1270 words - 6 pages One of many controversial topics in the United States is gun control. It is clearly written in the Second Amendment of the Constitution that the people will have the right to bear arms. Recently; however, people have been misusing those firearms and have been harming others with them. The government is trying to regulate the sale, distribution, and ownership of guns because of this reason. Some of the arguments being made by the politicians is

Relationship between Gun Control Policies and Gun Crime Rates

3084 words - 13 pages (According to the Ministry of Justice, total of 15,000 weapons were brought to the South Korean soil via illegal smuggling between these specific period of time ), the R.O.K. government had passed striker gun control policies in 1972 and 1978. Both policies clearly stated, anyone who has been found guilty of selling/buying or even possessing firearms will be sentence to 15 and 20 years in prison with minimum of 50,000,000 and 75,000,000 KRW which about

Gun Control and the Media

848 words - 4 pages The gun control debate has been in the news a lot lately. Their are two clear sides to the debate. One side states that they don’t want their second amendment rights taken away. While the other side sees guns as dangerous and wants reforms set in place so that certain people can’t have access to them. Some are against reform that, “private citizens who own guns are constantly told by gun-control advocates that only fully trained government

Politics and Gun Control

984 words - 4 pages rights as well as firearm safety. They argue that the gun control laws are of violation of the constitutional rights. They argue that bans on the sale on certain types of weapons have not been proved effective in reducing violent crime, and that stricter background checks at gun shows are designed to eliminate gun show themselves. The NRA believes that by being Americans we need to value the right to bear arms which is stated in the second

Crimes and Gun control

663 words - 3 pages in circulation is unimaginable. According to the 2nd Amendment of the Constitution of the United States, which guarantees that 'the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.' Those opposed to controls interpret this to mean that the government has no right to limit or ban ownership of guns.The opponents of the Gun Control Act, the National Rifle Association (NRA), believing that the rights of law-abiding citizens to buy

Gun Control and Regulation

2260 words - 9 pages Gun Control and Regulation The idea of gun control and regulation is becoming more and more popular throughout the U.S., although it may still bring up resistance among some people. Guns are sort of a foundation of American culture. This country's freedom was won over bloody and "heroic" wars with guns. Guns are portrayed throughout television, movies, and video games. Guns are a popular symbol of power, control, authority

Youth and Gun Control

1136 words - 5 pages better way to control the violence? Guns shouldn't be that easy to get a hold of because easy access will leave us wondering why they want to kill so badly, gun dealers make it easy to get them, and it increases youth violence. Reasons for violence What would cause students or minors to act out with violence, rage, assault, bullying? Many students show signs of breaking down, snapping, but no one really notices. When students stop doing what

The Gun Control Debate

823 words - 3 pages issue is hotly debated today. Between very limited gun control and very restricted gun control, there must be some medium that can somewhat appease both sides. More laws can be constructed that ban individuals that have a criminal background, mentally unstable individuals, or minors from buying a gun. Already, a background check is required for all individuals who wish to buy a gun; this comes from the Brady Law, passed in 1994, which allows

Gun Ownership and Gun Control in Canada

1037 words - 4 pages Gun Ownership and Gun Control in Canada The Oscar-won documentary ‘Bowling for Columbine’ has aroused people’s awareness of gun ownership and gun control issues. Should gun ownership be banned or should guns be controlled? Does gun ownership create a violent society? The answer is not measurable, however, from the firearm situation between America and Canada, the answer is more obvious. America probably has the

Gun Control

1009 words - 4 pages The Second Amendment of the Bill of Rights gives people the right to keep and bear arms. The ideas of setting strict laws that allow only hunting rifle use, and laws that allow more freedom has been argued over for many years. The best argument protecting the Second Amendment is that people have more security when possessing a gun. Although this is possibly true, gun control provides much more than comfort for the people. The second amendment

Gun Control

2205 words - 9 pages , such as the National Rifle Association, or NRA, firmly believe and argue the laws and regulations on gun control violate the constitutional rights of law-abiding citizens. The NRA has shown that the ban on the sale of assault weapons and handguns have not been proven effective on the reduction of violent crimes. In the State of Indiana, obtaining a license to carry a firearm is not difficult. To obtain a license, it is as simple as filling out an

Similar Essays

Gun Control And Rights Essay

909 words - 4 pages Gun Control By: Josh McCarn Gun control is a set of laws which control the rate of sale, manufacturing, possession, transfer, and the modification of legal firearms. Gun control laws are different around the world. These laws help people with safety and protection. These laws are needed to keep people from killing or threatening or other people and living things. Gun control in North Carolina consists of concealed permits, the right to bear

Gun Control Versus Gun Rights Essay

1411 words - 6 pages , Chris, (02/12/11). Court battle update: the NRA fights to enforce--and extend--gun owners' rights. Retrieved on (02/15/12.) James D. Agresti and Reid K. Smith, (01/22/12). Gun Control Facts- “Number of Hunters in America. Retrieved on (02/11/12)[6] Liptak, Adams, (04/23/08). Inmate Count

Gun Rights Vs Gun Control Essay

2035 words - 8 pages history behind the hot topic. The many pieces of gun control legislation throughout history are discussed. The article also explains both pro-gun and anti-gun control. The author states that some gun rights supporters think that gun legislation is violating the Second Amendment of the Constitution. On the other side, pro-gun control advocates believe that the Second Amendment means a collective, rather than individual, right to bear arms; implying

Gun Control Rights Essay

1086 words - 4 pages the question; if the right to bear arms is in fact guaranteed is the potential risk to law-abiding citizens worth ensuring this constitutional entitlement?The arguments for and against national gun control are too numerous to count. Yet, the most significant and politically controversial issues seem to continually make their way to the forefront of the debate. At this forefront is the most recognized and active gun rights advocate group the world