This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Battle Of The Somme As A Victory For The British

2168 words - 9 pages

The Battle of the Somme as a Victory for the British

This investigation seeks to evaluate the extent to which the Battle of
the Somme was a victory for the British. The main body of this
investigation will outline the way the British set out their
strategies to win the war and what were its weaknesses and
oppositions. During this investigation two main sources are going to
be used: "The first day of the Somme" by Richard Tames and the other
source is from the British newspaper "The Times" written on July 3rd
1916(still existing today).Through these 2 different sources we will
evaluate and highlight the differences and similarities about the
British "victory" over the Somme. To evaluate the success and failures
about the British offensive in the Sommeit is important to know who is
writing the source because the writer may be biased in favour of one
side. This will be mentioned during the investigation. The
investigation will also mention the origin purpose, value and
limitations of the sources chosen.

B) SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE:

The aim of the British army was to bombard the German defences by
breaking through their trenches and barbed wire until they gave up. At
first there were around 120,000 British soldiers attacking along the
18 mile front. The British and the French offensive against the
Germans were led by General Joffre and General Douglas Haig. According
to the Richard Tames book both the generals had certain qualities in
common. Both had a reputation for a cool head in crisis. They seemed
to be the right people to lead the British and the French through
victory according to the British point of view. During colonial
captures they were generals against the weak side. But this time they
were going to fight a stronger side which they were not used to. The
British army was strong but the German defensive strategy was
stronger. From the book of Simkin,J.: "… the Somme campaign might
yield that the necessity of relieving pressure in the French army… is
more urgent than ever": This quote is from Sir William Robertson who
gives a reason on why the British were involved in the war. He and
Douglas Haig had the same thoughts and were criticised for their
failures during the Battle of the Somme. Although the British were not
completely successful in the Battle of the Somme quotes like the above
convinced the French that the British were trying their best to help.
From the Simkin,J book Haig claims that:" the enemy's position to be
attacked was of a very formidable character, situated on a high
undulating tract of ground… well provided with bomb-proof shelters and
with numerous communication trenches connecting them… 2 belts 40 yards
broad, built of iron stakes interlaced with barbed wire". According to
Haig the Germans had a strong defensive strategy which could only be
...

Find Another Essay On The Battle of the Somme as a Victory for the British

Battle of the Somme Essay

1148 words - 5 pages destined for failure. The British offensive, an utter failure, resulted in a stalemate, which was common throughout World War One. The British development of the tank, while it eventually ended the horrendous stalemate, was ineffectively used during the Somme. Trench warfare became a common practice in World War One, leading to a war of attrition. Both the Allies as well as the Germans enacted similar basic defense strategies and dealt with many

Why the Battle of the Somme is Regarded as a Great Military Tragedy

1170 words - 5 pages Why the Battle of the Somme is Regarded as a Great Military Tragedy On 1st July 1916, General Haig prepared the battle plan for an offensive on German lines, designed to relieve the strain on French forces at Verdun and break through a strong line of German defences. While Haig would have preferred an attack further north, he was hopeful that the operation should be successful in drawing forces away from Verdun and

Evaluation of the Battle of the Somme

1941 words - 8 pages article published by The Daily Chronicle on the 3rd July which is explaining the events of the first day of the battle. At about 7 . 30 am this morning a vigorous attack was launched by the British Army. The front extends over some 20 miles north of the Somme. The assault was preceded by a terrific bombardment, lasting about an hour and a half. It is too early to as yet give anything but the bearest particulars, as the

The Battle of the Somme in 1916

2480 words - 10 pages extensive tasks better readied the British and French for battle and helped give them a more advantageous understanding of their enemy. One would think that all these preparations would have helped the Allies, but it did not reflect so at the Somme. The first day of the Battle of the Somme was a disaster. History Today noted that the first day of the battle on the Somme was at 7:30 a.m. on July 1st (Furtado 1). This marked the first horrific day with

Was the Battle of the Somme Justified?

2181 words - 9 pages . There were about 50 tanks that the British had at first that reached the Somme during September but because of mechanical and other failures made the number of tanks from 50 to 24 which was critical for the allied forces. The British and French had a great opportunity by using tanks to clear a lot of land but even with their own mechanical and other problems. As that the enemy within the last days of battle brought into action considerable number

The Realism of the Film The Battle of The Somme

1904 words - 8 pages The Realism of the Film The Battle of The Somme The film 'The Battle of The Somme' was released in Londonon the 10th of August 1916, it was a famous documentary that was filmed by Geoffrey Malins and J.B. McDowell. They were one of the first groups of cameramen to film the British soldiers on the Battlefields of the Western Front. They helped the government to produce a video, to show people that War wasn't as bad as it

Why was the first day of the Battle of the Somme a failure?

1065 words - 4 pages battle plans were not properly prepared, as there had been little fighting prior to the battle.The Battle of Somme was a dreadful failure. The main reason for this seems to be Sir Douglas Haig. He was the one who cam up with all these plans, and refused to listen to Rawlinson. He also disregarded so many reports during the battle of the number of casualties, yet he refused to listen to them. He was stubborn and had to have it his own way. He

General Haig's Role in the Battle of the Somme

1516 words - 6 pages . Some refer to him as the Butcher of Somme because of the large loss of life during the battle. Others however argue that he was simply doing his job and doing what he was told to do. On the one hand Sir General Haig is referred as the Butcher of Somme. One reason for this is that the battle did not go according to plan as there were a lot of casualties and from the first day alone there were approximately 60,000 men that were killed or

A Bloody Battle for the British At Kings Mountain

633 words - 3 pages this victory? The Battle of Kings Mountain was a very long and could be considered by some an almost hopeless battle because there were many inexperienced men fighting that day. The British may have had the upper hand, but they weren't expecting to be attacked suddenly. Obviously the Americans plan worked. The Battle of Kings Mountain should never be forgot. Among the Revolutionary War's battles, this is one of the greatest that ever occurred.

A newspaper-style article describing the end of the Boer war, ending in British victory

706 words - 3 pages Free State. In many major battles, the Boer forces defeated the British, the towns of Ladysmith, Mafeking, and Kimberly in the Cape Colony were taken over. The northern districts of the British owned Cape Colony rebelled and joined the Boer forces. These were humiliating blows to the British military. When the British recognized this war as more than a passing engagement that they first thought it to be, they sent for reinforcements and the British

Canada's Victory in the Battle of Vimy Ridge

996 words - 4 pages In the spring of 1917, the battle of Vimy Ridge took place. As the Germans occupied it, the British had fought long and hard, but had failed to capture it after many attempts. Their immediate solution was to order the Canadians to try and capture this valuable piece of land once and for all. Unlike the British, the Canadians had taken time to think up a plan, which would catch the Germans off guard. The plan suggested that the Canadians make a

Similar Essays

Battle Of The Somme Essay

1053 words - 5 pages The Battle of the Somme, or “humanity’s bloodiest battle”, took place between July 1st and November 18th, 1916 (Wikipedia). The German Empire was pitted against the French and British Empires, resulting in over 1,000,000 men wounded or killed, 60,000 of them being on the first day of the battle. This battle was one of the largest and bloodiest battles on World War I, making it consequential to the French, British, and German Empires. Although

Battle Of The Somme Essay

619 words - 2 pages loosing so many soldiers. Before the Somme battle the British army had to switch from all volunteers to all draftees. The British army learned a lot of this battle, like there tactics got a lot better, supply arrangements and administrations behind the lines became more efficient. But overall the Germans remained a more powerful fighting force. During this battle there allies were trying to make supplies, because of the fact that the Germans were

The Battle Of Somme Essay

1932 words - 8 pages Verdun. Initially, Haig opposed a battle on the Somme front, but in the end agreed that the Somme would lead to a final victory because of the great trenches. On December 19, 1915, Douglas Haig became the new commander of the BEF’s “British Expedition Force” First Army. He was a hard person to get to know and seemed to have no concern for the human suffering caused by the war. His colleagues found him strange because of his spiritual practices

Battle Of The Somme Essay

860 words - 3 pages The second battle of 1916 was the Battle of the Somme. In this the British and French armies tried to break through the German defences in the valley of the river Somme. The battle started on the first day of July 1916 as huge guns bombarded the German trenches. Then thousands of troops charged across no-man's land to press home the attack.The trenches of the British ran for 20 miles from the village of Hebuterne south across the Ancre to the