The Battle Over Same Sex Marriage Essay

2260 words - 9 pages ✓ Expert Reviewed

Same-sex marriage has grown into to a national issue. In 2003, the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples had the right to marry which provoked a firestorm of debate. The discussion extends from private livings rooms and local watering holes; all the way to the floor of the U.S. Congress and the White House. The debate about same-sex marriage has become a hot button issue, which pits secular-progressives who support gay-rights against religious and social traditionalists fighting for the sanctity of marriage.

When La Shawn Barber, Anna Quindlen, Andrew Sullivan and the editors at National Review wrote their opinion pieces regarding the topic of same-sex marriage the debate had already been raging for many years and it still is today. Freelance writer La Shawn Barber and the editors of National Review oppose same-sex marriage and argue that legalizing same-sex marriage would fundamentally redefine marriage and weaken it as a social institution. Conversely, contributing editor of Newsweek magazine, Anna Quindlen, and “The Daily Dish” blogger Andrew Sullivan support same-sex marriage and stress that same-sex couples should be treated no different than heterosexual couples, including when it comes to the right to marry.

In “The Loving Decision,” Quindlen uses the example of the historic court case Loving v. Virginia, which legalized interracial marriage, to argue that homosexuals should be allowed to marry whomever they want. Quindlen maintains that the Loving v. Virginia case is applicable to the modern-day fight for same-sex marriage because this is an issue of civil rights violations, much like the original case from 1968. In contrast, Barber, counters in “Interracial Marriage: Slippery Slope?” that Loving v. Virginia should not be applied to same-sex marriages because its intent is fundamentally different and not applicable same-sex marriage. Barber insists that although Loving v. Virginia dealt with the inequality of civil rights in marriages, it was still ultimately a fight for the right for one man to marry one woman. Therefore, in her opinion, the case is not applicable to the fight for same-sex marriage. Barber asserts that the goal of miscegenation laws “was to maintain a subordinate class of citizens based on race” (par. 8), and that current bans against same-sex marriage are intended to preserve traditional marriage, not to show prejudice against homosexuals.

Quindlen and many other same-sex marriage champions believe that the right to marry is an inherent civil right; which therefore should be granted to homosexuals under the law. Quindlen believes the desire to marry—even amongst homosexuals—is a “powerful [force] for good on earth” (par 12). She refers to a statement made by Mildred Loving, the woman from the pivotal Loving v. Virginia court case, in which Mildred maintains that all American’s “no matter their race, no matter their sex, no matter their sexual orientation should have...

Find Another Essay On The Battle Over Same-Sex Marriage

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage Essay

1223 words - 5 pages particularly unfair form is sexual discrimination which a same sex couple is not able to be married like a heterosexual couple. Slowly, this form of discrimination is becoming illegal which has caused much dispute. Even though there is debate about it, same sex marriage should become legalized because it deserves the same rights as heterosexual marriages. The idea of same sex marriage began when a court case in the early 1970s in Wyoming was tried...

Same Sex Marriage Essay

1772 words - 7 pages now. The two loudest voices in this battle seem to come from the gay community and the religious community. Homosexuals are of course fighting for gay marriage to be legal while the Christian based faith attempts to keep it illegal. Some people view same-sex marriage as immoral and a sin, however this ban on marriage violates the inalienable rights each individual should have, discriminates a minority, as well as infringes the true sanctity of...

Same Sex Marriage

744 words - 3 pages In attempt in to justify same sex marriage, Ralph Wedgwood makes the statement that restricting marriage to same sex marriage is stripping them from equality. He believes that if opposite sex marriage is accepted then same sex marriage should also be accepted not only by law but also by society as a whole. He argues for...

Same-Sex Marriage

988 words - 4 pages an opinion on what homosexuals are not allowed to do. I realize that there are many opinions regarding the legalization of same-sex marriage , but the people who are receiving the negative end of this are humans too. Homosexuals feel discriminated by the fact that they cannot marry the one they love over others opinions. Homosexuals feel judged because society tends to think that they chose to be the way that they are. Well, let me ask society...

Same-Sex Marriage

900 words - 4 pages Homosexual couples are faced with many problems along the lines of acceptation. The establishment of marriage is designed to bond a man and a woman, the meaning of this social establishment states same-sex marriage is unsuitable, but the present day definition of marriage ought to grant permission for all couples heterosexual or homosexual to experience this establishment. Purposes for legitimization of same-sex marriage for the homosexual...

Same-Sex Marriage

1744 words - 7 pages liberties, like same-sex marriage. If some change isn’t made now, their struggle for rights could last even longer than other minorities have endured. Since there is no national ruling made to abolish same-sex marriage, each state sets its own laws regarding gay marriage. Currently in the US, five states allow same-sex marriage, several states offer civil unions, and the large majority of states ban same-sex marriage. Today, several groups...

Same Sex Marriage

958 words - 4 pages stands right now same sex couples have NO say so in the decision of healthcare of their partner in the event of an emergency. Could you imagine not having a say so over the man or woman that you have shared your life with when their life may depend on it? This is just one small factor in the giant mess that is wrapped up in a political battle over whose right and whose wrong. Why are we more concerned with whether or not a man marries another...

Same-Sex Marriage - 1456 words

1456 words - 6 pages gender or sexual orientation is. Marriage is just one way for two people to show their love for another. Whether it is two men, two women, or a man and a woman, love is love. People against gay marriage do not have the right to deny people of showing their love for one another. Everyone deserves the same rights as Americans and also just as people. The United States of America promotes freedom, liberty, and justice for all people. Same-sex couples...

Same Sex Marriage - 2041 words

2041 words - 8 pages parties. These two groups constantly argue over the validity of same-sex marriage and never seem to come to an agreement. Each group presents valid and reasonable arguments to support their belief. Both hold their beliefs strongly and, therefore, aren’t willing to compromise. Those opposing claim that marriage is sacred and should be kept that way. Those supporting same-sex marriage state that marriage is nothing but a contract and prohibiting this...

Same-Sex Marriage - 1477 words

1477 words - 6 pages ruling that gay couples have the constitutional right to marry. In October the Supreme Court of Connecticut ruled that same-sex couples have the right to marry. By November 3 over 18,000 same-sex couples had married in California only for voters to approve a ban on gay marriage on November 4. There was talk of whether the 18,000 marriages were in fact valid when Attorney General Brown stated that any of the marriages before November 4 should...

same sex marriage

1233 words - 5 pages lesbian couples in the eyes of the law because the government and religious beliefs are supposed to be separate. Weather same-sex civil unions should be recognized legally is not a religious question. This is a debate over whether or not people of different sexual orientation are to be viewed equally in the eyes of the government, and will be accepted into mainstream America.However, some people argue that same-sex marriage would be tolerable...

Similar Essays

The Same Sex Marriage Debate Essay

1684 words - 7 pages The Same Sex Marriage Debate The controversial debate over whether same sex marriage should be legalized has gained a lot of attention in recent years and there are strong arguments for each side of the issue. There are many different factors that must be looked at when considering same-sex marriage. A marriage is not something that is just slapped on a piece of paper to show a couple's love; it involves legal, social, economic, and...

Same-Sex Marriage Essay - 543 words

543 words - 2 pages Same-Sex Marriage Should be AllowedA few weeks ago, the famous singer Elton John got married to a man he was dating for twelve years. Many famous people anticipated his wedding ceremony, and it was broadcaste over a worldwide hookup. Nowadays, same-sex marriage was allowed in some...

Same Sex Marriage Essay - 684 words

684 words - 3 pages �PAGE � �PAGE �1� Same Sex Same Sex MarriageNameCourseInstructorDate�Same Sex MarriageMarriage between two people of the same sex has been an issue over the last decades. Because of this, a lot of countries have their fair...

Same sex marriage Essay

600 words - 2 pages Kendrick AndersonANTHRO 202Cultural Anthropology30-April-2013Same Sex MarriageMarriage is an institution between one man and one woman. Same-sex relations wouldpresent many changes in the meaning of marriage. Marriage is a historic, culturalinstitution, and same-sex will confuse society generation. The amendment protect marriagefrom over-ruling by either state legislatures or the courts...