The Battle Over Same Sex Marriage Essay

2260 words - 9 pages

Same-sex marriage has grown into to a national issue. In 2003, the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples had the right to marry which provoked a firestorm of debate. The discussion extends from private livings rooms and local watering holes; all the way to the floor of the U.S. Congress and the White House. The debate about same-sex marriage has become a hot button issue, which pits secular-progressives who support gay-rights against religious and social traditionalists fighting for the sanctity of marriage.

When La Shawn Barber, Anna Quindlen, Andrew Sullivan and the editors at National Review wrote their opinion pieces regarding the topic of same-sex marriage the debate had already been raging for many years and it still is today. Freelance writer La Shawn Barber and the editors of National Review oppose same-sex marriage and argue that legalizing same-sex marriage would fundamentally redefine marriage and weaken it as a social institution. Conversely, contributing editor of Newsweek magazine, Anna Quindlen, and “The Daily Dish” blogger Andrew Sullivan support same-sex marriage and stress that same-sex couples should be treated no different than heterosexual couples, including when it comes to the right to marry.

In “The Loving Decision,” Quindlen uses the example of the historic court case Loving v. Virginia, which legalized interracial marriage, to argue that homosexuals should be allowed to marry whomever they want. Quindlen maintains that the Loving v. Virginia case is applicable to the modern-day fight for same-sex marriage because this is an issue of civil rights violations, much like the original case from 1968. In contrast, Barber, counters in “Interracial Marriage: Slippery Slope?” that Loving v. Virginia should not be applied to same-sex marriages because its intent is fundamentally different and not applicable same-sex marriage. Barber insists that although Loving v. Virginia dealt with the inequality of civil rights in marriages, it was still ultimately a fight for the right for one man to marry one woman. Therefore, in her opinion, the case is not applicable to the fight for same-sex marriage. Barber asserts that the goal of miscegenation laws “was to maintain a subordinate class of citizens based on race” (par. 8), and that current bans against same-sex marriage are intended to preserve traditional marriage, not to show prejudice against homosexuals.

Quindlen and many other same-sex marriage champions believe that the right to marry is an inherent civil right; which therefore should be granted to homosexuals under the law. Quindlen believes the desire to marry—even amongst homosexuals—is a “powerful [force] for good on earth” (par 12). She refers to a statement made by Mildred Loving, the woman from the pivotal Loving v. Virginia court case, in which Mildred maintains that all American’s “no matter their race, no matter their sex, no matter their sexual orientation should have...

Find Another Essay On The Battle Over Same-Sex Marriage

Same Sex Marriage Essay

684 words - 3 pages �PAGE � �PAGE �1� Same Sex Same Sex MarriageNameCourseInstructorDate�Same Sex MarriageMarriage between two people of the same sex has been an issue over the last decades. Because of this, a lot of countries have their fair...

same sex marriage Essay

3364 words - 13 pages AbstractSame-sex marriage has been around since the reign of Egypt, found in historical Egyptian artifacts. Over time, the practice began to become frowned upon, mainly due to the cause of Christianity. Stereotypes began to form, and hindered the social reputation of

Same Sex Marriage

958 words - 4 pages Same Sex Marriage! There are many different views and opinions on the relationship between a man and a woman vs. the relationship between a man and a man or a woman and a woman for that matter. Same-sex marriage is a big issue in the United States, many are against it however; many are for it. If you do your research, you can find many negative and positive reasons for which society thinks it should be legal or illegal. What people fail to...

Same-Sex Marriage

1456 words - 6 pages The legality of gay marriage is a hot topic for many reasons. Traditionally marriage has been known as a legal bond between a man and a woman. Times have changed since those days. More and more people are coming out of the closet everyday. There are more gay people today than there ever have been and that number is only increasing. Marriage is a way for two people to show their commitment towards each other, so it should not matter what their...

Same-Sex Marriage

1565 words - 6 pages Same-sex couples should not be excluded from the legal right to marry because they signify the same love and commitment in a marriage as a heterosexual couple. They fall in love and want to commit themselves to that person by getting married or having a family together, but the law states that...

Same sex marriage

735 words - 3 pages Egoism is a teleological theory of ethics that sets as its goal the benefit, pleasure, or greatest good of the oneself alone.Ethical egoism is the normative ethical position that moral agents ought to do what is in their own self-interest. It is important to distinguish this from psychological egoism, the claim that people can only act in their own interest. Any act, no matter how altruistic it might seem, is actually motivated by some...

Same Sex Marriage

2041 words - 8 pages Same-sex marriage has continuously been contradicted throughout our nation and so the arguments never seem to cease. Some argue the legality of same-sex marriage while others suggest that it compromises the sacredness of marriage. Various religious groups and their supporters in the U.S. tend to either support same-sex marriage or greatly oppose it, depending on their viewpoints and beliefs. Thus, the constant, bitter arguments between these...

Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage

1293 words - 5 pages Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage All couples in a committed loving relationship should be legally allowed to marry. United States marriage concepts have been changing in conjunction with society’s evolving culture. Traditional concepts assigning marital duties based on gender no longer apply, strengthening the effectiveness of the marriage in today’s world. Society is actively moving towards becoming a culture of contributing individuals who have...

Same-Sex Marriage

1477 words - 6 pages Just about everyone has an opinion on whether same-sex couples should be allowed to legally marry. The arguments range from personal beliefs to what marriage is said to be in the Bible. Why should a couple be forbidden from showing each other along with family and friends that they are fully committed to each other? What place is it for the government to say that said couple is not allowed to commit to the one who truly makes you happy? Why...

same sex marriage

1233 words - 5 pages Keilanie Leitch English 099-C Leitchk992@cobleskill,eduWe live in a free country but we are still not able to do what we please. Most people believe that they deserve more then what the government gives. Not all citizens have been given equal rights, gays and lesbians are always being denied the rights to be together because, in the governments eyes it "not the American away". Gay and lesbians couples do everything...

Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage

1238 words - 5 pages Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage"There's no reason that the government should prevent homosexuals from entering civil marriages because some religions object to the concept, any more than the government should ban atheism because some religions object to it" (Pampuch, 2). Same-sex marriage refers to the legal recognition of civil institution of marriage...

Similar Essays

The Same Sex Marriage Debate Essay

1684 words - 7 pages The Same Sex Marriage Debate The controversial debate over whether same sex marriage should be legalized has gained a lot of attention in recent years and there are strong arguments for each side of the issue. There are many different factors that must be looked at when considering same-sex marriage. A marriage is not something that is just slapped on a piece of paper to show a couple's love; it involves legal, social, economic, and...

Same Sex Marriage Essay

600 words - 2 pages Kendrick AndersonANTHRO 202Cultural Anthropology30-April-2013Same Sex MarriageMarriage is an institution between one man and one woman. Same-sex relations wouldpresent many changes in the meaning of marriage. Marriage is a historic, culturalinstitution, and same-sex will confuse society generation. The amendment protect marriagefrom over-ruling by either state legislatures or the courts...

Same Sex Marriage Essay 543 Words

543 words - 2 pages Same-Sex Marriage Should be AllowedA few weeks ago, the famous singer Elton John got married to a man he was dating for twelve years. Many famous people anticipated his wedding ceremony, and it was broadcaste over a worldwide hookup. Nowadays, same-sex marriage was allowed in some...

Same Sex Marriage Essay 1772 Words

1772 words - 7 pages White all over, bells clinging in the distance, the weather just as perfect as ever; everything perfect. The moment time stands still as you kiss your partner after the “I do’s.” What if this dream could never come true? Not because you never met the right person but because society did not accept it. That is exactly what is happening to same-sex couples. The fight for same-sex couples to marry legally has been an ongoing debate for many years...