This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Bedroom Tax: Is It Fair?

2806 words - 12 pages

Mention the words “bedroom tax” in conversation and the responses range from firsthand accounts of people being evicted from their homes to newly bereaved pensioners faced with the prospect of losing their homes because they can’t afford the rent. You can’t fail to have heard horror stories of desperate pensioners such as Stephanie Bottrill feeling suicide to be the only way out (DAILY MAIL, 2013) or a middle aged man “sick of all this shit...” slitting his throat in a benefit advice office. (DAILY MAIL JULY 2013) Is it fair to persecute the most vulnerable members of society? That all depends on how you define fair.
The bedroom tax, or under-occupancy charge as the government prefers it to be known, was designed to bring tenants in receipt of Housing Benefit (HB) in social housing into line with those living in private rented accommodation. From 1 April 2013, if you are a social housing tenant of working age receiving HB, and renting a home with more bedrooms than you need, your HB is reduced by 14% for one “spare” bedroom and 25% for two or more. (NORTHUMBERLAND COUNTY COUNCIL, 2013) The power to reduce HB in this way is contained in the Welfare Reform Act 2012 - quite possibly one of the most unpopular and controversial pieces of legislation introduced by the Conservative led coalition government.
It should be noted that the regulations do not define what a bedroom is, nor its size. Rumours abounded on various social media websites such as Facebook and Twitter that rooms under 70 square feet didn’t constitute a bedroom but this was a misconception based on an incorrect interpretation of overcrowding under the HOUSING ACT 1985.
The government says the bedroom tax is all about fairness; the aims of the welfare reforms being to reduce HB expenditure, encourage the unemployed to find work, and make better use of social housing stock. (CHANNEL 4 NEWS, 2013) Speaking at Prime Minister’s Questions on 30 January 2013, David Cameron said "we are now spending as a country £23bn on housing benefit and we have to get that budget under control." (HANSARD, 2013)
The Government states the bedroom tax will reduce the welfare bill by £465m a year although research carried out by Professor Rebecca Tunstall, Director at the Centre of Housing Policy University of York suggests this figure to be “exaggerated” and based on a “flawed” DWP model for calculating savings. Unsurprisingly, this figure is also hotly disputed by Rachel Reeves, Shadow Secretary for Work and Pensions who said “This research is another nail in the coffin for David Cameron’s crumbling case for the bedroom tax. Labour has repeatedly warned it could end up costing more than it saves.” (THE INDEPENDENT, 2013)
What is fair about forcing older people from homes where they have lived and raised a family for decades because their children may have flown the nest? Is it fair to reduce the benefits of a disabled person who is unable to find a smaller home...

Find Another Essay On The bedroom tax: is it fair?

Is it fair to call Aeneid Book 4 "The Tragedy of Dido"?

1927 words - 8 pages The suggestion that Book Four of Virgil's Aeneid ought to be called 'the tragedy of Dido' is a controversial one. It is firstly questionable as to whether Book Four fulfils the criteria of a tragedy in the ancient, or the contemporary sense of the word; and secondly if it is indeed a tragedy, whether the consequences are tragic for Dido alone.Virgil's motives in writing Book Four seem somewhat ambiguous. Throughout Books One to Three he presents

Everyone Is Equal? The World Is Fair?

880 words - 4 pages truthful, myself, and many other children came into the world believing that the world was a fair place, which it is not, but that is all right... now.Now days, not everyone can become whatever they want, but that was always the truth in the past. Men wanted to be kings, to rule over subjects with an iron fist, or possibly with the soft compassion of gossamer silk. With the kingdoms gone, and we turn to this day and age, we find more and more people

Financial Management - SingTel acquire Optus, Is it fair & reasonable?

2559 words - 10 pages (Q1)The offer price given by SingTel for the acquisition of Optus is not a "fair and reasonable" one. According to 3 different financial valuation models (discounted cash flow analysis, EBITDA & P/E Ratio - see attached Appendix), Singtel is also giving high premium to buy Optus in all above market approach analysis.The SingTel bid will bring more confidence to the telecommunications market, they are paying an A$4 billion premium, Optus

This Essay is all about the Boston Tea Party and how it lead to new British tax laws

932 words - 4 pages On December 16, 1773 a mob of angry Colonists, led by the charismatic patriot Samuel Adams, protested the newly passed tax on tea imports. The colonists disguised themselves as Native Americans and stealthily boarded the British merchant ships that were carrying the latest shipment of tea. After boarding these ships, the Colonists dumped nearly four hundred crates of tea overboard into Boston Harbor. This famous act of defiance became known as

Tax as a Means of Control and Stimulator of the Economy in the Uk. Is it a Good Idea to Fluctuate the Tax Rates for Stabilizing the Economy? Is Tax Necessary for a Country’s Growth? Is Green Tax ...

9199 words - 37 pages required to pay tax by law. Unlike past times when tax was charged on the goods that the peasants used to cultivate, now it is only charged financially and direct taxes are charged to only those people who have certain limits of income. For this reason some people find tax to be fair and others object it as unfair.Taxes can be categorised as, direct and indirect; direct taxes are the taxes levied directly off of an organization or an individual, an

Is the International Tax System Legitimate?

3072 words - 13 pages institutions. However, offshore wealth is highly unfavorable to tax authorities of the investor’s residence government as it has been considered a legal way to evade tax payable to the residence country. Despite the small share on the total wealth held offshore, the portion of offshore wealth are greater in developing world mainly in Asia-Pacific region than the wealthiest nation due to their faster wealth growing rate as a result of aggressive

When it is all said and done, the current criminal justice system is about as fair and effective as we can resonably expect

2326 words - 9 pages The incessant debate of whether the current criminal justice system is 'about as fair and effective as wecan reasonably expect' has yet again been addressed in this essay. It is argued throughout this essaythat the criminal justice system fails to meet with the protection and well being of the public by notappropriately processing offenders. Six main arguments of this essay highlight weaknesses within thesystem. The first argument of this essay

Title: Fair is Foul, and Foul is Fair Macbeth: Who is the true villain in the play?

1330 words - 5 pages “Fair is Foul, and Foul is Fair”"I believe that there is only one story in the world...Humans are caught--in their lives, in their thoughts, in their hungers and ambitions, in their avarice and cruelty, and in their kindness and generosity too--in a net of good and evil...A man, after he has brushed off the dust and chips of his life, will have left only the hard, clean question: Was it good or was it evil? Have I done well--or ill

Why the Flat Tax is Better for America Than the Income Tax

1576 words - 6 pages less. Currently low-income families pay little or no taxes. These people with lower incomes will be the ones most affected by a flat tax system. Also, there are allowable deductions under our current income tax system that will not exist if we change to a flat tax system. Although the federal income tax has loopholes and currently helps low-income families, it needs to be replaced. Congress is currently considering two major plans to try and

Inequality in Education - is it fair to have AP clases Vs standard classes

537 words - 2 pages have to be in school longer than others. This is because the higher level classes learn more information in a shorter period of time. Is it fair to say that if you were not able to keep up with the higher level classes you had to go to school while the “smart” kids got time off? Also, is it fair to say that if you can learn faster, that you came from a “better” family.Our society runs with a school system that has the same

Is it wholly fair to brand Durkheim as an advocate of an elitist system? - SUTD - Essay

1409 words - 6 pages inequalities.” (1893/1997, p. 313) Is it wholly fair to brand Durkheim as an advocate of an elitist system? The entire objective of Durkheim’s pursuit, is solidarity. The unification of society, be it through a collective consciousness or interdependence. He insists though, on moving towards the latter, but it is hard to come by one whose size does not exceed its responsibilities, in today’s context that is. Through the division of the available roles

Similar Essays

The Fair Tax Plan Essay

1941 words - 8 pages financial problems and how the Fair Tax would help. Lets say that the Fair Tax proposal was in effect in 2009. According to the economists, it would have generated $171 billion dollars more. That is right,” billion”, with a B. Also for the year 2010, it would have generated $267 billion dollars more. That is something to consider. Just think, if we had the Fair Tax proposal in effect for the past 10 years or so, we would have had trillions of

To What Extent Has The Bedroom Tax Affected People

2329 words - 9 pages Housing Federation website has given a detailed description of who will be affected and the implications it may have on tenants. But already only three months in to the bedroom tax and it has been reported “more than fifty thousand people have fallen behind on their rent and face eviction” Independent (2013). This report is going to concentrate on the affects the aptly named Bedroom Tax is having on people’s lives. A detailed report will be drawn

News: Is It Fair And Balanced?

2155 words - 9 pages Times remained objective, listing facts and interviewing people within Iraq who are directly involved in the war in Iraq. Different news sources provide the viewer or reader with a different view or perspective of the war. I found that a well-rounded view of the war is more easily found in the written news, such as The New York Times and The San Jose Mercury News. Objectivity, a fair and balance report, is what viewers are looking for and it seems

Encouraging Economic Growth With The Fair Tax Act

1805 words - 7 pages , and put bread on the table. Spending would increase, helping to stimulate our economy. Speaking of 401K’s, the Beacon Hill Institute reports that the Fair Tax “would encourage saving, investment, and capital formation, leading to an increase in production” (Tuerck 4). Saving is discouraged under our current tax system because it is taxed twice; once when we earn the money to invest and again when we receive a return on our investment. Under