The Pros And Cons Of Life In Communist East Germany In Goodbye, Lenin

2202 words - 9 pages

On the whole, does Goodbye, Lenin paint a positive or negative picture of life in communist East Germany?

East Germany, its demise relayed through the mass media of recent history, has in popular consciousness been posited as negative, a corrupt bulwark of the last dying days of Communism in Eastern Europe, barren and silent. The other Germany to its West, its citizens free, was striding confidently ahead into the millennium. Recent cinema has sought to examine re-unification, the Wolfgang Becker film Goodbye Lenin! (2003) a recent example of such an investigation into the past through cinema. In this essay I will look at the film and the narrative techniques it uses, probing whether it portrays the East German nation as positive or negative, concluding that though many negatives are identified, some positives are deduced from Honecker's state. I will also consider why, in recent times, East Germans have come to regard their former state with nostalgia, or as the Germans would put it, ostalgie, an act which Goodbye Lenin! (2003) explores.

Not a doom laden, emphatically political treatise on the reunification of East and West Germany but a touching and sometimes comedic insight into the gargantuan changes impacting on the small scale, day to day life as experienced by an East German family, Christiane Kerner and her two children Alex and Ariane. Awaking from a coma, Alex fears his mother?s condition may worsen if she learns of re-unification, going to increasingly elaborate lengths in maintaining the illusion of the GDR's omniscience. Becker?s stance as to reunification is ambivalent throughout, the film's concerns not didactic but subtly relayed. How the personal and political interweave is skilfully constructed by Becker, assessing the extent to which the society we live within affects us, how far its changing social landscape impacts our private one. Goodbye Lenin! (2003) appropriates the individual as bound to his environment, threaded, through strong cultural codes, to his neighbour. Regardless of the system, communist or capitalist, and though our goals may deviate, we are all pursuing happiness and comfort, the tools used to attain this products of that society. That said, it is immediately legible whereabouts Becker wishes us to view the East German state as wholly negative, and he does this through several key scenes.

At the film's opening, we learn of the first East German shot into space, surely an apotheosis of what a state can achieve, its grasp extending to the stars. But behind the curtain of this vast achievement we can see how it is brought about through the utter bending of citizens to the states will. Alex's mother Christiane, who we first assume the innocent of the piece, is interrogated by the Stasi for her husband has fled the country. We learn he was unable to live with a state he detested, the ordeal of the interrogation so testing for Christiane it sends her into a coma. Her husband and the children?s father...

Find Another Essay On The Pros and Cons of Life in Communist East Germany in Goodbye, Lenin

Pros and Cons of the Atomic Bomb in WWII

1007 words - 4 pages city could be destroyed in one swift blow, with no possible way to prevent the city from being destroyed. After the ultimate destructive power of this weapon had been demonstrated, Japan had no choice but to surrender.         Some may argue that by using the atomic bomb in the war, we started the nuclear arms race. This is completely untrue. Germany and Japan had begun research on the atomic bomb even before the United States had conceived

The Pros and Cons of Privatizing Government Services in Canada

2955 words - 12 pages Thorold. Thorold is a small municipality in the Niagara Region with a population of 18,000. Recently this year the city council paid for a Fire Services review to be done of the municipality’s fire and emergency services. The city is split in half by the Welland Canal that runs through the region, meaning that the city is broken up into 4 fire districts providing fire coverage for the downtown district, east and west sides of the canal and a smaller

The Pros and Cons of Using Information Technology in Teaching

517 words - 2 pages The Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Information Technology in Teaching The most obvious advantage of using information technology in teaching and learning is the flexibility for learners to get access to computers. Now that computers have become common, learners can get access to the Internet and engage in study at any time, any place and at their own pace. This is the reason why distance learning has become so common nowadays

The Pros and Cons of Protest in American History

1113 words - 4 pages State shootings and the Democratic Convention of 1968 are examples of protests that went terribly wrong. Sit-ins and singing protest songs against violence are examples of peaceful protest. The Democratic Convention of 1968 took place in Chicago, Illinois. This convention is known as the people’s convention because it was put on during a time of confusion and turmoil over the Vietnam War and youth protests that had sprung up all over the

The Pros and Cons of Illegal Immigration in America

754 words - 3 pages should show them what is means to have freedom. All they want is the “better” life. Although many states have illegal immigrants, the majority of them reside in California and Texas. According to the US Citizenship and Immigration Services “California has 2,209,000 and Texas at 1,041,000 as of the last census in 2000. The next leading state is New York with 489,000. The state with the lowest amount is Hawaii, with only 2,000. The

The Pros and Cons of Tracking in Schools

1747 words - 7 pages placed in the same groups based on their past scores, motivation and work ethic (Akos). The point of grouping students together is so students with the same academic ability can work together and be at the same level academically, this is supposed to help the students and the teacher. Academic tracking will be more effective and influence a better learning environment for students to succeed in their education. Tracking can especially help high

The Pros and Cons of Migration in London

854 words - 3 pages Introduction This essay seeks to investigate the negative and positive effects of migration in London. As the London Migration Observatory claim London has the largest number of migrants among all regions of the United Kingdom (UK). About 37% of the UK’s foreign-born population was in London (LMO, Dr.Rienzo and Dr.Vargas-Silva). Furthermore, According to the Benton-Smith statistic, London is the 5th International city in the world after New

The Pros and Cons of Classification Systems in Psychiatry

1606 words - 6 pages Classification refers to the procedure in which ideas or objects are recognized, distinguished and understood. Currently, two leading systems are used for grouping of mental disorder namely International Classification of Disease (ICD) by World Health Organization (WHO) and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental disorders (DSM) by the American Psychiatric Association (APA). Other classifications include Chinese classification of mental

Compare and contrast the role of Lenin and Trotsky in establishing and contributing to the communist state in Russia from 1917-1924.

786 words - 3 pages Lenin and Trotsky had both been able to contribute to the establishment and consolidation of a communist state in Russia 1917-24. In the beginning, before the Civil War, Lenin's past seemed to be the one of spreading ideology to communism by his speeches, slogans and other forms of propaganda. On the other hand, Trotsky was more of a realist. He took care of the action the Bolsheviks had to take in order to be successful. He, assumingly, led the

Turning Points in the Life of Vladimir Lenin

1452 words - 6 pages Turning Points in the Life of Vladimir Lenin In 1917 Lenin became the Russian dictator and is known nowadays as a Founder of Communism. Many events in his life have turned Lenin's attitude and changed him. In 1887, Lenin's brother was convicted of an attempted assassination on the Tsar and was consequently hanged for his crime. His brother's activity may have sparked Lenin's interest in revolutionary activity

Citizen Protest In Nazi Germany and the Middle East

1046 words - 4 pages The situation that is occurring in the Middle East is not the first political unrest that has occurred. The actions that have been taken to stifle the protestors are not similar to the actions that Nazi Germany took to suppress the Jews. The actions that differentiate these two groups are the circumstances that caused these violent acts to come about. The leader of Egypt and Hitler are two entirely different beings. The underlying causes of the

Similar Essays

Airport Extension In The South East Of England. Pros And Cons Of Building A New Airport At Cliffe

2507 words - 10 pages especially in the South East of England where demand is highest.There is already a capacity shortfall in the South East, especially at Heathrow where demand is much higher than supply. This shortfall leads to more and more delays. At the moment 65 % of all Heathrow flights are delayed (Department for Transport, 2002) and Gatwick and Stansted are also operating close to capacity limits.With forecasts predicting demand to treble until 2030 the

The Pros And Cons Of Standardized Testing In The Us

1508 words - 6 pages are not performing up to par, the district will be under intense scrutiny. This scrutiny can lead to the loss of a job, and in some cases, the school can be closed or taken over by the state. Although it is true that a lack of performance by students or teachers may result in the above consequences, I do not think that the information being presented to the students is relevant in life skills or important knowledge. Students spend hours

The Pros And Cons Of Women Leaders In The Workforce

2064 words - 8 pages Women, in today’s society are facing dilemmas in different occupations as they become more suitable for leadership positions. “Traditional definitions of leadership are challenged by the changing demographic of society in the United States, increasing numbers of women in leadership roles in the counseling profession, and shifting expectations in the workplace” (Levitt 66). Although, women status has improved over the past century, they are still

The Pros And Cons Of Bilingual Education In Malaysia.

823 words - 4 pages Earlier this year, Singapore’s former Prime Minister, Lee Guan Yew told the press (SinChew Daily, 2013) that he would like to urge all the parents in Singapore to let their children to receive bilingual education as soon as possible as it deliver more pros than cons for the development of the children. Traditionally, bilingual education was perceived by experts as “damaging” to children early language development as it may cause them to confuse