The Black Legend Essay

1107 words - 4 pages

The Black Legend is merely a false statement that people have used for centuries to depict Europeans as wild uncivilized animals. The legend states that the Spanish merely slaughtered infected and enslaved the Native Americans whom they encountered in the New World in the 16th century ( This Legend is held into question since although the Spanish did treat the natives crudely they also adapted parts of the Native American culture into their own and intermarried with the Native women creating a new Mestizo race. The main supporters of this belief were the French and the English who perpetuated this only to make their competitors in overseas colonies seem like monsters (Maltby, William). However ironically the Spanish did more to help the Indians than the French or English ever did. The Black Legend is a term promoted by the English and French to criticize the Spanish cruelty to the natives, it is false because the Spanish helped the gradual development of uniquely American culture, transformed religion in the new world, instituted education, and created a new society of people.Slowly and gradually a new and distinct culture emerged, a mix of the Native and European traditions combined into one. New holidays such as Thanksgiving Day developed. The Natives Americans did use horses to their advantage, contributed by the Spanish to produce more efficient hunting methods, and the new crops provided a richer diet therefore more food could be obtained increasing the live expectancy of the Natives ( The Indians also contributed many things to the European culture. Crops such as corn, squash, potato, beans and exotic fruits which helped the Europeans survive in the New World through numerous winters ( To survive in the newly discovered Americas it was necessary for them to adapt some of the Indian ways just as the Indian tribes came to be quite fond of the European products and culture. Many traces of Spanish influence can be seen today in our architecture and diet. Eventually the Spanish and Indian ways of life fused into a new and unique culture.One of Spain's primary endeavors of colonial expansion was to bring Christianity to native peoples. Kings such as Philip II dedicated large resources to sending missionaries and building churches in America and the Philippines (Gibson, Charles). The Black Legend is said to ignore this fact, as well as to depict the conversion of native peoples under Spanish rule in a brutal and violent manner. Such exaggerations are contrasted by Spanish policies, such as Queen Isabella I's Last Will that solemnly ordered that American natives be treated with respect and dignity (Gibson, Charles). The inquisition was not an institution of persecution or torture as the Black Legend intentionally portrays. The movement of Christianity established a religious institution that monitored Christian principles and teachings within the Catholic Church, and was supervised by the Spanish...

Find Another Essay On The Black Legend

The Story of Black Aggie Essay

1669 words - 7 pages The Story of Black Aggie Urban legends are the supernatural folklore of our modern society. From one generation to the next, they orally travel throughout the world, constantly changing from one region to the next. Although cultural variations exist, the core of all these urban legends remains the same, to unveil the universally known individual and societal fears. “The Graveyard Wager” is a timeless urban legend told again and again, and

Urban Legends: Fact vs. "Fact" / Discusses various aspects of urban legends and the "facts" surrounding them

1620 words - 6 pages ! Also, if someone were ruthless enough so as to surgically remove another person's kidneys for sale on the black market, why would they go to all that trouble to keep their victim alive, rather than just let them die? D. Goska, author of the 1997 book Southern Folklore, suggests that this particular urban legend was inherently created by women in an attempt to demean the male species, perhaps in response to men who have drugged and raped

The Slenderman

1271 words - 6 pages . One such legend is known through internet popularity as slender man. He towers at six to seven feet with unusually thin limbs, his “face” is featureless and white; though some say that it can morph into whatever you fear the most. His arms can stretch out to grab his victims and bend in unnatural ways with long, talon-like fingers used to scratch at the windows of children usually aging from 16 and younger. After examining the Slender man

Literary Analtsis: Urban Leyends

2373 words - 9 pages start to tell them to friends of your own. Not purposefully, but out of casual connection. Out of instinct. This is the purpose of an urban legend, to become integrated in every part of our society, changing it all the while. Works Cited Brunvand, Jan Harold. The Vanishing Hitchhiker: American Urban Legends and Their Meanings. New York: Norton, 1981. Print. Craughwell, Thomas J. Alligators in the Sewer: And 222 Other Urban Legends. New York: Black Dog & Leventhal, 1999. Print.

Art Analysis- "Death Of Constable Scanlon" - Sidney Nolan

595 words - 2 pages When Sidney Nolan painted the Ned Kelly series, he was interested in an 'authentic national vision'. The first series was made up of 27 paintings from 1946-1947. The paintings all-together form a storyboard, telling the legend of Ned Kelly. One of them in particular is 'Death of Constable Scanlon'.The series, including this one, were all painted with Ripolin enamel on hardboard. You can see the many brushstrokes but some objects are painted

Paulo Coelho's Alchemist

770 words - 3 pages of his dream and his destiny. The forces that keep Santiago in sight of his personal legend are not determination, but trust, fascination, and wonder. A scene that shows these attributes comes after Santiago leaves a comfortable oasis in Egypt, to attend to his dream once more. As he pauses in the desert, a horseman dressed in black rushes him, with a sword raised to kill. "Who dares read the meaning of the flight of the hawks?" he demanded

The Mysterious Myth of The Loch Ness Monster

1471 words - 6 pages approximately 12-16 feet wide and 5 feet high, could not have been a boat, and was some sort of animated object ("The Legend of Nessie the Ultimate Loch Ness Monster Site"). In 2007 a scientist took a two minute video clip of Nessie that he described showed a “long, black creature swimming just below the surface of Loch Ness.” From several other videos that have been reported, people who have believed they have gotten this monster on tape only

Washington Irving And His Works

604 words - 2 pages darkest spot. In the times that this story was written, people referred to the Devil as the "Black Man." The Devil tried to get Tom to sifn his book and hand over his soul.      Another parallelism of The Devil and Tom Walker and The Legend of Sleepy Hollow is that main characters in each story fear supernatural figures. In The Legend of Sleepy Hollow Icabod is afraid of the Headless Horsemen. Icabod is always looking

Analysis of Catherine de Medici's Reign

2312 words - 9 pages Catherine de Medici’s culpability for the turbulent events in France in 1559-72 remains a topic of some debate. Highly personal protestant pamphleteers associated Catherine with sinister comparisons to the contemporary evil Machiavelli which eventually developed into the ‘Black Legend’. Jean.H. Mariégol consolidates this interpretation, overwhelmingly assuming Catherine’s wickedness; the Queen Mother was deemed to be acting for ‘personal


586 words - 2 pages a mere boy raised in the south that was taught to love his mama and Jesus. These are the basic things that made him a great rock and roll legend. Elvis changed the face of rock and roll forever with his dance moves, sexuality, style of clothes, long hair, and different style of music that was not accepted by all Americans. Also his use of black music and black style made a lasting impression in history (Pratt 377).Elvis introduced many different

The Headless Horseman

1010 words - 4 pages Headless Horseman Short stories and movies that essentially share the same plot generally have a lot of similarities and differences. In Washington Irving's work, "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow", the Headless Horseman is not portrayed as a violent character, but more of a spirit that is unable to rest in peace. However, this is complete contrast to the character of the same name in the film Sleepy Hollow, directed by Tim Burton. Burton

Similar Essays

The Black Legend And White Legend: Relationship Between The Spanish And Indians In The New World

2525 words - 10 pages The Black Legend and White Legend: Relationship Between the Spanish and Indians in the New World The Spanish-Indian relationship can be defined in many ways. One definition used is through the Black Legend and the White Legend. The interpretation of the Black Legend can depend on whom you are talking to. The Black Legend speaks of the Spaniards abusing the Indians and being guilty of much more misconduct than history has ever

To What Extent Is It Possible To Discredit The 'black Legend Of Childhood' (Keith Wrightson) In 16th And 17th Century England?

2384 words - 10 pages would be neglected, beaten, and only considered valuable when IT was economically productive and could be sent out to work. IT would not live ‘happily ever after’. Such is the ‘black legend of childhood’ .There are no birth or death certificates for IT; no biographies or diaries. IT is merely a figment of this writer’s imagination; IT’s life is fictional and based upon theories of childhood put forward by historians

Marketing Analysis Of Legend

1870 words - 7 pages Overview of LegendLegend Group Limited is a diversified IT company in China with brand "Lenovo" providing advanced IT products and services from computer products, mobile handsets, digital products, to corporate IT solutions.The history of Legend goes back to 1984, in which Institute of Computing Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, established the Group, by 20,000 RMBs and 11 scientists. By 2002, Legend Group Limited, which once existed

Washington Irving, Comparing "The Legend Of Sleepy Hollow And !The Devil And Tom Walker"

659 words - 3 pages midnight looking for his head. 'He glided through the night with a head upon his horn.' (Washington Irving. p. 123) The supernatural figure in The Devil and Tom Walker is the Devil. The Devil lives in the forest in the darkest spot. In the times that this story was written, people referred to the Devil as the 'Black Man.' The Devil tried to get Tom to sifn his book and hand over his soul.Another parallelism of The Devil and Tom Walker and The Legend