This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Black Legend And White Legend: Relationship Between The Spanish And Indians In The New World

2525 words - 10 pages

The Black Legend and White Legend: Relationship Between the Spanish and Indians in the New World

The Spanish-Indian relationship can be defined in many
ways. One definition used is through the Black Legend and the
White Legend. The interpretation of the Black Legend can
depend on whom you are talking to. The Black Legend speaks of
the Spaniards abusing the Indians and being guilty of much
more misconduct than history has ever recorded. The White
Legend speaks of how the Spaniards benefitted the Indian
society by building communities, hospitals and spreading the
Word of God. There are two reasons why the Spaniards were so
intent on spreading the Gospel. The first is because Spain
wanted to ensure political and military means of safety and
independence of their own religious community and even more so
their predominance over others. The second was a deeper
desire to convert, which included appealing to the minds and
hearts of individual unbelievers by preaching, reasoning and
if needed by force (Plumb 152).

The conquest of the new world began with a small band of
Spanish soldiers. The soldiers proceeded to march against and
subdue the huge population of the mainland (Black 24). The
Black Legend speaks of all that the Spanish had done to the
Indians and the horrible things done to them and the land.
This Black Legend exists only in areas where the people are
"anti-Hispanic" especially where English is spoken, and in
modern Spanish America (24).

The White Legend is true only in reverse. The people who
claim to believe in this Legend hold to the belief that the
Spanish were a credit to society and help the Indians in their
everyday lives by providing livestock and new medicines and
also education including Religion. They, meaning the
Spaniards, believed that they eliminated cannibalism and human
sacrifice from their society.

The Black Legend states that Spaniards slaughtered
thousands of Indians and subjected the remainder to
exploitative forced labor. The treatment of the Indians by
the Spaniards could be compared to the treatment of animals
which was more tolerable, but the Spaniards viewed the Indians
as "dung and filth of the earth, and so little did they regard
the health of their souls that they permitted this great
multitude to die without the least light of religion" (Spanish
107).

Both legends are accurate, but neither gives the whole
truth. Basically the truth is only what one chooses it to be.

Another argument considered about the Black Legend was
that the Spaniards claimed to want to bring Christianity to
the Indians but this was not the case, for example: "That he
was a Christian, son of God, Creator of heaven and Earth and
that he had come to teach him his divine law." The chief
responded, "If thy God commands thee to go to the country of
strangers, robbing and burning, killing and doing every sort
of evil, we give thee to...

Find Another Essay On The Black Legend and White Legend: Relationship Between the Spanish and Indians in the New World

Explore in detail the poem 'Nothings Changed' by Tamatakhulu Afrika and the story 'Desiree's baby' by Kate Chopin, commenting on how the authors have presented the relationship between black and white...

1331 words - 5 pages Explore in detail the poem 'Nothings Changed' by Tamatakhulu Afrika and the story 'Desiree's baby' by Kate Chopin, commenting on how the authors have presented the relationship between black and white people."Nothings Changed" is an autobiographical poem written by Tatamakhulu Afrika. "Nothing's Changed" is set in South Africa. The area District six used to be a mixed race inner city community where people of all beliefs lived peacefully. But in

I was told to write a paper comparing a common theme between the movies Jaws, The Legend of Bagger Vance, and Finding Forrester

1150 words - 5 pages horror/thriller film could ever receive.Jaws is a chillingly frightening film about a wayward and decidedly hungry great white shark that is marauding the beaches of New England's usually peaceful Amity Island. Great whites are not common in those waters, so it takes several fatal shark attacks for police Chief Martin Brody to convince the mayor and others that the threat is real. Once everyone realizes that there is a huge shark munching on

Disparities Between Black and White Cancer Patients

990 words - 4 pages The main objective of this study was to examine the disparities between Black and White cancer patients through numerous avenues: information exchanges during oncology interactions, dosage levels of adjuvant chemotherapy, administration of standard or nonstandard chemotherapy, encouragement of “watchful waiting” or “active surveillance”, administration of definitive therapy (surgery or radiation), quality of medical facilities, health plans

The Man And Legend

1205 words - 5 pages shoot the black one in the hole, the game is over';(pg. 55-56, Y.B.I.) These kinds of statements only reinforce and idea of inequality. Instead of looking at the world as white and black there must be a way to merge all people into one category. Cornel West's take on this matter is that 'the sheer absurdity of being a black human being whose black body is viewed as an abomination, whose black thoughts and ideas are perceived as debased, and

The Life and Legend

1253 words - 5 pages Connor SweeneyMrs. Lowry5th Period17 March 2014The Life and LegendOne of the most important people in the history of the Roman Empire was Julius Caesar. He played a critical role in Rome's transition from a republic to an empire. Julius Caesar is regarded as one of the best military leaders of all time. Caesar was an excellent general and successful politician. By conquering many lands for the empire and making important political decisions, he

A Black (And White) Wedding: Traditional Filipino and Spanish Marriage Ceremonies

1451 words - 6 pages A Black (And White) Wedding: Traditional Filipino and Spanish Marriage Ceremonies The concept of marriage has existed in nearly all human cultures throughout history, though its participants, basis, and goals have varied a great deal. Still, in almost all modern societies it is seen as a person’s most important relationship and the foundation of family. Therefore, it is not surprising that weddings, the celebration of marriage, are treated as

Gallipoli and the Anzac Legend

1972 words - 8 pages 'in' thing to do and many just relish the day off work.Some historians even go against the popular beliefs of the Anzac legend. One such man is Dale Blair who wrote Dinkum Diggers: an Australian battalion at war.----- While traits such as egalitarianism, resourcefulness and initiative are assumed and maintained in the nation's popular memory as a truthful representation, not only of Australia's First World War soldiers, but also, of the national

Life and Legend 2 The Life and Legend of Al

1685 words - 7 pages /caponemain.htm). When Gabriel opened up his barbershop the Capone family had to move to a new location that was more convenient or the store. This move introduced Capone to a variety of cultural backgrounds. These cultural influences would later contribute to his Life and Legend 3 role in crime. Due to the prejudice American schools imposed on European kids, Capone was not encouraged to excel in his academics. (www.crimelibrary.com/capone

The Loch, the Legend, and the Monster

1875 words - 8 pages While the possible origins, attempts at proof, monsters throughout the world, and the tourist traps are interesting, the real phenomenon is not the supposed existence of a monster, but rather the way humans’ brains work. Sometimes all logic is abandoned as people attempt to make sense of the natural world. There are many theories in psychology that try to explain why humans believe in supernatural phenomena, including survival techniques from

Scarface; The Man and The Legend

1453 words - 6 pages reason, when his father died, he went back to the rackets and went to work for Torrio. Torrio had moved to Chicago and become much more successful (Bergreen 57).Al was wanted for murder in New York, for this reason, he went to Chicago and started over. Al was very successful in Chicago and before long Torrio's organization became the Torrio-Capone Organization (Al 1). They moved the headquarters from Chicago to one of its suburbs named Cicero

The Enduring Legend of Romeo and Juliet

2297 words - 9 pages around Mercutio) individual. His portrayal of the Capulet family is described as "a remarkable study in family psychology." (18). Families today are still being advised that being critical of your child’s choice of a partner will most likely cause them to rebel and become more attracted. Instead parents should remain silent and let the relationship run its course. Readers seem to look favorably on Romeo and Juliet. They want to identify them as

Similar Essays

The Black Legend Essay

1107 words - 4 pages The Black Legend is merely a false statement that people have used for centuries to depict Europeans as wild uncivilized animals. The legend states that the Spanish merely slaughtered infected and enslaved the Native Americans whom they encountered in the New World in the 16th century (Answers.com). This Legend is held into question since although the Spanish did treat the natives crudely they also adapted parts of the Native American culture

How American Indians Were Treated By The English And Spanish When They First Arrived In The "New Land"

644 words - 3 pages English also traded with them, while the Spanish were conquering them. In addition, the Spanish married the Indians, and the English had interracial marriages for the most part. Although they had many differences, they also had similarities. They both came to the new world seeking riches and profit. Both of them brought diseases to the new world which the Indians were never immune to. They both gained a lot of power from the Indians. All in all, they

To What Extent Is It Possible To Discredit The 'black Legend Of Childhood' (Keith Wrightson) In 16th And 17th Century England?

2384 words - 10 pages of historians.The ‘black legend of childhood’ is the representation of some historians work; other historians lean more towards a white legend. In the absence of conclusive, factual evidence the legend appears to be decidedly grey.BIBLIOGRAPHYReferencesAriѐs, P. Centuries of Childhood. Trans. Robert Baldick. London: Pimlico, 1996.Bideau ,A., Desjardins, B. and Brignoli, H.P. Infant and Child Mortality in the PastOxford: Oxford

Complex Relationship Between The American And Jig In Hemingway’s Hills Like White Elephants

1551 words - 6 pages The Complex Relationship between the American and Jig in Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” In Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants”, the American and Jig are like the tracks at the train station, they can never meet. While Jig represents fertility, life and continuity, the American represents sterility, dryness and death. Unfortunately, Jig depends emotionally on the American – as many women depended on their male