This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Book Is Better Than The Movie: What Is A Bad Movie?

1658 words - 7 pages

People always say that the book is better than the movie, and though they think they might be right, this isn't always the case. People like having the background knowledge of why a character is doing something in a specific case or why the events are happening and seeing the movie cut out all this extra information may upset them, but that doesn't mean that the book is better. It just means they're more informed reading the book. What is a bad movie? Not having enough information or just not being entertained. I happened to watch the movie before I read the book and I thought it was amazing, but after I read the book the movie just didn't compare to the book. Sure they had the same ...view middle of the document...

For the first two days she spent all her time trying to find water and collapses on the ground thats when she starts thinking of a reason why Haymitch won't send her any water and she sees it as a message that the only “one good reason Haymitch could be withholding water from [her] is because he knows [she’s] almost found it.”(169) Besides the book showing her skills it also goes into Katniss’ background, where we read about her connection with her family and where she got her skills from. From the beginning we have knowledge of her Father and how he was “blown to bits in a mine explosion.” (5) He also taught Katniss how to hunt using a bow an arrow, how to sell or trade the animals she kills, and he also taught her valuable surviving skills. After her father's death her mother suffers from depression and is “blank and unreachable” (8) and Katniss is left to look after her mom and little sister Primm by hunting and providing food. This background knowledge of Katniss is crucial to understand what makes her so unique and by reading this we get to know her better and it makes the book more personal.
In contrast the movie The Hunger Games directed by Gary Ross is shot in the perspective of the Gamemakers and we miss out what makes Katniss unique.We get to see the Gamemaker part in story more in the film, whereas in the book he is barely mentioned, and the film is mostly focuses on Katniss but we really don't know what is going inside her mind. In the film we lose that personal connection we have with Katniss in the book because we have no information on her background and we miss out on what makes Katniss more unique than the other contenders. In the book we got to know her family, struggles, and how she got her skills. During the games Katniss was stung by a tracker jacker, a genetically modified wasp made by the capitol, whose sting causes hallucinations which gives her a flashback. In the flashback we taken back to her house where the camera zooms in of a man in a picture frame that is sitting over the fireplace. We are taken to an outside location where we see the man in the picture and a group of men walking towards the camera and we get a close up of the man, then we see them boarding an elevator inside a cave, and as the elevator descends there's an explosion. Then we are taken to the picture frame in the house again and the explosion destroys the house. The scene then backtracks and the house is rebuilt and we see Katniss crying and screaming at her mother, who only has a blank expression on her face. What makes this scene powerful is the bleakness of the shots and the audio is replaced with gloomy depressing orchestra music. This scene can be interpreted differently depending on the viewer, if you have read the book before we know what this scene means, but for people who just see the movie it can be kind of confusing because they introduce a man, who we can only assume to be the father, and we see his death. The scene doesn't explain how...

Find Another Essay On The Book is Better than the Movie: What is a Bad Movie?

What Movie? What Book? Essay

889 words - 4 pages from Odyssey and Everett when they struggle through adversity during the story. For instance, Everett has to break out of jail, dodge cops, and resist temptation. Likewise, Odysseus faces the Cyclops, sirens, and the wrath of the gods. Another trait they share is bravery. Throughout the book and the movie bravery is a very big theme. For Instance, when Everett and his buddies dress up as KKK members shows great bravery because they could have been

Fight Club: A Better Movie than Pulp Fiction

831 words - 3 pages Mike BrennanPer. 1 English05 / 19 / 2005Debate CompositionIs Fight Club a Better Movie than Pulp Fiction?PROThere are many ways to declare one thing better than another. Be it through the message sent, the money made, or the critic's reviews, we have made that distinction between the two movies, Pulp Fiction, and Fight Club. Fight Club comes out as the overall winner in many categories that we use to define greatness. My intent was to prove this

The Hobbit: Book vs. Movie

786 words - 4 pages The Hobbit (There and Back Again) is an absolutely wonderful classical book. In fact, it has been made into a three part movie series, two of which have already been released. The two movies that have been released will be what I am covering in this report. Although the movies are a beautiful remake of the original book, there a quite a few distinct differences between the two. These differences can be very simple: like the fact that Gollum

Is the Portrayal of the Dinosaurs in the Movie and Book Accurate in Real Life

1315 words - 5 pages meters) long and weighs 661-992 lbs (300-450kg). The Dino Dictionary states that the Dilophosaurus is 8ft tall and 20 feet long. The combined ranges for the Dilophosaurus sizes (not including those from the Jurassic Park website, book, or movie) is 6.5-8 feet tall, 19.6-23 feet long, and weighs 661-2200 lbs. Ignoring weight, the Dilophosaurus in the Jurassic Park movie is too small. The Dilophosaurus also is endowed with a neck frill

Seperate But Equal. This is a review for the movie "Seperate but Equal." It analyses the good and bad points of the movie, and suggests areas for improvement throughout the film

632 words - 3 pages , historically speaking, I still knew what the decision was. Along the lines of history, Separate but Equal was historically accurate as well. From the characters used to the dates, times, and sequence of events given, the movie did follow the historical facts. It is not often that Hollywood goes out of its way to make a movie that does go along with history, however Separate but Equal does this quite effectively. The names of the Supreme Court Justices

To Kill a Mockingbird Comparing the Book to the Movie

1167 words - 5 pages , nearly throws up. I believe that this scene should have been put in the movie, because I feel as if the scene does a great job supporting the theme of “people are not always what they seem to be.” The children believe that “Boo” Radley is an evil man, who attacked his father with scissors, and belongs in an insane asylum. This scene shows that “Boo” is not what the children think he is, if he was this maniacal character who attacked his father, why


581 words - 2 pages does the book. He doesn't use a sentimental approach or political work, but shows how his characters lived, and why. Alex Haley depiction of Malcolm X life as told to him by Malcolm, shares the same perception as the movie, but what Alex provides in the book seems to be almost or all Malcolm’s different interactions with “white folks”, and each interaction Malcolm gained something from it - whether it was positive or negative - and that is one of

Harry Potter: The Book and The Movie

1258 words - 5 pages realization, even more than is presented in the book, that the boys and Hermione are growing up. The movie also does an excellent job of providing the same colorful humor that the book provides through its characters making the evil in the book less scary for her audience. Mad eye Moody is a good example; he is very funny in certain scenes. The fact that he is a death eater disguised as an auror is very ironic in the novel and the movie does well to

Jaws: The Movie versus the Book

927 words - 4 pages movie to be an ultimate hit. The book and the movie have a lot of differences. The book gives you an all around synopsis on every character while the Movie gives you a breath description on what the character was about and more emphasis on the shark. The title Jaws, is of course an innuendo referring to the shark. The opening credits start off by putting you deep in the treacherous waters of Amity moving along with an object that you assume is

This is who you should be! Explains conformity throughout the book The Catcher in the Rye and the movie Fame

538 words - 3 pages Conformity is an individual changing according to certain standards. In the movie Fame, directed by Alan Parker, and the book Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salanger, the pressure to conform is ever present. Teenagers in high school face the most pressure to conform, this pressure comes from different forces, including parents, teachers, and their peers.An example of such pressure is when Doris's mother wants Doris to conform to the way she wanted

"Chocolate" - Compare the book to the movie

1258 words - 5 pages and bad), the church v witchcraft, racial discrimination, and the role of women in society, euthanasia and food.Joanne Harris' husband was the inspiration for Chocolat. Annoyed that he was watching the footy on TV Harris asked him what he thought was the female equivalent of football. His answer was "chocolate", which resulted in Harris writing a novel based around the theme of chocolate.The story is narrated by two of the characters. Vianne

Similar Essays

Is The Book Always Better Than The Movie?

2117 words - 9 pages forged from the experiences in their lifetime. To counter that, some see the solution to create a movie based on the literary work to help better capture the accuracy that the book attempts to achieve by visualizing the events. A common debate that often occurs is if the book or the film provides a better narrative. It would be more interesting instead to analyze the historical accuracy of a novel and a film that take place during the same time

101 Dalmatians: Is The Movie Or Book Better?

2279 words - 10 pages several dog-human couple from the window he notices the perfect couple, who are direction to the park, so Pongo is trying to make Roger go for a walk to the park. They meet their ladies in the park, and then they both get married. The dogs’ expressions and dialogues of these scenes are witty and hilarious .The scenes between the characters in the animation movie are better than live-action movie. In the live-action movie, the action begins a little

The Setting In The Ambrose Bierce’s Story “An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge” Is Better Than In The Movie

712 words - 3 pages Student's Last Name 1 Spurlock PAGE 1 Tracy SpurlockDr. S. ThompsonEnglish 130212 April 2010The Setting in the Ambrose Bierce's Story "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" is better than in the Movie.Ambrose Bierce's short story "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" does a better job at carrying the plot more effectively than Director Robert Enrico did in his film production of the same title. The words used by Bierce are very descriptive from the

Analysis Of Henry Stewart´S Movie Review: Why 12 Years A Slave Is A Bad Movie

905 words - 4 pages 12 Years a Slave, is a movie based on the story of Soloman Northup, a free African-American man who was sold into slavery. 12 Years a Slave shows the hardships that Northup had to face as well as Northup eventually being set free again. Henry Stewart writes an article titled “Why 12 Years a Slave is a Bad Movie”, in his article Stewart tries to tear down 12 Years a Slave but fails to because of his weak assumptions, lack of evidence to support