The Border Patrol State Essay

1148 words - 5 pages

The Border Patrol State

In “The Border Patrol State” Leslie Silko makes accusations of the border patrol’s mistreatment of American citizens of Mexican decent, making the argument with almost evidence. Silko, a critically acclaimed poet, sees the border patrol as a governmental assembly addicted to interrogation, torture, and the murder of those they see fit.
Leslie Silko certainly makes accusations that some could argue far exceed the boundaries of journalism integrity, and fail to deliver with evidence to back them up.

The author of this piece is a Mexican-American living in the Southwest United States.
The author is using personal experience to convey a problem to his or her audience. The audience of this piece is quite broad. First and foremost, Mexican-Americans just like the author. People who can relate to what the author has to say, maybe someone who has experienced something similar. The author also seems to be seeking out an audience of white Americans who find themselves unaware of the problem at our borders. The author even offers up a warning to white America when she notes, “White people traveling with brown people, however, can expect to be stopped on suspicion they work with the sanctuary movement”(125). The purpose of this writing is to pull out a problem that is hidden within or society, and let people see it for what it is and isn’t.

This topic is a problem, but it may not be all that it is said to be. Throughout this piece the author shows us what is wrong with system of keeping illegals out of our country. She opens talking of her cousin Bill Pratt, who she claims rode freely from New Mexico to Arizona without disturbances throughout the early 1900’s. From a story of freedom of the past, she moves quickly to the lockdown conditions and harsh treatment of that same area her cousin once rode freely. She tells a story of her and her companion Gus being treated as illegal immigrants although they present Arizona identification.
They are pushed around and even have the dog unleashed on them. She goes onto compare the treatment of Mexican-Americans by the United States Border Patrol to, “Argentina’s “dirty war” in the late 1970’s”(124). From here it is onto how well the border patrol discriminates, and how they will do their best to find any reason to bring the brown man down. Silko explains the way in which people are detained. She actually reaches out to the reader and tells him or her personally how they could identify themselves being detained. She makes claims throughout this explanation of how the detainee is treated unjustly, like when she states, “They make it clear that if you force them to obtain a search warrant for the car, they will make you submit to a strip search as well”(125). Silko starts to bring some half-way evidence into the picture by talking about the more high profile cases of the abuse of the border patrol’s power. She gives us more facts as we reach the middle of the reading. Eighty...

Find Another Essay On The Border Patrol State

U.S. Border Problem Essay

716 words - 3 pages cartels, and there is an increase on human trafficking. The Border Patrol and the U.S. government face many great challenges, as the cartels become more powerful and corruption increases. In the United States, there are approximately 10 million illegal immigrants: 62% are Mexicans, 12% come from El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras, and 6% come from Philippines, India and South Korea (Richwine). There are many reasons why people cross the border

Illegal Immigration In The United States

1221 words - 5 pages U.S. Illegal immigration is a major threat to the country’s homeland security policies however some states are threatened by it more than others. Therefore, the immigration problem facing Florida and the rest of this Nation exposes pressing issues of border control, security issues, and economic stability. The country’s state borders are a passageway into the Nation. The insufficiency of security causes the country to become defenseless to

Border Fence, Made To Fail? - Opinion essay. For or against Bush's Border Fence Act of 2006.

1182 words - 5 pages dollars spent on constructing the fence will be put to better use if the government adds more surveillance on the border itself and has more border agents patrolling. President Bonner of the National Border Patrol Council Union claims that, "a fence will slow people down by a minute or two, but if you don't have the agents to stop them it does no good." (Riechmann)The effectiveness of the border fence is not only a doubt of the border patrol agents

The Price of Freedom

1275 words - 5 pages directed by Steven Spielberg and “The Border Patrol State” by Leslie Marmon Silko basic freedoms are infringed upon by a society that is supposed to be protective and free for all to enjoy. Both works use personal experiences, paralleled with the society’s responses to demonstrate that freedom does not always happen in the land of he free to foreigners and citizens alike. In The Terminal, a man (Viktor Navorski) is not simply stuck in the

Exploration of the Economic/Profitable Dimensions of Illegal Mexican Immigration for U.S. Economy

821 words - 3 pages The United States government, through its policy of discouraging immigration, has only caused further misery to the immigrants longing to cross the Mexican American border in search of work. The United States has a border patrol whose sole purpose is to stop undocumented immigration across the US/Mexican border; however, this policy has hurt both the U.S. and Mexican economies. The United States government loses economically not only in its

Human Trafficking and Abduction

1354 words - 6 pages labor. Examples include, agricultural, domestic, construction, and sweat shop work, as well as sexual tourism. In the year 2000, the US government passed the Trafficking Victims Protection Act. This act enhances pre-existing criminal penalties, gives new protections and benefits along with services to victims with the hope that some will come forward with information rather than fear repercussions. The US Customs and Border Patrol are

Latin American Immigration and the U.S. Immagration Policy

2597 words - 10 pages . Eventually, the United States Border Patrol was officially incorporated into the Department of Labor in 1924, closing off many U.S. ports of entry from Mexico and the Caribbean. (9) Today, the Immigration and Naturalization Services (INS) controls the many border programs and operations throughout the U.S. and on its borders. The main focus for INS is to watch-over all legal immigrants, secure border regions from illegal alien immigration, and

The History of Mexican Immigration to the United States

2079 words - 8 pages aliens come up with many different ways to enter the United States. "On a hot summer day they like to put on bathing suits . . . and swim to shore. They wade through raw sewage in the Tijuana River. They jam themselves into car trunks and into boxcars, and they ride across the border spread-eagled on the top of freight trains. The boldest ones merely sprint through the backed-up traffic at the port of entry, defying the Border Patrol to chase

Climbing The Fence: Immigration across the US-Mexico Border.

1621 words - 6 pages , D.C. 18 Jan. 2007.Hopfensperger, Jean. "No Border Patrol for Guard... Yet." Star Tribune. 12 Dec. 2006.18 Jan. 2007. ."Lexis-Nexis Global." Lexis-Nexis Global. (2006). Reed Elsevier, Inc. 18 Jan. 2007.."Look at Corruption Cases Involving Immigration Officers, A." 24 Sept. 2006. The Associated Press State and Local Wire. 18 Jan. 2007MacDonald, Heather. "Seeing Today's Immigrants Straight." City Journal (2006) 18 Jan 2007.www.city-journal.org/html

Increasing Security at The Mexican American Border

3791 words - 15 pages seize their competition up, the US Border Patrol with limited funding, is up against multi-national billion dollar organizations being the Cartels. There is no question that the Cartels are winning the war on drugs. So the main question is, how are the illegal immigrants and drug smugglers winning the border war? How does the richest nation in the world, a nation that has put men on the moon and has the technology to disarm a nation

Illegal Immigration and Equal Rights

1657 words - 7 pages thorn in the side of citizens around the world. As economic tensions worsen around the globe, immigrants will continue to take the brunt of the blame for unemployment, the depletion of public resources, and social services. The problems of illegal immigration are serious issues that deserve complex evaluation. The lack of enforcement of immigration laws from state to local governments, border patrol abuse issues, the rising number of undocumented

Similar Essays

Border Patrol Career Report

1636 words - 7 pages Security (DHS). Border security is made up of several different federal, state and local agencies. The primary agency is the Boarder Patrol itself. As stated by the Border Patrol, "The United States Border Patrol is the mobile uniformed law enforcement arm of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS)."(Overview). Other organizations on all levels that cooperate with the Border Patrol are the DHS, DEA, FBI, ATF, U.S. Customs, Highway Patrol

Homeland Security Chapter 9 10 Essay

1081 words - 5 pages Chapter 9 is committed to the study of homelands security’s attempts and successes at border patrol. Beginning with the U.S customs and Border Protection, the Border Patrol office has like many other agencies, merged with the DHS following 9/11. The reason is because the Border Patrol is now after 9/11 been concerned with the prevention of terrorist’s entry. The Border Patrol also merged with customs, which has a long history with border

Improving Border Control Essay

2048 words - 8 pages “better secure the border”, which both require the dedicated work of the Border Patrol (“US Tightens Border”). The Border Patrol manpower can be looked at from many ways, such as the extent of the workforce and decrease in corruption. As of 2013, the politicians were seeking improvements by adding more fencing, more military equipment and increasing the labor force to 20,000 agents (Holmes). Even though this may sound like great stretches for

Recruiting In Federal And State Law Enforcement Agencies

1689 words - 7 pages Many people studying in the field of Criminal Justice should choose their career carefully. There are many interesting careers that are arising as the years pass by. To become a successful employee you need to be able to fulfill many requirements, qualifications, and training. The two fields that at this time are recruiting include the Border Patrol and the Texas Probation. These two fields include some of the most extensive hiring process