The Brothers Karamazov By Fydor Dostoyevsky, Rebellion Existence Of God.

1279 words - 5 pages

In the novel The Brothers Karamazov by Fydor Dostoyevsky, chapter four is entitled rebellion; Ivan is questioning the existence and/or character of God. In this chapter, Ivan and his brother Alyosha, discuss if God is just and give examples to support their questions. Ivan suggests that believing in God, or spirituality for that matter, can bring unhappiness and suffering. Ivan explains this rationale by telling stories of mistreated and abused children whom he calls "innocent" because they have never committed the sins of adults. Ivan proclaims that if there is such a God he must be heartless and a tyrant to allow sins to affect the innocent.Ivan uses the old biblical tale of Adam and Eve to distinguish the difference between adults and children. Ivan explains that adults (Adam and Eve) ate the apple, sinned and therefore should continue to be punished. On the other hand, Adam and Eve were not children; which explains why Ivan feels they are not innocent. Ivan states that since adults were the original sinners then children have not had the opportunity the sin yet. Ivan is wrong in many ways because everyone, regardless of age, commit sins. In fact, more crimes are committed by children than adults because most of those children were from broken or abusive homes. Although children have always been categorized as "innocent" children have and do commit horrific and unthinkable crimes. Ivan could argue that children develop this mind set to commit crimes from unsuitable parents or guardians. Many times children who commit crimes are profiled as abused, either sexually, physically or mentally, by a parent or family member. Ivan could also say that children sin and commit crimes because their parents tortured them as in the case with Richard.Ivan tells the story of Richard, a six year old boy who was given away to some shepherds. The shepherds treated Richard so inhumanely that he didn't know any better but to treat other as such. Although it is sometimes looked on as a cliché, the expression "treat others as you would want to be treated", applies to this case. Richard was given away by his parents at an age that he was old enough to remember. This probably left Richard with a feeling of inadequacy and abandonment. Ivan tried to explain that Richard never knew of a God or anything one is taught about God. The expression stated above goes back to the teachings of Jesus, but since Richard was never taught about spirituality, he never learned any respect for mankind. It seems reasonable that Richard would commit the crimes of theft and murder since he only knew those ways. Richard had to steal from pigs just to get the nourishment that all humans need. In today's society, many people would be sympathetic to Richard and his situation.Ivan then goes on to discuss the sensuality some feel when beating another, especially a child. Ivan tells the story of a mother and father who beat and tortured their seven year old daughter. "They beat for a minute,...

Find Another Essay On The Brothers Karamazov by Fydor Dostoyevsky, Rebellion-Existence of God.

The Existence of God Essay

1022 words - 5 pages , and not framed by me, nor in any degree dependent on my thought “ -Descartes (Meditations) Descartes definition of God is a “supremely perfect being,” a being with ALL perfections.He seeks to simply establish the existence of God through this definition. As necessary (eternal) existence is a perfection, therefore a supremely perfect being must exist necessarily. If asked would you rather have a £10 note which didn’t exist, or one which did

The Existence Of God Essay

1209 words - 5 pages uncertainties in our world may explain why the existence of God is so real to many people. For the believers, God provides a convenient answer to all these questions except for the answers regarding God itself. The following are some of the general arguments for the existence of God. The first argument comes from the theory of design; there are orders in the universe which can't be occurring by mere chance. Secondly, the existence of God

The Existence of God

2488 words - 10 pages :44-46): "The Kingdome of Heaven is like this. A man happens to find a Treasure hidden in a field. He covers it up again, and is so happy that he goes and sells everything he has, and then goes back and buys that field." The topic that concerns me in religious philosophy is, can the existence of God be revealed or can He be proved by other people's arguments. The arguments for the existence of God divide into two main groups, a priori

The Existence of God

1724 words - 7 pages ). Given such characteristics draws criticism and ire considering that on any given day the world as we know it is plagued by death, pain, suffering, and an overall unsatisfactory life. It goes on to say that if God was what he is thought to be and more shouldn’t his power reflect as a utopian world? First of all, before using human suffering as an excuse to deny the existence of God it is necessary to establish the origins of suffering which fall

The Existence of God - 2245 words

2245 words - 9 pages i.e. takes place with those who are already believers. God is believed first via faith which means that by having a basic framework it'll make you accept religious experiences. It is possible to conclude that it is a learned belief. Could one go as to suggest that religious experiences are proof for the existence of God? For a religious believer the involvement of God in human affairs is to be expected. The argument

The Existence of God - 736 words

736 words - 3 pages Saint Aquinas defines the existence of God with the upmost clarity. Saint Anselm and William Paley attempt to tackle the existence of God but are weighed down by weaknesses within their argument. Even with Saint Anselm being a Christian theologian, he does not incorporate his personal religious beliefs into his argument. St. Anselm relies purely on logic and ontology to define what he constitutes as God, defined as a being in which nothing

The existence of God

771 words - 4 pages The Existence of God For many centuries the mysteries of our world and the cosmos have plagued mankind. Why the stars illuminate the night and where the sun disappeared to everyday has caused our ancestors to create myths to answer these perplexing questions. The existence of God as many Christians worship him today in America is just that- a myth; a construct of our superstitious past that is no longer relevant in the modern world; there is

Theodicy and Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov

2618 words - 10 pages Theodicy and Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov The problem of reconciling an omnipotent, perfectly just, perfectly benevolent god with a world full of evil and suffering has plagued believers since the beginning of religious thought. Atheists often site this paradox in order to demonstrate that such a god cannot exist and, therefore, that theism is an invalid position. Theodicy is a branch of philosophy that seeks to defend religion by

Book Report On Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov

2849 words - 11 pages happiness resulting from a renunciation of God is a delusion; he discovers that it is God that is keeping the entire race of man from sinking into the depravity and cruelty that he could not accept in the first place. Confronted by a conflict in ideas that he is unable to solve, he declines into madness. THEME One of the major themes of The Brothers Karamazov is the idea that life without God can only lead to destruction. Dostoevsky

Proving the Existence of God

1100 words - 4 pages result, we have five proofs of the existence of God by St. Thomas Aquinas, all of which are based on logic and observation of nature. One of his proofs is based on the idea of a first mover and another is based on the idea that intelligence is necessary to direct non-intelligent objects. I believe that this fifth argument is better that the first. St. Thomas Aquinas' first argument tries to prove that there must be a first mover. He calls this first

The Existence of a God

1059 words - 4 pages since "that which does not exist comes into being by something that exists"(Knowledge, 134). And, as we saw in relation to movers and to causes, so we cannot but postulate the existence of some being having of itself its own existence and not receiving it from another, but rather causing in others their existence. Thus, one may observe evidence of the existence of "god". Comparisons between things using "more" or "less" show that there must

Similar Essays

Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov Essay

1760 words - 7 pages three Karamazov brothers is their explosive exhibition of their passion. The youngest Karamazov, Alexei, is passionate about religion. He passes some time in the town monastery where he is greatly influenced by the elder Zosima. Even though he decides against living his life as a monk, he vows to uphold the teachings of his mentor. Throughout the entire book, he attempts to exhibit to others the workings of his God. Alexei is greatly admired and

A Discussion Of The Grand Inquisitor From 'the Brothers Karamazov' By Fyodor Dostoevsky

686 words - 3 pages The Grand Inquisitor is an adaptation from The Brothers Karamazov, a novel written by Fyodor Dostoevsky. It is a Russian novel, set in 19th century Russia. The Inquisitor, the part of the story that we are dealing with, is a discussion between two of four brothers, Ivan and Alyosha.Alyosha is the youngest brother, of about twenty years of age. He is preparing to become a monk in the Eastern Orthodox Church. Ivan is older, about thirty years of

Portrayal Of Man In Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov

1216 words - 5 pages Portrayal of Man in The Brothers Karamazov           Debauchery, dueling, infidelity, orgies, and even monastery life are all used to help Fyodor Dostoevesky define his characters in The Brothers Karamazov. At the beginning of the novel, the reader becomes filled with contempt for a few members of the Karamazov family, yet filled with admiration for others. The legitimate members of the Karamasov family each represent a separate aspect of

Concept Of Free Will In The Brothers Karamazov

2583 words - 10 pages  God.  “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God.  “Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness' sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.” (John 5:2­10, English Standard Version) One of the most important concepts in Dostoevsky’s novel, The Brothers Karamazov is the concept of free will. It is important to the novel because of the overall theme that everyone is responsible in some way for everything