The Burgess Story Essay

3377 words - 14 pages

The Burgess Story

"I don't like to say bad things about paleontologists, but they're really not very good scientists. They're more like stamp collectors.
- Luis Alvarez, Physics Nobel Laureate -

Luis Alvarez evidently had some very definite ideas about what a good scientist does, and it is especially telling that such a comment comes from a physicist. What could Alvarez have had in mind when he made this remark? He may have been making a mental comparison of the approach commonly used in physics -- that of laboratory experimentation -- with the way the study of paleontology is conducted, A paleontologist is very much a historian -- someone who is involved in the "reconstruction of past events ... based on narrative evidence of their own unique phenomena" (Gould 278). In Alvarez's eyes then, good science is characterised by the experimental approach of experiment, quantification, repetition, prediction, and restriction of complexity to a few variables that can be controlled and manipulated" (Gould 277). This seems to me too narrow a definition. Such an approach can hardly be used in fields such as paleontology, which study the occurrence of one-off events such as evolution. In cases such as these, what standards can we use to determine whether something is admissible as good scientific practice? Philosophers of science such as Karl Popper and Thomas Kuhn have each come up with their own ideas of what constitutes good science. Can they perhaps shed some light on other possible definitions of good science? Can these other definitions of good science be generalised to all disciplines of science?

Popper and Kuhn have proposed strictly theoretical ideas -- It remains to be seen whether a concrete example of scientific research would validate their ideas or not. Since we are interested in searching for a definition of good science that is also applicable to fields such as paleontology (where laboratory experimentation is severely limited if not impossible), it seems reasonable to look at a concrete example from the discipline of paleontology itself In his book Wonderful Life, Stephen Jay Gould provides us with just such an example. He describes the story of the Burgess Shale in the Canadian Rockies, where Charles Walcott discovered animal fossils of the Cambrian era in 1909. The Cambrian era marks the time when "virtually all major groups of modern animals" (Gould 24) made their entrance, thus it is a period crucial to our understanding of evolution -- specifically, how the modem phyla of fauna evolved and why these phyla in particular. The discovery of the Burgess is a very significant event for the discipline of paleontology, because it is the "only extensive, well-documented window upon that most crucial event in the history of animal life, the first flowering of the Cambrian explosion" (Gould 24). The hard parts of animals are the parts normally preserved in fossils, but they offer at best a limited insight into the anatomies of animals....

Find Another Essay On The Burgess Story

Use of Language in A Clockwork Orange

2029 words - 8 pages Examination of the Use of Language in “A Clockwork Orange”      The created patch-work language of Nadsat in the novel, A Clockwork Orange, satirizes the social classes and gang life of Anthony Burgess’s futuristic society. The most prominent of these tools being his use of a completely new language and the depiction of family life from the eyes of a fifteen year old English hoodlum. Burgess effectively broke arcane

A Clockwork Orange a critical anylsis of the critically acclaimed novel by anthony burgess

2146 words - 9 pages ' of society that England was dealing with at the time that Burgess wrote this novel (Malafry). Alex is the personification of all that society would like to ignore or eliminate (Hausey). Aside from pitting Alex against 'normal' society, Burgess uses his story to magnify their decline. He uses this surreal method of therapy (which was actually being discussed at the time) to show the dangers of this type of 'human experiment'. Alex loses his

Clockwork Orange

2301 words - 9 pages Clockwork Orange In all of my reading, I have come to the conclusion that Anthony Burgess is one of the greatest literary genius’s of the twentieth century. His masterpiece, A Clockwork Orange, is unrivaled in obvious depth, insight, and innovation. The novel is a work of such quality, such perfection, that it seems to be genuinely written by a literary demigod. The novel's main theme deals with free choice and spiritual freedom

A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess

1323 words - 5 pages Imagine having stolen, raped, and even murdered all at the age of 15. The new canon of dark literature and controversy has finally hit the stage. A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess written in 1962 could only be described in the old cockney expression “queer as a clockwork orange”. Meaning it is bizarre internally, but appears natural on the surface. The story begins with the protagonist and narrator Alex a 15-year-old boy, who sets the bar

Comparing Burgess and Draper's Theory of Family Violence and the Film, The Burning Bed

2156 words - 9 pages Comparing Burgess and Draper's Theory of Family Violence and the Film, The Burning Bed   I.  Introduction      Burgess and Draper argue coercive patterns of family interaction represent the principal causal pathway that connects ecological instability to violence within families.  They maintain this raises the possibility that some of the common correlates of such violence are themselves reactions to sudden or chronic ecological

A Clockwork Orange

1687 words - 7 pages  Clockwork Orange There have been many books published solely on philosophy, and many more than that solely written about human nature, but very infrequently will a book be published that weaves these fields together as well as A Clockwork Orange, by Anthony Burgess.  In this Book Burgess speculated on the fact “the significance of maturing by choice is to gain moral values and freedoms.”  He achieved this task by pushing his

About the novel, A Clockwork Orange, by Anthony Burgess

1687 words - 7 pages A Clockwork OrangeThere have been many books published solely on philosophy, and many more than that solely written about human nature, but very infrequently will a book be published that weaves these fields together as well as A Clockwork Orange, by Anthony Burgess. In this Book Burgess speculated on the fact "the significance of maturing by choice is to gain moral values and freedoms." He achieved this task by pushing his angsty teenaged

A Wonderfull Life by Stephen Jay Gould

2296 words - 9 pages Walcott in 1909. There is some dispute about how and when he found it. Walcott's story says that his donkey tripped on some rocks and kicked them loose. Then after close examination Walcott returned in the last few days of the season and found and extracted most of the known Burgess Shale that we know today. Then he came back the next season and extracted the remaining fossils and examined them all. But after closing looking at Walcott's journal

A Clockwork Orange Essay: A Movie Analysis

1724 words - 7 pages , but the movie portrays her young.      It was the dawn of the age of pornography that enabled Stanley Kubirck to exploit, to a serious artistic end, those elements in the story which meant to shock morally rather than merely titillate. These elements were shielded from the reader of Burgess' novel through his invention of his teenage lingo, Nadsat. Burgess' language diminished the impact of such violent acts as kicking a man in the guts

A Clockwork Orange

611 words - 2 pages A Clockwork Orange      To leave out the final chapter of A Clockwork Orange is to change the entire meaning of the novel; as Burgess says in the introduction, his story is transformed into a fable. Without the last chapter the reader is left with a dark and pessimistic theme, that absolute good and evil exist in this world and it is possible for a man to be pure evil. Alex is conditioned and unconditioned, and in the

The Affect on Free Will of A Clockwork Orange's 21st Chapter

1562 words - 6 pages the book a dark side, the appeal that, given the choice, people would rather be bad then be good. However, chapter 21 portrays the protagonist as a changed person, which only makes sense. What good is a story unless the protagonist goes through some sort of change? Once again, I feel the author puts it best, in that "The American or Kubrickian Orange, is a fable; the British or world one is a novel" (Burgess, viii).In closing, it seems that

Similar Essays

The Need For Brutality In A Clockwork Orange

4715 words - 19 pages the story would fall into the same logical trap as did the old, anti-lynching Hollywood westerns which always nullified their theme by lunching an innocent person."   Given its astronomical degree of reinforcement, freedom of choice stands out as the dominating theme of A Clockwork Orange. The biggest paladin of these principles is the prison "charlie," through whom Burgess expands the metaphysics of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard into a social

The Need For Nadsat In A Clockwork Orange

2498 words - 10 pages .            There is also a bit of Cockney rhyming slang as well as a little German influence.  Cockney rhyming slang, from the East Side of London, takes the meaning of a word and rhymes it with the last word of a phrase. Burgess translated these words and meanings directly from their Cockney origins.  They include hound and horny for corney, luscious glory for upper story (Cockney slang for hair), and pretty polly for lolly (slang for money

Psychoanalytical Criticism Of A Clockwork Orange

1727 words - 7 pages Anthony Burgess via Alex DeLarge Psychoanalysis is based on the idea that literature is an extension of the conscious and subconscious mind. In a novel, the emotions of an author are manifested as a story of a protagonist and his world. The protagonist is created as the author’s persona, and the setting of the story parallels events from the author’s past. In Anthony Burgess’s A Clockwork Orange, the protagonist Alex DeLarge is a direct

Analysis Of A Clockwork Orange

2528 words - 10 pages like presented the other cheek" (Burgess, Clockwork 121). Another very significant bit of irony is in the name of the house that follows Alex throughout the story--the house that gives A Clockwork Orange its title and most of its major themes, and that ultimately causes Alex's downfall. The name of this house is HOME. When Alex's gang first encounters HOME, Alex calls it "a gloopy sort of name" (Burgess, Clockwork 19). Home is a word